HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jnky

358 karma · joined July 23, 2011

submissionscomments
jnky··on The Secret Button
To move windows between displays, you can also use Win+shift+left or Win+shift+right.
jnky··on A Grain of Salt
> Outside of cities you're limited to 100km/h (or less ofc - but 100km/h is the maximum you'll get if we ignore rare cases with 4+ lane roads and a solid barrier in the middle 120km/h

That's not quite correct. The speed limit is generally 100 km/h outside of cities, except when there are either two lanes (or more) per direction and a line between the two different directions or if there are less than two lanes per direction, but there is a sold barrier between them. In those cases there is no speed limit, just like on the Autobahn.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
> I guess our difference is mostly in how important we see language as part of culture and/or how sensitive we are to mightier cultures/languages taking over others.

I think you are absolutely right, in that this is the key difference between our respective opinions. I nonetheless enjoyed the surrounding discussion.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
> Not meant to offend (didn't even knew the parent was German at the time, thought I was an American), but it wasn't an gratuitous reference either. It's not like someone in an internet forum calling someone a "nazi" because they disagree with them or anything.

The comment you took your quote from already mentioned that I'm German.

That's alright though. I'm not "offended" by the Nazi comparison because of my German heritage. I just wanted to highlight what I perceived to be needless hyperbole that inevitably derails the discussion about the idea at hand by way of Godwin's Law.

> I legitimately believe that there are plenty of legitimate lessons to be learned (to avoid, of course) from the Nazis, as WWII and the Holocaust is the single most deadly and morally disastrous event of the modern era.

Agreed.

> And these kind of schemes for "one global government" / "one common language" etc, do have parallels and historical precedents on ideas such that of the Third Reich. An occupied, German speaking Europe, if not world, was indeed one of their stated goals.

Your argument is basically: "The Nazis did X, hence we should never do X - for all X". I think this is a fallacy. There has to be difference between subduing Europe/the world and proposing to standardize language as a tool of communication for greater peace and more collaboration. I don't think choosing a standard language is any more sinister than choosing standard units of measurement or base 10 numbers.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
> Having a distinct culture doesn't necessitate having a distinct language, but having an existing distinct culture in a specific language necessitates preserving the language for preserving it

I'm not saying other languages shouldn't be preserved. I'm saying there should be a standard language. I don't think that one precludes the other.

> An english speaking China will be a very different culture

Maybe, but why would that be worse (or better for that matter)?

> And we haven't even mentioned the Shapir/Worf hypothesis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity

That's an interesting point, but on the other hand I'm still not convinced that this means that having a lot of distinct languages is "better". While on the other hand, there would be clear benefits to everyone speaking the same language or having at least one common language.

> You mean besides obliterating every existing culture and using it for parts?

Isn't that what always happens with all culture as it evolves?

> Everything that's wrong with monocultures of all kinds and singular ways of thinking and doing things [...]

This is where I strongly disagree. I think that some things are tools for a specific purpose and should be standardized. Language is a tool to convey facts and ideas.

I recognize that culture should not be standardized, of course.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
First off, I disagree that a common language means a common culture. There are a lot of distinct cultures that share a language.

Personally I don't care that much about the ease of doing business. Rather, I think standardizing on a language would have a real benefit for humanity as a whole.

Apart from practical considerations, think about how often people from other countries are somewhat dehumanized as an "other" or "the enemy" without you being able to get a view of the situation from the other side of the fence because of the language barrier. I'm wondering for instance if the Cold War could have happened in a world where both parties share a language while being connected over the Internet.

Also, congrats on the unnecessary Nazi comparison.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
Yeah but if everything can be effortlessly translated by everyone in a lossless manner, why not just standardize on a language then? Do languages at that point not become an unnecessary hindrance in personal communication without perceivable benefit?
jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
For what it's worth, I'm not a native English speaker and I don't live in an English-speaking country. However, I think I am "allowed" to voice this opinion without being labeled a racist, regardless of my native language.

I still think that there should be a standard language.

I really don't like that language is often conflated with having a distinct culture. I acknowledge that there is some connection between language and culture, but I don't think having a distinct culture necessitates a distinct language. There are many distinct cultures that share a language already. Even if that was the case, what would be wrong with cultivating a world wide culture? Also, some languages like Latin died out, while we still benefit from its speakers cultural achievements.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
You make a couple of great points and I concede that their would surely be some friction losses.

However, my point is that I think the pros outweigh the cons in this instance and that humanity would be better off if everyone could communicate with everyone else.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
Yes, my comment is for real.

I disagree that the language of choice should be Chinese or Spanish, because as far as I can tell more relevant content exists in English.

If however a standard language would be chosen and it was Spanish or Chinese, I would still be in favor of it.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
But that's exactly my point.

Instead of having a bunch of barely connected Internets walled off by language, why not standardize language and have one global venue of communication, where everyone can work together?

I am German and I often come across this with my friends, all of whom speak English as a second language. Yet they consume mostly the German parts of the Internet out of habit and convenience. But as far as I can tell, they are worse off for it, since they don't have access to a lot of the stuff the Internet has to offer.

That is especially obvious when searching for IT/tech/science topics, but also relevant in other contexts.

jnky··on Ask HN: Without Googling it, what's your definition of Serverless?
I define serverless as something that is client-only and/or peer-to-peer.

In that sense I'm baffled that you guys define Serverless as something that relies on services on Amazon's servers.

jnky··on A cool way to use natural language in JavaScript
On a related note: why are we putting up with other languages anyway? I've been asking myself for a long time why we (as in humanity) don't try to standardize on a language.

The language of the Internet is English for the most part, and since the Internet is the greatest facilitator of communication in human history, that standard language might as well be English.

I firmly believe the world would be a much better place if people from everywhere could communicate with each other without being inhibited by the language barrier.

I understand that this is not something that can be done overnight, but a lot of people learn English as a second langue today, so maybe a switch could be made in a generation or two, as people who don't speak English as a first or second language slowly die out.

jnky··on Universal Boilerplate for Creating Libraries with Rollup, JS, TS, GCC, and Babel
I honestly cannot tell if this is a legitimate thing or or a satirical commentary on the state of the various JS based ecosystems.
jnky··on Google Chrome 51 disables HTTP/2 on most Linux distros due to old OpenSSL
Just because something is no longer supported upstream does not mean that the distributions won't support it anymore.

As far as I can tell it is more likely the package maintainers will backport fixes to their old version in those cases.

jnky··on Hey Android, why no love for UTC?
On a related note, I live in Germany and like setting my device's language to en-US. I like the US news, as they are personalized to my taste anyway.

What I dislike is that temperature and distance in a couple of apps are now in US units, which I find unreasonable. I should be able to choose SI units if I want to.

Windows has been getting locale settings right for ages now. I find it sad that Android is so far behind in that regard.

jnky··on CaptionBot by Microsoft
> The issue here is that race relations in the U.S. are so convoluted and have so much history that it's literally impossible to tell what would be considered "racist" without a broad understanding of the culture and a comprehensive list of past racial slurs and grievances.

I understand, but isn't the logical conclusion that one cannot make a piece of technology (like an image caption bot) that is unaware of, for instance, such complex racial relations? And if so, should technological progress really be hampered by people's sense of outrage, even in the absence of malicious intent?

jnky··on CaptionBot by Microsoft
I don't think there is as much to understand as you make it out to be. People feel insulted when called apes, because it is frequently used as an insult.

It may well be taxonomically correct to say that humans as well as apes are primates and members of the Hominidae family, but that doesn't make it any less insulting.

Just because something is technically correct doesn't mean it isn't dehumanizing and suitable as an insult. I'm sure nobody would like to be called a sack of meat either.

jnky··on CaptionBot by Microsoft
I get where you're coming from, but black people being compared to apes is kind of an age old racist trope, so it is understandable that people would be unhappy about it.

Being mislabeled as a bear on the other hand does not generally carry the negative connotations as calling people apes, so I suspects that this is why CapitionBot is erring on this side of the classification.

jnky··on CaptionBot by Microsoft
I couldn't agree more.

I'm all for not discriminating people, but on the other hand I firmly believe that technical progress should not be second to people's feelings.

jnky··on CaptionBot by Microsoft
I found it curious that this Bot is really bad at recognizing apes: chimpanzees and gorillas specifically. I fed it a lot of the images from a Google image search for these animals and more often than not it either doesn't recognize anything or considers them bears.

I don't mean to offend, but I'm left wondering if the creators of image recognition services disincentivize their neural nets from recognizing something as an ape, gorilla or chimpanzee so as to avoid the same mistake Google made when it falsely recognized black people as gorillas [1].

[1] http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2015/07/01/google-mistakenly-tag...

jnky··on Let Me Get That Door for You: Remote Root Vulnerability in HID Door Controllers
> Google has had security vulns too. Do you find it "ironic"[^1] that Tavis would disclose vulns in other companies software?

No, the thing in this instance is that a) Trend Micro is a dedicated "security" company and b) the vulnerabilities in its software were especially negligent.

> You really should look up the definition of this word.

One definition I found was "happening in the opposite way to what is expected, and typically causing wry amusement because of this". Considering that, I'm quite happy with my usage of the word. That said, English is not my first language and I often see people nitpicking about this particular word. My feeling is that people understood me just fine despite of it.

jnky··on Let Me Get That Door for You: Remote Root Vulnerability in HID Door Controllers
I think it's rather ironic that this was published by Trend Micro, a company that has had at least two critical vulnerabilities in their own "security" solution:

https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=69... https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=77...

I realize that the two teams are probably unrelated, but maybe it would be worth verifying that their "security" software is indeed, you know, secure.

jnky··on Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide
The ESC is definitely seen as a fun contest for longer than that, at least in Germany. Case in point:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X3q7Y3fgTIc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJgszpNj7dY

jnky··on How Imgur Became a Megacommunity
Ah, yes. Eternal September. A problem almost as old as the WWW.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September

jnky··on How Wired Is Going to Handle Ad Blocking
Sure, there are browser plugins to override the HTTP user agent header and in my experience impersonating Google Bot works quite well. On the other hand, this tactic runs afoul with sites detecting your UA for browser specific hacks (especially with HTML5 video) or parts of a sites where bots are blocked by policy.

Also the IP ranges of search bots are more or less well known, so it would be trivial for publishers to block this kind of hack, if they wanted.

jnky··on Have FTDI kicked-off round 2 of the clone wars?
Just FYI, but displaying a Message Box from the context of a Windows device driver is not trivial and would add significant overhead to the driver.

I'd prefer it if FTDI weren't utter douchebags around this whole ordeal. I understand they have to make money, but since when is it a problem when devices are API-compatible with existing device drivers? As far as I'm concerned, this is a rather common and generally beneficial thing.

jnky··on Exploring the new .NET “dotnet” CLI
You may enjoy this dated blog post to give you a hint why the executable is 656KB, not to mention the runtime and garbace collection overhead:

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/abhinaba/archive/2008/09/15/how-many...

jnky··on Hostnames and usernames to reserve
I would suggest adding "autodiscover" to the list of disallowed hosts. It is used by Microsoft Outlook and Exchange ActiveSync clients (e.g. in smartphones) to automatically detect the correct server settings.
jnky··on Barren islands that countries never stop fighting over
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_China_anti-Japanese_demon...
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →