HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knaik94

2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015

knaik1994 a.t gmail d(o)t com github knaik twitter @knaikk
submissionscomments
knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
That wouldn't scale because each new set of printer dots would require a complete re-encode. You can find raw rips on the high seas, so anything less than hard-coded dots would just get stripped anyway. If you take rips from two sources, you could also just subtract one identical frame from another to isolate the dots and remove them.
knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
You're making a lot of incorrect and dismissive generalizations. If you're able to notice the differences in color calibration and film grain, more power to you. Most people can't explain the difference between the saturation in video when watching something on a phone compared to watching it on their TV, if they even detect it. For what it's worth, I just did a Farnsworth-Munsell 100 hue test and got a perfect score again. I'm not sure why telling apart fingernail polish shades would make a difference in how meaningful or noticeable changes in saturation or film grain are to people.

Readability is dependent on screen brightness and difference in contrast between background and foreground colors. These decisions aren't based on what engineers assume matters, it's dependent mostly on A/B testing and perception psychology. It's the same kind of research that went into making the OPUS audio codec and deciding which parts people will notice missing and which parts don't really make a difference. Tiny to moderate changes in visibility/readability make a much smaller difference than you imagine.

https://www.colorblindnesstest.org/farnsworth-munsell-100-hu...

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
It's impossible to have a pristine signal when talking about film and tv. Having to transmit over wires and having to go from analog to digital will introduce quantization noise. Additionally raw capture and playback isn't an option because of transmission bandwidth limitations. And displays aren't in 12bit color depth, the most obvious visual example of poor quantization is color banding. While less obvious, film grain does the same for increasing the perceived texture. The quantization errors observable in video are different than in audio and I was trying to make an analogy that feels intuitive. I think the street picture in this link is helpful.

https://www.hdnumerique.com/dossiers/962-test-4k-ultra-hd-bl...

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
We fundamentally disagree on how removing film grain, or changing things like saturation, affects end user experience. I don't believe it harms the viewing experience in a meaningful way. I respect that you care about artists' intent, but I think you're assuming more people care or notice than actually do. I don't believe adhering so strictly to the artists' intent will lead to a better watching experience. For some films where only a 1080p master remains, if you don't denoise before upscaling and then adding in artificial film grain, it'll look terrible.

There is an endless list of poor Bluray and UHD Bluray transfers where the the film grain makes it unwatchable. The unfortunate thing is that the nicer the display is, the sharper the image and the more distracting the grain. In some cases, I would trust the AV1 endcoder decoder to do a better job at adding a more reasonable amount of grain than the 4k transfer did. It's not a slippery slope, bad transfers and poorly color graded films/shows already exist. Mistakes exist in both directions, the UHD remaster release of Terminator 2 is a exceptionally horrible example of too much DNR. In my opinion T2 is bad enough to bring real actors into the uncanny valley.

The developers aren't doing anything different from what films do when going through an analog to digital transfer.

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
When going from film to digital, you have to modify the source noise in some way and there's no way to avoid it. A 1 to 1 transfer is possible, but I haven't come across any. Instead I have seen so many times where films either denoised too much or added too much artificial grain during the transfer. Starting from a very good source definitely helped, but film is limited in certain ways that digital isn't. Additionally, color grading for HDR10 and Dolby Vision was done. I didn't think that HDR would make a huge difference in a mostly black and white film but it does. The second picture comparison is what encouraged me to rewatch the movie again. [1]

[1] https://www.hdnumerique.com/dossiers/962-test-4k-ultra-hd-bl...

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
The artists' intent argument doesn't hold up, but is one that continues to be used as justification for "tradition". Most people aren't watching movies strictly in IMAX or even a color calibrated TV. Most default TV settings, even on the most high end devices, have things like dynamic saturation and motion smoothing on by default. The most popular brands of headphones do have custom eq from the factory, most people don't listen to studio monitor style flat audio. Most people don't realize there is a difference.

The meaning of art is up to the viewer, not the artist. There's nothing wrong with having a preference, like using things like temporal denoising or increasing/decreasing saturation. Even an IMAX movie theater isn't enough because that's not what the film was graded with. Pretending that art shouldn't be modified because it moves away from the artist's intent is a bad faith argument. There were certain House of Dragon color grading decision that made me feel very disappointed, and I was watching in Dolby Vision on a nice high dynamic range TV.

Artists' intent is useless if 99.999% of the population can't enjoy the actual art.

https://www.vulture.com/article/why-house-of-the-dragon-epis...

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
Similar to dithering, I believe film grain does help you resolve finer visual details. Having no texture would cause issues when trying to match things shot on different cameras as well. I agree with you that many movies and shows are guilty of adding so much grain it becomes distracting, but I was watching Schindler's List in UHD and loved how natural it looked. Things like clothing just felt more real and I didn't realize until the end that it was because of the expertly used film grain. The value of grain becomes obvious when you look at clips of that movie online.

https://www.audiocheck.net/audiotests_dithering.php

knaik94··on Netflix: 30% bitrate saving using Film Grain Synthesis
I'm not sure if it's because of growing up watching most things online with limited bitrates, but I realized I dislike film grain a lot. I know that to a certain degree, film grain helps humans resolve finer details. Similar to using noise shaped dithering to allow you to hear more than the theoretical dynamic range in audio or see a larger range of color tones in a picture. But I found that on certain 4K uhd blurays, if I am watching on a small screen the film grain looks very obnoxious. The problem doesn't exist when watching on a big TV, so I know it's not related to projecting on a screen. I really dislike when directors go out of their way to add artificial film grain. Will media players eventually allow users to adjust the film grain that is added back in?

This reminds me of Steve Yedlin's, cinematographer on everything from Brick to Star Wars: The Last Jedi to Knives Out and its 2022 sequel, Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery, who showed through research that film can be completely emulated using digital techniques and mixed digital and film shots during Star Wars.

https://www.audiocheck.net/audiotests_dithering.php

https://www.polygon.com/2020/2/6/21125680/film-vs-digital-de...

https://www.yedlin.net/NerdyFilmTechStuff/MatchLensBlur.html

https://www.yedlin.net/OnColorScience/index.html

knaik94··on Kickstarter shut down the campaign for AI porn group Unstable Diffusion
This isn't surprising, but is disappointing. Stable Diffusion 2.0 removed NSFW images from the training set making human anatomy generation a lot worse even for SFW prompts. This Techcrunch article is pretty unfairly biased against all AI art generation.

I dislike how much more political this debate has gotten. It's now impossible to defend one "side" without having a lot assumptions made about you, and often get anger aggressively targeted towards you. Very little online discourse seems to be happening in good faith.

There's a bunch of people exploiting the fine tuning to make models based on popular artists who explicitly don't want their art used in training sets. There are also a bunch of artists and non-researchers spreading misunderstandings about how art generation works and targeting researchers and AI artists very personally on places like Instagram and Twitter. I understand the anger people feel from both sides. But there's a very clear pattern of assuming people on each "side" as equally harmful as the most problematic on both "sides".

I think having a deeper understanding of the technology and it's limitations makes it clear that the best art is made by already trained artists. There's things that are generated wrong, like shadows in complex scenes, that everyone can recognize but only artists have the knowledge to recognize and fix properly. Like most things, the optimal solution is a hybrid approach, like using generated art as inspiration or mockups.

Midi instrument libraries exist but movie composers like Hans Zimmer still hire out philharmonic bands to record the score. I can't tell the difference but composers working at that level can. But they also have music banks of recorded music they rely on for certain instruments. But it's clear they will always prioritize live recording. Art is no different, in my opinion.

AI can generate an idea but it will not generate art in the exact way you want or imagine. Some situations allow you to get away with good enough if you don't look closely, but that's rarely the point of making art in the first place.

knaik94··on What AMC’s streaming troubles say about the greater TV industry
Being on YouTube is the same as being on Television, seeing it as a network is part of the problem. New media doesn't fit into old frameworks. Many YouTube creators have set up successful crowdfunded channels. Certain topics are always demonetized and can't run ads, and creators just use YouTube to help distribute content. Patreon rolled out its own platform after Vimeo became too expensive to host on. Twitch, arguably, is a meaningful competitor to YouTube but exclusively focuses on live streaming.

Over the last couple of years, YouTube managed to get top Twitch creators to switch with contracts of above 1 million dollars. Some leaked ad spots, like watching a trailer on stream or playing a game for 30-60 minutes, were between 2k and 10k USD for a streamer with around 8,000 average viewers per stream. There was a leak recently of how much top streamers on twitch made, and there were multiple 500K+ salaries. But the platform unfortunately follows the 1% of creators earn 90%+ of all income rule of thumb.

knaik94··on If you can read this, your browser captions are broken
Slightly off-topic, what is the current status on the progress of VLC and other local players rendering WebVTT? There's certain effects, like karaoke, on certain Youtube videos that, when downloaded in the right format can covert perfectly from srv3/ytt to .ass/substation alpha but .vtt to .ass fails.
knaik94··on If you can read this, your browser captions are broken
What do you mean by working better with speed controls? The playback speed multiplier affects both the video and captions for me on Youtube. I like opening up the "transcript" too from the hamburger menu on YT.

For local playback of media files, I use daum kakao Potplayer, I have never come across something more power user friendly. MPV is weaker in a lot of areas, in my opinion. Potplayer interfaces with everything I'd want including vaporsynth and madvr and it has options for subtitle resync based on a multiplier and also converting based on framerate 60 -> 30. There is even an option for live subtitle translations. I personally like using it with smooth video project, but I understand it's not everyone's taste.

knaik94··on Raspberry Pi 5 not arriving in 2023
I wish more companies took this approach. A current Amazon listing has the Pi 4 4gb for 170$ usd and Ebay similarly has 120$ for an open box. I've seen the 8gb ram frequently listed for over 200$. I recognize the shortage of new Pis but, at those prices, I don't understand the demand. I just found a used, tested, ebay listing for a Intel NUC Micro PC i5-7260U 2.2Ghz 8GB RAM 250GB SSD with Windows 10 for 160$. That's not a cherry picked example, similar specs are available across multiple listings at the same price +- 20$.

Are there situations outside a power draw limits where choosing a Pi makes more sense than a used NUC or business mini PC at a comparable price?

knaik94··on What AMC’s streaming troubles say about the greater TV industry
AMC alone doesn't say much about the greater TV industry since people have loyalty to specific shows and not the channel. Breaking Bad didn't become popular while airing, it became popular because it released on Netflix. Cable channels have outlived their purpose. Emulating cable channels by partitioning shows into streaming services is pushing people back to piracy.

The traditional TV industry is continuing to fail to adapt to the different way in which people watch content. Youtube demonstrates really well how people are no longer loyal to a network, they are loyal to a creator or topic. There have been certain groups of channels that sort of remind me of an old school TV channel, like MatPat and his youtube channels Game Theorists, Film Theorists, and Food Theorists could have been a TV channel in combination with some other video game or theory crafting channels but people don't search by a bigger topic. People find content based on recommendations, either algorithmic or popular things watched by friends. Netflix Originals and Amazon Originals seem better, but I can't understand the metrics Netflix uses when deciding what to cancel.

As someone who has shifted to online media as the main form of content I watch, I can't tell you what makes a cartoon network show a cartoon network show. I know because of the logos between shows and during ads, but I struggle to find a strong underlying identity.

The easier access to international media has also caused an oversaturation of available good media. I no longer need to worry about what part of the world a show is made in, if it's popular enough, you'll be able to find it sailing the seas. HBO Max, the supposed online equivalent to the cable channel HBO will drop Westworld from its online catalog. Some fantastic Disney+ Marvel shows, like the critically acclaimed Loki, have no announced plans of getting a physical release and Loki released back in Jun 2021. When a TV show enthusiast sees those two pieces of news back to back, a normal conclusion is that the only "sure" way to own shows is piracy.

knaik94··on AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating
Having to push the entire class to learn instead of just the self motivated is a bureaucratic decision. Everyone is paying 80,000$ to be there, it would be problematic for many reasons to ignore those that seem uninterested. For pre-college education, minimum student performance is usually the strongest metric tied to funding. I don't think the current schooling system is set to let everyone find things they will care about learning and not cheating in. It's not realistic to expect no one to want to cheat. Even the brightest student can feel insecure enough in their ability, feel pressured to cheat if they believe those around them will cheat, or just want to get that little bit more ahead of the competition. Cheating is not strictly tied to honesty.
knaik94··on AI breakthrough ChatGPT raises alarm over student cheating
I don't know how many teachers or administrators will say it outright, but LLMs and ChatGPT assisted essays are a lot more difficult to detect. ChatGPT is accurate enough to answer many typical reading comprehension questions at a high school+ level.

Students will always feel some incentive to cheat, even if they wouldn't in isolation, they could feel pressured based on their peers. A strong curriculum isn't enough to encourage every single student not to take shortcuts. Despite all external circumstances, it's still an active choice to cheat. Cheating is framed one-way because it's generally discussed imagining the laziest and most adversarial student possible, similar to how you'd red team for security testing.

I think the concern is things like ChatGPT will lead to a lot more students cheating. I think it's human nature to want to take shortcuts. I agree with you that the way in which cheating is demonized in a school environment is counterproductive in the long run. I think admin and teachers have hid behind students' fear of academic integrity violations being reported on a college application to not have to admit that most are terrible at catching cheaters. It's from the perspective of imagining ignorant teachers and adversarial students. Most minor cases of cheating aren't caught, even at a college level.

knaik94··on Apple Music deletes your original songs and replaces them with DRM'd versions
I know for a fact that YTM still has poor metadata support, the only way to fix it is to reupload the entire file. That's a huge reason why I moved to a self hosted solution. I know there were multiple cases where the metadata was wrong and two separate versions of a song were tagged as the same track. But I never lost any data. I would recommend doing a takeout and exporting all the songs if possible.

I have to imagine Google HAS to dedup on the server side, otherwise even a 100,000 song cap would be too much data to host for free. Google doesn't play ads on uploaded tracks. Google stores not-transcoded music files and has since "Google Music". When GPM first came out, it was a storage locker and felt more like direct competition to Grooveshark than iTunes.

Record companies seem to have a very tight not just on the songs, but also the metadata surrounding them. No service really offers the "radio mode" or suggested tracks for local playback, from what I found. I'd happily give a company playback metadata if in return I got that feature back. I wonder if Pandora has patents for certain parts of music recommendation algorithms. Spotify and YTM can rely heavily on user-generated music connections, but maybe that is why it can't work for local/uploaded files.

knaik94··on Apple Music deletes your original songs and replaces them with DRM'd versions
I think it's understandable that someone wouldn't expect to need a backup of their music library. At a bare minimum, I would expect iTunes to keep both versions of a file if an identical one can't be retrieved from Apple servers.

People that care enough to keep a library of music after the popularity of Spotify are the same people to leave the ecosystem permanently when this kind of stuff happens.

knaik94··on Apple Music deletes your original songs and replaces them with DRM'd versions
I gave up on iTunes after realizing how aggressively and poorly it matches your library against its catalog. I remember times when I intentionally deleted a "match" and when the scan was triggered again it would erase my copy again. I thought there was something I was doing incorrectly since I couldn't find much online about it.

Google Play Music was the last true third party hosted solution, in my opinion. YouTube Music allows you to upload files but segregates your uploads from the YouTube Library for recommendations and smart playlists. I haven't found a great "smart recommendation" service for self hosted files.

knaik94··on Apple Music deletes your original songs and replaces them with DRM'd versions
I had a different experience, on export my files were all in the original encoding. The value of Google Play Music was that you could upload files. I have also never had any files replaced.

I have enjoyed self hosted solutions since YouTube Music broke the smart Playlist and integration for uploaded files with steaming files.

knaik94··on Nvidia ends Gamestream on all Shield devices. Suggests switching to Steam Link
I am a little surprised, I assumed Gamestream was mostly local. I imagined it was similar to Plex/Jellyfin where the computer is doing all of the transcoding.

I know that the Nvidia Shield TV Pro is a flagship product and highly recommended in home media server circles. It's not hard to imagine Nvidia shifting their focus to that product and sunsetting a feature that doesn't overlap a lot with that crowd.

Nvidia Shield TV Pro is one of the only devices I know of that can play back Dolby Vision files properly, at least via Plex/Kodi. The specific DV profiles supported is a work in progress but the most common webrips are detected properly and enable Dolby Vision mode on the TV. BD Rips aren't completely supported by any device other than disk players, but non DV fallback usually works fine. Chinese TV boxes have unofficial DV support but certain surround codec support can be spotty and support could mean simply discarding the metadata. Kodi added support recently on android builds but DV needs hardware level support as well for true playback.

knaik94··on Windows 11 update added 'Search' label to taskbar search button – how to remove?
A lot of this list already exists in windows 10.
knaik94··on Investigating Logan Paul's biggest scam [video]
I imagine it comes from people's optimistic belief that trust can be rebuilt and bad people can be reformed. When a public figure was disgraced so openly, by the entire planet, any kind of comeback indirectly reflects a positive change. If they were bad people, it's hard to understand why they are still popular. I am not arguing that any of that logic is correct, just sympathizing why Logan Paul was given a second chance by a lot of these people.
knaik94··on Facebook owner Meta sued for inciting hatred in Ethiopia
My position is that Facebook should be protected under section 230. Section 230 says no online content hosting platform will be liable for what their users post as long as they attempt content moderation in good faith. My understanding of this lawsuit is, Facebook is being sued for 2 Billion USD because it was enabling hateful speech and targeted posts that lead to the death of man. Facebook is allegedly directly liable because of poor moderation.

The distinction you are making doesn't make sense. Are you making an analogy to the idea that you can use the word fire but you can't yell fire in a crowded place? Facebook doesn't choose individually what posts are highlighted, the engagement of other users does. The complete weights of what is highlighted are also unique per user. You're arguing that Facebook has a duty of care, but as it stands section 230 already addresses that. The duty of care is fulfilled with good faith moderation. The only way Facebook can be found liable is if section 230 is weakened and good faith moderation is redefined.

"Tort liability indicates that someone is held accountable for wrong actions (other than under contract." Tort liability is the phrase you would search if you wanted to learn about previous legal rulings related to this. I thought the Columbia Law Review article I linked was pretty approachable. It's not possible to talk about this in a meaningful way without understanding tort. I haven't tried to obscure or distract from my position intentionally.

I think Force v. Facebook was the proper ruling. There's nothing new courts have to decide, because section 230 already addresses this. Fundamentally, people are hateful and will engage and interact with hateful content. It doesn't make sense to blame an algorithm for not realizing a post is hateful and highlighting it. I made my position clear without technical jargon in the top comment. The DW article says the lawsuit wants to legally force Facebook to change its algorithm. The change would directly be related to moderation. This would be a slippery slope. Failing to understand the limitation of what an algorithm does is the only way you could expect a separation of the concept of posting content vs posting it "like that". I hope I was able to clarify my position.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/24/technology/section-230-he...

knaik94··on Raising the bar for software security: next steps for GitHub.com 2FA
The health service application my doctors use, MyChart powered by Epic has that functionality. I get the option of using SMS or email, and I think they allow email because it's information the doctor's office confirms when I visit. I can imagine 2FA being approved for emails, but only for providers that have proper 2FA for email login. Otherwise it's just pushing the problem to a different place. Maybe email 2FA isn't used because email that doesn't enforce it for email login can't be assume to have it.

I don't think there's a way to allow recovery based on only information because then recovery become the primary method to take control of your account. Once you start adding limits to recovery attempts, you end up back where we already were before 2FA become popular. And what's stored in your head becomes a very easy target, especially for those less tech literate.

I really liked Facebook's idea of trusted contacts based recovery. It would allow a complete true loss of everything based on who and what you know and doesn't rely on a company having any information other than who your friends are. Which Facebook already knew since you were friends with them. Facebook's single identity model made that easy but for Gmail or Instagram it's common to have multiple that you don't check often.

knaik94··on Raising the bar for software security: next steps for GitHub.com 2FA
I am very happy about Github's clear and upfront 2FA policy to rely on TOTP and only allow passkeys as a secondary method. This feels like the most reasonable way to manage logins and security moving forward.

I am not sure where friction exists for an audience of, presumably, tech literate people deploying TOTP 2FA. I understand the concern in a more diverse group, but I'd assume developers have a better understanding of security.

I can understand reservations about using a non open source service, but with apps like Aegis on Android and Ravio OTP on iOS. I have an encrypted backup of my secrets synced from my Android phone to Dropbox and Google severs. The encryption is based on a password I chose. I lost my device and restoring my 2FA was as smooth as I expected.

I am very annoyed by Google constant push to try to get me to start using my phone like a WebAuthn passkey and it's pushing me further and further from the technology. I don't believe security exists if I don't control my secrets. I hope they shift their approach to the same as what Github's currently is. Google nags users to login with the passkey every once in a while if it's registered, regardless of what primary 2FA you want to use.

"Authentication with a security key is secondary to authentication with a TOTP application or a text message. If you lose your security key, you'll still be able to use your phone's code to sign in."

https://docs.github.com/en/authentication/securing-your-acco...

knaik94··on Ways to get around ChatGPT's safeguards
It gives incorrect information about the process all the time. For making LSD one of the steps was waiting for a specific color change, but with the wording of the prompt changed it used the same context but specified a different color.
knaik94··on Ways to get around ChatGPT's safeguards
Look into KoboldAi, it doesn't need to download the internet, just interface with it.
knaik94··on Facebook owner Meta sued for inciting hatred in Ethiopia
I have not experienced the toxic negativity you have associated with only modern social media. I am in a couple of online groups of the things you are describing as social spaces of before, there's a local hiking group, an unofficial puzzled pints group, multiple AI and Defcon related groups, TV show discussion groups, and occasionally concert groups for when an artist I enjoy is playing near me. If you're not using Facebook or Discord or some other social media for this, I would suggest you look into it. Social media is focused on self curation as much as algorithmic curation. If you have to approach your social media feed like a warzone, I would start by muting or unfollowing as many problematic people as possible. It'll be up to you to make sure your feed doesn't become an echo chamber, but at a minimum you won't feel such negative anger towards a literal piece of code.

Like and Dislikes are only as valuable as users allow them to be. A great counterexample to many of your arguments is the social media site we are discussing this topic on. The culture on Hacker News de-emphasizes Likes and Dislike. Comment karma is visible to the poster, but to a reader, a +100 karma comment is equal to a +4 karma comment with the only difference being what is seen first. I personally forget about that and end up reading comments to the end of threads I enjoy anyway.

I think letting such hostility build for the concept of social media is as damaging as any political extremism the censorship is supposed to combat. It feels like the extremism isn't gone, just redirected. Social media and the internet has changed who people interact with, not just how. In the past extreme ideas existed, but were tempered because of others around them. Social media has allowed people to choose to only listen to people with the same perspective, letting extreme ideas go uncontrolled. You can argue that it's the fault of the technology, but the main responsibility falls on the individuals.

Social media doesn't make people hateful, it makes it easier for hateful people to convince other to think like them. Bullies have existed long before social media and continue to exist in every context.

knaik94··on Facebook owner Meta sued for inciting hatred in Ethiopia
> We can decide that for example they could not have predicted this outcome and so are not liable, or that they should have and were neglectful, or something else.

We fundamentally disagree on whether or not what Facebook "should" have expected or "should" have done is worth considering. I don't think it's legally relevant. Profits can demonstrate incentive that otherwise wouldn't exist.

The existing legal precedent for how algorithms are considered under tort liability [1] are still unclear. It's clear to me that allowing this lawsuit to move forward would be directly contradicting the ruling of Force v. Facebook (2019) and would force a ruling on how AI algorithms should be held liable with respect to section 230.

From the perspective of the user, making a platform liable would mean that the platform would fundamentally shift what users are allowed to post and strongly weakens basic rights to freedom of expression. It's hard to depict how different and more censored the internet would be if section 230 continues to become weakened.

"Critically, the finding that AI algorithms can be found to be harmful allows for the tort liability process to come into effect. While this kind of legal approach has not yet been taken, Patel indicates that corporate liability is a possibility. If an AI algorithm causes harm, it must be prosecuted through tort liability."

"However, in the same timeframe as Patel’s ruling in 2019, ... a group of U.S. citizens who were victims of a Hamas terrorist attack, sued Facebook, arguing that Facebook implicitly assisted Hamas by keeping their violence-promoting content online through their AI algorithm’s oversight. [12] However, in accordance with 42 U.S.C. 230(c)(1), the rule that protects social media platforms from liability for content on their platforms, the court found that Facebook could not be found to have criminal or civil liability for content. [13] This case complicates the implications of Patel, as it found that Facebook was shielded from liability because the content itself was not created by the platform. "

[1] https://www.culawreview.org/journal/extending-corporate-tort...

← PreviousPage 9 of 23Next →