HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jospoortvliet

79 karma · joined April 21, 2015

People person, technology enthusiast and all-things-open evangelist. Community manager at ownCloud, SUSE and KDE marketing veteran, loves biking through Berlin and cooking for friends and family.
submissionscomments
jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
NodeJS didn't exist, Python is slow and Go scales fine on ONE server but doesn't scale horizontally very well... while PHP scales perfectly that way. It has downsides, which is why we pick other languages for some components (our Spreed High Performance Back-end for Nextcloud Talk is written in Go, our app store in Ruby).

But talk was initially written in Go, which made it harder to install, so we actually rewrote it in PHP... There's a lot of value in having a built-in app store that is easy to use from the web UI. There is a reason why the web runs on PHP. And it isn't because it is perfect, but it has some neath advantages that just help in many scenarios.

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Yup. Also, VC funding? Heck no, we started Nextcloud because VC funding had bankrupted and blown up ownCloud... I mean, seriously. It is now owned by a German real estate agent...
jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
All for avoiding Panini's, but we're a Content Collaboration Platform - and Nextcloud Social fits certainly well in that.

WRT server-side encryption, it gets work all the time, though it is mostly an enterprise feature that gets love when enterprises pay for that. Very few volunteers work on it, if any. Help is of course welcome, in the end - either somebody pays for it, or somebody puts in free time.

This is true for every open source project, of course.

WRT MediaGoblin, no worries, it isn't like Nextcloud Social has all our attention. I guestimate it is at most 5% of our engineering time, if that. That is enough to make it work and improve it release over release, and we'll put in more if there is customer interest or lots of community contributions, but we always start such new things small. Talk started as a night-long-hacking-to-prove-it-could-be-done and now has 3-4 engineers on it full-time, because customers want to pay for it. Which also means it doesn't take away from other things - if we didn't do it, we simply couldn't afford these engineers in the first place. It isn't like they would work on server-side encryption ;-)

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Sorry, we don't offer that. We focus, instead, on paid support for larger enterprises, ideally well over 100 users. This way we don't get tempted trying to monetize home or small enterprise users, but instead have an incentive to provide them something that works out of the box so they 1. don't ask questions on the forums/twitter/etc and 2. advocate for what a great solution Nextcloud is!

So, it should 'simply' be good enough for home and SMB users. If it is, we failed, and I'm sorry for that and hope we can fix it!

Of course, nothing is ever perfect, especially given the unlimited ways people use Nextcloud and the hundreds of thousands of Nextcloud servers out there...

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
3-5 pics per hour is indeed insane, that is a certainly some bug. Especially if it is iOS specific. Be sure to file the bug with as much info as possible (see if you can probe network activity or just see if the app uploads a file and waits for 10 minutes or something...)

We do very frequent releases so perhaps it'll just be fixed at some point ;-)

Good luck and sorry for the problem!

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Sorry to hear it broke.

Try logging a support ticket on portal.nextcloud.com. LDAP is an enterprise feature so it is an area where we strongly focus on customers and their issues first, and if none of our customers experience this problem it can take a long time to get resolved as we're always very busy...

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Hi,

Sorry to hear about the bad experience, that shouldn't happen. We explicitly design Nextcloud to be seamless for small installations like yours - but if you need support, you can simply purchase it directly on https://nextcloud.com/enterprise/buy/ so you don't need to wait for sales people. We'll fix your issues for sure.

Keep in mind: using a bog-standard LAMP stack is your best bet, but you can always add the 1-day installation help to let an expert guide you through the decisions on how to integrate in your infrastructure. We have hundreds of customers with literally tens of millions of users deployed, so by now pretty much every problem has been seen and can be fixed ;-)

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Of course, you lose support for 2FA, have crappy notifications and activity feed and so on, plus it is entirely unsupported so I'd recommend against that...
jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
That's really a nice, sympathetic idea.

The main issue with that is that it simply doesn't provide anywhere near enough money to pay a real team.

Our forums, for example, have about 17.7k users according to help.nextcloud.com/about

Let's say we get ALL those users to pay 10 bucks per year. Not going to happen, of course - but let's say we put in a lot of effort there. That can pay for 3-4 developers. We have 25. Should we really spend time on that? Or spend that energy on getting a few big customers who pay 100K each?

We have explicitly chosen not to even TRY to monetize any installation under 50-100 users.

That means we don't try to squeeze money out of small businesses and home users (for example by not fixing issues for those users to try and get them to sign a contract). Instead, our incentive is to make Nextcloud easy and good enough that anyone <100 users can just use it without needing us. Because then 1. they don't ask too many questions on our forums and github and twitter etc and 2. they advocate for how great Nextcloud is to our real potential customers: businesses with 500 to 50 million users.

Of course, if community members want to donate or if contributors want to earn a cup of coffee, there's always https://www.bountysource.com/teams/nextcloud But our employees aren't allowed to take money out of that, they have to donate it back to issues they/we care about.

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Hi Markus,

I'd argue the opposite, actually, ownCloud is betting on providing hosting for small and medium businesses, while Nextcloud targets large businesses.

And that is what reality shows. Nextcloud has far larger customers than ownCloud, which breaks down at instances over 50K users. The only large-ish oC setup is actually a bunch of separate universities.

Nextcloud is far more scalable. Thanks to Global Scale, our largest installation has tens of millions of users on a single instance, and customers like the German government (300K users) wouldn't be able to work with oC unless they split up their users and create silos.

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
... and it is all over HTTPS, so certainly very 'web', no need for special ports etc.

See https://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
If you're not sure about the security you can firewall it of course, but keep in mind we pay 5K to anyone who can find a remote execute vulnerability in Nextcloud (and smaller amounts for smaller bugs).
jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
It is all apps. You can even disable sharing. Heck, you can disable the Files UI...

Note that most people use Nextcloud to work with others and features like these are crucial to their productivity. In the end, we're guided by community contributions and customer demand... Luckily you can disable things you don't like :D

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
That is like saying ice cream makers should focus on the 'core' tastes, claiming that that is banana and vanilla because you like those.

For you calendar and contacts are core for a file sync and share software? Above somebody also asked us to focus on 'core', meaning adding ACL's and probably dropping the calendar/contacts.

So it's like the fable where god decides to ask people what weather they want and everyone wants something different so he decides to go back to doing whatever the fuck he wanted. We just keep letting ourselves guided by contributors and customers...

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Let's be honest, if we did a release with only stabilization, it might get us more users. Not more customers. And it is customers who pay for the development.

Everyone asks us to focus "on the basics" and then claim their pet feature requests are, of course, basics. ACL's and user mgmt in your case, perfectly fine features, but features nonetheless.

In the end, our development is guided by the community and customers. If you're not either, we might not do what you want... That's the reality of any open source project.

And you're right, for a large installation, you should obviously get an onsite engineer, or, much better, a contract with us which is both cheaper and better. That's what most larger installations do, and that is how we earn the money to make Nextcloud better.

WRT the E2E, that sadly took a whole lot longer to get working than we had expected. Of course, if you think it is important or need it, time and money can speed it up, we have only so much of those.

jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
Thanks for helping to fix the bugs, that's the best way of getting this improved ;-)
jospoortvliet··on Nextcloud introduces social features, joins the fediverse
All depends on your server and settings and network of course... But the mobile clients could probably do more uploads in parallel, like the desktop client does.

Just keep in mind it uploads the original files, not, like eg whatsapp, downsized, compressed one that is 1/10th the size...

jospoortvliet··on Japan to add millions of new nodes to federated Nextcloud network
try nextcloud.com/migration - but keep in mind that it is slowly getting harder and harder to switch. We try to keep it easy and smooth but ownCloud is backporting a lot of potentially breaking changes in their 'stable' branch, rewriting low-level code etc. Their engineers are of course new to the code base so they make, well, different choices than we would make :D

While feature-wise, we're still not really missing anything oC has, the underlying codebase is really diverging, we're not really merging any code from oC since a year now...

Migration will become a real, risky pita at some point I'm afraid. Apps are already dropping compatibility and mobile apps, too.

jospoortvliet··on Japan to add millions of new nodes to federated Nextcloud network
From what I understand of STUN and TURN, there is absolutely no point running STUN an TURN on the same server as Nextcloud - if you do, you could just as well skip running them in the first place. STUN and TURN only help if they are on a dedicated box, as close to a internet root server as possible, ideally in a big datacenter somewhere on the internet backbone. They can't be behind firewalls and layers of routers...

So your performance will already improve if you delete your local STUN and TURN and use the Nextcloud STUN as our free STUN runs in a big data center. Then you have to find a TURN somewhere that you can run also close to the backbone, or try using without...

Yes, running STUN and TURN properly is a pita.

I'm no super expert so check what I'm saying, but this is based on my best understanding of what these do and I had to write our documentation for customers about our Spreed High Performance Backend which, among other things, does STUN and TURN ;-) (Nextcloud marketing dude here)

jospoortvliet··on GitLab acquires Gitter, will open-source the code
True. Still, I think most companies will take cost of living in the area where the potential employee lives into account. When thinking about it it seems odd, indeed. I guess it is kind of normal and expected. But entirely rational it is not.
jospoortvliet··on GitLab acquires Gitter, will open-source the code
I'd LOVE to hear what red flags are in the comment from the recruiter or the other person - whom I guess is a manager. I've re-read it a few times but I see nothing but reasonableness. Then again, I'm neither a developer myself (does that make a difference) nor a recruiter...
jospoortvliet··on The Gig Economy Celebrates Working To Excess
I'd go as far as claiming Berlin is a very low paid place in Europe. Living costs and standards are quite low here compared to Munich or Amsterdam. You'd earn 50% more there for the same work.
jospoortvliet··on When Factory Jobs Vanish, Men Become Less Desirable Partners
Human nature isn't anywhere near as simplistic as economists tend to believe. That is why half the theories doesn't work in reality, people are far from the rational actors they're made out to be.
jospoortvliet··on Men not at work: Why so many men aged 25 to 54 are not working (2016)
Yet this has little to do with socialism but rather with Kleptocracy, which is the same in USA and now coming to the US with this new president.

Pretty much everywhere in the world, lower income inequality is closely correlated with being a nicer place to live in for everyone - like Finland, Sweden, Norway, Netherlands, Germany and so on.

That there are countries where the government, under the ruse of either socialist or libertarian policies, steals from its people has little to do with it.

jospoortvliet··on Men not at work: Why so many men aged 25 to 54 are not working (2016)
I tend to agree with this, yeah. There is plenty of room for change in how we run the economy giving everyone a chance for a good job.

For one - the working hours in the US are crazy. Cap it at 32 hours and badaboom, everyone has a job. Combined with a decent minimum wage, you'd be fine. And yes, if this would result in economic collapse, Europe would've gone to sheise a looooong time ago yet the countries rated as best to live are the ones who have executed exactly that recipe.

jospoortvliet··on A defense of Christianity helped unlock the secrets of the brain
Lots of Muslims blow themselves up, believing in 77 virgins and stuff like that. Is that proof of those virgins or merely their belief?

I appreciate the list of martyrs but it is hardly unique to Christianity.

jospoortvliet··on A defense of Christianity helped unlock the secrets of the brain
Well, no, most of his claims were quite common in the time, not much is radical. Also most of those we only know 2nd or third hand and we know it's been heavily redacted on the way. If radical claims are a reason to consider someone divine, Buddha has much better cards.
jospoortvliet··on Things You Notice When You Quit the News
I'm sure this is what is happening. Income from readership of physical paper goes down, pressure mounts and even reputable news papers feel thsy have little choice... ask any journalist. It is brutal, earning a decent living is hard, earning it from actual quality reporting is impossible because the vast majority of customers can't separate anote article written in 10 minutes without any research or fact checking from the results of a 1 year research has undercover project...

So yeah, no surprise they deliver more of the 10 minute pieces and quality goes down. If we don't pay we get what we pay for - nothing. Hot air..

jospoortvliet··on Things You Notice When You Quit the News
I suppose fake news has been totally normal in the showbizz coverage world - and popular. Now it goes mainstream and people complain...
jospoortvliet··on Venezuela’s Currency Has Had its Biggest Monthly Collapse
... Problem is that we can only do cider things based on the information we have and to the extend we understand the issues. Controlling media and limiting education are two powerful ways in which both governments and companies control people.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →