2,308 karma · joined August 21, 2012
Unfortunately, this is also strike in favor of the blockchain people (like Farcaster) — the best of which have been working to find ways to keep systems permanently decentralized (and not just temporarily decentralized, like Bluesky/Nostr/Mastodon/SMTP/etc.).
In the end, and perhaps in service of my original utilitarian impulses, I feel that entirely abandoning utilitarianism is the right path. This is sometimes referred to as `esoteric utilitarianism`, something that Sidgwick wrote about — suggesting that even teaching people about utilitarianism (himself being a utilitarian) might be immoral. Virtue ethics has been particularly appealing!
At the application layer, email clients (like the Gmail or iOS email app) are typically bundled with a reliance on centralized email hosting (running the mail server) and relying on their centrally-controlled name (@gmail.com, @icloud.com, etc.). This in turn gives the app developers significant leverage against the protocol layer, since they completely control how their users (through their app) interact with the protocol layer.
At the protocol layer, email relies heavily on a de facto reputation system, since any valuable and truly decentralized and permissionless system will have an abundance of spam. The reputation system is used to filter spam and isolate bad actors. This is why running a home email server is not really what this is about: it's about who you need to rely on to have your emails delivered.
The challenge isn't designing a protocol without reliance on any single actor. What's difficult is designing a protocol that can avoid becoming de facto centralized when critical features (like spam prevention, registration, etc.) need to be filled in by agents outside of the protocol.
The crypto people recognize this and that's why they want to build the economics explicitly into their protocols (a critically important part of any protocol; all protocols without exception have economic components whether one recognizes this or not). This is also why they emphasize global consensus and more.
Hacker News and others hate blockchains because they see the scams (which happen in all permissionless systems, and they are even more obvious when the financial components nakedly visible). Yet HN laments when the properties of decentralization that they love and value are lost for seemingly mysterious reasons ("dead internet theory", "enshittification"). The truth is that the reasons are right in front of us.
An even bigger problem is that most of the economic and social benefits have come from technology. This even includes shorter work weeks and paid leave (typically falsely credited to unions) and greater disposable income, which have come from technology (broadly speaking) and not from activism.
A tech "ethics crisis" and the "dangerous" profit motive are just renewed attacks against capitalism, and "tech" is itself just the tip of the spear of capitalism (and the cultural nom de guerre of capitalism's elites).
This strategy has been in use for years and I perceive such subject lines as an indicator that an email is probably an outright scam. All senders receive a silent and permanent block from me without exception.
Maybe the author isn't aware of how much alienation he's creating for his brand.
The decentralized architecture is interesting but ultimately pointless since every uses the same app, which is where they reintroduce censorship (with very limited personal control over what is censored and moderated for you).
You're just explaining why crypto is becoming increasingly popular for businesses in general: the tech works.
Don't test drugs on Africans: "why aren't drugs being tested on Africans?"
A little charity in interpretation goes a long way.
[1]: https://a16zcrypto.com/posts/article/accelerating-the-world-...
[2]: https://a16zcrypto.com/posts/article/a-new-era-in-snark-desi...
This is typical for bitcoin. Anyone can see this for themselves. So the interesting question is to ask why CNBC thinks it's worth sharing a story that blames interest rates with no evidence? It could be as simple as "people will click it". In any case, very dumb.
Kind of like the state of California is trying to do here.
I'm not sure that it makes sense to alter marriage to solve immigration issues.