HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

likpok

1,477 karma · joined November 9, 2008

submissionscomments
likpok··on FAANG promo committees are killing Kubernetes: A Short Thread
You wouldn't want to run one giant cluster, but at hyper scale you're talking about running thousands or tens of thousands of kubernetes clusters. That's the part that doesn't scale well, for a couple of reasons.

The biggest one is just mechanical: with that many clusters it will be hard to move capacity between clusters, and locality gets baked into everything you do (people do try to build around this, but it's awkward).

If each service or team runs their own kubernetes that's a lot of overhead: kubernetes will need something like 6-7 machines for the cluster (I don't have production experience with kube, spitballing here), so small teams or jobs will have terrible efficiency. Big teams will have to spend a lot of operational effort to manage their fleets.

It's worth noting that at hyperscale there will be individual jobs in a datacenter that are bigger than kubernetes handles comfortably. Handling this efficiently becomes very important, it's literally billions of dollars worth of hardware.

likpok··on FAANG promo committees are killing Kubernetes: A Short Thread
At hyper scale you don't need to worry about sharing as much because the important services are far bigger than one machine. That sidesteps the problem: you can apply whatever sysctls or configs you need to do before starting the container.

"Multitenancy" here means "I have a giant pool of machines and I run a bunch of jobs across them" not "I have a pool of giant machines and I stack jobs on them".

likpok··on FAANG promo committees are killing Kubernetes: A Short Thread
10^5 is also on the low end of hyperscale. I'd bet that google/amazon have high single-digit millions of machines.

So yes, big companies can afford to pay people to customize their systems, and do so. The infra teams at these places are enormous, even just counting job orchestration.

The argument upthread (mine) is that the companies do so, and that kubernetes is the wrong choice for them. As a result, they don't really contribute to it.

likpok··on FAANG promo committees are killing Kubernetes: A Short Thread
Kubernetes doesn't get patches from hyperscale companies because kubernetes is not really hyperscale software. If I recall correctly (probably don't), clusters can handle tens of thousands of container hosts. That's not manageable at large scale unless you're selling people individual kubernetes instances directly (which, to be fair, google and amazon are).

In my experience the thing that kills open source at big companies is the divergence of needs: The company needs massive scale software, but the community wants ease-of-use and features. Most open source models are a big drag on productivity (you can't just refactor all the callsites to do a migration!), and it's hard to change directions when the company's need does (since the other contributors will likely want the original software).

The tailscale people have been arguing this as well (with more data and better reasoning), but fundamentally you need different software when you're a scrappy startup or a medium size company or a giant behemoth.

likpok··on Reinstating our SAT/ACT requirement for future admissions cycles
The top link is a study that shows that the improvement is pretty marginal in practice.

It does miss something: in specific ethnic enclaves SAT coaching is much more effective, perhaps because of a culture of out-of-school schoolwork and teaching beyond SAT prep. Those enclaves aren't particularly wealthy either (if I recall correctly it was a Korean enclave). Even then we're talking 70 points -- not nothing, but also not a radical transformation.

likpok··on Largest bacterium ever discovered has unexpectedly complex cells
It would be easy to determine if Morgellons was caused by a bacteria or some other physical thing: you can take samples and look at them under the microscope. When the CDC did just that (looked at samples of the fibers), they found them to be likely cotton.

If this were the cause of morgellons then their result would be "morgellons caused by infestation with unknown large bacteria" not "people with morgellons have no physical evidence of infestation".

likpok··on Logging at Twitter
You can even handle impressions/clicks/conversions in a lossy system, you just have to bound how much loss you're willing to accept. The counterbalancing factor is how expensive you want your logging infrastructure to be -- the more consistency, the more it costs. The other trade off is availability: what do you do when the logging backend is temporarily down? Return a 503 to the user? Or accept that you're not making money on that impression and move on?
likpok··on The housing market needs more condos
Tokyo’s population has constantly risen, even as japan’s has fallen. Tokyo has inexpensive housing because they’ve allowed people to build it. You can compare the chart of new housing growth in Tokyo versus Paris, London and NY, and Tokyo blows them out of the water.
likpok··on Facebook Pay
That's the same way that Venmo (or any of the other p2p payments) work (though I guess Venmo has a specific "opt in to some extra protection for a fee").
likpok··on Meta is not threatening to leave Europe
Is answering subpoenas in the US strictly necessary for the provision of a service? I believe that's the wrinkle with Privacy Shield.
likpok··on Meta is not threatening to leave Europe
So you propose to copy the private data of European citizens on US servers?

What happens when the law makes that illegal?

likpok··on Meta is not threatening to leave Europe
There are a lot of edge cases that people don't think about.

A lot of communication data has two people associated, and a lot of it is highly sensitive. If a US person and a French person chat how does each get the messages? Message data is obviously highly sensitive and shouldn't be shared.

Does the US person need to hit the French servers to see new messages, and vice versa? What about quoting?

Message metadata (i.e. the fact that these two people are talking at all) is also pretty valuable -- the classic pen register is just a record of which calls were made to which numbers. Where do you store the metadata of the thread? It arguably belongs to and is private to both people.

likpok··on Wordle Now Redirects to NYT
The wordle code has two distinct arrays: the list of answers and the list of other words you can guess. If you carelessly remove words from the answers you will also make it impossible to guess them. I figure they removed some answers without adding them to the acceptable guesses because they didn’t think about it.

Fibre, agora and pupal are a little esoteric. Not as much as many words on the SOWPODS list, but enough to perhaps be annoying.

likpok··on Grep flags – the good stuff
Zsh (and possibly other shells?) will expand a raw ^ into filenames. '' is a little shorter than '^' if you have to quote it.
likpok··on Pwnkit: Local Privilege Escalation in polkit's pkexec
How does this exploit avoid environment sanitization? Is that because most environment sanitization (e.g. clearenv) adjusts the pointer rather than the memory, and argv[argc + 1] is the original environment location?
likpok··on IRS Will Soon Require Selfies for Online Access
All this boils down to: in India there's a national ID database you can use, which makes this a lot simpler.

The US does not have a national ID database, and there is a lot of resistance against making one. Each state could probably use the driver's license, but that locks out people who don't drive -- a small but disproportionately marginalized group.

Government services are tricky because they need to serve everyone. That means that you have to handle a lot of special cases and struggle to categorically ban bad actors. Google can say "you've used your gmail account to send spam emails, so we're banning it". The IRS can't do that (I think even if they put you in prison for tax fraud).

likpok··on Microsoft to Acquire Activision Blizzard
Are you saying it's a good thing that Comcast was able to break up an upstart competitor? I'm not sure a world where that's easier would have fewer monopolies to today. Even in your example the large and established company was suing the upstart.
likpok··on Reddit ‘antiwork’ forum booms as millions of Americans quit jobs
I stopped reading a couple years ago after it was clear that many of the most interesting posts were fictional. There was a series written by someone styling themselves as the "troll queen" (all under different accounts). In general I think the increasing popularity driven by bestoflegaladvice made things worse.

Yes, the boring posts are probably real and I never claimed otherwise. But the posts people remember and engage with are not the boring posts and have a much more mixed track record. There have been cases both of "someone creates updates with an impossible resolution/schedule", "post describing the opposite point of view of a recently popular post comes up" and "post touching on hot-button internet arguments". You can argue that only the first category must be a fake, but the rest pop up with a suspicious frequency.

Similarly, you could see a big jump in the number of legal issues relating to whatever excited bestoflegaladvice recently. It doesn't seem likely that there's a sudden uptick in the number of people who have neighbors cut down their trees, or who have a landlocked property.

likpok··on Reddit ‘antiwork’ forum booms as millions of Americans quit jobs
Legaladvice is also a place people love to put creative writing, so I’m not sure how much you can take from that.
likpok··on Tesla Q4 2021 Vehicle Production and Deliveries
The question isn't whether there's a bull case for tesla, there obviously is. The question is the bear case which the GP laid out pretty clearly.

Tesla might grow to eclipse the existing auto industry! Certainly the story of "incumbent industries fail to adapt to changing conditions" is a common one but "industry supports several equally sized competitors" is as well.

likpok··on Tesla Q4 2021 Vehicle Production and Deliveries
The bear case is that Tesla merely becomes the worlds number 1 electric car manufacturer but does not become the worlds only electric car manufacturer.

Right now Tesla's market cap is about 10x that of Ford, on a third to half the revenue (2021 numbers aren't available, I'm estimating based on Q1/2/3).

Tesla was about 2x as profitable as ford in q3 2021, but that varies a lot quarter-to-quarter. It was generally around 10% though.

Instead of car companies, consider a similarly sized company in market cap, Meta. Meta has 85 billion in revenue and a 30% (!) profit margin.

For Tesla to grow into its cap it needs to massively increase both its scale and its profitability. It'd need to more than double its revenue while also doubling its margins. New sources of revenue for tesla are going to be moving downmarket, which makes profit margins hard in a manufacturing business. Tesla has nice cars but it has a lot of competitors with deep sales teams and manufacturing excellence (consider other comments in this thread: Tesla cars have bad fit and finish for how expensive they are and lack a lot of standard features).

Tesla is clearly going to continue to be a big car manufacturer but its current valuation requires that it become staggeringly gigantic.

likpok··on Fortification, Part IV: French Guns and Italian Lines
During the Edo period Japan was quite peaceful. The linked page shows nothing between 1638 and 1863. The Tokugawa shogunate started a little earlier (1600ish) and marked the start of a long period of internal peace. That's 200-250 (depending on how you count some of the events in 1600-1640 -- I think they had limited impact on the home islands?) which ended with the Meiji Restoration.
likpok··on No, we didn’t accidentally create a warp bubble
Journalism about physics has always been like this. The Alcubierre drive is 25 years old, even before that there were widely-publicized discussions of the same kind of idea: invert the equations and come up with interesting results.

The realities of space travel are kind of grim: months to visit even nearby uninhabitable planets and decades to get anywhere interesting. Relativity has always been a huge and ever-increasing impediment to that, and the ways in which it is have percolated out. There's also the demand for hard science fiction with space battles (I personally am a fan!) that similarly runs aground on "you can't have a galactic empire where it takes a hundred years to reach the next province over".

So there's lots of demand for "hey this thing makes FTL travel possible" and not as much demand for "scientists publish paper but everything still sucks".

likpok··on The Great Bifurcation
Good VR headsets are cheaper than computers today and cheaper than computers were back when Second Life was getting started. People almost universally own smartphones which can support a LOT of additional activity.

That's not to say that the metaverse will take off (I think it still lacks a compelling use case), but many of the parameters have changed.

likpok··on Americans are rethinking where they want to live
There was a big study a while back that showed something like only 30% from out of state?

The tricky is they had an expansive definition of "local": they were measuring where people most recently became homeless, which means almost any housing in SF for almost any amount of time meant they counted as local.

likpok··on Code to flood Kellogg with bogus job applications after strikers sacked
Why would a company's management be aligned with the workers here? If you're hiring people to run your food production factory "crosses a picket line" seems like a good thing.

Collective bargaining might help, but even Kellogg's union isn't capable of doing much -- only one factory is striking. Why would an unaffiliated union spend huge resources on helping Kellogg workers rather than its own members?

likpok··on Code to flood Kellogg with bogus job applications after strikers sacked
Being a striker does give additional legal rights you wouldn't other wise have, but I don't think that this is one of them. It's also unclear whether the author or people using the script are actually fired employees or bored teenagers jumping on the bandwagon.

Spamming a police department with fake tips is specifically illegal (making a false police report and/or obstruction of justice and/or USC 1001). I'm not sure about fake appointments for a hospital, that seems the most unclear of the cases you've listed.

likpok··on Burned-Out Forests Are Not Re-Growing
Forest management history is complex and varied, and depends a lot on specific details about the forests.

Logging practices over the past two hundred years have had big impacts on how the forest ecology works: what trees grow, what animals and insects live there and how much floor litter there is. All of this has an impact on whether a fire comes through and sterilizes the soil or leaves it fertile.

There was immense pressure for the forest service to support logging and grazing, both of which dramatically alter the landscape.

Another complication is that the native Americans in the area had their own silviculture practice that optimized for their own needs (by and large not lumber), so pre-white historical guides aren’t necessarily “natural” either.

So the forests always regrew, but then we changed them (and stopped allowing fires). In the meanwhile the environment changed as we pumped more carbon into the atmosphere. Now when we reintroduce fire the results are different.

likpok··on Facing housing crisis, L.A. voters back duplexes in single-family neighborhoods
To add on, California has CEQA that allows for any person to demand long environmental reviews. This has been abused by neighbors (along with historic preservation) to prevent development.

The "historic" Mission laundromat is a classic example, as was the lawsuit against the tech shuttle system.

likpok··on Facing housing crisis, L.A. voters back duplexes in single-family neighborhoods
Tokyo is a notable exception to that list as housing prices have stayed steady even as population grew. It did this by building an enormous number homes over the years.

It's true that many cities face the same problem: by making it difficult to add new supply they make existing homes expensive. Even US cities that aren't famous for being expensive have the same problem (if at a lower scale). They lack the flood of new wealthy population but have the same lack of development.

← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →