HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knaik94

2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015

knaik1994 a.t gmail d(o)t com github knaik twitter @knaikk
submissionscomments
knaik94··on Why I Two-Space (2012)
The issue with that analogy is that even with em and en spaces, the "correct" way of using them is based on where you learned their function. For example, the American use of em vs en dash and the British use is different. The guidelines are based on style rules, they aren't even grammar rules.
knaik94··on Why I Two-Space (2012)
Two spacing does not increase legibility of the information. That is the only meaningful metric I care about. If there are studies to show that two-spacing vs single spacing has a meaningful difference in how quickly a human parses or understands information, I will care about changing spacing. The author argues comfort, but because I am so used to single spacing, the two-spaced writing feels awkwardly spaced. I can't easily parse where sentences start and end. The other arguments are pointless.

I recognize people still read print, but I can safely say that 90%+ of all of the reading I have done in the past month has been digital. I don't think most people choose vim over a word editor like google docs or microsoft word when writing. The most common ebooks I read are in the epub format, which is based on html. The only pdfs I read are technical papers that are in two column format. There doesn't seem to be a place where two spacing will make a difference.

Looking at the page source shows the sentences are two-spaced. But that's not how any of the information is presented. If the author is used to it, there's no reason to change it. I believe that being trained to write the way most people write is more important.

It doesn't take much to search+replace two blank spaces with one. Going in the opposite direction is only a little more involved with having to specify a punctuation so you don't end up double spacing every word as well.

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
The liver itself might be simple but the complexity is in the enzyme pathways. The marker of "elevated liver enzymes" doesn't tell us much.

Taking a step back, there is only one organ I will admit we understand better than the brain, the heart. It's the only organ where we know enough to replace it with a mechanical counterpart. We don't know enough to make it last a long time, but it's enough to prolong someone's life in a meaningful way.

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
Psychologists encourage patients to seek out psychiatrists if they believe medication is likely to help a patient. Psychiatrists aren't the same as pharmacists, they are an active part of your treatment plan. I would suggest you take some time to understand the end goal of treatment and why people seek treatment. The goal is not to make patients docile.
knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
This is where the problem is and what I argued above as well. People handwave the efficacy and use of medication by arguing "we don't understand". That is exactly what you are doing. A lot of my knowledge comes from when I was able to work with surgeons at the local university hospital in order to do signal processing on data collected from electrodes that were installed into patients who suffer from Parkinson's, for DBS.

I would urge you to look into the recent advances in neuroimaging.

https://www.biomedcentral.com/collections/advances-in-neuroi...

https://www.additudemag.com/neuroimaging-adhd-findings-limit...

The reality is the news tools for research are still in their infancy. It's not close to the maturity that the diagnosis of diabetes and other diseases are at. But there is a very clear path forward, it's no longer theoretical.

There is still no clinical definition of insulin resistance.

And as far as ADHD and Diabetes go, yes I can confidently say the current medications and therapies that are available for Adhd can address most cases similar to how insulin does for diabetes. Treating metabolic disorders is as complex as treating ADHD. Stimulants don't "fix" ADHD any more than insulin does for diabetes.

The complication doesn't come from the lack of science, it comes from the fact that behavior and cognition is affected directly by the stimulus people are exposed to. I can't play music that will distract a kidney but I can distract a child very easily the same way.

I did read the article you listed,

"In McNally's view, there's little danger that mental health professionals will forget the importance of environmental factors to the development of mental illness. "I think what's happening is not a battle between biological and non-biological approaches, but an increasingly nuanced and sophisticated appreciation for the multiple perspectives that can illuminate the etiology of these conditions," he says.

Still, translating that nuanced view to improvements in diagnosis and treatment will take time. Despite decades of research on the causes and treatments of mental illness, patients are still suffering. "Suicide rates haven't come down. The rate of prevalence for many of these disorders, if anything, has gone up, not down. That tells you that whatever we've been doing is probably not adequate," Insel says."

He argued exactly what I am still arguing. Specific to how far out he thought these tools of diagnosis were, I would absolutely disagree. Having a Nobel prize doesn't mean his predictions are prophetic.

It's not just the field of neuroscience, the last 10 years of technology have reshaped the entire landscape of medical diagnosis and treatment. If I said that AI will be able to help diagnose cancer in the next 10 years in 2012, most people would think I was being optimistic to a fault, but that's where we are now. The fMRI was invented in 1991.

From APA, if you clicked on neuropsychology and scrolled down, you would have seen Michael Treadway’s fantastic work at Emory on the relationship between inflammation and stress and how it links to depression.

https://www.apa.org/monitor/2021/09/career-lab-depression

"“What I’m seeing with my research, and that of others, is that there are many types of depression, schizophrenia, or any number of mental illnesses, each with its own source,” Treadway said. “I would really like to get to the point where we have discrete definable pathologies that are measurable, using objective tests, for different types of depression, for example, or even different symptoms of depression. That could really open up a world of new treatment possibilities.” "

I can only hope you gain some of my enthusiasm after reading some of these.

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
I think it's valid to want a reproducible study done, regardless of how obvious it seems. The studies have already been done.
knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
I do. I equally scold anyone that says MDMA or LSD is the cure all of depression.

It's not an analogy. There is no mechanical difference between someone using Amphetamines to treat their ADHD and someone using insulin to treat their diabetes. There are just as many external as internal factors that go into how someone can get diabetes and what dosage of insulin they need at a specific moment in time. Science has advanced to a point where diabetes specifically can be monitored easily by a patient. The same is true of hypertension.

The difference for mental health issues is that there is no easy quantifiable way to diagnose someone.

Every organ is the most complicated organ in the human body, at a certain level every organ has a mechanism science doesn't understand yet. That's not a valid argument.

The same is true for pain management. And Multiple Sclerosis.

I would suggest you look into the modern state of neurophysiology and neuropsychopharmacology. The "we don't understand" is not true anymore. The reality is that there are so many factors affecting a certain visible outcome that it's hard to specify a root cause.

I am not a medical professional, I have only taken some 300 and 400/grad level courses in psychology.

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
I would appreciate it if you did say more. I don't understand how you came to the conclusion that psychologists hate medicine. In most cases psychologist and psychiatrist work together to provide treatment to a patient. Why would psychologists see the use of medicine as failure?
knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
The reality is that both models work together. The amount that each side contributes in a certain individual is dependent on their circumstances and their genetics.

Depression is very much a chemical thing, look into the "comedown" recreational users of ecstasy feel after a night of rolling. MDMA is a stimulant that also excites the same receptors many classic antidepressants work on. MDMA effectively increases the effectiveness of Serotonin and Norepinephrine, the effect on Serotonin is uninhibited and is what causes the "high". After the "dump" of Serotonin into the brain, the brain recalibrates and the baseline Serotonin from before feels like less than it should for a few days. The symptoms are classic anhedonia depression. Clearly an imbalance causes depression.

Depression is also a very situational and mental thing. The traumatic loss of a loved one for example causes deep depression in many people. Even a breakup after a long term relationship can cause deep depression. Therapy and psychoanalysis can help someone become more mindful of their thought patterns. It can push someone to get past the immediate hurdle and regain momentum to live a happy and fulfilling life again.

Neither answer is complete. Trying to find a generic solution is part of what is keeping Psychiatry closer to the blood letting ages of medicine rather than the fMRI scan age.

My personal experience has left me biased and jaded about the current state and future trajectory of Psychiatry and mental health management. Both from the medical professional side as well as from the society side.

It may be a cultural thing, I come from an Asian background and my parents have hung on to that culture. I have stopped bringing up the topic and will excuse myself from conversations when they bring it up because when I try to speak honestly, they treat me like I am trying to peddle narcotics. To them there is only a binary choice, either live drug free and "clean" life or fiend for drugs like an addict. The line isn't based on all drugs in general either, there's a very different stigma around psychoactive vs non-psychoactive drugs. Beta blockers for blood pressure is okay, but beta blockers for performance anxiety and general anxiety is not. I know it comes from a deeper belief system of not taking mental health concerns seriously.

Reading this article was interesting, because I didn't realize western medicine had the same faulty starting point.

I am lucky to have grown up in a time of computer assisted dental x-rays. It's a culture shock knowing how recently Psychiatry was still in the age of lobotomies.

The US still hasn't officially banned lobotomies. The oldest sister of President Kennedy, Rosemary Kennedy was given one in 1941. They continued to be performed officially until the 1970s.

The nobel prize in medicine defends the usefulness of lobotomies and rejects the idea of rescinding the award given to Moniz. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/medicine/1949/moniz/articl...

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
Studies to show morphine is better than placebo in treating what?

Here is a link for Study protocol for a randomised, placebo-controlled, single-blind phase II study of the efficacy of morphine for dyspnoea in patients with interstitial lung disease (JORTC-PAL 15) https://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/11/5/e043156 .

I would suggest you look into the drug approval process in the US, I think you will learn a lot.

knaik94··on Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
It's weird that we treat psychoactive drugs differently than other drugs. We don't have a fear of a diabetic becoming dependent on insulin or someone with high blood pressure becoming addicted to beta blockers. There are side effects is a bad generalization of all drugs used to treat mental health issues. When I say I am taking beta blockers, most people comment on how I am a bit young to be taking them, but when I was prescribed benzos for the same condition, everyone decided to become my doctor and tell me what I should and shouldn't take. Endless stories about how then knew someone who got addicted to pain killers and became homeless and how they heard benzos are just as bad. I chose to switch off benzos to beta blockers.

Doctors and the patient are the best judge for the benefits and risks of living with certain conditions vs being medicated for them. In most cases there aren't side effects.

knaik94··on Ask HN: Are we all burned out?
I think both are true. Therapy will help you get sorted out, you can go once or twice, there's no rule saying it has to be ongoing. Many many people feel the way you do. Covid pushed a lot of people into the darkest moments of their life.

There was a 1 month waitlist to see a new therapist and 2 month to see a psychiatrist. That's in a densely populated state like NJ, usa.

There are many more things today that are able to more easily exhaust your emotional battery. News has gone from click bait to concern baiting in order to keep your attention. Every other news story is "breaking news". It's not.

I have been feeling burned out too and it's more severe than I have felt it in the past. I can't speak about pre 2010, I was too young. But in 2010s it was so much easier to figure out what needed my attention and what didn't.

There have been, what feels like, back to back world changing events. The reality is there always were. Covid is the first one that managed to touch every single person in the world's life. There's state and country level events like the war. The impact of those events spread it out to continents.

But in my lifetime and maybe most people's, there hasn't been a world effecting event like covid since, maybe WWII. Age is a factor for the previous one I think of, it's not the same for everyone.

Phone and content consumption are things that help me make it through the day. Tiktok is seen as "bad" but to me it's nice to spend a half hour watching random people do funny things. My timeline is tuned to show me cute animals and funny videos. No drama, no news, no stress.

My advice to you is find a hobby with a small local community. If you can't, find somewhere to volunteer. For me, there's an archery shooting range that has Friday night shoots at indoor targets. I see people from different age brackets. I can invite a close friend or two to come and hang out and talk about nothing in particular.

Like this lady tried to argue that she had dibs on a specific box of fruit because her hand touched it first. I just gave it to her but it was funny in retrospect. There were 30 other boxes.

I don't care about getting good enough at archery to make be competitive or go hunting. I feel happy about getting 9s and 10s. I don't feel bad about myself if I don't.

I would say go back to some root. Make a book club with your friends, or join the one at the local library. Volunteer at the local senior center or whenever. Get into 3d printing. Local open intramural sport. I know some of my friends do basketball game tournaments.

Do something you have done already so it's not new. Something you put down and forgot about or just didn't have time for.

Video games are decent, especially if you focus on single player games and not online multi-player.

I love my phone. I have friends I stay in touch with across time zones because of my phone. I am in many discords. There's never a moment in time where I can't pick up my phone, find people talking about a show I like or about some tech project I also like and just talk. They're strangers but we start with something in common. Specific communities talk about drama but I just go to a different discord channel.

Having a community you have a shared interest with gives you something to look forward to. I am in the stable diffusion community and it's pretty nice. Interesting projects and technical discussions.

Other people advising you to use your phone less don't understand the root of the issue. Whether or not you get therapy is up to you. Maybe a heart to heart with a friend you really really trust is enough.

knaik94··on Ask HN: Are we all burned out?
The war is affecting my friends. My friends and family are all entering different stages of their life. It's been hard to meet new people. Office friends are even more removed and many moved away because of covid and work from home. I see how expensive my grocery bill has gotten every other weekend.

Phones and technology are some of the only escapes left.

This is bad advice, even worse than saying use the phone more because it's dismissive of the larger issues I am facing in life. The phone isn't the thing doing the killing, it's the governments of countries like Iran, Russia, and Ukraine. There's are good and bad guys in war, but both countries experience a loss in souls.

That's also not how dopamine works.

knaik94··on Why Disconnecting from Your Phone Is So Good for You – and How to Do It
I dislike this and similar articles because there is so much poor science in them and yet the authors always write in a very patronizing way. Correlation isn't causation. There is some good journalism but this is not it.

It's very clearly written from the perspective and mindset of someone that grew up without the internet. Asking most people who end up doom scrolling on social media if it's something that makes them happy and they will reply no, they are just bored. There are some valuable tips for people who want to move towards a tech-lite lifestyle. That's great and a personal choice, but it does not mean that people who decide they don't want to give up social media and technology are "addicted".

Your brain doesn't respond to "hits" of "dopamine", if your dopamine system is disordered, you should look into getting tested for ADHD if you haven't. Every one of negative consequences they imply as being caused by an "addiction to a screen" actually go back to something bigger like ADHD.

"It has been proposed that genetic variants of dopaminergic genes and other “reward genes” are important common determinants of reward deficiency syndrome (RDS), which we hypothesize includes ADHD as a behavioral subtype." [1]

Phone usage past reasonable boundaries is a symptom of something bigger, just like binge eating, impulse control disorders, addiction, and every other negative they listed in the article is. Impulse control disorder can cause weight gain which causes low self-esteem which feeds into a toxic cycle that leads to morbid obesity. There's an equally toxic cycle that can happen from using technology for escapism. But we shouldn't blame technology just like we don't blame food as the reason for a binge eating disorder.

Subjective overuse of technology isn't and shouldn't be treated the same way. It corrupts the definition of what an addiction is. As someone that grew up with internet from a very early age, articles like sound like feel good articles written for people who think they are better than others for not using technology.

Generalizing phone usage as "screen time" shows a clear lack of understanding of just how many different things can be done using a phone. Being "practically fused to their phones" isn't a crazy that should be seen as abnormal behavior, it's how to function in modern society. People that grew up without technology or choose to be out of touch, can't understand how much of teenage and young adult culture making happens in via technology.

I have this theory that I have been seeing more and more evidence for, the idea of generations dictated by what you grew up with is not going to be useful for the future. Internet has reached a point where physical distance no longer matters. IRC was ahead of its time with how it allowed people to connect to others across the world in a somewhat anonymous way. We're finally seeing kids grow up that have never experienced a world that wasn't connected. Kids today go on discord and gaming lobbies and can connect to thousands of others across the world just based on shared interests.

The idea that technology separates a parent from their kid is more a reflection on the cultural difference between a parent that decided they don't want to use a lot of technology and a child that embraces technology and understands that's how the rest of their peers are too.

"The internet has also become a crucial meeting place for children to exercise their right to freedom of expression by connecting with others online. Many children surveyed can be considered ‘active socializers’ who take part in a number of social activities online each week – such as chatting with friends and networking with those who share their interests. Our research suggests that children who socialize more actively online are better at managing their online privacy, which helps to keep them safe.

“Online, I can show my true self, there are no rules … I have more than 5,000 friends online.”

- Boy, who identifies as gay, 15, Philippines" [2]

Unicef, office of research-innocenti, has released a fantastic report on the trends and challenges kids growing up in a technology drive world will face. I recommend anyone thinking of using pre-internet mentality as boundaries for their kids read it. Things like not giving a child a phone until their are in high school is going to severely limit their child's ability to socialize.

"But faced with complex and fast-evolving technologies, many parents do not feel confident enough to supervise their seemingly tech-savvy children. Parents may also be influenced by popular worries about ‘excessive screen-time’, ‘internet addiction’ and ‘stranger danger’. The temptation is therefore to restrict children’s internet use rather than to guide them to use the internet safely.

Instead of limiting internet use, parents can get involved in children’s online lives by encouraging them to learn from the internet or suggesting ways to use the internet safely. By taking a more positive and supportive stance, parents can help their children develop resilience while also reducing conflict between parent and child. In most of the 11 countries surveyed, such enabling mediation helps children to engage in a wider range of online activities and slightly reduces their exposure to risk." [2]

Adults aren't different from kids in this way. It's fair to worry. It's understandable that adults who reduce screen time for themselves feel better. But that's not because there's something bad about technology, taking a break gives people room to re-examine their life. It's a personal choice to live a technology-lite lifestyle, but society as a whole is becoming more technology based. During covid the entire workforce and education system became technology based, I didn't hear parents complaining about screen time for virtual classes. I heard parents complaining that they struggled will encouraging kids to want to learn. I tutor on the side and I got non-stop calls from parents reaching out because they want to me help get their middle school-early high school aged kids motivated to learn and care about grades.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2626918/

[2] https://www.unicef-irc.org/growing-up-connected

knaik94··on Valve's latest Steam Deck trailer briefly plugs a Nintendo Switch emulator
If Denuvo wants it to be effective, they need low level access from Nintendo. It's not possible for this to get approved to run on the switch without going through Nintendo. Depending on how effective this is, Nintendo would most likely be the first publisher to use it. Nintendo develops many of its most popular games in house. There was a lot of negative reactions to this so I imagine Nintendo wanted to distance itself from it publicly. It is the same company that took Game Genie, a game cheat cartridge for the NES, to court on the basis of "copyright infringement". Nintendo lost that case, but they have won recent cases taking down rom hosting sites.
knaik94··on Valve's latest Steam Deck trailer briefly plugs a Nintendo Switch emulator
I haven't ready any public writeups from emulator developers, no games have been released with it but Zelda BOtW2 is expected to have it. Some guesses are that it will be based on measuring specific call execution times.

The switch is already weak in terms of hardware so I am not sure how many games will end up integrating it. Regardless of what Denuvo says in marketing, it will slow down games. Nintendo has since tried to distance itself from it, but Denuvo has said they have entered NDA agreements with large publishers already. Denuvo would also need low level access and approval from Nintendo, so I am not sure why Nintendo is pretending to separate itself from this effort.

knaik94··on Valve's latest Steam Deck trailer briefly plugs a Nintendo Switch emulator
While this is legal, Nintendo is very vocally anti-emulation. Nintendo and Denuvo announced anti-emulation measures for switch games in August 2022. There's a big difference between support and marketing support. Nintendo doesn't care what other companies do internally, but cares a lot about what is shown publicly. I remember when Nintendo took down a bunch of youtube videos showing how to jailbreak the original switch. Nintendo isn't coming to PC anytime soon though, so I can't imagine this having any major impact, but it is bad manners. Video and thumbnail edited out Yuzu.
knaik94··on Google Pixel 7 and Pixel 7 Pro
Me not caring about security fixes means I will continue to use those features without worrying about potential exploits. Video formats aren't going to suddenly change. Apps will still get updated, the system framework will still get updated.

In all my life, I have not once seen an android phone actually exploited. I have read about a lot of them online. But I haven't seen an exploited phone in person. Other than exploits that I have used to gain root access on devices, which all require physical access. Around 18 percent of the current android market share is made up of devices running Android 9 and earlier. Android has 3 billion active devices according to the most recent Google I/O. That's 600 million devices. I imagine I will be fine for the next 4 to 5 years regardless of the security update situation.

I will support phone manufacturers that have proper hardware, like a headphone jack and sd card slot over manufacturers that promise security updates every single time. I will continue to boycott phones that don't have a headphone jack. I will not make my current technology deprecated by design in order to have a supposedly flagship phone/device. We should support decent companies like Sony that don't remove useful features in order to create new revenue streams. I have really nice headphones, any phone manufacturer that removed the headphone jack is encouraging me to generate e-waste in order to use their product.

Right now is a terrible time to judge a phone company, the chip shortage hasn't gone anywhere, international markets are still heavily limited. Sony doesn't seem to be looking into becoming a replacement for LG, it seems to be happy existing in its current niche. The advances in camera technology engineered into Sony phones show it does not plan on going anywhere. I will be very disappointed if Sony leaves the phone business.

There are interesting phone manufacturers that I would like to buy a phone from, but they have essentially zero presence in the US.

knaik94··on Google Pixel 7 and Pixel 7 Pro
Hundreds of thousands of phones that are past their last security updates run fine. I don't install random apps or from third party websites. This phone along with last year's phone as well as the year before is rootable. If you care about security that much, you can install an updated vanilla android OS. If you're that scared about security, uninstall all third party apps. You still receive project mainline security updates.

About 75% of the current android version market share is Android 11.0 and lower. Android 11 came out in 2021. What's wasteful is thinking you have to throw away a phone because it won't receive security updates. You absolutely should not scrap phones like this.

knaik94··on Google Pixel 7 and Pixel 7 Pro
I have expensive headphones and I don't care to have one more thing I have to charge daily. My daily hours of use of headphones means that I'd have to buy two pairs of headphones and switch them halfway through the day to charge. Wireless headphones are still very far in terms of audio quality, compared to wired headphones. More importantly, for certain applications, the audio latency due to bluetooth is unacceptable. A single device might be okay, but it's not across all of the devices I use.

Most importantly, I want to charge my phone while using headphones at the same time.

Phones aren't getting faster enough for me to care about having the newest phone anymore. If my laptop and my tablets and my tv remote, and game controller all have 3.5mm jacks, buying a phone without one is a dumb decision. Why would I intentionally pay for a worse daily experience?

Usb c to 3.5mm adapters all have had worse quality than a native port. A phone lacking a headphone jack isn't a feature, it's a way to generate a new revenue stream.

I know I am in a very small population of hours spent listening to audio in a day, probably top 5%, but I believe my phone should make my life easier, not harder. Bluetooth still isn't anywhere close to having feature parity to the 3.5mm headphone jack. If it was, companies would have dropped headphones jacks from their laptops.

Dell xps 13 plus, released feb 2022, doesn't have a headphone jack. No laptop since has followed this decision, not even apple.

knaik94··on Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
Their chosen field of study doesn't affect the teaching ability of a professor. That's not relevant information. Do you imagine the professor keeps track of every pre-med student and gives them a different teaching and grading experience compared to others?
knaik94··on Google Pixel 7 and Pixel 7 Pro
The Sony line of phones are great options. Latest gen processors, oled, microsd slot, fantastic (if not best) camera front and back, headphone jack, 5000 mah battery. Current issues are thermal throttling, especially for long runtime 4k hdr video recording, and expensive. A previous year model is still a great choice though for 90% of the population. All previous generation models also have a headphone jack and most have microsd card.
knaik94··on Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
I think organic chemistry is hard enough as a subject to where students shouldn't have to face the additional difficulty of having adversarial teachers. A weeder course shouldn't be the same class students are expected to learn how to teach themselves material. If anything, a weeder course should have the best teachers in the department.

How to help make sure the teachers don't burn out is a different issue. I imagine it's hard to be the teacher of these kinds of classes year after year.

knaik94··on Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
I don't see how in a class of 30 students, having only 1 A and 1 B is a indicator of a good teacher. By definition the grades should reflect how well the students learn the material. Making your class artificially hard doesn't do anything to offset artificially easy courses. A class where 93% of students didn't properly master more than 80% of the material demonstrate a failure of the teacher not students. I am glad you gained something positive from that class, but I would say that is despite the professor, not because of them. Having good or bad grades is currently a poor reflection of how well a student will pickup new technologies exactly because of skewed grading methods like that of your professor. I am glad you gained something positive, but I wonder how many promising students were discouraged and pursued other interests over the years due to opaque testing standards. Tests are supposed to gauge how much information students are retaining from a teacher. In a high level class cross-listed for graduate students, the concern of lazy students shouldn't be an issue.
knaik94··on Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
From what I've experienced certain professors make it very clear they dislike teaching and expect students to teach themselves. I dropped out of a pre-med track at my university due to failing organic chemistry. I wasn't set up to succeed. This was made clear by the fact that it was the year with the most failed students in organic chemistry in the last 10 years. I also learned more things every recitation than in both weekly lectures combined, and my TA made it clear that this was normal and he was going to help us not fail. That teacher was not invited to teach a large 200 level class again. It was a distinguished research professor, and being at an R1 research university, he was very valuable as faculty but it was clear that he had no interest in teaching. He was much more comfortable as a mentor/teacher for higher level chemistry courses where the students have already learned the foundations and focus on their own research or independent study.

I ended up switching to CS, finished all of the required courses in 4 semesters instead of the usual 6+, and graduated only 1 year late, 5 years instead of 4. I even ended up doing an independent study and NIH funded summer research as an undergraduate in CS. I got to work in a grad lab on campus, one of the few non-phd candidates.

Organic chemistry is interesting because the cognition required for it is pretty similar to the cognition required for software development. The underlying technique is about knowing fundamental puzzle pieces and putting them together in new ways to solve problems/equations. This is a generalization and the techniques are obviously distinct at higher levels. But there are strong parallels between the problem solving method and techniques in organic chemistry and software engineering.

I should have really loved organic chemistry but I didn't. I still hate it to this day, not because of the material, but because of the negative emotions associated with the class.

It's really frustrating that CS education has a strong culture, in the US, of having to teach yourself to be successful. This is true regardless of how great of a university you end up at. It's equally true at MIT and Stanford as it is at any state University. I understand the motivation to foster an environment of students passionate to learn on their own, but forcing them doesn't accomplish that, it just pushes the issue to the next year. I understand the need to make students learn that at a certain point in their academic journey, they need to be comfortable teaching themselves because no one else will really have an answer for them. This gets warped into this fear based teaching method of encouraging the idea that anything less than a B means failure but at the same time getting an A is impossible unless you're a prodigy. It's very damaging to the mental health of the students. Professors dismissing this fact shouldn't teach because they clearly can't foster a healthy environment for students.

I don't know if that's true for every university, but it was true for mine, a respected R1, top 20 math, top 30 CS, physics, top 50 Bio, Chem program in the country. It was true for the 300+ level classes in biology and chemistry as well as math and CS.

knaik94··on Did an NYU professor get fired because students hate organic chem?
I have heard the opposite about Maitland Jones from people that have taken a course with them.
knaik94··on Gambler’s Ruin Problem [pdf]
This reminds me how I was introduced to this topic, the St Petersburg paradox. It was after a discrete 2 final. The professor heard us talking about a competition from our Quant finance club and decided to ask us this problem. Essentially asking the same thing but with a dice, so with replacement, with bigger values and asking what logic our stop algorithm would be to maximize our return. And what would happen if the gain and loss weren't equal with something like +4,+3,+2,-1,-2,-3 as well aas with -4,-3,-2,+1,+2,+3. We ended up staying an extra 2 hours discussing it.
knaik94··on Bruce Willis Sells Deepfake Likeness Rights So His 'Twin' Can Star in Movies
I agree with you, that conclusion does make the most sense. From reading articles about what recent directors that work with him said, he was aware of his difficulties but was genuinely optimistic.

Celebrities unfortunately can have their careers made or broken on the basis of these kinds of rumors. Culturally, in the US, it seems like critical thinking is being valued less. I can't say for sure if that's true. I recognize that I live in a cultural bubble and rarely interact with people of the opposite opinion that I can have a respectful conversation with. My framework of certain groups is almost completely based on the media tropes and reaction-baiting social media posts of them I come across on things like Reddit and Youtube. Reasonable opinions make boring content.

I believe it was worded slightly differently when I responded to it. On hindsight I might have been feeding a troll comment. I appreciate your perspective. Hacker news just isn't a place where I am used to seeing this type of conjecture based conclusions.

knaik94··on YouTube age-restriction quagmire exposed by 78-minute Mega Man documentary
I wonder when AI will reach a point where it can reasonably detect and classify more esoteric forms of humor. Deadpan humor is very difficult to explain to a computer, the reason it is funny is because the delivery sounds like it is not a joke. You have to intuit that the speaker would never ever believe what they are saying for it to be funny.

At some point even comments will become a signal Youtube uses to decide how to classify videos.

And no, there have been many channels over the years that have complained about the age-restriction issue even though they expressed clearly that the are a mixed-audience channel.

To show a much much more severe example, here's a tweet showing youtube misclassifying Happy Tree Friends as kids friendly, a cartoon style animated show about cute looking animals that get gruesomely killed in various cruel and disturbing situations. Clearly a parody of things like Tom and Jerry in many ways. Reasonable and artistically meaningful, especially when it came out in 1999, but clearly no human was in that misclassification process. They are 1 to 5 minute episodes.

https://twitter.com/Rat_Tail_Tony/status/1215015868515655680

knaik94··on YouTube age-restriction quagmire exposed by 78-minute Mega Man documentary
I think "the algorithm" is the only reason Youtube is popular at all. It's also the reason Tiktok became popular. "The algorithm" more than anything else explains both Youtube's popularity for long form content and its failure for short form vertical video content as well as livestreaming. "The algorithm" recommends new videos based on what you previously watched and that depends on creators emulating others and creating content in similar areas. "The algorithm" dictates not only what the viewer can find but also what creators will spend time making and what areas new creators will try out. It's hard to predict what new thing will become popular on Youtube but it is easy to predict when the performance of similar videos is so readily accessible. View count is the first thing anyone reads after the title and creator of a video by design.
← PreviousPage 13 of 23Next →