HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

larsiusprime

6,276 karma · joined April 4, 2012

I'm a real estate mass appraisal researcher, author, and former game developer.

This is my company: www.landeconomics.org

This is my book: www.landisabigdeal.com

This is my personal website: www.fortressofdoors.com

This is a game I worked on: www.defendersquest.com

submissionscomments
larsiusprime··on Building SimCity: How to put the world in a machine
Simulations and models, regardless of whether they're designed for fun or for realism, can still teach you plenty of things about the real world; sometimes not from the simulation itself but explicitly by its omissions. The fact that SimCity famously removed all the parking lots tells you something interesting right away. The fact that City Skylines bites the bullet of traffic and renders it in fairly sophisticated detail -- to the degree that the game often devolves into "Traffic Management Simulator" instead of "City Builder Simulator" -- is another such interesting lesson.

But in terms of "how directly transferable are lessons learned directly from the model" is always going to depend on the model's assumptions.

Fun fact -- have you ever heard of the "Monocentric city model?" It comes up in a lot of econ papers, and a lot of urban economics, and therefore a lot of real world policy is based on it.

The "Monocentric city model" is about as simplistic as it gets -- it models the city as a LINE. IE, you have a bunch of agents, and they live some distance from the city, and they have different travel/commuting costs proportional to their distance from the city center; let's run that and see what kinds of consequences fall out of it.

Turns out it's actually a pretty good model and generates outcomes that are pretty analogous to what we see in the real world! Is it perfectly representative of the real world? Of course, not, it models the city as a friggin line. But if we're talking about sheer complexity alone, SimCity is already orders of magnitude more complex than this famous economic model. But that in and of itself doesn't mean that a successful SimCity city would make for a successful real world city, because it's not just about sheer complexity, it's about the appropriateness of the assumptions.

larsiusprime··on Land value tax in online games and virtual worlds (2022)
I'm actually not a single-taxer, for the record.

> The author mentions Decentraland. The whole point of Decentraland, which is a crypto metaverse, was to make land prices go up. They didn't. Decentraland is boring and nobody goes there. But it does work, and it's up and running all the time. There are other crypto metaverses. Most of them never got beyond the hand-waving stage or the occasional demo of a small virtual world, but that didn't stop them from trying to sell overpriced land. Despite all the noise from the metaverse crowd, few of them got very far on implementation.

We are in agreement. I thought the crypto metaverses were stupid and said so loudly at the time and predicted they would fail for many reasons; the point about land speculation with crypto games is that charging for the right to upload UGC is literally the dumbest idea in the world.

The difference between a crypto metaverse and the real world is you can opt out of existing in any individual virtual world. This is all mentioned in the article.

> The supply of land is not limited [in Second Life].

This is mentioned in the article.

> Despite doing things the way this author likes

> You pay Linden Lab a fixed fee per square meter, regardless of what you're doing with the land

A fixed fee per square meter without regard to land use or location is literally the opposite of the system I have described.

As for evidence real-world cities, you might observe from evidence real world cities that have done the opposite of an LVT -- proposition 13 in California for instance. And you might notice states with very high property taxes (an imperfect tax to be sure, but one that definitely puts a higher holding cost on land, despite the inefficient tax on buildings).

Tell me, is housing more affordable in states with high property taxes, or in states with very low property taxes?

larsiusprime··on Land value tax in online games and virtual worlds (2022)
Simpler ways of going about it are indeed possible and are discussed in detail in the article; a simple regular leasing of land accomplishes all the benefits of an LVT without any of the more complicated bits.

Also -- you can just make a game where land isn't fundamentally scarce, that's an even simpler option too.

> I'm not entirely sure how this makes much sense if one can't generate any revenue from land and lots are limited to a single tenant - which seems to be the norm.

It's important to remember that just because something doesn't generate "monetary" income, doesn't mean it isn't providing value, and players will pay for value -- either in "hard" currencies like real money or in-game gold, or "soft" currencies like time, effort, and putting up with pain-in-the-butt. Housing in MMOs is typically a vanity item, but consider that social status, vanity, and the like are real genuine utility for human beings.

> If the land can't really be used any more efficiently, outside of repossessing unused plots owned by absentee players, then all this does is ensure the wealthiest players are the only ones who can afford the most in-demand lots (assuming the valuation varies).

If something can't be used any more efficiently (which suggests that it either is already being put to its highest and best use already, or that its potential use is severely restricted, akin to real-world municipal zoning restrictions), then there are several ways to look at that:

1. This is fine, actually; the asset is actually being used for its intended purpose and not simply hoarded 2. The developers could remove restrictions on the use of the thing so that there is a higher and better use for it than currently exists 3. The developers might reconsider their underlying assumptions for making the asset scarce in the first place

Did you have a concrete example of this scenario? That might make it easier to discuss if you provided an illustration from a particular game (or one you could imagine).

larsiusprime··on Rent in Cities Skylines 2 was too high, so the devs removed landlords
Actually, if you model LVT as a revenue-neutral tax shift (a universal exemption on buildings), most residential single family home owners already come out ahead on net versus existing property taxes in high property tax states like Texas.
larsiusprime··on Rent in Cities Skylines 2 was too high, so the devs removed landlords
What I'm curious about is how they derive land value in the first place. Do they have an actual supply and demand model driving it?
larsiusprime··on Rent in Cities Skylines 2 was too high, so the devs removed landlords
Oh hey, thanks for linking my article!

I fleshed that out later into a full fledged policy paper / how-to guide: https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/land-value-tax-in-...

larsiusprime··on Norway discovers Europe's largest deposit of rare earth metals
Norway has a very long and interesting history regarding natural resource development and stewardship, and lately a huge conversation has been about what is going to come after Oil. Would be very interesting if the answer is rare earth minerals!

I highly recommend a particular paper, entitled "The New Oil" which gives a very good overview of the history of Norwegian resource development:

https://www.idunn.no/doi/pdf/10.18261/issn.1504-2936-2021-01...

Of course that is entirely in Norwegian, so for the anglophones here's a link to a translated version that I did for a friend's blog:

https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2022/05/17/norway-the-once-and...

larsiusprime··on Ask HN: Devs/data scis who pivoted to a new career in 30s/40s, what do you do?
Thanks for the kind words
larsiusprime··on Ask HN: Devs/data scis who pivoted to a new career in 30s/40s, what do you do?
My path was anything but conventional.

I had to leave game development because my seven year old son suffered a tragedy which completely disabled him. Game development is simply too volatile and risky a career for someone with that kind of family obligation.

As for the transition, I had accidentally achieved some recognition as a researcher of land economics through various blog posts. This attracted the attention of a new friend who was inspired by my work to put a startup together, seeing real estate mass appraisal as the most important missing piece for policy reasons, but also a potentially great business idea.

Investors agreed with him and a startup was formed. This gave me an alternative to game dev when I needed it most.

As for the actual work transition, I had a lot of subject matter to learn which we facilitated by hiring experts from the field, including former IAAO researchers (that’s the relevant standards body) as well as local appraisers.

I’m still learning but a lot of my skills transferred. The biggest difference is this is typically a pretty low tech field so many essential skills are soft — all the tech in the world doesn’t matter if you can’t explain things in simple terms to a citizen. As I like to say “Prepare for a property tax protest defense, not a PhD thesis defense.”

The other big difference is cost structure and expectations and competition. Game development is essentially selling one of the hardest kinds of programs to write, to the world’s best served audience, under maximum competition, for the lowest prices.

In local government you can charge what felt to me like large prices and still be genuinely considered cheap compared to what existing vendors charge. And people are used to software that doesn’t work and customer support that never responds. So if you can exceed expectations that is an edge here.

But many tech people have failed in this field, because they can’t master the soft skills and they can’t communicate simply; that part is deceptively hard.

larsiusprime··on Ask HN: Devs/data scis who pivoted to a new career in 30s/40s, what do you do?
I left video game development for statistical mass appraisal of real estate for property tax purposes when I turned 40. No regrets.

Completely the opposite of game development in every way.

larsiusprime··on The Basque Country’s Mondragón Corporation is the largest industrial co-op
Mondragon was founded by a Catholic priest and IMHO is more accurately described as Distributist than classically Socialist:

https://distributistreview.com/archive/mondragon-revisited?f...

larsiusprime··on The U.S. government may finally mandate safer table saws
If you get in an accident and the seat belt saves your life you do in fact have to replace (at least) the seat belt.
larsiusprime··on Ant Geopolitics
I'm not convinced we could drive ants to extinction even if we tried.
larsiusprime··on GenAI and erroneous medical references
I’m aware, I come from a medical family. You haven’t answered the question.
larsiusprime··on GenAI and erroneous medical references
They often give clinical recommendations and prescriptions, usually after a quick skim of the medical history and a rushed five minute conversation with the patient. It would be nice to know how many of these typical in-office recommendations wind up being actually backed by the current state of the research, whether a citation is given in the visit or not.
larsiusprime··on GenAI and erroneous medical references
> Unfortunately, very little evidence exists about the ability of LLMs to substantiate claims. In a new preprint study, we develop an approach to verify how well LLMs are able to cite medical references and whether these references actually support the claims generated by the models.

Is there a corresponding control group for how well an average doctor is able to cite medical references and whether these references actually support the claims generated by the doctors?

larsiusprime··on Is something bugging you?
Was an eaaaaaaaarly tester for this. Pretty neat stuff.
larsiusprime··on Games don't need venture capitalism
Having worked in games for 10+ years, and having recently joined a more traditional VC-backed startup outside of games, I think you are 100% on the money.

The VC model doesn't make a lot of sense for games. So many outsiders come into games thinking they know what they're doing and they learn some hard (and expensive!) lessons fast. Thanks for writing this.

larsiusprime··on Four Magic Words
Author here, for what it's worth I a) own a gun b) have not shot a dog, and c) am not personally endorsing David Mensch for president of the Universe.
larsiusprime··on Four Magic Words
(author here): Fun anecdote: I showed this to a friend of mine who is an English literature professor and she responded, "I'm not entirely convinced that David Mensch is a reliable narrator"
larsiusprime··on Four Magic Words
> Our science journey has been about gradually moving humanity away from the center of the universe. Ptolemy, Newton, Darwin, Einstein, et. al., taught us that we're part of nature rather than a privileged special case. Scientific thought has incrementally removed the justifications for human exceptionalism.

Author here; gonna have to agree to disagree on this one. This is kind of like saying, "See the ancients were wrong in calling whales fish! Actually they are mammals!" and then the ancients say, "Dude, that's just our word for 'thing with fins that swims in the ocean.'" Yeah, they didn't know a mitochondrian from a midichlorian, and were wrong about a bunch of factual stuff, but the kind of stuff they get called out on like this to prove some kind of point about their moral deficiency are often category errors and misapprehensions.

For instance, there's a particular misapprehension in your sentence: "moving humanity away from the center of the universe".

Do you know what is located at the precise geometric center of the classical medieval model of the universe?

Earth, right?

No, not quite. What's located in the the center of the earth in the classical medieval model?

Hell. And who is located in the center of hell? Satan.

Also, who is the most "important" character in the medieval cosmological model? As in, the prime mover, the big cheese, the most important being? It ain't human beings -- its God. And where is God located in this model? Not in the center -- Hell is by definition his absence. Not on Earth, beyond a brief physically incarnate visit and ongoing influence. No, God lives in Heaven -- located far beyond the celestial spheres, outside, as far away from the center as possible. The closer you get to the center, the lower a sort of being you are! Sure, in medieval cosmology redeemed humans are higher than angels, but in the meantime they are in their place -- Earth, the land that sucks, the vale of tears -- down there, below, while the angels are up in Heaven beyond the celestial spheres with God.

All that aside, I don't think any particular scientific discovery about how vast the universe is, or how tiny subatomic particles are, really obligates us to hold one set of values over another, as much as materialists tend to smuggle such assumptions in through the back door.

I recall back in the early 2000's during the tiresome religious vs. atheist debates, the atheists would scream at the religious, "Look how grand the universe is! Look how small we are! The Universe is vast and profound, your cosmology is impoverished and provincial!" and the religious would scream right back "Look how grand the universe is! Look how small we are! God is vast and profound, your cosmology is impoverished and provincial!" Opposite conclusions from the same basic facts, even if you limit the debate to two sides who both believe in evolution.

As Dave said in the story -- values aren't true or false. They're literally just what people care about. Science can help inform your choices, but at the end of the day it doesn't tell you what is good or bad, because science is about brute material facts, there's no good or bad in a raw materialist understanding of the universe, but you're a human being and so at some point you're going to insist on an 'ought' somewhere rather than being content with a bag full of 'is.' And for that we get to fight over philosophy and values.

And good luck convincing the human race that the human race doesn't matter. You're way more likely to expand the moral circle of concern by getting them to care about non-humans TOO than you are to get them to stop caring about humans. Probably the latter gets you even worse results than you're hoping for, if recent history is any guide.

larsiusprime··on Four Magic Words
A fair question. I work from home and spend a lot of time with them. I'm lucky.
larsiusprime··on Four Magic Words
Also, the author* can have a little death (as a treat!)

*(I am the author of the story, to be clear)

larsiusprime··on Losing my son
Automatic feature of ghost blogs, not something I put there for what it’s worth.
larsiusprime··on Losing my son
Fortunately I haven’t been saddled with enormous bills yet. We somehow qualified for public assistance. Granted we have also spent a very large number of hours on the phone and had to jump through many other hoops, and this is far from over.
larsiusprime··on Losing my son
The quote was one of my wife’s favorites. The image is just from ChatGPT and I believe the current legal doctrine is AI generated images aren’t copyrightable.
larsiusprime··on Losing my son
Anesthesia definitely has non-zero risks, but for what it’s worth was entirely uninvolved in this accident.
larsiusprime··on Losing my son
Literally nobody knows what to say including me. It’s okay that it’s not okay.
larsiusprime··on Losing my son
And to anyone who feels like telling me what a bad person I am for drawing the line in a slightly different place than you do on Euthanasia — go read Four Magic Words before you post something glib assuming you know anything about my reasoning and motivations.

Go ahead and have a reasoned debate about euthanasia if you want — I’ve never subscribed to “the person who is suffering the most this second gets to be right about everything.”

Just know five things:

1) I respect you if you would make a different decision than I would.

2) I landed in about the most controversial edge case imaginable.

3) You don’t know me

4) It has not been sentimental, romantic, or spiritually invigorating. It’s been horrible.

5) I don’t do this because I can’t emotionally bear to be parted with what’s left of him. It’s the opposite if anything.

larsiusprime··on Losing my son
We are different people. We draw the line in different places. All such lines are ultimately arbitrary. Please don’t judge me for drawing it in a slightly different place than you do; my position is likely closer to yours than you think and I’d appreciate not being judged on a public forum for not being 100% in agreement with you.
← PreviousPage 5 of 24Next →