HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kelnage

577 karma · joined May 21, 2009

submissionscomments
kelnage··on Garmin Outage Persists After 24 Hours Downtime
Aviation database updating has apparently been hit by this [1], and pilots are mandated by the FAA to keep them up-to-date. Car navigation won't be significantly affected as long as the roads haven't changed drastically since the maps were last updated - all the plotting and directions are done on the device itself.

1. https://www.zdnet.com/article/garmin-services-and-production...

kelnage··on Garmin Outage Persists After 24 Hours Downtime
Rumour has it that it's been caused by a ransomware attack (although Garmin hasn't commented publicly) - I can't think of much else that would cause such a long outage.
kelnage··on The Dyson Battery Electric Vehicle
Dyson Eye 360: https://www.dyson.co.uk/robot-vacuums/dyson-360-heurist-over...

Although the connectivity with their app is a bit rubbish half the time!

kelnage··on Growing Anomalies at the Large Hadron Collider Raise Hopes
Alternatively, see "The Three Body Problem" by Cixin Liu [1] for an interesting take on what such anomalies could indicate!

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three-Body_Problem_(novel)

kelnage··on Does your video call have End-to-End Encryption? Probably not
My understanding of how these E2E products often do their (video) call encryption is not that they use a clever communication protocol like the one used in Signal to protect each frame/packet (which would likely introduce huge amounts of delay - not a good user experience!). Instead during call initiation, they do the key negotiation/sharing over the same messaging protocol they use to transmit their normal messages; i.e. effectively they generate the call encryption key on the device, send it as a E2E encrypted message to the call recipient(s), and use the standard call encryption methods (probably based on SRTP?) to actually protect the call.

Thus, assuming the call encryption methods work correctly (which I have no immediate reason to believe they don't), for an adversary to obtain the key (and decrypt the call), they would need to break the E2E encryption used to transmit the messages; therefore the call is E2E encrypted.

kelnage··on Coke and Pepsi are getting sued for lying about recycling
Yes, they took it. But my understanding is that only a small proportion that made it to China even got recycled and much of it ended up in Chinese landfill or being incinerated [1]. Hence they banned accepting it.

1. https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/3/7/e1700782?ijkey=8...

kelnage··on Google plans to move UK users' accounts outside EU jurisdiction
Although if you look at the actual text on the UKUSA agreement document HW 80/2 [1], rather than the short synopsis from Wikipedia, it says very clearly that the UKUSA agreement covers only sharing of "foreign communications" where footnote 3 on page explicitly excludes communications of both the UK and the USA.

1. https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C1153691...

kelnage··on The new business of AI and how it’s different from traditional software
To me, this sounds a lot like a justification built upon an bias (i.e. of course the tool the start-up was trying to sell was what the potential customers needed, it must have been those darn data scientists preventing the sales).

From my experiences at the time, there are a lot of such start-ups around, most of which did not actually entirely (or often at all) meet the needs of their customers, and were promising a lot more than they actually delivered. Whereas having data scientists in your organisation meant that at the very least, they were able to develop a proper understanding of your business, and actually create real value.

kelnage··on Unexpected places you can and can’t use null bytes
Better let Wikipedia know that then! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Null-terminated_string
kelnage··on Man vs. Horse – Racing Ultradistances (2018)
It so happens that I’m doing the man vs horse race in Wales mentioned at the bottom of the article this year - and although I’ll be giving it my best, I’m not exactly optimistic of my chances. Only two runners have ever won since the race started in 1980, the first did the 24 mile course in 2 hours and 5 minutes, which is a amazing time given the terrain.

I think, over that shorter distance, the only reason men have won before is because the horses go through a vet check halfway - but that seems entirely reasonable given the risks.

kelnage··on Which Emoji Scissors Close?
But your statement is about purchases, rather than common use. Just because 4-6-0 locomotives were being purchased then, it certainly doesn't follow that you wouldn't see any 4-4-0 locomotives in 1870, does it? Especially since 4-4-0s were still being built in the US as late as 1893 according to Wikipedia [1].

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4-4-0#United_States

kelnage··on Former White House climate adviser calls methane ‘irrelevant’ to climate
I assume you therefore would also go to a mathematician or a physicist for a medical diagnosis, over a doctor or chemist too? If not, why not?

(And yes, there are Environmental Science departments - or at least that's what they're called in the UK)

kelnage··on Stop Explaining Black Box Models for High Stakes Decisions
The Morning Papers had its take on this paper: https://blog.acolyer.org/2019/10/28/interpretable-models/
kelnage··on Intel slashes prices in face of AMD competition
I'm pretty sure neither manufacturer is really that worried about their Linux support. And, as far as my experience has gone with them both on Linux, they have both had their good years and their bad.
kelnage··on E-books at local libraries: a fight between publishers and librarians
But such a back and forth that could go on forever. Many e-books vendors frequently reduce their value by limiting access to a specific app/reader, or limit how useful the functionality you describe can be. For example, search is very much restricted within Kindle (e.g. I can't search for words across my entire library, I have to go into a specific book). And whilst it is true that some people are limited in how much physical space they have access to, it is certainly not universal.

Hence putting a hard price on this functionality is nigh impossible - whereas re-sale value is often easier to estimate and clearly tangible to the consumer. Claiming that they are equal is certainly not clear to me.

kelnage··on South African bank advises against the use of password managers
If it's a US Federal Government service, you should point out to them that they are going against the explicit recommendation of NIST[1].

1. https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html#sec5, under 5.1.1.2 Memorized Secret Verifiers, 'Verifiers SHOULD permit claimants to use “paste” functionality when entering a memorized secret.'

kelnage··on VAIO announces tiny laptop with tons of ports
And of course there are still a lot of VGA-only projectors out there (especially the ceiling mounted ones in meeting rooms) - having a VGA port is a godsend when you come across them!
kelnage··on How to factor 2048 bit RSA integers in 8 hours using 20M noisy qubits
This paper may be relevant to your interests: https://cr.yp.to/papers/pqrsa-20170419.pdf

TL;DR: yes, just moving from 2048 to 4096-bit keys will not suffice. But, if you make a composite key out of many 4096-bit keys (such that the key file is now ~1Tb) then then can achieve a reasonable level of security. And yes, I do think the paper is (at least in parts) somewhat tongue-in-cheek!

kelnage··on Repositories held for ransom by using valid credentials
This paper may be relevant to your interests: https://blog.acolyer.org/2019/04/08/how-bad-can-it-git-chara...
kelnage··on Massachusetts Court Blocks Warrantless Access to Real-Time Location Data
You're not wrong, but you've missed the main distinguishing factor between the Third Party Doctrine and the ECPA.

ECPA is about unauthorised access (think tapping a phone line, but for the digital age) to electronic communications/cloud data. The Third-Party Doctrine is explicitly about the Government requesting these records - thus they would do not fall under "unauthorised access" in the sense used under the ECPA. Basically they cover two completely different situations.

kelnage··on P = NP Proofs: Advice to claimers
Nor would it necessarily work (quickly) if the order of magnitude for any constants were sufficiently large (after all, a runtime of 2 * N and a runtime of (2^512) * N are both O(N)).

If I remember correctly, in the semi-regular survey conducted with CS experts about this question, the most likely explanation that accompanied a response saying they believed that it may be the case that P=NP was “...but with very large constants”.

kelnage··on Plagiarism detectors are a crutch, and a problem
As someone who teaches degree level content to apprentices, I definitely think these tools have value. I know that until very recently my current institution has not bothered with such a tool and I saw with my own eyes that quite obvious (to me) plagiarism was rampant and that the already overburdened assignment markers were not catching these instances. By moving to an automated tool, our students were immediately put on notice that such behaviour would not be acceptable.

That said, I do still hear worrying comments from my colleagues (“what number is too much?” is I’m afraid a common question) - but I can clearly see the change in student behaviour - so I don’t think this is such a bad thing. Yes, markers do still need to watch for plagiarism - and there are of course other types of plagiarism that these tools can’t usually deal with (ghost-written essays being a common talking point these days), but just because a tool may be misused or may be misunderstood, it certainly doesn’t necessarily mean it is all bad.

kelnage··on Handsontable drops open source for a non-commercial license
I agree completely - there are FOSS licenses that are easier to make money with than others. One of the most frustrating things I regularly encounter on HN is the “MIT/BSD is best, don’t use anything else” mentality. I think some of that is likely coming from the ease of use commercially (I worked for organisation who’s legal department literally said MIT/BSD = green, GPL2 = yellow, others = red).

But as you have yourself pointed out, it is (or at least may be) possible to make money as a commercial entity whilst still using a FOSS license, without entering the netherworld of “what is commercial use” arguments that these bespoke licenses create.

P.S. I know CKEditor very well, having used its predecessor FCKEditor on a small website for a local charity over 15 years ago! So thank you for continuing to support FOSS :)

kelnage··on Handsontable drops open source for a non-commercial license
Okay, I can see what you're getting at. I'm still not convinced that this move is the right way to go about it, as compared to simply keeping an FOSS license and setting up consultancy payments or similar (as they had previously) - as others point out, the commercial licenses can be a serious pain to navigate in many companies, that can significantly reduce the benefit your product offers.
kelnage··on Handsontable drops open source for a non-commercial license
Because commercial software companies never die (and take their IP down with them)? And are you seriously advocating that a lack of knowledge about a factor you have identified as being important (most commercial companies rarely tell you how many developers account for the majority of the code changes) is somehow beneficial to you, compared to actually knowing?
kelnage··on Wave – A private and unique messenger for iOS
No, you really can’t. That’s a library for symmetric cryptography. The key distribution/exchange problem cannot be solved with symmetric cryptography alone - unless you are acting as a trusted party and conveying the symmetric key - in which case you are not implementing end-to-end cryptography.
kelnage··on Wave – A private and unique messenger for iOS
Or, more importantly, how does key exchange work? You can’t really claim to be totally anonymous without explaining these details.
kelnage··on Apple Watch detects irregular heart beat in large U.S. study
You may be interested in a Garmin smartwatch then. They are primarily designed for exercise, so have very good optical-based wrist heart rate sensors, and are designed to minimise battery usage - I can easily get a week and more out of mine (a Garmin Fenix 5), even whilst making heavy use of its GPS and other functionality.
kelnage··on COI – Chat Over IMAP
"Last but not least, every COI client app can offer a variety of end to end encryption options to keep your communication absolutely private."

The fact I had to read quite so far down the page to find this snippet emphasises to me how unimportant the developers of this protocol see E2E encryption to be :( And leaving it to the client seems like a terrible idea, especially if there are options, as then surely it will depend on what E2E encryption options your and your recipient's clients supports?

kelnage··on PKI for busy people
The problem is that the amount you need to teach someone in order to explain all the intricacies of a complex subject like cryptography means that it is otherwise completely impenetrable without making some inaccurate simplifications.

There’s a similar problem in physics - schools still teach Newton’s laws, even though they are wrong - because they are a sufficient approximation for many uses.

The problem is of course when people assume what they’ve learnt at that early level is sufficient to work with at a level that is above their knowledge - but I’m not sure what the solution to that is.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →