HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

keiferski

33,971 karma · joined November 15, 2010

"The street finds its own uses for things."
submissionscomments
keiferski··on 'That's so AI ' What gen Alpha's biggest insult tells us
In the world of arts/media, I think AI basically only has a future as a hidden thing. Openly admitting that you used AI to make something will be used against you, in order to dismiss your work. For a lot of people/things, it already is - see Hank Green, or the daily comments about "I don't want to read what you didn't write."

Expect a massive marketing reversal in 6-12 months, when every "AI-powered" company removes the keyword from their home page.

keiferski··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
Yes, I should have looked into West Coast systems, as they seem to have this more. I had the East Coast/NYC more in mind.

However, I wouldn't be so confident about Portland's working well:

> The transit agency has identified a significant increase in fare evasion, prompting the introduction of new technology to control access at train stations...The report said TriMet has the third highest amount of fare evaders in the country, trailing only San Diego and Los Angeles.

https://katu.com/news/local/trimet-considers-adding-gates-to...

keiferski··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
There seem to be a fair number of commuter train lines that do this, but I don’t really consider a train to be the same as an urban tram/bus system. The latter has orders of magnitude more daily passengers, and it’s a far wider breadth of people compared to the typically better-off suburban commuter lines.

And as someone that’s ridden the bus in LA many times: the culture of acceptable behavior there is infinitely lower than the typical Central European bus.

To be fair I did have NYC in mind when writing the comment though, and I should have looked into west coast systems more.

keiferski··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
Interesting, I’ve never been to Seattle. But it looks like they are adding fare gates, so apparently it isn’t working.
keiferski··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
America is an entirely different cultural universe and simple things like this seem logical but just wouldn’t really solve the entire problem, IMO, as an American that’s lived in Europe for a decade+.

Another great example are the “open air” transit systems in Germany, Poland, etc. where you can freely enter trams and buses, with inspectors patrolling infrequently to check if you bought a ticket. That kind of system would absolutely never work in America, no one would pay, and the ticket inspectors would be hated as some kind of secret police.

keiferski··on If You Knew God Exists, Wouldn't You Become a Priest?
I'd be pretty skeptical that the number of people that think this way is a few hundred, tops. Don't take the bizarro HN opinions to by representative of anything than some very isolated people.

And no, most of the things you're describing are not religious behaviors, they're just obsessive ones. This is a common misunderstanding, that "doing something a lot = religion. Religions are not that simple, but people claiming that social media is a religion, or AI obsession is a religion, etc. are just lacking knowledge of what a religion actually is. Religions are pretty much the most complex topic there is, sociologically/anthropologically/philosophically, but "serious" people don't study them anymore, hence the half-baked opinions of otherwise educated people.

And even then - if we assume that all of what you said is true, it's not really clear how that maps to the Catholic Church analogy. Certain people may obsess over what ChatGPT thinks about something, but it's not really clear why they would value the opinion of someone that works at ChatGPT, which is what the post was about.

keiferski··on If You Knew God Exists, Wouldn't You Become a Priest?
Viewing AIs as gods is the wrong analogy and mostly just signifies that the user of the analogy doesn't understand religion very much. For 99% of believers, religion is a cultural system, not a question of omnipotent beings existing or not. AI companies are not priesthoods, they have no cultural output and are in no position to make ethical statements or be respected for those statements. Comparing them to the Catholic Church really doesn't make much sense.

AI is better thought of as a tool or a weapon, a piece of technology. Something like the printing press is a better analogy: it had a huge effect on society and information transfer, and while companies that owned printing presses did exert influence (newspapers) they were not worshipped or treated as some kind of protected class, and the technology itself dispersed over time as it became cheaper. It seems like the same thing could happen with AI.

keiferski··on AI-generated posters don’t have to be horrible
This is one example of how knowledge is still useful, even in the world of AI. If you know about different art movements, aesthetics, etc. you can prompt images using them, and make stuff that doesn't look like the generic slop that uses that recognizable round-corners style.
keiferski··on Warren Buffett Steps Down as Berkshire Chairman, Names Son to Replace Him
Buffett has been planning this since at least 2011:

CHICAGO (MarketWatch) -- Warren Buffett has told the CBS News program "60 Minutes" that after he dies, he wants his son to become non-executive chairman of Berkshire Hathaway. Howard Buffett, a farmer with no college degree, would be a good successor, the elder Buffett said, because he understands the values of the company.

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/warren-buffett-wants-farmer...

keiferski··on Pre-Greek: The lost language hidden within Ancient Greek
From what I understand, and I might be oversimplifying here; many of the differences between Indo-European languages today are a result of the languages that were there before. So the reason Proto-German and Latin were different is in part because of the pre-IE languages in each of those regions. But we don’t have a ton of information on those languages, so scholars are not sure.

Of course there were other reasons languages changed, and the inheritance is only one factor.

But in some sense there are many lost languages hiding inside contemporary ones.

keiferski··on Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photography
Oh yeah I’m sure it was already a thing. Just cool to see that it’s become more mainstream.
keiferski··on Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photography
Hey I predicted this awhile ago. Although it is kind of an obvious solution so I can’t claim much insight hehe.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44135416

keiferski··on Most people prefer traditional architecture
Architecture built today is mostly optimizing for the developers’ budget and the local regulations.
keiferski··on Mullenweg has returned as CEO after attempted board ouster
Shopify is a public company and thus subject to far more regulations and expected behavior of the CEO.

I also specifically did not merely say that being controlled by one person was bad, but that it was bad in the context of also being slow at decision making. In many cases having a single decision maker is a must for being dynamic.

Haven’t heard of Solidus, but I’ll check it out.

keiferski··on Mullenweg has returned as CEO after attempted board ouster
I hope someone eventually does a deep-dive on the organizational structure of WordPress and how much of a mess it is.

As someone that’s pretty much worked in/with WP for my entire career, it’s always seemed like the worst of both worlds - distributed and slow-moving, yet still ultimately controlled to a massive extent by a single individual.

These kinds of absurd situations just slowly push people toward Shopify, other CMSes, etc. There will be no grand exodus, because too many companies are intertwined to the WP ecosystem. But combined with AI, the horrible design of Gutenberg, and half a dozen other things, I really worry for the future of WP. At this point I generally only recommend it to people that need something extremely customized. Other platforms are easier to use and don’t have the soap opera drama.

keiferski··on After Math
A useful term here is “instrumental reason.” The Ethics of Authenticity is a good read on the topic:

https://jaredhenderson.substack.com/p/the-modern-malaise?r=5...

keiferski··on After Math
Most people don’t reach self-actualization and never have. This has nothing to do with AI.

With regards to technology specifically, new tech has been making high-investment skills useless for the last 500+ years. The printing press, the loom, etc. This is not anything new.

Some of these AI doomers really need to read more than AI Substacks and Twitter feeds. I suggest a book about the history of technology.

It is perfectly reasonable to suggest that we make an effort to direct a technology in certain directions. It is not reasonable to throw all rational thought out the window and operate as if real world AI is synonymous with science fiction.

keiferski··on google.com/goto: Google's anti-scraping update
Yeah seems pretty obvious to me that most people are not going to be using a search engine in 5 years. In the sense of searching for something and combing through the results to find the answer.
keiferski··on Resist "AI"
I know you’re trying to be clever and critical (boy am I tired of this trope on HN) but no, I don’t agree.

Being curious about a lot of things doesn’t mean you’re willing to invest 15 minutes every time you have a question.

AI makes the cost of asking these questions functionally zero. Previously I’d ask maybe 1/10 of them on Reddit, get a smartass negative answer, if I get an answer at all. Now I have an assistant that answers an infinite number of questions on demand.

I suspect that a lot of AI-hostility from tech/nerdy people is because they don't have the ability to display their expertise as easily as they did on Stack Overflow/Reddit/etc. A huge percentage of comments on HN are still just people trying to display their knowledge. (And I'm very guilty of that as well.)

keiferski··on Resist "AI"
I'm not a programmer so I can't really relate directly, I was replying more to the idea of using AI as an information-gathering tool.

I guess the analogy could be: with AI you should be doing more complex and more (quantity) programming than you did before. But don't quote me.

keiferski··on Resist "AI"
I can buy the idea that AIs are making people a lot lazier intellectually, on average.

But I do think that for the atypical user that is "information-hungry," AIs are a massive productivity booster. I've probably asked ChatGPT 1,000 questions over the last 2 years that I otherwise would have needed to spend 15+ minutes researching. Prior to AI, I would have just... not spent the time looking them up.

The danger is just when you start using AI but otherwise continue doing exactly what you were doing before.

keiferski··on Resist "AI"
Yup. If current-gen AIs were capable of writing articles, but not code, then devs wouldn't care at all. None of these articles would exist, and some new variation of "learn to code" would be the snarky reply to nay-sayers.

In fact, we already pretty much have proof of this: devs didn't care when software destroyed the journalism industry twenty years ago. Turns out that people ultimately only care when their only jobs are on the line.

keiferski··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
No, because people talk to each other even when using their phones.

This is easily observable in literally any social situation.

keiferski··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
Big difference between being at an event and recording it via your phone, and using ChatGPT to make an AI image of it. Images are not all the same.
keiferski··on On Really Trying (2009)
It kind of depends on your definition on high-performing people. The definition you seem to be operating by might work for the sort of the lone, cantankerous academic genius, someone who’s work is largely dependent on their ability to focus, study, and have certain output. I imagine a lot of people on HN have this definition of success.

But if your definition of success is remotely related to any form of leadership, then your suggestions are extremely flawed. To be a good leader, you need to manage people, have empathy, sympathy, tact, charisma, and so on.

Adding to that - many things in the real world end up being a mix of both, which means you need both to get to the top. Tom Brady or Michael Jordan don’t become the best in the world by being assholes to their teammates. Significant political / activist figures don’t start movements by belittling people. And so on.

Which means that the attitude you’re displaying here really kind of locks you into the upper middle class overachiever definition of success as a doctor, lawyer, etc. and not into the class of the truly successful.

keiferski··on ChatGPT Images 2.5
This is such a contrived imaginary situation that is pretty divorced from reality. No one wants a fake AI photo to commemorate a real event.
keiferski··on Robot writes in languages it has never seen before (2019)
They really missed an opportunity to use Chinese, and have the robot be in a hotel room.
keiferski··on She Also Found It at the Movies
Do you only read autobiographies, and by extension, blog posts/novels/etc. by people you morally agree with?
keiferski··on Every novel is boring until it isn't
Yeah it does seem like he picked his story structure in 1984 and decided, “well, that’s done, now on to the interesting parts.”
keiferski··on Site Is Closed on Sundays
The tone of the comment is sarcastic and snarky, not the content.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →