HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ksk

2,376 karma · joined October 5, 2011

submissionscomments
ksk··on Do things that don't require scale
>oing something simple worked in 2000s but nowadays a single developer cannot do what was passible back then and you need a team, and as mentioned above, massive financing to be fast to market.

I would like to add to this that our tooling has also seen massive improvements, which in turn greatly boosts the leverage of each individual contributor. For e.g. A single person can throw together a rudimentary web-browser in a week by leveraging existing components/tools/etc. Not to mention other benefits like easy access to experts via online forums, automated testing frameworks, etc, etc.

ksk··on “I monitor my staff with software that takes screenshots”
I think you're getting to the the crux of it. Exactly What actions make it seem like the other person has branded you as untrustworthy? Would a cashier counting the money you gave them be a sign that they don't trust you? Or an airport security making you pass through a metal detector? Or a Police officer running a speed gun on your car?

With the old 'Trust, but verify' idea, the disagreement is always on the 'how' in verify.

ksk··on Uncomfortable Questions About App Signing
I would expect someone with principles to behave differently. There certainly are principled people at Google (the recent-ish google walkouts come to mind). Maybe the principles I'm thinking of are no longer valued at Google.
ksk··on Google's Sundar Pichai says future of office is employee 'on-sites'
>Everything everyone says about greenhouse gas benefits of remote work just went out the window as soon as air travel is mentioned.

Well, but that kind of criticism applies to anything and everything. For e.g. Do you also judge whether to buy a particular computer based on the amount of greenhouse gas or chemical pollutants in the supply chain that were caused due to its manufacture? Or do you also consider the fact that every-time you make a purchase it has to be put on a ship or a truck or a plane so that it gets to you? If you live in a remote area with low pop. density, there is more fuel being wasted bringing things to fewer people, etc, etc. Trying to reconcile Whats good for the planet vs Whats good for me/everyone is going to involve compromises.

ksk··on Google's Sundar Pichai says future of office is employee 'on-sites'
As you alluded to, if you only judge something in its most optimal setting, then of course that thing seems very workable and successful. There are very few objective truths when it comes to WFH policies; there are only compromises that people are willing to make/accept. People always seem to make it about one-size-fits-all X is Good Y is Bad.
ksk··on Amazon restricts how rival device makers buy ads on its site
Google is the new Trump :P (relax, its a joke)
ksk··on Uncomfortable Questions About App Signing
If Google has their way, a big chunk of the web will be absorbed by AMP. I don't understand why so many talented people at Google continue to support this kind of takeover. It goes completely against the hacker ethic that built the internet.
ksk··on Spotify employees threaten to strike if Joe Rogan podcasts aren’t edited/removed
It's ironic to see this news as social media companies fight against online echo chambers, and social media bubbles.
ksk··on Windows XP source code has leaked
Unfortunately, this is not possible on their consumer OS branch (unless you hack the system, but I have found that it often makes the OS unstable because its in an unsupported system state). For me, our IT manages the systems. They get to decide when the systems update. I have a test box that regularly sees months of uptime.

https://i.imgur.com/XN2Hjia.png

ksk··on Windows XP source code has leaked
Today's software is vastly better in UX than software in the 90s and 00. Certainly I don't attribute all of that to telemetry, but your opposite view is incorrect.
ksk··on Windows XP source code has leaked
What are you basing this on? Are you talking about Windows or just random telemetry?
ksk··on Windows XP source code has leaked
I fully understand the frustration after seeing people having their computers reboot in the middle of presentations and other important events. That's why they made multiple products. Consumer OS = you don't want to be the sysadmin of the computer. Enterprise/LTSB OS = do what you want.
ksk··on Windows XP source code has leaked
Agreed. I think MS has decided (for better or for worse) that the average user is not a good system admin, and/or a consumer OS shouldn't require one. Our IT maintains W10 pretty well. I have a test box in my office and I regularly get months of uptime without any nags of updates and other nonsense. I work in biotech and you don't want your cleanroom computers rebooting in the middle of an expensive batch. =)
ksk··on AppStore Reviews Should Be Stricter
There are several ways to approach the curation/kid-friendly problem. You can have simple curation apps (which are banned in the current appstore AFAIK) that are not full stores but simply point to an app store (apple or non-apple). You can have websites that link to apps that have been vetted. On the iOS side, there could be a specific kid-mode that prevents certain APIs to be used. I'm thinking no video, audio, location/tracking services, no ads (unless the ad-network takes responsibility), etc.

Apple won't brand any particular app-store as kid-friendly, or otherwise endorse them.

ksk··on Google Drive trash items will be automatically deleted after 30 days
I agree with this policy in principle, but a ton of non-technical people in my office know that the recycle bin in Windows is never automatically emptied and rely on that fact (scary!). The 'expectation' can vary based on your experience IMO.
ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
Well, then the good thing for you is that you have to simply not install those other stores, and keep buying from Apple's official app store. Why prevent other users/devs from using them?
ksk··on AppStore Reviews Should Be Stricter
Or, you can have multiple app stores and kid-friendly app stores will specially curate apps to make sure there is no adult content, or other unwanted features. We already do this with a wide variety of physical goods.

Apple doesn't get the source code for the App anyway, so a third party can perform the same type of automated + manual review that Apple does. Its time to open up the app store to competition. As a consumer, if you don't trust a particular app store, great, don't use it.

ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
>I find it hard to see as a win for consumers based on the scummy practices of the companies in this advocacy group. Comparatively consumers are much better with Apples requirements from my perspective.

Its a clear win for users and developers because of competition in stores. Different stores will have different overheads and operating costs and can offer different discounts to both users and developers. Apple's brutal monopoly prevents that.

>So given that there is potential for significant harm AND developers have a choice of platforms to develop for why should Apples rights be taken away?

There is harm being doing today by Apple to users and developers. We need to undo that.

>So if I sell an app that does something like only sells to white people Apple shouldn’t be allowed to step in even though the negative press is likely to harm their brand image?

That went straight over my head, sorry. I didn't understand what your point was..

>Apple should be forced to work on behalf of other companies with no benefit for them?

Apple keeps their own APIs secret, or rather, artificially bans Apps from using them. This is merely leveling the playing field to allow other app stores to operate.

>Is this not true today? If it’s not Apple setting those standards it’s surely some other biased entity right? How is one better than the other?

Multiple app-stores will ensure competition.

>Why? It’s their platform. Developers are free to develop their own phone / OS, right?

I don't want Windows to ban Chrome or Firefox or arbitrarily block people from accessing websites either. "Its their platform" so they get to abuse their position of power is not a winning argument for me anyway. Clearly our views differ on this.

>Apple would surely say developers do not pay an unfair or unreasonable amount. Who sets this standard?

We set a fair income tax through the political process (however flawed) that allows stakeholders to participate. No system is perfect and we can only strive to improve the existing one. Right now, its Apple's dictatorial approach that is setting the rules. I'm glad there is a pushback.

>Why? If your App Store bricks an iPhone, Apple shouldn’t be able to prevent that from being installed on their devices?

That is ludicrous. A madman could use a knife to kill you so lets ban knifes?! If we have to be mature and rational about it, we need to evaluate things in a much more nuanced fashion.

>Transparent is subjective. I don’t see how this won’t result in the same types of TOS that people without legal degrees are not equipped to parse/understand.

Everything is subjective here. Apple's robbing of 30% of sales needs to end.

ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
That is great, you can avoid using app stores you don't trust. Why prevent other users from using stores they trust? Apple isn't the only company that can run an online store. There are countless online web stores selling all kinds of things, and people trust them with their money. Apple is artificially preventing competition in iOS stores here because they can abuse their dominant position.
ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
If you build an OS + hardware, how are you assuming apriori that you have users and also developers who write software that targets your platform? But anyway, the answer is no you should not be legally mandated in your case of boutique products.

The rules are different when free-markets fail, and one product or service dominates the entire market segment or exerts a large influence on the market (as determined by a legal authority).

The entire purpose of government is to serve our needs, if its no longer doing that we should amend laws/rules/policies as necessary. Everyone should be free to make an argument for their case.

ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
Its a vision document that outlines their vision. Nobody gets 100% of what they want anyway.
ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
Its not on the outside of the box, its on the inside. Apple forbids in-app discussion. I wonder what Apple would say if the app had a browser component that directs users to a web-page. These draconian rules are such a clusterF* hope these guys succeed.

BTW, all analogies are flawed in some manner or another. If you take away the abstraction, every single one breaks down. And then you end up talking about the intricacies of the thing you wanted to abstract away making it moot! :)

ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
Anything you disagree with here? https://appfairness.org/our-vision/
ksk··on Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for app store changes
What do you disagree with on this page?

https://appfairness.org/our-vision/

ksk··on Show HN: Use iPhone as a password manager for your desktop PC
>If you do want to use Firefox on iOS (irrespective of having your logins there or not), Secrets is also able to fill in FF using iOS's Password AutoFill feature.

Well, that solves my problem!

ksk··on Show HN: Use iPhone as a password manager for your desktop PC
This is the first I've heard of Secrets. Seems like a cool product! I've been relying on FF to save my web logins, but annoyingly iOS opens up links in Safari and I have to re-open them in FF to get the auto-fill to work.

Any future plans to support sync with FF logins/pw?

ksk··on Tables: Tracking work for teams
The point is, what differentiates products that come out of this project from another startup that is also struggling to stay afloat? If the answer is nothing, then why should anyone treat you any differently (because those other companies also get hit hard on that point)? Why shouldn't customers be weary about relying on your products if there isn't a commitment? You are free to call it a boring meme, but to me, these are very valid concerns. Sorry, you don't get a free pass because you're Google, and IMHO it should get scrutinized even more because its from Google for obvious reasons (poor privacy, track record of poor UI performance, s/w is often sluggish/resource hog, etc, etc)

>Then you have a company like Microsoft that keeps things around in perpetuity, but sometimes to the chagrin of users who want new features added or you get incongruent UX (you can still find plenty of very old apps in Windows 10). And this is fine too, but it's not a meme and so never comes up.

I'm not exactly the biggest fan of MS, but our company has saved tens of thousands of dollars in software costs because we could use old software designed for Win XP/7 on Win 10 w/o re-buying the software from the vendor. (Biotech s/w costs can get super crazy, esp with 21CFR validation)

ksk··on Ask HN: Does Apple profit from sharing user data?
https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US#infosharing

"We provide personal information to our affiliates and other trusted businesses or persons to process it for us, based on our instructions and in compliance with our Privacy Policy and any other appropriate confidentiality and security measures. For example, we use service providers to help us with customer support."

I'd like to know who those 'affiliates' are, and the exact nature of the data 'processing'.

"We may share non-personally identifiable information publicly and with our partners — like publishers, advertisers, developers, or rights holders. For example, we share information publicly to show trends about the general use of our services. We also allow specific partners to collect information from your browser or device for advertising and measurement purposes using their own cookies or similar technologies."

Who are these 'partners' ? Exactly what kind of non PII information is shared? Their "for example" doesn't cut it. I'd like a detailed list.

---

As an aside, I liked this statement from their original Privacy Policy.

" Google does not willfully disclose individually identifiable information about its customers to any third party without first receiving that customer’s permission."

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/07/10/opinion/googl...

ksk··on New Steve Jobs recordings from the '80s released
Indeed, I thought they might have missed it :)
ksk··on New Steve Jobs recordings from the '80s released
Your [1] , its here: https://www.quora.com/How-did-Steve-Jobs-thrive-in-a-technic...
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →