A lot of the guidelines are hard or impossible to police, and rely on developers following the “honor” system.
For example, Apple's App Review does not – and cannot – know what really happens to your data once an app has access to it.
3,217 karma · joined September 8, 2017
A lot of the guidelines are hard or impossible to police, and rely on developers following the “honor” system.
For example, Apple's App Review does not – and cannot – know what really happens to your data once an app has access to it.
Regardless, Apple could still mandate use of their own payment system alongside optional 3rd-party systems, and let all options compete on their merits - ease of cancellation being one of them.
Perhaps a WebKit monoculture isn’t such a great idea after all?
On iOS this can’t happen, regardless of whether an app was downloaded from the App Store or elsewhere.
Today, iOS has a strong sandbox where apps can’t access data of other apps unless explicit permission is granted (eg. access your location/contacts/photos), and apps can’t access or modify system files at all.
Also consider that sideloaded apps does not mean allowing unvetted apps - Apple could still mandate macOS-style app notarization to prevent malware:
> Notarization is a malware scanning service provided by Apple. Developers who want to distribute apps for macOS outside the App Store submit their apps for scanning as part of the distribution process. Apple scans this software for known malware and, if none is found, issues a Notarization ticket. Typically, developers staple this ticket to their app so Gatekeeper can verify and launch the app, even offline.
> Apple can also issue a revocation ticket for apps known to be malicious—even if they’ve been previously notarized. macOS regularly checks for new revocation tickets so that Gatekeeper has the latest information and can block launch of such files. This process can very quickly block malicious apps because updates happen in the background much more frequently than even the background updates that push new XProtect signatures. In addition, this protection can be applied to both apps that have been previously and those that haven’t.
https://support.apple.com/guide/security/protecting-against-...
This is a vicious cycle for newcomers, and at the same time a virtuous cycle for the incumbent(s), further cementing their dominant position.
> Now apps from both the App Store and the internet can be installed worry-free. App Review makes sure each app in the App Store is reviewed before it’s accepted. Gatekeeper on your Mac ensures that all apps from the internet have already been checked by Apple for known malicious code — before you run them the first time. If there’s ever a problem with an app, Apple can quickly stop new installations and even block the app from launching again.
> Absolutely vile. This says everything about @tim_cook’s Apple and what it thinks of developers. I hope the company gets exactly what it deserves. Everybody on their executive team should be ashamed, and some of them should not be here when it’s all over. We all see you.
> We’ve been told that if Apple ever asked its employees to betray their principles, they’d leave. In a similar vein, everybody, top to bottom, involved in planning, editing, implementation of everything in this document should leave Apple. You betrayed us.
1: https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/14895589519056691...
> Absolutely vile. This says everything about @tim_cook’s Apple and what it thinks of developers. I hope the company gets exactly what it deserves. Everybody on their executive team should be ashamed, and some of them should not be here when it’s all over. We all see you
> We’ve been told that if Apple ever asked its employees to betray their principles, they’d leave. In a similar vein, everybody, top to bottom, involved in planning, editing, implementation of everything in this document should leave Apple. You betrayed us
https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/14895589519056691...
We’re not asking for that on iOS.
So there’s no reason to think you’ll ever need "6 apps pre-installed designed purely to prevent malware/viruses” on your phone.
> Apple was hit with a second 5-million-euro fine for not complying with a Dutch regulator's order.
> The regulator told the company to let dating apps in the Netherlands use non-Apple payment methods.
The point about sandboxing is relevant because many people conflate sandboxing protections with the protections offered by App Review, and thus are afraid that non-App Store apps will be able to install viruses or brick their devices - which isn't the case.
Lastly, the automated malware screening that’s part of the App Review process can be offered separately, thus the risk of "catching malware” from non-App Store apps will be the same as with App Store apps.
Apple has turned the magic of software development from “how cool would this be?” to “how cool would Apple be with this?”
That’s an environment of software suppression instead of free innovation, and Apple has felt little pressure to change.
For anyone concerned about the security and privacy implications, don’t fall for the misconceptions perpetuated by Apple: non-App Store apps will still be sandboxed (so they can’t access other app or system data), and also scanned for malware by Apple - just like App Store apps!
> The FTC, under its Biden-appointed chairwoman, Lina Khan, has been shifting the terms of the argument, focusing less on harm to consumers or even rivals, and more on how the bigness of Big Tech harms companies that are, in essence, its partners.
> To understand, we have to look at an unusual word the FTC has used of late: “monopsony.” If a monopoly is a market with one dominant seller, a monopsony is its inverse, a market where one buyer is pre-eminent. Monopolists can gouge consumers. A monopsonist has the same power over sellers.
> Big tech’s platforms—the things that have made them so much money—effectively make them market-controlling middlemen, and the FTC is saying that the tech giants are abusing their positions as, in effect, the ultimate proxy buyers for all users of their platforms.
> By this logic, Apple’s App Store is the dominant place that app sellers must go to sell their software and services, because globally, it rakes in twice the revenue of its next-biggest competitor, Google’s Play store. Amazon wields its power over companies that want to sell goods online. Google and Facebook lord theirs over the publishers selling ad space.
We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
> Apple can also issue a revocation ticket for apps known to be malicious—even if they’ve been previously notarized.
https://support.apple.com/guide/security/protecting-against-...
https://developer.apple.com/documentation/security/notarizin...
We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
You still wouldn’t need to be paranoid if sideloading became possible. Sideloading doesn’t imply that app isolation (sandboxing) is also going away, nor does it imply that any app would ever be able to trick the user into running it with escalated privileges (sudo/root) as is the case on most computers.
We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
So this malware that you had to clean off of those laptops would still not be possible, even for sideloaded apps.