HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jivatmanx

1,417 karma · joined October 10, 2012

submissionscomments
jivatmanx··on The shadowy cartel of doctors that controls Medicare
I totally agree with this.

Similarly, Socialists can point to most European countries that get superior service for much less cost, while Capitalists (I lean this way) point to amazing efficiency innovations that happen in countries with less regulated systems like India's[0]

What's clear is that our system has somehow found a way to be the worst of both worlds, very expensive, bad service, not universal.

[0]http://online.wsj.com/article/SB125875892887958111.html

jivatmanx··on U.S. government recognizes gamers as athletes
Is chess a sport? If so, this decision is logical.
jivatmanx··on Things Most Americans Don’t Know About America
Since the Glorious Revolution of 1688, English Bill of Rights 1689, the Monarchy never since had absolute power, there was always a powerful parliament.

The English Civil War, a few decades earlier, was fought between pro-parliament (Oliver Cromwell) and pro-monarchist forces.

Without these events, it's unlikely the U.S. would have been founded explicitly as a Republic. As it was, Alexander Hamilton and other Federalists argued at the constitutional convention for an elective monarchy. (Which is why the presidency is more powerful than the anti-federalists and others would have liked)

jivatmanx··on Statement by Edward Snowden to human rights groups at Sheremetyevo airport
"Americans have a short attention span, care more about Kim Kardashian's baby than their liberty" Isn't going to be an effective argument with patriotic Americans.
jivatmanx··on Statement by Edward Snowden to human rights groups at Sheremetyevo airport
Only two countries directly: Germany, which clearly has a superior human rights record than the U.S, and Brazil, which can certainly be argued to have a better record.

Edit: Perhaps "Ranking", or current policy is a better phrase than "Record", but in any case, the Nazis were a very long time ago, there aren't even that many WWII veterans alive anymore, much-less in power.

jivatmanx··on Chevron Granted Access to Activists' Private Internet Data
Puts this recent statement in context:

"Carney is asked about the involvement of Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International in defending Snowden.

Carney praises the work of those organizations. However "Mr Snowden is not a human rights activist or a dissident," Carney says, but a leaker of highly classified state secrets who faces three felony charges."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jul/12/edward-snowden-t...

jivatmanx··on Secure Ideas will not be presenting at DEF CON this year
This isn't the first time the U.S. has faced a non-state organized group with worldwide ambitions killing innocents as a political tactic, the late 19th century anarchists were identical in all of these respects.
jivatmanx··on Secure Ideas will not be presenting at DEF CON this year
Yes, looks like it's commonly but wrong attributed to him.

It's more interesting in the context of Lincoln's suspension of Habeus corpus in the Civil War than as an unpopular dissenting opinion in a free speech case, though.

jivatmanx··on Secure Ideas will not be presenting at DEF CON this year
"The Constitution is not a suicide pact" is a quote from Abraham Lincoln, as the civil war really was an existential threat to the union itself.

Similarly, the cold war was clearly an existential threat to the union itself, the most obvious example being the hundreds of nuclear ICBM's in Cuba.

Terrorism of the Boston Marathon sort is now an unfortunate reality, but is in no way comparable to these two events, and I simply don't see how it poses any existential threat to the union at all.

It's important to put things into perspective by understanding the threats we have faced in the past, and all that has been sacrificed to bring us the freedom we have now, so that we don't throw it away due to overreacting.

jivatmanx··on How Microsoft handed the NSA access to encrypted messages
"ACLU technology expert Chris Soghoian said the revelations would surprise many Skype users. "In the past, Skype made affirmative promises to users about their inability to perform wiretaps," he said. "It's hard to square Microsoft's secret collaboration with the NSA with its high-profile efforts to compete on privacy with Google."

I have a feeling the FTC won't go after them for violating truth-in-advertising laws.

jivatmanx··on Too Many Cops Are Told They’re Soldiers Fighting a War. How Did We Get Here?
I'm sure they're protecting their turf, but they didn't start the drug war, and they're not at the forefront of promoting it.

Nixon declared the "War on Drugs". He also pioneered the "Southern Strategy", and many elements of his campaign are now well accepted to have been used as code words.

It wasn't a personal appeal to the puritan morality of drug users to stop, it was an appeal to the fears of scared whites.

The "War on Drugs" almost exclusively effects poor, minority communities and individuals.

jivatmanx··on Secret government: America against democracy
Indeed, the Roman Republic turned into an Empire as it gained more territory, and having a representative system with most people being non-citizens became an untenable contradiction.
jivatmanx··on Venezuela: My experience in the surveillance state
More or less total surveillance and indefinite storage exists today.

It takes very little creativity to imagine this being abused. Choose a few keywords, and you can easily identify everyone in the U.S. with any significant civil libertarian.

Once you've got the list, all you have to do is prevent these people from getting political power, and voila, 1984.

The robot thing definitely takes more creativity to think of than that.

More generally, I tend to think that all Brute Force methods are the most crude, and a last resort even in a tyranny.

jivatmanx··on In Secret, Court Vastly Broadens Powers of N.S.A.
The Ninth amendment states that the Bill of Rights is not intended to be exhaustive enumeration of liberty.

There is no danger in erring on the side of too much liberty. Parent errs on side of denying of liberty already clearly enumerated.

jivatmanx··on In Secret, Court Vastly Broadens Powers of N.S.A.
The rule existed in traditional English Common law from long before the U.S. declared Independence.

Being that the Fourth Amendment itself was a reaction against General Warrants and Writs of Assistance, it's hard to imagine the founders would have wanted even less protection here than English law already provided

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusionary_rule#History_of_th...

jivatmanx··on In Secret, Court Vastly Broadens Powers of N.S.A.
Who could forget the calm, thorough, logical debate about liberty vs. security that took place in the media and congress, when these programs were passed?
jivatmanx··on Venezuela, Bolivia offer asylum to U.S. intel leaker Snowden
Interesting, the negative connotation might have been a legacy of prohibition.

It's unfortunate that people don't feel the same about the war on drugs, simply because it mostly effects minorities.

jivatmanx··on Venezuela, Bolivia offer asylum to U.S. intel leaker Snowden
Not sure this quote is quite as relevant as it used to be, due to the extreme ubiquity of information storage.
jivatmanx··on Venezuela, Bolivia offer asylum to U.S. intel leaker Snowden
NATO at the moment is basically just "U.S. + anyone else who wants to help"

With the info that NATO has been used to spy on the E.U. I definitely see incentive for a separate European military arrangement.

jivatmanx··on Venezuela, Bolivia offer asylum to U.S. intel leaker Snowden
Bin Laden is definitely the Gavrilo Princip, but I disagree with the opinion that our leaders were just innocently and emotionally reacting to 9/11, as most of Bush's cabinet consisted of hardcore, , Team B[1], neoconservative ideologues.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Team_B

jivatmanx··on Did you know John Roberts is also chief justice of the NSA’s surveillance state?
>2. This is pretty much a solved problem as far as they're concerned. Congress tends to tack "solutions" on top of "solutions". They rarely refactor.

Lack of simplicity in law is a serious problem, but not the main one, at least in this case. The problem is that laws increase the arbitrary powers of government, and rarely if every restrict them.

In most cases, such as the patriot act, they will simply find that vaguest provision and interpret it in the broadest way possible, And, in this case, that interpretation is also secret. The rest of the text is basically filler.

jivatmanx··on If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism?
I agree. Not sure why I worded it that way.
jivatmanx··on If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism?
"If humans were angels there would be no need for government to begin with, and if elected leaders were angels there would be less need for protection of our privacy -- but humans are not angels and we have experience with elected leaders that are partisan, opportunist, short-sighted and, sometimes, even corrupt. Government's natural inclination is to abuse its power, one critical reason why our Founders limited it. "

Sounds like direct plagarism of this:

"Sometimes it is said that man can not be trusted with the government of himself. Can he, then, be trusted with the government of others? Or have we found angels in the forms of kings to govern him? Let history answer this question."

-Thomas Jefferson, first inaugural address

jivatmanx··on Join the largest online protest since SOPA to stop NSA spying
"But the US founding fathers saw this situation: Someone with 'standing' brings a legal case, and eventually the case makes it to the Supreme Court of the US"

Thomas Jefferson opposed the creation of the supreme court in Marbury vs. Madison. Madison was his secretary of state.

Here is his reasoning:

"You seem to consider the judges as the ultimate arbiters of all constitutional questions; a very dangerous doctrine indeed, and one which would place us under the despotism of an oligarchy. Our judges are as honest as other men, and not more so. They have, with others, the same passions for party, for power, and the privilege of their corps.... Their power [is] the more dangerous as they are in office for life, and not responsible, as the other functionaries are, to the elective control. The Constitution has erected no such single tribunal, knowing that to whatever hands confided, with the corruptions of time and party, its members would become despots. It has more wisely made all the departments co-equal and co-sovereign within themselves"

It's difficult to consider the counter-factual of the court not being created and common law having been continued, but it's useful to understand that there was opposition, and why, so that if you support it, you can use this knowledge to make it better.

In more modern times, partisanship does seem to be a problem, with many of the most important decisions are made 5-4 on party lines.

As you have brought up, another problem is that, contrarily, that it may be that the supreme court isn't actually not be powerful enough. If the U.S. is using the U.K. to spy on Americans, isn't that a blatant end-run around the constitution? But where can standing be, if legal opinions are based on secret courts, and gag orders are imposed on everything?

At the same time, it's not "Just the supreme court's" job to uphold the Constitution. Ultimately, it's the people's, and our most direct representatives are the House. They take an oath to uphold the responsibility, and they can't simply subcontract it, it doesn't work that way.

jivatmanx··on No free trade agreement if charges of espionage are true, warns EU Commissioner
Yes, but for both good and ill.

The reformation's idea was that no authority or intercessor was needed to interpret or use the bible.

I'll skip the details, but this idea was an essential precursor for the idea of self-government, and the enlightenment in general.

jivatmanx··on No free trade agreement if charges of espionage are true, warns EU Commissioner
I don't believe that corporations are libertarian, largely because "limited liability" completely divorces them from the responsibility of the individual, which forms the basis of everything in the libertarian system.

I don't see any problem with partnerships and sole proprietorships, though.

As with any system, these people need to be ethical. But corporations have a sort of legally forced amorality.

jivatmanx··on On the freedom to speak
The American revolutionaries were indeed conservatives in the sense that they just wanted what they felt were their rights as English citizens.

Across the Atlantic, Edmund Burke was the founder of modern conservatism. He did not want the colonies to secede and was deeply pained by it, but supported them because he felt their rights were violated. He was an unqualified opponent of the French Revolution, however, and extensively fought with Paine on this.

Edmund Burke did, in a sense, a classical liberal, he passionately defended English rights, but never really universalized them or subscribed to Enlightenment ideology. He's sometime called "The most important philosopher who wasn't a philosopher"

Most of the American revolutionaries were, deep, strong believers in universal enlightenment ideology.

Two of the most important, Jefferson and Franklin, were also "Makers", polymaths who made contributions to many fields. Especially Franklin who both made real, major scientific advances AND in the literary sphere, founded BOTH the American satirical and ethical traditions.

Again, both were unapologetic followers of the enlightenment: believed in universal natural rights, were Deists, etc.

jivatmanx··on Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce
Also interesting is that Milton Friedman considered his role in ending the draft his proudest achievement.

Friedman had no qualms about describing himself as a libertarian and not a conservative, and his influence in the Reagan administration was considerable, even outside of economics.

I find it strange that so many conservatives admire Reagan as their ultimate hero, but ignore any libertarian influence in his administration.

jivatmanx··on On the freedom to speak
I love Lessig, and completely it's stupid to attack him over this, or believe he's part of some conspiracy. He was primarily trying to bring up the incredibly fascinating, and important issue of: "Can, in the long run, purely technological means protect privacy?"

It is, however, entirely reasonable to question if a corporation that took part in "Team Themis" could/would actually develop such technology.

jivatmanx··on Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce
Benjamin Franklin's vision of "A Republic, if you can keep it" requires questioning in a desire to preserve what can, in fact, be lost.

What Keith is going for here, is , "My Country, right or wrong", blind following.

← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →