781 karma · joined April 8, 2010
I apologize if the questions of myself and other users on this site today has set you on edge - and I am sure that today, in public and in private, you have seen many ugly things that the majority of us do not, and you reasonably draw a trend-line. I believe that you should extend the same charity of trend-spotting in the other direction.
We live in tumultuous times, and the speed at which the ratchet is moving seems to be ever-increasing. There are significant concerns, as I know you know, about censorship abroad, and also at home in various western countries. I believe the overwhelming outpouring you have seen today has been in response to one undeniable fact -- that even a genuine accident on the part of some engineer somewhere could apply CCP (or any country's ruling party) censorship globally is a line in the sand that many did not realize had been already been crossed.
Whether accidental or intentional, this is a watershed moment in the debate over censorship and freedom. It seems likely there are many more such errors in configuration actively deployed right now. That we have no way of knowing what, or how many such incidents there are is an existential threat to non-authoritarian systems of governance across the globe.
To see something that seemed unthinkable even a few months ago - that Tank Man could be censored in western countries on the anniversary in remembrance of the struggles he literally stood for - crossed a threshold for me in terms of what I believed could be possible more broadly. To see the extremely reasonable discussion around it disappear from hacker news, and stay dead for hours (I note that both the inappropriately-flagged article and the accidentally-marked-as-dupe article both still maintain those statuses at the time of this writing [EDIT: The flagged article's status was changed a few minutes after. Thank you, dang. Doing so does not mean you are re-writing history, and we appreciate it]) made it feel like it had encroached even closer to home than I had suspected.
It made it feel like perhaps I'd been even more naive than I had ever imagined. I'm sure you must feel the same way, after some of the more hateful things I'm sure you heard today.
All of this is to say that I treasure the community that you have played the single largest role in shaping, and your explanations have completely satisfied me.
I apologize for the way your day turned out, and any negative ways in which I have contributed towards that.
EDIT: Thank you for your response, dang. Hacker News is a special place, which is why we have responded so strongly to today's events - I apologize if the tone above came off as less-than-civil. I (and it seems, many others) look forward to hearing more about the 'dupe' article others have linked to below. It was only upon seeing the article marked as a dupe after seeing the previous flagged out of existence that it began to feel like more than just a user-initiated action, so I am sure further information on the mod-initiated actions will put these fears to rest.
Likewise, in a documentary series on any given people, perhaps episode two could focus on the difficulties, after episode one contextualized them with their successes?
I don't believe anyone suggested hiding or otherwise not sharing the history of oppression of any people in this comment thread. I recommend that you look back through and consider why you came away with a different impression.
And as importantly, that doing things in the other direction may have the effect of blunting that.
Which, given that it's pushed so strongly, and mostly by upper class whites, is starting to feel like the point.
We used to have a term for this - 'the soft bigotry of low expectations.' When did it become so progressive for well-educated white Americans, who clearly would never a day in their life follow their own advice, having 'upskilled' themselves to the max in the Ivy League, to encourage the removal and abdication of all forms of personal power and growth from people of color?
While I'm sure some people must truly believe this, I can't help but get a bootleggers and baptists vibe from the situation. It almost feels like a deep suppression of a fear of competition from some, and is starting to come off as a desperate attempt to protect themselves and their status by tricking others into staying 'in their place'.
The only way we will will sustainably succeed in raising wages for 'low-skilled' positions is through some combination of decreasing their fungibility (celebrity dish-washers?), decrease the competition for them, or increase alternative prospects through education. If everyone can be doctors, scientists, engineers, and titans of industry, the dish-washer will either be a valued, appreciated, and well-paid position - or we'll have figured out how to do it by machine.
A YouTuber.
I find it hard, as the poster seems to, to imagine a scenario in which even 100k clones of Alex Jones could cause the same level of harm. And while Alex himself may never uncover any real conspiracies (and really, how could you personally guarantee that?), that doesn't mean the same tactics used on him won't be turned on someone who has uncovered genuine malfeasance. (keep in mind, I've never been a fan, and I think he is a personally odious, obnoxious, and ill-intentioned individual who no one should listen to. Still, he shouldn't be silenced.)