HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

joshjkim

411 karma · joined September 8, 2013

josh at bandcamp dot com
submissionscomments
joshjkim··on Dropbox Is in Talks with Advisers for Possible 2017 IPO
yes, possible to early exercise an ISO and then elect 83(b).

however, if you definitely want to early exercise, NSO is preferable since an NSO has more favorable tax treatment wrt to timing: for NSO, long-term capital gain treatment starts one year after exercise, whereas for an ISO you need to wait both one year after exercise AND two years after the option grant date.

so, specifically: if you early exercise an ISO on the day it is granted, you have to wait 2 years for LTCG treatment vs. with an NSO, you only have to wait one year after you exercise, even if it's on the date of grant.

joshjkim··on This Is Your Life, Brought to You by Private Equity
private equity specifically does mean stock that is not publicly traded. BUT (and I may be wrong here, so apologies if I am!) I think some of the confusion may be that the term "private equity" is more commonly/generally used to describe private equity funds and their investment strategies.

In that case, private equity funds are essentially investment funds with a strategy something like this (and I'm trying to be as bland in description here as possible, as private equity fund strategies very often result in some unpopular results - ie. mass layoffs, selling for parts, etc.): purchase a controlling interest in a company (often times financing the purchase with debt acquired by the company they are purchasing), operate the company with a super focus on some sort of efficiency (usually profitability or revenue), and then re-sell the company 3-5 years later at a 2-5X return (ideally, of course sometime that doesn't happen).

the reason they are called private equity funds is that in order to get a "controlling interest", PE funds almost always either target (1) smaller private (usually industrial) companies that are operated by their owners (my cousin works at a fund that focuses on oil-services companies that are private but have $100m+ in annual revenue) or (2) public companies that they think are undervalued by the market or poorly run that they can "take private" by purchasing all the stock and then running more efficiently (these are the big sexy PE deals, biggest recent example is: Dell - http://www.forbes.com/sites/connieguglielmo/2013/10/30/you-w...)

there's a WHOLE lot of other details that I won't get into on how PE funds work, and about how PE funds are now so massive that they almost act like unregulated banks and have a bunch of strategies other than the one I described above, but that's the traditional fund strategy (at least based on my experience) and I think a good place to start.

Another good way to learn would be to learn more about the biggest PE funds themselves:

KKR: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kohlberg_Kravis_Roberts TPG: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TPG_Capital Silverlake: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silver_Lake_Partners (work in tech a lot, did the skype deal where they bought from eBay and sold to MS)

Another way to learn more might be learning how a leveraged buy out (LBO) works, as this is one of the more traditional PE fund financing strategies for their deals: http://www.investopedia.com/articles/financial-theory/08/lev...

If you really get into it, the book "Barbarians at the Gate" is considered a classic book written by two WSJ journalists about KKR's takeover of RJR Nabisco, the largest PE deal in history ($25b in 1988), I enjoyed it!

joshjkim··on iPhone Sales Drop, and Apple’s 13-Year Surge Ebbs
A recent book that tries to address this (kinda annoying title): http://www.rushkoff.com/books/throwing-rocks-at-the-google-b...
joshjkim··on Tech Startups Choose to Stay Private in I.P.O. Standoff
I agree - put another way, bad-but-hyped companies are hiding in the private markets, because they can maintain a high-valuation with a strong PPT and unaudited financials vs. going public getting punished by the market for weak (maybe terrible) GAAP financials.

but, like you said - we just don't know, and it appears they don't want us to know. and that makes me think: in general if someone is keeping something from the public, what are the chances its good vs. bad? I'd say it skews to the latter =)

Sometimes, it's justifiable if the company really needs a private period to invest deeply in something the public markets may not understand, but I'd say mostly it's not - the ongoing markdowns by traditional investors is at least one indicator.

joshjkim··on Tech Startups Choose to Stay Private in I.P.O. Standoff
admittedly 0 in the last quarter is unusual, but the trend is explainable, and it's weird that the article acts like there's some sort of mystery here, when the reasons for the trend seem pretty clear (and have been discussed at length before..):

tech companies are not going public because

1. They don't have to (they can raise just as much $$ in the private markets with far less scrutiny) and

2. Going public is a huge pain that most people want to avoid (reporting, quarterly (read: short-term) goals, public scrutiny).

Also, a bunch of other reasons, but that seems like the two most well-known factors that for some reason are not mentioned at all in the article..unless I'm missing something.

The article hints that the market's poor reaction to recent IPOs is a major factor, but I'd say it's less than the two I mentioned above, though I can't quantify that here.

joshjkim··on The company that bribed the world
ah yes - that is right. I attempted to say something like this when I mentioned western corp's ability to "overpay vs. the local bribery market" and all that, though I admit I didn't flush it very well out. here's a try: this is the natural result of massive western corps having access to economies that rely on bribery wide-scale, and what sucks is that, due to the western companies massive resources relative to the local economy, the bribery gets much further out of hand and continues longer vs. if the local economy had remained isolated.
joshjkim··on The company that bribed the world
Cynical reaction: well, we all knew someone was doing it, now we've identified a few.

One thing I can't help think here is: this is just another uncomfortable truth re: what a truly global economy looks like (frankly, similar the factory jobs leaving the US for cheaper labor countries, etc.). The bottom line is that in many developing countries, bribery is part of the economy, and if western companies want to engage in the economies of those countries, then it's not surprising that they need to participate wholly. Because of western anti-corruption laws, they of course can't engage directly, so these Unaoil folks found a solid business opportunity to exploit.

What sucks of course is that western companies often have funds to overpay vs. the local bribery market, so they end up reducing local economic competition, slowing internal development, flooding incumbents with cash, keep incumbents in power longer than they would be otherwise, and contribute to their illegitimacy.

They still should stop, I guess my point is that corrupt systems (usually) pre-existed western corp. participation. If I'm being optimistic, stories like this hopefully will motivate the US and other western gov. to recognize this reality, and then actually develop and enforce international laws to handle this effectively - though I wouldn't hold my breath =)

(Of course, the involvement of western governments in colonization and in creating this atmosphere is a whole other discussion, which I won't start here..ha)

joshjkim··on The company that bribed the world
In terms of developing countries that are the subject of this story (with no real campaign finance frameworks and/or enforcement, and maybe not even open elections), I think you're right to say there's probably no real difference.

However, in the US and other countries with (relatively) developed election and legislation processes, I think there's some key differences:

Lobbying usually requires a level of policy rationalization (however disingenuous) that bribery does not. Lobbyist can say behind closed doors that they want X for selfish reasons, but in order for it to be politically tenable the legislator usually will require at least some publicly defensible rationalization for the action.

Similarly, lobbying usually involves the legislative process and getting a political actor to make certain political/legislative decisions that would benefit the lobbyist's clients. Bribe's usually involves getting a person in power to make decisions that often don't involve the political process or legislations, like the awarding of a contract by an agency under their control, or withholding an investigation.

Seen this way, lobbying can be and has been characterized as interest groups subsidizing the legislative process by providing competing research and proposals to an understaffed legislature. Whether that's a good or bad of making law is another discussion, but I think it's fair to say that bribery could not be considered that way, and therefore serves no acceptable public purpose other than the enrichment of the briber and bribee.

joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
There's a couple answers here - as you mentioned, marketing is a huge cost, and they have to support a massive global ad sales organization as well to support the free tier.

IMO, what's really more problematic and complicated is their economic arrangement with the major labels, which, while ostensibly "70/30" is actually way more complicated than that. The article does a decent job of explaining it: http://www.theverge.com/2015/5/19/8621581/sony-music-spotify...

TL;DR: to induce a major label to sign, Spotify had to give them a sweetheart deal, including minimum per stream payments, minimum % of ad revenue, and free ad space.

The really tricky things to consider are: usage-based and per subscriber minimums. Hard to determine exactly, but it's highly possible that Spotify is much worse off than the 30/70 spotify/label split.

Also, note that there's a good chance the contract is already re-negotiated since that was published, and given Apple Music, likely not in Spotify's favor.

joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
Good point - it's all or nothing for Spotify, they are not profitable at current scale and need critical mass re: subscribers + defense against Apple, and if they don't get there, then they are dead anyhow.
joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
Ya - sucks. I said this in a comment below, but also relevant here: capital > labor
joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
heh true, they might not care at all - Apple makes more $$ in a quarter than several Spotify market caps. But, here's a few theories: if Spotify keeps calling itself the "leader" in streaming and Apple decides it wants this to stop, it would be an easy/cheap way to impact Spotify's brand negatively, and even potentially bring them down entirely. Alternatively, by driving the price down, it could also force Spotify to explore selling itself at a low price (see: Pandora), and if Apple wanted some fast/easy subscribers, it could acquire them cheaply.
joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
True - probably, founders have no choice. One side note though: it's increasingly common for founder's to cash out a few million in later stage rounds, often under wraps, to "keep them from being tempted to take lower buyout offers" is the usual theory, which is code for getting them to be more aligned with the investors. In any case, those deals are often not accessible to employees, just founders.

The most cynical take is that the investors are buying them off to be not just more aligned with investors, but less aligned with employees =)

joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
Very little can be done, and it's designed that way. Capital > labor, all that.

The best option is to attempt downside protection by selling shares in the secondary market, even at a discount - of course, Spotify being a EU company, I don't know how difficult it is to do that, though I imagine (like most other things) it's more regulated (aka. tougher to do) than in the US. Even if easy, it's getting harder and harder to find secondary market buyers.

Rough out there!

joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
Oh, and I would not be surprised if Apple basically times major announcements re: Apple Music (subscriber numbers, if good, or new product features, etc.) around Spotify's IPO date and first earnings call to kill the pricing on both front - if I were Apple, I know I would =)
joshjkim··on Spotify raises $1B in debt with devilish terms to fight Apple Music
"TPG and Dragoneer can sell their shares just 90 days after the IPO, before the 180-day lockup period ends for Spotify’s employees and other investors."

Among many the bad terms disclosed in the article, IMO this is probably the worst - basically, this right is a license to cash out and torpedo the company within 3 months (just the right amount of time to see how the market reacts to Spotify's first earnings call as a public company..), leaving the other investors (and employee common stock holders!) with greatly devalued stock.

Of course they have a disincentive not to do this: if they did start to sell after 90 days, the stock would start plummeting before they could sell all shares, so the last shares that TPG/Dragoneer sell would be worth much less than the first bucket of shares, but if they do sell it means that things are very, very bad and they'd rather cut their (20% discounted...) losses, and will be much, much better off than the other investors and employees 3 months later.

godspeed Spotify!

joshjkim··on Ask HN: Best payment processor?
ah yes, ur right. not cheaper.
joshjkim··on Ask HN: Best payment processor?
also - it would be good to know, are they:

1. payments from customers to you

2. payments from you to users

3. revshare marketplace payments (payments between two users, of which you take % a cut)

4. pure marketplace payments (payments between two users, and you charge a flat fee)

5. something else?

that would also impact what suggestions I and other would have, as different services are better than others for each case.

joshjkim··on Ask HN: Best payment processor?
not sure if low margins = smaller $$ value for each payment or just small % your taking, but Paypal offers a micro-transaction fee rate: 5% + 5 cents (USD). For transactions under $12, this is usually preferable to the standard rates from Paypal or Stripe. If transaction size goes above and below that, you can set-up two separate accounts and direct payments above a threshold to one account and payments below the threshold to another account. we do that at my company, and it saves us LOADS in fees.

Last I checked, no other service has any separate fee for micropayments. Paypal doesn't make it easy to find this info out, but it definitely still offers the product.

of course paypal can be really, really annoying to work with, as their code is VERY old and their APIs can be confusing. They also have a weird variety of products that semi-overlap, so selection of which specific product to use can be confusing (Express Checkout vs. Instant Checkout vs. Adaptive payments..?).

a few other things to note: paypal's international coverage is much better than any other provider, so if you want to expand to EU or South America quickly, they are good for that. also, paypals payout process (MassPay) is much easier to use than ACH or any other solutions I've seen, and much cheaper (2% transaction fee for payouts). Also, all the payee needs is an email address, no bank account info, etc.

Truthfully, those are two reasons we still use Paypal. Otherwise, it kinda sucks =)

joshjkim··on Entry-Level Startup Jobs Are Now Mostly Dead Ends in the Boondocks
3 reasons that, in early stages, startups have customer service at their HQs (IMO), and why it makes (financial) sense to move them to lower cost areas when a startup reaches a certain size:

(1) at the early stage basically everyone is part of customer support in that they are addressing/solving a slew of new/unanticipated problems together in real time and therefore its beneficial/valuable to have everyone in the same place. they also (usually) don't know how to run a customer service organization and are learning how it goes on the fly, esp. for the new product.

Later, the product matures and the majority of customer issues and their solutions are known and the process for addressing them can be (mostly) crystallized into a pre-determined set of responses, meaning that the customer service team can be separated from the rest of the organization. This is usually identified (or forced) by a more experienced customer service manager trained at a larger organization.

(2) at an early stage, costs associated with customer service are still relatively low vs. other investments (ie. product development, customer acquisition, technical hiring) so it seems relatively cheap to grow (you can hire 3-4 CS people for the price of one eng. in SF)

Later, as the organization grows, customer service can quickly balloon into a massive, expensive organization that grows in a more linear relationship with business/customer growth vs. product or dev teams, which (ideally) can be more leveraged.

(3) at the early stage, they are focused more on growth than profitability, so they aren't looking to optimize for lowering customer support costs and are more focused on the speed at which they are solving customer problems, aka. resolving impediments to growth.

Later, when it comes time to pay the piper (which is what appears to be happening with many, many on-demand startups..), customer service is a very easy place to try and cut costs, esp. when up until this point they had been run very inefficiently.

conclusion:

Once a company realizes that their support teams don't need to be at the HQ anymore, that the teams are inefficient and (oh shit!) they want to (try and) be profitable, it makes a lot of sense to move the customer service team to a lower cost location, or outsource it entirely. there's a reason most large, mature corporations do it.

joshjkim··on Dropbox Shares Offered at 34% Discount in Secondary Market
This is a copy/paste from a prior HN discussion that I had:

[it's definitely true] that employees are discouraged from seeking buyers because there is an unspoken implication that this means the employee is "losing faith" or "believes less" in the company, or is getting ready to leave.

If the party line is: "hey, we are going to be a billion dollar company!" and then one employee says "hey, I want to sell at this $100M valuation", even if the $100M is a solid upside from the employees strike price the next natural question for the founder is: "hey, why would you sell at this valuation if we all know we are going to unicorn?" Lots of people are reasonable and could understand many good reasons to sell at that point, but in high-growth culture those are not always appreciated. Sure, employee can/should suck it up, but it still makes it more challenging.

Generally, I think this is why company's should more regularly organize secondaries, it removes this dynamic to a certain extent.

joshjkim··on Munchery’s chief customer experience officer leaves company (after 5 mo)
ha yes, these are always juicy (having seen a few from the inside...). I would have loved to see the maneuverings during E. Pao's departure from Reddit, for example. Overall, for most the execs and companies, a healthy severance package and accelerated vesting on equity is usually enough to keep things quiet with a separation agreement that contains a mutual non-disparagement clause.

On a separate note, Zenefits recent public breakup is one that wasn't spared, and Buzzfeed did a decent job summarizing IMO:

http://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden/zenefits-ceo-parker-con...

http://www.buzzfeed.com/williamalden/how-high-flying-zenefit...

joshjkim··on Lyft Settles Worker Classification Lawsuit for $12.25M
same here - e-mail in my profile. i have a good amt of experience on this type of stuff.
joshjkim··on SoundCloud Will Be Worth More Than Spotify
IDM could also stand for "intelligent dance music"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_dance_music

lame term i think, but it exists!

joshjkim··on Big Company vs. Startup Work and Compensation
2 things: (1) this may change soon but for the past 2 years I've seen a decent % of startups pay around the Google scale ($130-$160), with raises not too far from the scale set-out in the article. However, the big difference of course is that many of these startups will never make it to year 5... (2) this should be qualified as "...for Engineers" (maybe implied by the venue ha). The math is pretty different when you talk about (a) finance/consultant types deciding between big institutions and startups [pay is MUCH worse unless you win big, but hours and work satisfactions are higher..or supposed to be] and (b) sales/ops types [pay is comparable, hours are worse, but potential impact is higher..or supposed to be].
joshjkim··on Financial Misstatements
Yes, they do! Other VCs are kind of following suit, but it sure cuts into those management fees so they aren't running to it =)
joshjkim··on Financial Misstatements
you are right, I've worked with a few. Problem is that it's a cost to the company they often don't want and they don't value the work (I think this is what SA is trying to change). Also, vetting/hiring folks etc. is it's own burden. VC pushing this gets rid of the friction and forces founders to take this seriously.

Agreed they may have divided loyalty, hopefully mitigated by a very temporary relationship and the fact that at early stages, VCs and founders should be super aligned, at least around the ops numbers (sale decisions, etc. are a totally different ballgame for sure).

joshjkim··on Financial Misstatements
Interesting idea: VCs should have in-house finance folks specifically meant to work with portfolio companies who spent a few days a month for year 1 after investment, or until the company gets it own finance team. Most VCs do less than 10-15 deals a year, so this seems tolerable and a relatively low cost way of to really know what's going on with the portfolio. (I know some VCs already kind of do this (Vantage Point). Also, harder for YC, given # of investments, so maybe not as applicable for true seed funds but still might be worth it - I'm sure they could get 5 mid-career CPAs for the price of one partner, and they would love the job! I think)

The fun part is that then the VCs will have a direct line into the company's nitty-gritty operations, which really they are entitled to receive anyhow (though usually they just take the board deck at its word..which is not always good).

This might suck for the company since you have the VC in-the-know on your nitty-gritty (though I'd argue that if you don't want them in-the-know, you should not have taken their $$...though I understand it's more complicated than that haha), BUT that might also serve to incentivize the company to build out the finance team quickly, and also give the management team a taste of what a good finance person can provide (assuming the person the VC provides is good, which they should be if they are to be trusted with multiple portfolio companies).

joshjkim··on Leaked Uber financials from 2012 to 2014
You are right, IF the early markets are still not profitable - the key numbers that we don't have are: how are the first 100 cities they launched doing? how are the first 10 cities they launched doing? If those cities have achieved profitability or are approaching it, then it works. Unfortunately, we don't have those #s.

However, if you look here there's some indication that earlier markets were at least closing the operating loss gap: QQ4.12: 8.2M / 7.0M Q1.13: 12.9M / 7.3M Q2.13: 19.3M / 8.1M

Losses slowed dramatically here, while revenue grew. Note, Uber was still launching cities at this point, but had already taken most of the major US markets - my guess is that SF + NY + LA were getting closer to paying for themselves while they streamlined their launch process into smaller markets in the US. I feel OK making that guess because it's hard to believe that an investor would not have asked for that, and it's hard to believe that an investor would value Uber at $3.5B (the valuation at that time) if that wasn't happening. (Note - I understand that investors are not always actually this rational, I'm just making an assumption in this case).

I imagine the pitch was: look at our early markets, they are cash-cows, and we know how to make them. Now, give us $XB to go make more of these cash-cows please and don't ask us about losses for a long time, thanks! Which is why they don't really care about these leaked #s.

joshjkim··on Leaked Uber financials from 2012 to 2014
Basic rundown of Rev / Loss from reports:

Q1.12: 1.4M / 3.4M Q2.12: 2.1M /2.3M Q3.12: 4.3M / 5.4M Q4.12: 8.2M / 7.0M Q1.13: 12.9M / 7.3M Q2.13: 19.3M / 8.1M 2013 (total): 104M / 56M Q1.14: 45.6M / 52.2M Q2.13: 56.9M / 108.8M

Rev grew faster than losses consistently all through 2012 and 2013 which is really amazing (2013 is when Uber jumped from a 330M valuation to a 3.5B valuation so investors noticed too)...then losses abruptly charged ahead in 2014 (see data pulled below).

Uber launched China in Q1 of 2014 - they are basically betting huge on China / India, and smartly being very clear to their investors that the $$ is for that very costly cause, so they can earmark the cash they are burning for international expansion as "meant to be burned." Also, if the bet goes the wrong way, they can (sort of) cleanly write it off as a failed (billion dollar) project, and ask investors to focus on their (hopefully by then) cash-cow business in the US.

Burn is all about international expansion, which is SUPER expensive, especially at the rate they are attempting. There is an insane learning curve that costs a lot of money to get on the other side of (hiring, culture, regulations, consumers, marketing are all different in each country - not to mention the fact that local competitors have all those in line already!) - look at pretty much any major US company that has attempted to succeed in China.

Good luck!

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →