HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

konstruktor

1,306 karma · joined July 9, 2011

submissionscomments
konstruktor··on Kotlin: A statically-typed language that compiles to JVM bytecode and JavaScript
I like that you can even explain why it is complex. I was just able to give an example, that is explained by your argument (a type system for a purely functional language as opposed to a mix of everything).
konstruktor··on Kotlin: A statically-typed language that compiles to JVM bytecode and JavaScript
This reminds me of one of my favourite Stackoverflow threads, where Odersky himself explains in just a few paragraphs why the signature of the map function in Scala is not overly complicated: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/1722726/is-the-scala-2-8-... I am not joking when I say that they have actually introduced "simplified signatures" into the API docs after this :)

So yeah, if it takes several paragraphs to explain why something that can be as straightforward as this (Haskell)

(a -> b) -> [a] -> [b]

is actually not that complicated when it looks like this

def map[B, That](f: (A) ⇒ B)(implicit bf: CanBuildFrom[List[A], B, That]): That

it is clearly the stupid infidels that don't get it. This doesn't mean that Scala is a bad language in general, just that it is ridiculous to state that it isn't complex, especially compared to Lisp.

konstruktor··on FeelBetterBot wants you to feel better
This is a very dangerous project idea. Have you, for one second, considered that this is not a sales funnel, where the only thing that counts is the "success rate" at the other end, but something dealing with people in a crisis? People who may just be considering suicide, and can be tipped in both ways. For example by a pseudo-empathic bot that tells them the same shit they hear all day in the US, which sounds nice but is the culturally accepted way to say "Please either pretend to be happy, or shut up" [1].

Please generously apply the hacker mentality to software, arduinos, knitting, cooking and art, if you like. Don't be afraid to fail, nothing bad happens there. Build, test, iterate, enjoy.

There are, however, things in life where the stakes are higher. They require more knowledge than you can quickly gather with a Google search, and, you know, professionalism. Healthcare is one of these topics.

[1] As this seems to be a bit of a cultural blind spot for people in the US, I highly recommend http://www.amazon.com/Bright-Sided-Positive-Thinking-Undermi...

konstruktor··on Toyota's firmware: Bad design and its consequences
The cost of the level of training airline pilots get (around 100kUSD) would be prohibitive for individual driving. Also, they fly with an equally well trained colleague who will run the checklists in an emergency and correct their mistakes. I assume private pilots make as stupid mistakes as individual drivers.

Aircraft investigation is really good at overcoming hindsight bias and looking at human factors in a more objective way. What seems absolutely logical for you to type, having read about these incidents before, might not be as obvious to a driver who hasn't read about unwanted acceleration but is suddenly experiencing it.

konstruktor··on Toyota's firmware: Bad design and its consequences
Very well said. The focus on convenience and cool features over safety makes me really sad, and want to force automotive engineers to watch some Alan Kay talks. He loves to talk how people who don't know the history and basics of their craft will arrive at inferior solutions, for example in this one: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvmTSpJU-Xc
konstruktor··on The E-Cigarette Industry, Waiting to Exhale
I as a non-smoker can buy an e-cigarette, so one should judge the safety of the product on its own, not compared to something that is clearly harmful.

Methadone, for example, is used for harm reduction. It's only available as an prescription alternative to a harmful addiction. And still, substitution therapy is treated like any other form of medicine, i.e. the industry has to prove the merits of their product before it can go on sale.

Nicotine patches, which are available OTC to the general public, at least had to be proven as safe in clinical trials.

konstruktor··on The E-Cigarette Industry, Waiting to Exhale
The burden of proof, in this case, should be on the e-cigarette industry. They are selling an addictive recreational product, consisting of a new combination of substances, with a novel delivery method (that involves deep inhalation). It would be naive to let them play the game the cigarette industry has played for decades, that is trying to dodge the burden of proof for safety and spreading uncertainty.

And let's not forget that, for a novel product, the baseline for safety is not using the product, not using something that is known to be extremely toxic.

konstruktor··on Seagate just reinvented the disk interface using Ethernet
"Über alles" will be primarily associated with Hitler's anthem of the Third Reich by most native speakers of German who know some history. Not a good choice for a title.
konstruktor··on Dr. Arjun Srinivasan: We’ve Reached “The End of Antibiotics, Period”
> If you cut back on keeping them healthy, you're cutting the amount of food available for human consumption.

You are cutting the amount of meat and dairy available for human consumption, not food. Eating animal products is not a terribly efficient way of getting nutrients.

konstruktor··on Fructose: The Poison Index
The rise of the lipid hypothesis wasn't the general scientific consensus being wrong, it was the US government cherry picking science based on lobbyist pressure. So while I fully trust science to advance, I don't trust the US government to build science-based, non-biased dietary guidelines based on scientific findings.
konstruktor··on Fructose: The Poison Index
The advice you get there is a political consensus, not a scientific one. Have a look at http://www.choosemyplate.gov/, linked directly from health.gov: You will have a hard time finding a recommendation against any food product. The non-obvious trick used to appease the food industry is basing the recommendations on nutrients and ingredients, allowing the industry to push their "Any food product can be part of a balanced diet" myth, and reengineer the processed food so that they can put whatever nutrient or ingredient is considered healthy right now on the labels.
konstruktor··on Because it needs to be said
Nice ad hominem, but it doesn't address my question. Also, what you are taking out of context here is the author describing her life falling apart after this incident, not her behaviour before the incident.
konstruktor··on Because it needs to be said
The problem with "ask first" is that it is a self-defeating behaviour in current culture: Touching is an integral part of flirting and also common in interactions that don't involve sexual or romantic interest. And the current social norm is to start with light touching at a non-intimate place, and see if the other person reciprocates. Doing so is associated with confidence. "Can I touch the outside of your arm?" would be perceived as creepy for two reasons: It will be considered a sign of insecurity, and people often aren't explicitly aware of the implicit rules on touching, and would thus find the request strange.

Asking first already works well in some sexual subcultures as well as some professional settings: For example, in some armies, a superior will ask a soldier whether they may touch them before fixing something that's wrong about the way they are wearing their uniform. That's a very professional way of dealing with having to touch somebody who is reporting to you. The hard question is how one can engineer this cultural change in society in general. I would love to see that happening in my lifetime

konstruktor··on Because it needs to be said
Cool advice. Now please tell me about an industry where "drinking with the guys" is not a central part of the networking/socializing needed to have a career.
konstruktor··on Because it needs to be said
We have a culture of alcohol being involved in most team interactions outside of work. Those mostly take place in the evening, a time when, usually, private socializing, including mate seeking behaviour, happens. That alone would be quite a fertile ground for sexual harassment, if you add a few females to a group mostly consisting of men. Then add companies where people work long hours and have little life outside of work. And now consider conferences, where people are away from their regular social circle for extended periods of time.

I would not want to be a young, attractive female working in this environment.

konstruktor··on Because it needs to be said
According to the story, the other person involved was allowed to leave the company, saying it was his own decision. Nobody forced him to blog about it. He, however, chose to take the topic of his leaving the company public, in a way that one can easily see would sound like derision to somebody who was a victim of assault: http://objo.com/2013/01/31/funemployment/

So now it's internet mob behaviour if she posts her side of the story?

konstruktor··on Swiss to vote on 2,500 franc basic income for every adult
> One of the main questions about something like this is about who would do boring, low-paid work with this sort of basic income.

I think that with basic income, this question would not make sense, and that's exactly the reason that I like the idea so much. The reason why people do boring, dirty and dangerous work for little money is that there are folks who have no skills that would enable them to get a more fulfilling, cleaner, safer job that pays more. Those people depend on income, any income, to live, so they do the dirty jobs, and since there is a large pool of these workers, the shitty jobs can even pay just enough to survive.

With a decent basic income scheme, i.e. the basic needs of the people taken care of, the job market would probably flip: You would have to pay people very well for doing unpleasant work, and not so well for fulfilling jobs.

konstruktor··on At 16, Ganesh got a job in Qatar. Two months later he was dead
I was, obviously, saying the very opposite, i.e. that what you are describing is an inherent flaw of democracy, and that some discrimination is just more obvious for cultural reasons. Usually, institutions like the supreme court save the day in the worst cases, but when this control fails, like with the popular votes in Switzerland on Voting rights for women, democracies can be quite barbaric.
konstruktor··on At 16, Ganesh got a job in Qatar. Two months later he was dead
Women not being allowed to vote is actually an inherent flaw of democracy: Those who are allowed to vote decide who else may vote. All democratic countries make this kind of decision for many groups. Voting age, if and when immigrants may vote, whether to let people convicted of a felony or prisoners vote: all of these are cases of the voters deciding on who else will share their privilege. Switzerland was just slightly different because referendums are binding and were not overturned by the supreme courts, and the discriminated group was more visible/obvious.
konstruktor··on Microsoft’s Hardware, Round 2: Surface 2 and Surface Pro 2
Downvoted you because this looks like astroturfing. New account, seemingly random nickname, a persona matching the target audience of this site and several postings with purely positive content and a style that doesn't look right on HN.

That said, the Surface Pro 2 looks really appealing.

konstruktor··on Drug addiction: The complex truth
Are you sure you are talking about the destructive potential of heroin itself and not the circumstances in which it is consumed? It is not necessarily an IV drug, but the price, driven by criminalization, makes smoking prohibitively expensive (see the other comment about the Vietnam soldiers). In countries where the distribution of syringes is criminalised (Russia, USA), syringes are reused and shared. The price of the drug encourages the users to resort crime to obtain it and neglect other aspects of their lives (nutrition, hygiene, living conditions). All of those aren't necessarily effects of the drug itself.
konstruktor··on List of Wall Street CEOs prosecuted for the financial crisis
Madoff ran a Ponzi scheme and was convicted for fraud.
konstruktor··on Don't trust me: I might be a spook
On the Space Shuttle, four computers with identical software ran redundantly, and a fifth with independent software was used to detect errors. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle http://www.hq.nasa.gov/pao/History/computers/Ch4-4.html

This was, of course, very expensive, and made software changes a very difficult and slow process.

konstruktor··on The 10 commandments for happiness and success
Are you sure the people on the other side of the world, living in famine, also consider your ignorance bliss? What is more irrational: Choosing to ignore grave suffering that we have the resources to end, many times over, for the sake of avoiding bad feelings, or at least acknowledging the suffering of others? I think the latter is an essential step in bringing modern society to a state that can truly be called civilised.
konstruktor··on Official statement from WikiLeaks regarding Edward Snowden's exit from Hong Kong
Your personal experience is not a source, keep your reddit speak where it belongs.
konstruktor··on You use PHP because you don't know better.
I don't know a single PHP fanboy but I know good developers who maintain PHP applications, know and hate all the problems of PHP mentioned in the article, and many more. However, existing PHP applications fulfill needs in the businesses that use them. Maintainance developers deserve respect for what they do, not the blame for decisions made a long time ago by somebody else.
konstruktor··on The IRS has upgraded its technology to track virtually everything you do online
This is the status quo but doesn't address parent's argument. If corporations want the same rights as natural persons in one area of the law, it would be cherry picking to want to keep a privileged position in another, e.g. tax law. A good argument against parent would need to attack the premise that cherry picking privileges is bad.
konstruktor··on Apple Updates The Mac Pro
For example via one of the many TB docking stations that have been promised for a long time.
konstruktor··on Did Obama Just Destroy the U.S. Internet Industry?
I absolutely agree with you about drone strikes being even more dangerous. The analogy I saw was the mindset that causes people to be enraged about US citizens being killed/spied upon while being rather indifferent to the same thing happening to people in other countries.
konstruktor··on Did Obama Just Destroy the U.S. Internet Industry?
While consumers may be too lazy to care, cloud providers will lose a lot of business. You can bet that every trade magazine outside the US will have articles discussing if it is even legal to store data with US providers given the particular country's regulation and the information we have.
← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →