HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

johnday

1,394 karma · joined March 22, 2014

submissionscomments
johnday··on Wikenigma is an encyclopedia for topics with unknown answers
> For every n irrational numbers you name, I can name n+1 rationals.

I name "x+pi for every rational number x". Good luck!

johnday··on General Motors Streetcar Conspiracy
If we give these tax dollars to General Motors, they could turn into anything! Even tax dollars!
johnday··on Unix didn't use to support '#!', a brief history
Yeah, it's different: "Didn't use(d) to [...]" means that there was a time where it did not [...]; whereas "Never used to" means that at every previous time it did not [...].
johnday··on ISO name change for Türkiye
> Most English speakers would accept ñ and even write it e.g "El Niño event"

FWIW this may be true in the USA but in the UK and other non-NA English-speaking countries I don't think this holds.

johnday··on ISO name change for Türkiye
This is a naïve take which I find über annoying. Maybe I'll tell my local café owner, Emily Brontë, about it.
johnday··on Met Police UK Live Facial Recognition
> Comparing LGBT activism in rural Poland and ultra liberal parts of London, is not valid. Go to Luton or Yorkshire and see what happens...

Oh, you mean like Pride in Luton (https://prideinluton.org/) or Yorkshire Pride? (https://www.yorkshire.com/inspiration/features/yorkshire-pri...)

johnday··on Parsing with Haskell
In fact, I would recommend against enabling OverloadedStrings while writing parsers, since it can be confusing. Some bright spark added an IsString instance for IsString a => Parser a, meaning that "Hello" is a parser for the string "Hello". It also means that `many "Hello"` will parse "HelloHelloHello", which is kinda cool but confusing for a beginner.
johnday··on Texts, web searches about abortion have been used to prosecute women
> There are only 36 weeks in a pregnancy.

What an extremely weird thing to get wrong. Pregnancies are 40 weeks long.

johnday··on Haskell in Production: Channable
> Like it or not, most problems you will want to solve are not "purely functional" but rely on sound management of shared mutable state.

This is a claim which is certainly not true in all domains. For example, web applications and compilers, two of Haskell's "killer problem domains", do not heavily rely on shared mutable state. That said, Haskell's approach to shared mutable state is no less sensible than the rest of the language.

> Just look at all of the theoretical mumbo-jumbo associated with something like Lenses...now look at the utterly trivial problem they solve.

With all due respect if you believe this then I'm not sure you fully appreciate the problem that they solve. The terminology is indeed obtuse though.

> Even for a FP tool, Haskell is riddled with cruft. Look at the set of compiler pragmas that are pretty much required to be in any useful Haskell. Including basic crap like overloading the String type. These are hacks, pure and simple.

That's not fair. Haskell is a language that is (de facto) defined as a basis, the Report, plus a set of modernising features which have been implemented since. They're not hacks, they are deliberate optional language features. It's a different approach to most modern languages but no worse. A combined set of such features, called GHC2021, is the new "standard" and enables a huge swath of them by default.

If anything I'd say there is very little hype around Haskell. People look at it and think it's cool, but that's not because of people hyping it up. In fact every post/article I've read about Haskell has been extremely measured and open about its shortcomings.

Sorry if you just wanted to get something off your chest, but it makes me sad to see a perfectly fine language disparaged unfairly.

johnday··on US prison workers produce $11B worth of goods and services for little to no pay
> which means that's de facto what it says.

ITYM that it's de jure what it says. de facto is the opposite.

johnday··on “Cell Tower” Word Game
Because puzzles have unique solutions. This is often (but, admittedly, not always) part of the definition of a puzzle, as a specific form of a problem or a game.

If the fact that a solution is unique is given as part of the rules, then it can be used directly to rule out some classes of solution. That seems to be the case in Cell Tower.

johnday··on How to walk underground from Liverpool Street to Farringdon
The subway tunnel from London Bridge national rail station to the Underground has some of this, but I agree that it's astonishingly rare. Very few stations even have so much as a toilet, let alone a cafe or shops.

Personally I'm a very big fan of TfL's approach on this - the minimalism of the network is really quite nice.

johnday··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
And, obviously, (3) how do you recoup a multi-year investment across the period of only some months? Making games is extremely expensive and MMOs are by far the most expensive type to make.
johnday··on Netflix’s bad habits have caught up with it
> Disney pretty clearly proves rehashing the exact same thing over and over again is a never ending gold mine.

And yet, Disney's business itself was once a brand new, revolutionary idea.

Perhaps the table stakes aren't just "making something innovative", but creating opportunities for themselves to build the next Big Thing.

johnday··on Pipewire to replace Pulseaudion on Ubuntu 22.10
Seconding this. On my c.2020 high-end laptop running Win11, from switching on my BT headphones to hearing audio through them takes around 8 seconds and sometimes requires manual intervention. On my c.2013 laptop running Arch+PW, 3 seconds.
johnday··on “Amateur” programmer fought cancer with 50 Nvidia Geforce 1080Ti
> ...breast cancer is one of the most survivable (in part because, well, everyone loves boobs. Prostate cancer, on the other hand...)

Extremely weird take. Not least because the survival rates for breast cancer and prostate cancer are very similar.

johnday··on Does liberal bias affect academia? Advancing a deadlocked debate
You'd be hard pressed to find an academic who would be willing to defend the position that climate change doesn't exist, or that the sea is luminous purple.

The parameters of Brexit are sufficiently well understood by any academic who is involved enough to participate in such a debate. The reason that one finds it so difficult to find a defender for it is that Brexit is not driven by any well-meaning intent and any argument in favour of it is inherently intellectually dishonest and trivial to dismiss.

johnday··on Please Stop Using Grey Text
I do something similar!

Can highly recommend greasemonkey for automating the process. Once it's in place it makes the web so much nicer.

johnday··on 9-Euro-Ticket
It seems like an almost-free, unlimited-use ticket would suffer the same way.
johnday··on Plagiarized in a plagiarism atonement essay
The person I'm replying to dropped in "albeit with a reference" as if that's not the critical point.

If the author referred to in the original article had cited the plagiarism website, there would be no issue here whatsoever. It's the misrepresentation of others' ideas and rhetoric as one's own (paraphrased or otherwise) that's the problem here.

johnday··on Please Stop Using Grey Text
This will be significantly faster, since it only queries the DOM once, rather than O(n) times.
johnday··on Plagiarized in a plagiarism atonement essay
> It just baffles how much effort as humans of modern education and academia have put into being super mad for using other people's ideas. Sure, I agree that this guy is somewhat the victim and she shouldn't have done that.

Degrees are awarded off the back of people producing work. If you reproduce another's work instead of creating something original, even if you then go on to make superficial modifications afterwards, you have not produced work and gaining qualifications off the back of that is fraudulent. Citations of sourced work, among other things, exist to declare the parts of work which are not your own.

johnday··on Plagiarized in a plagiarism atonement essay
They're not written completely differently. They share the same structure and cover the same content using the same rhetorical devices. The fact that they use different words does not diminish the fact that this is plagiarism.
johnday··on Plagiarized in a plagiarism atonement essay
That's not plagiarism, that's (cited) paraphrasing. In this case, the author of the original work is explicitly named. It's literally step one in the link that you just posted.

Plagiarism is taking someone else's work and presenting it as your own, original, work. The two are fundamentally different. Confusion between them is the essence of the problem at hand.

johnday··on Bluetooth relay attacks allow Tesla Model 3 / Y to be unlocked and driven away
MITM is more general and includes the case where the MITM alters the information in transit to misrepresent the communications of the two parties to each other.
johnday··on How did Tropicana lose $30M in a packaging redesign?
I'm not sure if you're being sarcastic, but I really don't think this is "clear to consumers".
johnday··on See's Candies is Warren Buffett’s ‘dream’ investment
Per the end of the attached article, you're wrong - maybe their price would quadruple, but their value would not change at all.
johnday··on Patenting Your Perpetual Motion Machine
No - the second law of thermodynamics implies that, sadly, the ride will come to a stop eventually.
johnday··on Patenting Your Perpetual Motion Machine
Pseudorandomly generated data is not random data. There is no way to compress actually random information, by definition.
johnday··on Preview, the Mac app people forget about
I believe that powertoys enables this.
← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →