5,522 karma · joined September 2, 2019
Physics StackExchange: https://physics.stackexchange.com/users/83398/knzhou
Personal website: https://knzhou.github.io
For example, the "good speech" counterpart of David Icke is a number of real experts who are taking to Twitter and blogs. I've seen a few. They usually have single digit reach. In five minutes, Icke can reach a larger audience than all of them combined throughout their entire lives.
"We just can't know if the polio vaccine will work, because it's just fundamentally impossible to decide what is true and false."
"What about the trials the scientists did?"
"No, grandma, believing the scientists would be picking a side."
The only reason that anybody thinks deciding the truth is impossible is because we're currently living with the greatest amount of free speech in history. It's a slippery slope but in the exact opposite direction than everybody thinks.
The progress of science wasn't driven by nutjobs delivering spittle-flecked rants on Youtube. Almost all of it was driven by careful peer review of ideas -- which is the exact opposite of unrestricted speech.
This is one of those completely false things that people only believe is true by repetition. Go back and actually read the full set of WHO statements in mid-January. They have a bunch of statements saying that nations should get prepared, one saying that specific studies haven’t yet found hard evidence for person-to-person transmission (because at that point most of the cases they’d managed to find were tied to the market). The WHO never, ever said that it can’t be transmitted, and they absolutely never said that people should do nothing about COVID-19. They were urging nations to act for months before they actually did.
> 4. Masks don't work (but health workers need them!).
They don't say masks don't work either, they say that health workers need them more. Here you need to remember that the W stands for "World". They worry the most about the poorer countries who have much fewer masks available.
It doesn't. That's precisely why Icke's ban is necessary: he was incredibly popular.
Any such channel which is truly open to questions immediately gets swamped by political attacks, along with an endless horde who think they're in the smartest 5% yet accuse the scientists of being in the pocket of the lizard people. Malicious agents will be able to mine even slightly nuanced explanations for out of context quotes to show that their political opponents are stupid or evil. If the channel is to be useful at all, it must make statements under uncertainty, but that gives it the chance of being occasionally wrong -- and anything it ever gets wrong will be repeated ad nauseum as an argument to defund it. If the channel is visible and trusted, it also becomes a prime target for politicians looking to shift blame away from themselves.
The reason I'm completely sure this will happen is that the information channel you're asking for already exists. It's called the World Health Organization, and they've been doing informative press conferences this whole time. However, everybody on this site has decided that they're useless because of a single, incorrectly read, out-of-context tweet from 4 months ago.
> - Maybe I don't fully understand why LIGO needs two arms. If you had a clock that could accurately measure light wave crests, could you do it only with one arm?
Yes, that's absolutely right. The two arms cancel out the frequency fluctuations of the laser itself. If we had a perfectly stable laser, we could make do with just one arm.
Regarding the question about what stretches and what doesn't, I think the general rule is that rigidity prevents "stretching". For example, a hydrogen atom in expanding space would lose momentum over time, because it redshifts, but the atom itself wouldn't get any bigger. There's no need to invoke a higher dimension here, just some things are rigid (like laser cavities and the Earth) and some things aren't (like electromagnetic waves). In fact, in general invoking higher dimensions without a strong reason to is discouraged when discussing general relativity, simply because the math is already very complicated in 4D.
I don't have time to "school" you in everything, because you wrote so much that was wrong that I don't have time to. That's literally the whole point of a gish gallop: it takes 10x more words to refute bullshit than to state it.
While I'm having my morning coffee let me do a few:
> the CCP has made a big show of shutting down the wet markets, only to allow them to reopen quietly
This is completely wrong, because it mixes up wet markets (which literally mean any market that doesn't only sell dry goods, and which also exist throughout Asia, in Europe, and even in the US, and are far less weird than you've been told: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whbyuy2nHBg ), and the exotic wildlife trade. The latter was shut down, and remains shut down. The former have never been shut down, because it's where people get their groceries.
> The Wuhan Institute of Virology was scrubbed of information about one particular young woman who was working as an intern there, and has been named as a possible "patient zero."
If you actually read the complete evidence that Project "Evidence" gives for this, it is:
1. There was a graduate student at WIV that graduated 5 years ago (as graduate students do)
2. There was once a rumor on Chinese social media that this person was patient zero, but absolutely no reason given why that would be the case (and obviously, Chinese social media is just as unreliable as social media everywhere else)
3. This graduate student has not recently made any dramatic public appearances or viral social media posts (because why would they)
4. This graduate student is no longer on the lab website (this is completely normal; they would only remain 5 years after graduating if the lab managers forgot to keep updating the site)
That pretty much sounds like zero evidence to me. But how do they summarize it?
> Would it really be impossible for the Chinese government to get in touch with her and have her issue an in-person statement to the media? It would only be impossible if she was dead.
I mean, forget about how weird this demand is — it’s negotiating with China as it they were the Borg. Even if the demand were in good faith, does that sound like a document aiming to find the truth? Or is it just trying to make a series of low-evidence claims sound maximally sinister? Are you really the kind of person who falls for this?
> conspiracy theory [...] has since been corroborated in multiple Western mainstream publications
Not the ones I've read, and I've read plenty. This is a massive claim with no evidence.
From the perspective of understanding the universe, that is nothing. Decent consolation prize though.
It's the exact analogue of how serious student athletes throw away their whole undergrad education for a shot at a pro career, usually to end up injured and useless a couple years later.
This is one of those completely false things that people only believe is true by repetition. Go back and actually read the full set of WHO statements in mid-January. They have a bunch of statements saying that nations should get prepared, one saying that specific studies haven’t yet found hard evidence for person-to-person transmission (because at that point most of the cases they’d managed to find were tied to the market). The WHO never, ever said that it can’t be transmitted, and they absolutely never said that people should do nothing about COVID-19. They were urging nations to act for months before they actually did.
The point is that in elementary school arithmetic, you define addition, multiplication, subtraction, division, decimals, and equality, but you never define "...". Until you've defined "...", it's just a meaningless sequence of marks on paper. You can't prove anything about it using arithmetic, or otherwise.
What the "arithmetic proofs" are really showing that if we want "..." to have certain extremely reasonable properties, then we must choose to define it in such a way that 0.999... = 1. Other definitions would be possible (for example, a stupid definition would be 0.999... = 42), just not useful.
What probably causes the flame wars over "..." is that most people never see how "..." is defined (which properly would require constructing the reals). They only see these indirect arguments about how "..." should be defined, which look unsatisfying. Or they grow so accustomed to writing down "..." in school that they think they already know how it's defined, when it never has been!
However, the damage has already been done. He's already done his media blitz, so no matter what happens next, effectively zero people will hear the correction (or more likely, subsequent retraction). It'll just become yet another piece of zombie information, which will appear in dishonest talking points or gish gallops. The quality of public discourse and the reputation of science will continue its decline, and we'll be talking about the next example of this tomorrow.