HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on The Army’s Newest Recruits: Tech Execs From Meta, OpenAI and More
> He was named "Horatio" after his godfather Horatio Walpole, 1st Earl of Orford (third creation), (1723–1809), the first cousin of his maternal great-grandmother Anne Turner (1691–1768). Horatio Walpole was a nephew of Robert Walpole, 1st Earl of Orford, (second creation) the de facto first prime minister of Great Britain. [1]

Horatio Nelson

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horatio_Nelson,_1st_Viscount_N...

klelatti··on Personal Computer Origins: The Datapoint 2200
Thank you and particularly for the clarification! I'll update with a footnote to make it clear how the CRTs operated.
klelatti··on Signs You Used ChatGPT to Write That
Or 'ChatGPT, make me sound like the New Yorker'.
klelatti··on I'm manually transcribing the AltairBASIC source, ten lines a day starting today
Am I alone in thinking that it's revealing that Gates himself hasn't released this as open source? I'm not sure how that would work as presumably the copyright rests with MS and not Gates but I'm sure that he could have found a way.
klelatti··on The Soul of an Old Machine
That's very good. Thanks so much again.
klelatti··on The Soul of an Old Machine
Thank you! That's really helpful. I see I wasn't first with new -> old.
klelatti··on The Soul of an Old Machine
Thanks for confirming that.

I'd quite like to do a follow-up post on DG. Any really good sources that I could tap into?

klelatti··on The Soul of an Old Machine
Thanks for sharing this.

I definitely didn't intend to endorse this view. I think if it was really true that they had purposely misled him and he'd taken it all in then there would be some major technical 'howlers' in the book. As far as I can see there aren't any.

Maybe they didn't like the way they were portrayed - which I can understand - and there was a collective, organic 'well of course it wasn't like that' soon after the book was published.

klelatti··on The Soul of an Old Machine
Author here (of the post not the book!)

A kind reader pointed me towards an interview with Dick Sonderegger who worked at Data General at time of the development of Eagle [1].

His view based on discussions with people who appeared in the book is interesting:

'They did not have flattering things to say about Tracy Kidder ... This is a historical novel, this is not what actually happened'.

'To a man [they said] he didn't know anything, we could have told him anything and he could have bought it. And reading the book that's accurate'

DG section is at approx 21 mins

[1] https://operationcode.org/podcast#dick-sonderegger-link

klelatti··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
> it takes a major chunk of their margins

Completely false. Cost of VAT is passed on to consumers not met by companies and as EU companies pay VAT too it doesn't force US companies to lower prices and so harm their margins.

klelatti··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
Not the point I was making.

In any event US cars don’t sell in Europe for a range of reasons including size and fuel consumption. Those stricter rules apply to everyone and I don’t think it’s beyond US manufacturers to meet those rules for cars sold in European markets.

If you’re saying that Europe should loosen its safety rules just so the US can export more cars then the answer will certainly be no.

klelatti··on US Administration announces 34% tariffs on China, 20% on EU
> So US is easy to sell in for everyone, EU is "hard" to sell in for everyone, but maybe less so for EU car makers. So there is something to this argument, it's not entirely without merit.

It's completely without merit. Do you really think US regulation isn't written for the benefit of US companies? It is!

klelatti··on Notes on the Pentium's microcode circuitry
Also the Gary Davidian of Intel vs NEC fame!

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/intel-vs-nec-the-case-o...

klelatti··on The Guardian flourishes without a paywall
Not from before 1959 when the paper was renamed. 'The Guardian' name actually appears in the ad.
klelatti··on The Guardian flourishes without a paywall
It's interesting that The Guardian's name itself reflects one of the UK's enduring problems: the extreme dominance of the South East and London in particular.

Originally founded, written, published and printed in Manchester and bearing the name 'The Manchester Guardian' it's now abandoned all of these in favour of London with just a handful of Manchester based journalists.

The contrast with the US and Germany say is stark.

klelatti··on SoftBank Group to Acquire Ampere Computing for 6.5B
Somewhat but not competing with its customers has been a central part of Arm's proposition for three decades, for good reason. There are at least a lot of competitors for Nvidia's design. Your options if you want to build a server core are a lot more limited.
klelatti··on SoftBank Group to Acquire Ampere Computing for 6.5B
Largely agree. Arm / Softbank is in a tricky place if there are no credible customers in a given market. Does it just sit on its hands or actually get out there and build some chips! It has helped fund or help some startups that were using Arm designs to get into new markets (eg Annapurna Labs) but sometimes that doesn't work out at all (Nuvia!)

And to be fair I think Rene Haas has been fairly upfront about changing their approach.

klelatti··on SoftBank Group to Acquire Ampere Computing for 6.5B
So Softbank now competes with Arm's customers and (unless I've missed something on new governance arrangements) also gets access to confidential information on Arm's customers' businesses (plans, volumes etc). Hmmm.
klelatti··on Ex-Facebook director's new book paints brutal image of Mark Zuckerberg
Are you really saying that first hand evidence of Zuck’s character is irrelevant to our understanding of him because it relates to a period when he was relatively young? We can’t use that together with his more recent actions to create a more complete picture of his character and motivations. That biographies should all start at age 30?
klelatti··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
If it's so cheap and easy then why haven't they done it already?

ChatGPT was announced Nov 22. The opportunity has been clear for two years and still essential software breaks.

klelatti··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
Since 2007 Nvidia has built with CUDA and compatible hardware

- a large and growing ecosystem

- a massive installed base of backwards compatible hardware

- the ability to massively scale delivery of new systems

- and lots lots more

They now have scale that enables them to continue to invest at a level that no competition can do.

None of these are easily reproduced.

As per SemiAnalysis AMD in late 2024 can’t get essential software working reliably out of the box.

It’s easy to say AMD ‘is close to perfecting ROCM’ the reality of competing with Nvidia is much harder.

klelatti··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
Because we already see firms competing effectively with OpenAI.

There is as yet no indication that AMD can match Nvidia's execution for the very good reason that doing so is extremely difficult. The head start is just the icing on the cake.

klelatti··on Microsoft is plotting a future without OpenAI
> AMD could have ROCm perfected if they really want to.

It's not an act of will or CEO dictat. It's about hiring and incentivising the right people, putting the right structures in place etc all in the face of competing demands.

Nvidia have a huge head start and by the time AMD have 'caught up' Nvidia with it's greater resources will have moved further ahead.

klelatti··on Alibaba Launches C930 RISC-V Chip Amid Shift from Western Tech
> The article would be equally fact-free non-news ...

It may not be surprising but it's not fact-free or non-news. The pace at which Alibaba is developing its RISC-V designs is significant. Removing one dependency on western supply chains is material development even if the dependency on TSMC remains.

klelatti··on The Birth of Chipzilla
Inexpensive personal computers weren’t shipped with EPROMs, they were shipped with mask programmable ROMs. EPROMs were used in development but they were nowhere near as important as the microprocessor.
klelatti··on Beginnings of Roman London discovered in office basement
I worked in that 1950s office block (Temple Court) and was involved in the sale of the site to Bloomberg.

The Temple of Mithras sat outside the office a few feet from the pavement with free public access at all times. It attracted very little interest though as there wasn't much to mark it out.

IIRC it had to be moved as part of the redevelopment and the idea to relocate to its original location were a very early part of the proposals. Not a big deal as part of a very large project and obviously a way for Bloomberg to gain favour with the City of London planners.

There are a few interesting videos on YouTube on the history e.g.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAEtYSJ4GLE

klelatti··on I believe 6502 instruction set is a good first assembly language
Completely agree with all these points and that without the 6502 the ARM1 would not have looked like it did. One might say ARM1 was inspired by the 6502 and it prevented them going down the CISCy 68k route.

But I don't think that ARM 'ARM borrowed most of its design from 6502' or (to my mind at least) looks like a refreshed 6502. There are just too many fundamental differences:

- ARM1 was a load/store architecture / 6502 wasn't.

- 6502 had a few special purpose registers / ARM1 had loads of general purpose registers.

Plus there are lots of key innovations in ARM1 that weren't in either 6502 or RISC 1 such as conditional execution. Furber and Wilson were really quite innovative and didn't just borrrow ideas from other ISAs.

klelatti··on I believe 6502 instruction set is a good first assembly language
Could you say why? It doesn’t feel much like it to me at all!
klelatti··on I believe 6502 instruction set is a good first assembly language
> ARM borrowed most of its design from 6502

Not really (perhaps leaving mnemonics aside). The 6502 has little in common with the first ARM. The ARM's designers liked the simplicity and speed of the 6502 and it was their favourite 8-bit ISA. And a visit to the Western Design Center convinced them to design their own CPU.

However, the early RISC papers were the biggest influence on the design of the ARM. There is even a clue in the name 'Acorn RISC Machine'.

klelatti··on Alibaba/T-HEAD's Xuantie C910
Thank you, that's very helpful.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →