HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lakecresva

299 karma · joined September 20, 2020

submissionscomments
lakecresva··on Unix shell programming: the next 50 years
I think this has to be tempered with an understanding that it is actually possible to improve things and create better systems. It's probably good to be skeptical of claims that whatever new thing comes along is inherently better, but it doesn't seem helpful to assert up-front that something better than the unix shell can't/won't be developed in our lifetime.
lakecresva··on Are dynamic languages going to replace static languages? (2003)
Hey look, another thing Uncle Bob was completely wrong about. It's telling that after using "we" to set up the initial question, literally every pronoun in the article where he waxes on about testing is a personal pronoun. He never mentions "...And my colleagues found it easier to understand my code", or "and people found my library more inviting".
lakecresva··on Six Years of Professional Clojure
>You simply do not have that in a static world.

I keep seeing lisp people bandy about all of this design by contract/arbitrary predicate validation stuff. Can you give an example of an instance in which static types + runtime checks don't completely subsume this?

My intuition is that almost all of these methods people are talking about would have to be enforced at run-time, in which case I don't see how it's providing anything fundamentally more than writing an assertion or a conditional.

lakecresva··on “Tivoization” and Your Right to Install Under Copyleft
If you have access to legal databases like Westlaw/Lexis, you can look up the lawsuits the FSF and SFLC have been a party to. All of those suits were settled and the plaintiffs secure monetary compensation, disclosure of the source code, and in some cases the ability to pre-screen future releases to make sure they're complying with the GPL. The reason why many shops take copyright seriously or ban the use of GPL software (you can argue either way that the latter is or is not a victory for the GPL) is because this creates a deterrent effect.
lakecresva··on “Tivoization” and Your Right to Install Under Copyleft
Commercial users still take copyright issues pretty seriously because of the remedies available to copyright holders under title 17. Even if an author doesn't register the copyright until they want to begin the suit (you lose statutory damages and attorneys fees this way), they can get an injunction against further distribution and disgorgement of profits from the infringing work, so if you get caught, your product is dead and has made (you) no money. This is also why the FSF/SFLC has like a 100% success rate when it comes to extracting highly favorable settlements.

Without a doubt people still infringe, but it's not a complete free for all.

lakecresva··on Analyzing the legal implications of GitHub Copilot
I'm not sure that someone who published their work under the GPL hasn't thereby given consumers the right to put the repo on github. If the rights Github asks for in their ToS can be construed as a subset of the rights granted by the GPL, Github is just another GPL licensee. Unless they violate the conditions of the license, they're just utilizing their GPL rights.
lakecresva··on Analyzing the legal implications of GitHub Copilot
It doesn't have to, the rights you grant Github when you agree to the ToS and upload your work exist independent of any rights you might grant as part of the repo's license.
lakecresva··on Mr. Rafieh’s Tehran Pencil Shop
He was interviewed for a TV segment in 2018, seems like a cool guy.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJHIByLnGVo

lakecresva··on Jeff Bezos will fly on the first passenger spaceflight of Blue Origin in July
>Elon Musk has promised to eventually fuel Starship with synthetic "green" methane.

Just so I can pencil this on my calendar, where does this fit on the timeline relative to full self-driving and the hyperloop?

lakecresva··on Online cheating charges upend Dartmouth Medical School
> Tensions flared in early April when an anonymous student account on Instagram posted about the cheating charges. Soon after, Dartmouth issued a social media policy warning that students’ anonymous posts “may still be traced back” to them.

It's totally normal and proper for a university to tell students who speak out about being expelled by a kangaroo court of administrators "we will find you".

If they didn't want students looking at the material they should have just removed it, not relied on this insane post-hoc attempt to try and identify cheaters. Using this to try and destroy these students futures in the medical profession is unconscionable.

lakecresva··on Opposition to net neutrality was faked, New York says
I wonder if the millions of communications that fraudulently bear the names of their constituents have anything to do with that lack of enthusiasm.
lakecresva··on Opposition to net neutrality was faked, New York says
It's actually very easy, regulators are directly subordinate to congress and leadership is appointed by the president and confirmed by congress. The fact that people were willing to spend millions of dollars engaging in widespread fraud solely for the purpose of manufacturing the appearance of broad popular support pretty strongly suggests that you're wrong. The campaign directly targeted congressional offices.
lakecresva··on Opposition to net neutrality was faked, New York says
The whataboutism is already strong in here. Net neutrality is the battleground, but the issue is pretty universal. Corporate actors are signing off on illegal activity to directly undermine the democratic process in a way that should frighten you, and even when they're caught for it they're not being punished. Investigators with the NY AG's office "said that Broadband for America acted to give Mr. Pai “cover” to repeal the broadband regulations.". The companies fingered by the AG didn't even pay as much in penalties as they made under their contracts with the telecom companies.

The fact that some other corporate actors might be doing similar shit in the other direction is totally irrelevant; if they got caught, we should all want to bring the hammer down on them too.

lakecresva··on Opposition to net neutrality was faked, New York says
Because you're saying up-front that you didn't even bother to click the link to see whether it was different, and you're suggesting that corporate malfeasance is only worthy of scrutiny if it's fresh.
lakecresva··on CLUI: Building a Graphical Command Line (2020)
I'm glad you guys are still doing stuff with this, I thought the demo was really promising. Even though it's specific to your thing it seems like a good test case for how this can best be applied in the general case. Putting this in something like extraterm would be HN's nightmare, but I would be very interested to see whether there's a future in a cli base that actively takes advantage of the fact that it's not emulating 40 year old hardware.
lakecresva··on What is Chia cryptocurrency and why is it bad news for hard drives?
> It even seems doubtful to me that the people who developed Chia are the ones who'll make the money off it, if there is any to make.

Oh I wouldn't be so sure about that. From their FAQ:

" Why are we pre-farming?

Chia has a novel business model to both, lower volatility of the coin and increase adoption. By loaning Chia and managing the interest rates of those loans as well as other tools like buying our stock with chia coins, we hope to lower the quarter to quarter volatility of the coin. To drive adoption, we intend to loan Chia to Global 5000 companies who will use it to pay their international vendors quickly, less expensively, and more securely. We also intend to use the strategic reserve to aid development and adoption. We plan to do things like invest in promising startups in the Chia ecosystem, potentially increase farming rewards during limited periods of time to spur additional farming, and fund corporations paying 105% of the value of their international payables in Chia instead of fiat currency.

Is Chia doing an ICO?

No. Chia is not planning an ICO. Instead, our goal is to take the company’s equity public on an American stock exchange. This way, shareholders can share risk and return with management with transparency and disclosure and we can use well understood corporate controls to make binding statements about how Chia Network intends to use the Strategic Reserve. The Chia digital money is meant to be a useful payment instrument and not an investment opportunity. Chia intends to complete a fully compliant SEC registered equity IPO and will come to market as market-timing is amenable after the launch of mainnet. "

lakecresva··on Google’s lawyer accidentally made a sensitive document public
> I'm not a lawyer but I can't see how having every court case public is a good thing.

Well for one, the US has a common law legal system, so it's entirely dependent on the public availability of court cases. In terms of fairness, I think the current status quo is (in this limited respect) very reasonable; you're entitled to absolutely iron-clad privacy in the interactions which you pay for, which are your interactions with your attorney. When you start making use of public funds by bringing your dispute to the courts, the public has a right to know what it's money is being spent on and it has a right to know what's going on in the community. The vast majority of legal disputes are settled in state district courts, which are local in scope.

I also don't think privacy mixes well with the degree to which the judiciary is uniquely unaccountable, though this is admittedly less and less relevant as time goes on since basically nobody in government is accountable for anything at this point.

lakecresva··on Apple will finally fix issue that blocked searches for 'Asian' as adult content
I have 'Enable to view adult and NSFW (not safe for work) content in your feed and search results' enabled in my user profile, and this is what I'm seeing when I click that link: https://imgur.com/gm9PZqZ
lakecresva··on Apple will finally fix issue that blocked searches for 'Asian' as adult content
I think you're misusing the search. If I enable nsfw by adding `nsfw:yes`, both 'asian' and 'european' show ONLY porn results both for content and communities. If I omit the `nsfw:yes`, but allow my profile to view nsfw content, both 'european' and 'asian' don't show any porn in the search results.

The search filter is either a binary, or there's just so much porn for everything that it doesn't matter.

lakecresva··on TLA+ Action Properties
I think your judgment is clouded by this insistence that you're doing math rather than something which is squarely in the middle of the cs/math venn diagram. Relational algebra has an accepted notation for left outer-join (⟕). Do you think `I><|` is preferable to `LEFT JOIN` because mathematics™? If I were to sample 100 TLA+ specifications, do you think I would find more people specifying things like paxos and concurrency models, or would I find people doing algebraic geometry and number theory?
lakecresva··on TLA+ Action Properties
Touche.
lakecresva··on TLA+ Action Properties
I think you'll be more successful as an advocate for TLA+ if you just say "yeah, the syntax isn't for everyone", or "the tooling has some issues" instead of writing long missives about how syntax like `[][x' /= x => y' = x]_<<x, y>>` is actually motivated by some deep mathematical insight, or suggesting that the desire for an editing environment that doesn't feel 20 years old stems from a failure to understand the difference between specification and programming.
lakecresva··on Bitcoin Is Worse Is Better (2011)
I think the more important lesson from the DAO hack was the fork itself, and that by organizing it, Vitalik and friends saved their own wallets (after hilariously asking exchanges to stop trading). If the people holding the reigns can get what they want by applying the right amount of influence, it's not any better than what we already have, and is probably not a great vehicle for realizing the utility of self-executing financial or legal agreements.
lakecresva··on Whistleblower: Ubiquiti Breach “Catastrophic”
> a source who participated in the response to that breach alleges Ubiquiti massively downplayed a “catastrophic” incident to minimize the hit to its stock price, and that the third-party cloud provider claim was a fabrication.

I'm sure their lawyers don't know anything about tech or forensics, but they know how buy shareholders time in a way that minimizes anyone's chances of going to prison or facing serious civil liability. If you ask someone in charge of hiring corporate counsel what they look for in a lawyer, they will flat out tell you "a good risk manager who understands discretion" which just means "someone who's going to tell us what we can get away with".

The regulatory system in the US is sufficiently dysfunctional that there is zero incentive for corporate counsel to even consider what's in the best interest of consumers.

lakecresva··on Elon Musk’s anti-union tweet from 2018 must be deleted: U.S. labor board
> To repeat the key info from this case that makes one question the NRLB ruling...

These issues (among others) are addressed at length in the NLRB's decision (https://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d45833d3fce) which takes into account probably thousands of pages of briefs, witness statements, and legal analysis.

The decision itself is only ~50 pages and is readable without a legal background. The section "credibility findings" which starts on page 32 might interest you.

The full docket activity page for the case is here (https://www.nlrb.gov/case/32-CA-197020).

lakecresva··on India to propose cryptocurrency ban, penalising miners and traders
> will act as a catalyst in driving away the next generation of bright young Indian innovators and engineers from the country.

Somehow I doubt there's much of an intersection between "the next generation of bright young Indian innovators and engineers" and crypto miners who care enough or run an operation large enough to justify leaving the country over this.

lakecresva··on The U.S. Air Force just admitted the F-35 stealth fighter has failed
How are you calculating the cost of medicare for all?
lakecresva··on In two incidents, F-16 aviators were rendered unconscious, but saved by software
Or just exhaustion. There's an interview with a Japanese ace Honda Minoru on yt in which he talks about how pilots were so exhausted from flying eight hour combat missions every day of the Guadalcanal campaign that they would fall asleep at the controls, slowly fall out of formation, and hit the water. They (amazingly) had no radios in their aircraft at the time, so they just watched it happen.
lakecresva··on The Rise and Fall of Bitcoin Billionaire Arthur Hayes
I think it's pretty clear at this point that fines do not effectively deter white collar criminals.
lakecresva··on Cryptocurreny crime is way ahead of regulators and law enforcement
There was widespread fraud (of the criminal variety) in the run-up to 2008. A number of journalists, particularly Matt Taibbi, have written extensively about this.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →