But clearly, this isn't the basis of my comparison. A soldier is completely subject to the arbitrary will of his superiors, without any real legal protections.
See also: Ratio of reported rapes vs. prosecuted rapes, scandals of enforcement agents.
1,417 karma · joined October 10, 2012
But clearly, this isn't the basis of my comparison. A soldier is completely subject to the arbitrary will of his superiors, without any real legal protections.
See also: Ratio of reported rapes vs. prosecuted rapes, scandals of enforcement agents.
Soldiers are, in a sense, slaves. A standing army is a vast apparatus under direct control of an executive.
But, the opposition to standing armies is long forgotten. We also forgot the reason why only congress was given the authority to declare war, which has become dead letter, and these ideas considered quaint and outdated. But 1776 wasn't that long ago in the history of human governments, and the history of human governments is the history of abusing power.
"Not to know what happened before you were born is to be a child forever." - Cicero
In retrospect, the retroactive immunity thing should have been a hint...
The Civil War started right after the industrial revolution ended. By this time, the balance of power was greatly in favor of the North.
"Society is indeed a contract. It is a partnership in all science; a partnership in all art; a partnership in every virtue, and in all perfection. As the ends of such a partnership cannot be obtained in many generations, it becomes a partnership not only between those who are living, but between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born." -Edmund Burke
"Judges generally confer only with government lawyers, and out of public view. Yet the judges have the power to interpret the Constitution and set long-lasting and far-reaching precedent on matters involving Americans’ rights to privacy and due process under the Fourth Amendment. And this fast-growing body of law is almost entirely out of view of legal scholars and the public. Most Americans do not have access to the judiciary’s full interpretation of the Constitution on matters of surveillance, search and seizure when it comes to snooping for terrorist plots — and are limited in their ability to challenge it"
"The judges that are assigned to this court are judges that are not likely to rock the boat,” said Nancy Gertner, a former federal judge from Massachusetts who teaches at Harvard Law School. Gertner, a former defense and civil rights lawyer named to the bench by Democrat Bill Clinton, added: “All of the structural pressures that keep a judge independent are missing there. It’s one-sided, secret, and the judges are chosen in a selection process by one man."
I've never been particularly fond of Marbury vs. Madison (I'm not sure it was wise to trash the Common Law system), but if this is true it's potentially in violation of that precedent, by, apparently, creating a rival supreme court, whose rulings are secret and which is stacked with yes-men by the executive.
P.S. This story has restored some of my faith in WAPO, which has been questioned by some of their actions in this story.
I think that these petitions are helpful for the otherwise apolitical, who get a mental cue, "I signed this petition, I am for this cause". Nobody starts out writing letters, and it's not helpful to condescend those who aren't as committed as us.
Assuming they were doing so simply as an end-run around U.S. wiretap law, that's a pretty obvious violation of the spirit of the law, but the letter?
Yes, we're better than China, but pretty far from the leader.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Press_Freedom_Index
The U.S. is the most important nation in terms of it's historical importance to freedom in the world, but it's been decades since it's been considered an example to emulate, in terms of either the electoral and political process, or rule of law based in natural rights.
Besides, Democracy promotion wasn't even the original rationale for the war. That was "Saddam helped do 9/11". Then it was WMD. Only when those failed was Democracy promotion used as the final fallback rationale.
I'm not saying that Iraq cannot possibly be a legitimate Democracy, but it hasn't yet had the moment of national consensus that that real ones have had at their formation.
(Or if "journalists" still believed their job was to serve as a check on, rather than an apologist for, the powerful)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Che_Guevara#The_.22New_Man.22.2...
But here we are, over 10 years after 9/11, and an enemy who simply does not pose any existential threat to the U.S. And yet no limits have been passed on Patriot act powers.
What I find most amazing about this story is that the House would actually do something to serve as a check on executive power.
The problem being that, in the executive bubble, where most of seats and nearly all of the money is held by the military-industrial complex, that's the consensus you will get.
I believe that prior to Bush, some such system did exist with respect to some types of records.
Based on trends, it will also soon exceeded by a few Asian countries such as South Korea.
Given that China has copied the same economic and political transition of other Asian countries such as South Korea, but is simply further behind chronologically, please tell be why it's completely inconceivable that China will exceed the U.S. in freedom.