HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kapowaz

237 karma · joined February 6, 2012

submissionscomments
kapowaz··on No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app
Whilst I agree with some of the sentiments the article conveys, I'm doubtful that many people who feel this strongly actually would bother to go through these steps. Of those news organisations whose sites you regularly read, which of them actually do this and of those which would you feel happy installing an app for? I read numerous news articles on the web, but I only have one news app installed (for The Guardian), and they don't even exhibit this behaviour.

It would seem to me the most practical thing to do is to just dismiss the alert, cluck my tongue at the site's hubris, then read the article within the mobile browser — which more often than not is an option. Where it is not, to actually go down the route of installing the app of an organisation that manifestly has contempt for the end user, then upon discovering it offers up a terrible experience conclude this is fait accompli in the debate of web vs native apps seems like wilful prejudice.

The concluding remarks offer up straw man arguments for why native applications are a bad thing, in spite of the anecdote really just being about companies (which coincidentally makes money from somebody other than the end user) who treat the end user like nothing other the commodity they truly see them as.

kapowaz··on Ruby mistakes
What would such a more sensible name be? I look at this as a trade-off between code readability and consistency. Particularly when assuming it is a predicate (without greater knowledge of the method) is not a dangerous assumption, I'd say the trade-off is a good one.
kapowaz··on Ruby mistakes
I'd say that justifying it as because you can still determine the truthiness of a string is missing the point; defined? (http://ruby-doc.org/docs/keywords/1.9/Object.html#method-i-d...) can return one of a number of string values, or nil, depending on what expression you pass to it. The actual return value can be useful to you depending on what you're doing, or you might be happy enough just accepting that there it returns a value other than nil (which is to say you don't care what it is, just that yes, something is defined which matches the passed expression).
kapowaz··on Did George Lucas Read Vogue?
He may not have been inspired by this particular magazine, but it's likely he was inspired by similar opening crawls that existed in cinema as early as the 30s, such as Flash Gordon: http://i.imgur.com/XNzi7.jpg. There are a whole bunch of things that Star Wars can be reasonably said to have copied and reused, and if you're at all interested in this you should definitely check out Kirby Ferguson's excellent ‘Everything is a Remix’ series, which looks at Star Wars in more detail here: http://vimeo.com/19447662
kapowaz··on An Advanced Guide to HTML and CSS
> I've never seen selector performance used as an argument for OOCSS.

Harry Roberts is one of the most vociferous proponents of OOCSS, and he has written about it a few times, notably here: http://csswizardry.com/2011/09/writing-efficient-css-selecto...

> That's a pretty broad sweeping statement that I think you'd be very hard pressed to back up.

I'll admit it's an opinionated statement, but I don't think that in itself makes it invalid. Opinions are certainly divided when it comes to how to structure CSS selectors, and I am firmly in the camp that OOCSS is bad stuff.

I've had a half-baked article on the whys of an alternative structure to OOCSS drafted for about 18 months now, so I guess it might be time to dust it down and fully write it up.

kapowaz··on An Advanced Guide to HTML and CSS
> One functionality of CSS often abused without awareness are selectors [...] How elements are selected within CSS affects performance, including how fast a page renders

This assertion used to be thrown around as one of the supporting arguments for using OOCSS, but I'm sure I later read that it was largely debunked; the performance implications were negligible and so it was just making CSS less legible/maintainable for no real reward. Has that changed? Have you any recent benchmarks to share?

kapowaz··on The Homely Mutt
I knew if I made this joke I'd get a wall of text explaining why I was wrong; thanks, HN — you delivered!

On a more serious note, I use Sparrow every day. About the only quibble I have with it is some of the icons aren't retina versions (hardly a dealbreaker). Otherwise I'd say it meets my needs very well; doesn't that also make it ‘done’, rather than ‘effectively dead’?

kapowaz··on The Homely Mutt
> Now that Sparrow is effectively dead

Sparrow 1.6.4 was released on September 11, 2012. Mutt 1.5.21 was released on September 15, 2010.

You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means.

kapowaz··on Apple scrambled to hire iOS 6 maps engineers days before launch
If by ‘relaxed’ you mean ‘tabloid’, sure. It seems to be a requirement that any Register article about Apple products has to be dismissive towards people who use them (even though that is most people who might read the article these days):

> fanbois and fangrrls across the world branded the new satnav-like service as rubbish

1. needlessly trollsome, 2. alludes to them being irrational supporters, and yet… these are the people being critical? Maybe they're not irrational fanatics after all…?

kapowaz··on Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond? (1982)
> Don't sell cheap. Sell authentic, sell natural, sell one-of-a-kind, sell meaning, sell status, sell a story, etc.

Basically: sell it better than De Beers has been doing for over half a century.

i.e. best of luck!

kapowaz··on Why you should not be displaying relative dates.
This sounds like more of an argument for why you shouldn't be distributing stuff in the form of screenshots (although the horrendous entropy of the web is a compelling argument in favour of that, I realise).
kapowaz··on Typing Practice for Programmers
Or me (en-GB, Safari, OS X Mountain Lion). I'm guessing it doesn't like how we invoke it with option-3 ?
kapowaz··on Twitter to Client Developers: Drop Dead
The two are not mutually exclusive. It is infrastructure, but it's also subject to network effects.
kapowaz··on Transform Ubuntu 12.04 Into Mac OS X Lion
My comment wasn't made in my official capacity :)

I'm mostly just remarking with bemusement that such a thing would garner attention. But I guess it takes all sorts.

kapowaz··on Transform Ubuntu 12.04 Into Mac OS X Lion
> The article demonstrates the malleability of Ubuntu's CSS theming system.

That doesn't make this newsworthy.

kapowaz··on PHP is much better than what you think
Really?

> Rants about PHP are everywhere, and they even come from smart guys. When Jeff Atwood wrote yet another rant about PHP…

That's not how it reads to me.

kapowaz··on PHP is much better than what you think
It's like he didn't actually read Jeff Atwood's article, or if he did, he entirely missed the point. It wasn't a rant about PHP; it was a rant about people ranting about PHP! So much heat; so little light.
kapowaz··on Walrus.js - Mustache on steroids
I think maybe you got the wrong end of the stick; I'd always rather go with Handlebars.js over Mustache. Plus you get nice things like helpers. Walrus looks to take it to a whole new level though, so I'm itching to try it out.
kapowaz··on Walrus.js - Mustache on steroids
My point wasn't that Mustache lacks these features, but that they're so essential as to make not handling them well feel like an omission. It needlessly bloats your template code to have to write within these constraints, and for what benefit? Some nebulous ‘logic-less’ purity?
kapowaz··on Walrus.js - Mustache on steroids
Conversely, my experience is that there are very good reasons not to use Mustache (and instead use Handlebars etc.) — there are just too many limitations that force you to push commonly required functionality into an awkward place within the application stack.

Plus there's the whole thing that ‘logic-less’ is a big white elephant: templates need logic, or they quickly become unmanageably bloated and un-DRY. Being able to iterate and conditionally branch are fundamentals essential to templating languages, and so whilst Mustache is an interesting starting point, it's usually not the best solution.

Of course, the one benefit Mustache does have is parsers in lots of languages, allowing you to share templates across client and server-side — it'd be great if somebody were to invest time in producing (say) a Ruby version of Walrus, as it looks like a very useful tool from reading through the docs.

kapowaz··on Anti-Piracy Boss: TV Fans Are Unreasonable For Wanting Content Quicker
> I think it comes down to: You want to be a part of the culture.

This is the crux of it, and why HBO et al are just completely behind the times. How people consume entertainment has changed drastically and pretending otherwise simply won't cut it any more. The good news is that all these people with outdated concepts will eventually retire or be overtaken by newer businesses that ‘get it’, but the transition is going to suck (in a first-world-problem kind of way).

kapowaz··on Anti-Piracy Boss: TV Fans Are Unreasonable For Wanting Content Quicker
Ah, that famous HN logic; this doesn't bother me, so I don't see why it should bother you.
kapowaz··on Anti-Piracy Boss: TV Fans Are Unreasonable For Wanting Content Quicker
> Waiting one week is not a big deal.

It is when the show in question is Game of Thrones, a story which revolves greatly around plot twists which could easily be spoiled if you're forced to wait longer than others to watch it. I already find I have to carefully moderate my online activity on a Monday before I can watch Game of Thrones in the UK, and we only have to wait one day!

kapowaz··on Chromebox
It reminds me of some other similar device I can't quite put my finger on…
kapowaz··on Why Windows 8 Scares Me -- and Should Scare You Too
Apple is a hardware company. They make money selling computers and other gadgets. Those computers and gadgets happen to run software, but that isn't what they make their money from (it's akin to a loss leader, even if it might not actually lose money).

Those customers you speak of, who stay away from the Macintosh because of the price; how much more money do you think Apple would make from them if they chose to buy a clone sold by another manufacturer? And how much money would they cost Apple in effect by taking advantage of software development subsidised elsewhere?

Killing the clones was (from a business point of view) one of the smartest things Steve Jobs did when he returned to Apple, and I can't see that decision ever being reversed.

kapowaz··on CSS arrow please
The gathered troops here were all cooing at this demo until the drop shadow was noticed as absent from the arrow. A real shame (although obviously the box-shadow being bounded by the rectangle makes it impossible to do this way).

Maybe it's time to propose a mask-shadow property?

kapowaz··on Show HN: my Mac app just got fireballed
I wanted to find out more about this app when I saw it mentioned on DF, but opening the link on my iPhone I was automatically redirected to the App Store. There I was given a message about this only being available on the Mac App Store, and a link presented which re-opened Mobile Safari and took me to a page talking about Mac OS X Lion and the App Store.

Partially Apple's fault, undoubtedly, but are you deliberately redirecting people to the App Store? Or is that some freebie that comes with embedding an App Store link/banner?

kapowaz··on Overpriced Developer Conferences
> The next conference of the day is Future of Web Design. I believe these tickets are well above £1000.

She could have at least checked before making this nebulous claim; the most expensive ticket at FOWD London is £695+VAT, some way shy of ‘well above £1000’. It does somewhat undermine your argument if you pull numbers out of thin air…

kapowaz··on Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox
What I find amazing is that people find it so easy to dismiss the cost of running an online store with almost no downtime, delivering music, television episodes, movies and apps to customers all around the world, with fast download speeds, with all the recovery facilities that iCloud offers for past purchases. Apple's famous North Carolina data centre cost about $1 Bn to construct (http://arstechnica.com/apple/news/2011/02/apples-nc-data-cen...). At that price, you'd need to collect 30% of $3.3 Bn in revenues just to break even.
kapowaz··on Apple rejecting applications which use Dropbox
Whilst I can see the reason why people baulk at giving Apple a cut, what doesn't ever seem to be widely discussed are the reasons why that cut might be justified or even well worth it.

The user experience of in-app purchasing on iOS is very good. Compared to the myriad online purchasing systems I've experienced in over a decade of buying things online, it's easily the most reliable and satisfying I've encountered. Case in point: I've had two separate third-party apps crash or stall during in-app purchase (one because of a loss of network connectivity, another where the app just crashed). Upon relaunching, iOS was able to work out where I'd gotten to with the in-app purchase and reassure me that I wouldn't end up paying twice.

This kind of reassurance is invaluable to consumers who aren't tech-savvy, and will almost certainly lead to higher conversion rates. In fact, it means that the user experience of a customer buying in-app purchase with a completely different product makes them more likely to use in-app purchase with your product! Where else can you benefit from this kind of self-reinforcing behaviour? Apple realises that providing this seamless experience is important, and so does what it can to discourage alternatives where a worse experience (an experience which might lead a customer to erroneously blame Apple or the device) might be the result.

Another important point to remember is that Apple targets the iTunes store to run at break-even (http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/12/02/23/tim_cook_addre...), so accusations that this is motivated primarily by profit are wide of the mark. Yes, that 30% cut helps run at break-even, but let's not forget what other benefits you're getting as part of the deal. And if you're certain those benefits aren't worth it, go try the Android Marketplace, and let us know how that works out for you.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →