HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lotu

989 karma · joined November 15, 2007

submissionscomments
lotu··on Google – My Activity
I actually think that might be a good idea. I feel like a lot of people's privacy concerns would would be muted if browsers defaulted to private browsing.
lotu··on Google – My Activity
Normally it is impossible. Normal logs have the user name and IP address removed, they even do stuff to truncate URLs in case a website is hiding usernames or passwords in the URL. If to perform your job it is needed to access a user's data (I'm not actually sure what that job would for consumers), that goes through a separate system which where every access is logged and audited.
lotu··on Amazon defeated Rekognition shareholder revolt by a large margin
It really sounds preferable to me, even if the initial versions of these algorithms are biased. They will provide a concrete thing against which to test for bias and improve against. It is easily verifiable if your changes to an algorithm have removed the bias you are worried about. Conversely it is basically impossible to tell if your training on a human has changed their biases in the field, sort of just having them do their job again and see if they are biased.
lotu··on Google faces first investigation by its European lead authority over GDPR
No it is not! Google requires each individual website to gather consent affirmative for personalized ads before Google will provide personalized ads. There was big issue over if Google would effectively force everyone to use it's solution as it would be the only way Google could be 100% sure the publisher isn't cheating. In the end Google allowed publishers to use whatever method they want.
lotu··on Google faces first investigation by its European lead authority over GDPR
The type of personalized ads you describe only trigger if the user has clicked on the "allow personalized ads" button. If they did not only non-personalized things happen this is things what the website is about and course location (city or zipcode) (the latter is not personalized information as they lawyers explained to me because "it can't identify a person").
lotu··on Price Fixing: The Legal Argument That Could Destroy Uber
I don't really see how this is an existential threat. Uber and Lyft have a simple option allowing each drive to set their own prices (presumably $ per expected mile and $ per expected time idling according to Google Maps traffic info). Uber/Lyft gets a defined cut. The user could then choose the closet or cheapest car, and you would have a self working market where the price is set by the drivers according to market forces. The main downside would be prices could fluctuate wildly if their are very few drives in an area.
lotu··on Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher”
While people often don't have to do the explicit differentiation and integration taught it calculs that doesn't mean you aren't using knowledge learned in a calculus class.

I often think about rates flows and how they relate to each other. For example to do monitoring we count the total number of messages received in each task at a given time, then use the diffrence to get a rate. That is basically differentiation and understanding calculus makes it easier.

The other thing you acquire from doing Calculus is problem solving experience, figuring out how to apply various approaches to a problem to get to a desired solution. In this way calculus strengthens your brain similar to how a sports player might do weight lifting even if their sport doesn't involve lifting heavy objects.

lotu··on Gmail tracks the history of things you buy, and it’s hard to delete
Gmail was never used to serve ads outside of gmail. The use of email to serve ads was stopped in 2017. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/23/technology/gmail-ads.html
lotu··on SAT to Add ‘Adversity Score’ That Rates Students’ Hardships
Just because a school has access to the information doesn't mean they have the expertise, time, or money, to turn that information into a number that can then be used in admissions. Admissions tests have existed for centuries the idea of the SAT is by having a single standard you can have one group of people make a better test for less money (and student time). This is very much the same thing, figuring out how to rank high schools and estimate adversity by street address for the whole nation is a HARD problem.
lotu··on SAT to Add ‘Adversity Score’ That Rates Students’ Hardships
That is going to look like you fucked up horribly at great school and where going to get expelled but managed to avoid it by transfering.
lotu··on Amazon can't yet completely delete Alexa voice transcriptions
I think this is obvious however I also understand that most people aren't that clever/interested in these things, and would not realize it. This creates a dilemma of how to message this information in a way that is all at once concise so as to not waste people's time, informative, and not alarmist which freaks people out and is counter productive not only to having a viable product but also to the general adoption of technology.
lotu··on Google to push new ads on its apps
The cheapest iPhone (iPhone7) is selling for $449 new in the US. I'm not sure how cheap you are but this is reasonable compared to Android phones
lotu··on After city switched to a new bodycam vendor, Axon threatened its credit rating
In short they got bad legal advice about a contract from someone at the company on the other end of the contract. It is not even clear if this person is a lawyer, who would have understood the details of the contract, but they very clearlly are not the lawyer for the city.
lotu··on Notes on AI Bias
This is feels like an elephant in the room when it comes to AI bias. We develop an AI that accurately predicts outcomes and discover it is biased, then instead of asking if maybe this means our current system is deeply biased and needs to be changed, we say, "don't use the AI; keep using the people who might or might not be biased but we don't know because we can't measure it in the way an AI can be measured."

If it isn't acceptable to use an AI to create biased outcomes how is it acceptable to use people to create the the same outcomes. AI decision making can be examined and tuned in ways that people cannot.

lotu··on It's Time to Panic About Privacy
I don't think they had those exact specific details but the importance of the end user controlling their technology has absolutely been around for that long. The EFF was founded in 1990 and one of the ideas of the open source community is to ensure the end user is in control of their technology not somebody else.
lotu··on Facebook showed me my data is everywhere and I have absolute no control over it
I think this was a really good distinction, because it suggests a course of action. It sounds like you would support a requirement in a consumer contracts that a person's contact information may not be used for marking purposes or shared with others to use for marking.

This could essentially decimate the direct marketing industry, but that might be the desired outcome. Unfortunately governments don't like to pass laws the decimate any industry no matter how small.

I think it is also very valuable because it more clearly defines what you mean by privacy. The privacy violation happens, not when they collect your contact information, or when it is put into a list, it is when it is used to send you advertising which you find unwelcome.

lotu··on Facebook showed me my data is everywhere and I have absolute no control over it
More to the point building up lists of people's phone numbers and physical/electronic addresses has been how direct marketing has been done for literally centuries. From wikipedia:

> In 1667, the English gardener, William Lucas, published a seed catalogue, which he mailed to his customers to inform them of his prices.

I just have trouble seeing how adding computers to this practice is the line that is too far for people.

lotu··on It's Time to Panic About Privacy
This kinda feels like worrying about how the telephone would allow people to spread rumors and damaging information about each faster and further. Or perhaps discriminate against a potential job applicant based on their voice, instead only getting to see a letter.

This feels like a non-tech person has realized what tech people realized 20 years ago. Technology makes everything we do faster and more efficient even if those things are bad. What they don't propose is any general statement of the problem or any type of solution.

lotu··on Chicago is tracking kids with GPS monitors that can record them without consent
I don't know, building system that handles all complex cases and can respond intelligently to any 16 year old is hard. Having a human in the loop that calls you up and says, "Remember you have to plug the device in." is going to be a lot more effective than a blinking red light or an auditory beep when the batteries are low, (after all the user might be asleep when that happens), a human would be able to remind the user before the battery is low or even escalate to another human for example calling a parent to remind the child in person.

It is fair to question if this extra flexibility is worth the cost in privacy. Though personally I think the GPS monitor is a much bigger incursion on privacy, but I think we generally accept that the benefits outweigh the costs in this situation.f

If you don't think this for communication as described what do you think it is for?

I don't think covert surveillance makes sense because the wearer is already going feel surveilled (that is kinda the literal point of the device). Sarah Staudt, Chicago Appleseed Fund for Justice, obtusely suggests the device is for sexual deviants.

> The idea that an adult can turn on a listening device while a child is, say, in the bathroom or in their bedroom is not good.

I presume she is referring to the fact this is where children masterbate/have sex, as otherwise listening to a person sleep or use the bathroom really is not interesting or particularly hard to do (though if you do that is kinda creepy).

Anyways, this feels like way too much work if you just want to listen to 16 year old sexy-time, and the decision makers (like the mayor or chief prosecutor) isn't even going be in a position where they get to abuse the system to do that.

Perhaps this is a form of public corruption? Build an unneeded system in exchange for kickbacks this feels the most plausible but I don't see anything here that would make this more likely the case for the system mentioned in the article over any random public contract.

lotu··on Chicago is tracking kids with GPS monitors that can record them without consent
This article shows many issues with society but the title is super click-baity. It doesn't mention that it is talking about juvenile offenders, leaving the reader to assume Chicago is picking arbitrary children and tracking them. Furthermore, the main point of the article is not about GPS monitors, as those are already long accepted, as a condition of release, but instead about a two-way auto-pick-up call system built into the device, and the fact those calls are recorded.

Also lot of the issues they talk about go beyond the main privacy focused thrust behind adding a two wall call system to GPS tracking bracelets. How kids can get re-arrested because they forgot to charge the device, or are humiliated and effectively drop out of school because the device beeps in class, or are unable to eat because they are not permitted to leave their house which has no food because their family is poor.

These are real issues and deserves more attention, it is a shame that we only see because there is a clickbait headline. The problem isn't this specific feature being added to these devices, but rather a larger "emergent system" that is the result of many individuals and organizations acting independently and in a self interested fashion. As a society we have not managed to ensure the moral character of those with power over other people.

Technology isn't the cause or the solution to this problem because the problem is the people. People will find ways use things to be cruel or kind to each other regardless of of if that thing is latest advances in telecommunications or just fist sized rock.

lotu··on A majority of consumers do not expect Google to track their activities
Nitpick, can we say "the user's attention is the product" instead of "the user is the product". It is less descriptive and hyperbolic which reduces the speaker's credibility. It also minimizes the suffering of people that have (and unfortunately still are) sold as slaves (literal human products).
lotu··on More jails replace in-person visits with awful video chat products
> You can't have prisons run by for-profit companies and then expect everyone to believe you want low recidivism rates

Sure you can, it's just no one is doing. The private market is very efficient at finding the most efficient way to provide the things they are paid for. In this case they are paid to house people where house has a specific minimum definition. They figure out how to provide that stuff and nothing else.

If instead we paid in a way that encouraged reducing recidivism they would find a way to do that instead. For example today (according to google) the average prissioner costs $30K per year per inmate. let's say we paid $10K per year as a base, but then paid another $10K every year a former prisoner didn't commit a new crime for 5-7 years after they got out. Then these companies would be looking for ways to ensure that people don't reoffend because that means they lose out on the vast majority of their pay. I would expect the greedy selfish private prison companies to start providing lots things that prisoners will need to be successful when they leave for example behavior management strategies, life skills classes, GED programs, diagnosis and treatment for mental illness, even providing free post release things like job placement, or family counseling. All because these are things the will prevent recidivism and get them that sweet yearly payout.

The thing about greedy capitalists, is they are very easy manage, if you are the one paying them. If they are the ones paying you... well we call that corruption.

Really I think the fact we don't see more of this type of pattern suggests that city and states that run prisons care more about punishment than rehabilitation.

lotu··on I Lied When I Said We Did Everything We Could
I 100% agree with you. Though everyone should be able to make their own decision and because people are diffrent they will come to diffrent conclusions about what the right path for them is. We should not be trying to impose our path on other people.

That said I'm going to speculate that as a doctor being asked to do long series of futile actions while watching a person die has to be traumatic. So I can understand why many doctors like the idea of palliative care.

lotu··on Family finds hidden camera livestreaming from their Airbnb in Ireland
From the article:

> Aoife Mullen, communications manager for Ireland's Data Protection Commission, told CNN that the commission was "aware of the issue," adding, "we will be seeking further information from Airbnb on the matter."

It appears that authorities were contacted and will investigate. I would guess this is more a civil case rather than a criminal case though. Still might result it jail time but probably doesn't require sending police out to find and arrest the host right away.

lotu··on Making Video Games Is Not a Dream Job
This is effectively how the game industry works. Young idealistic people get hired and work for a few years; and eventually realize this is shit deal burn out, quit and get replaced.
lotu··on Gmail confidential mode
This is unfortunately how lots of people and companies think "secure" email needs to work. Any message from my bank or doctor works this way even it is something as simple as an appointment reminder. It is massive waste of user's time and programing effort, but I'm afraid that is where the world is moving.
lotu··on EU government websites have undisclosed adtech trackers from Google and others
I recall from reading the law the the government is explicitly exempt from GDPR. I can't pull up a citation right now so take it with a grain of salt.
lotu··on EU government websites have undisclosed adtech trackers from Google and others
In a way this is actually the only "solution" to ensure privacy. A lot of ensuring privacy is knowing down to a very precise detail exactly what data is sent where and what happens to it. The only way to know this realistically is if you wrote the darn thing yourself. Otherwise you have to trust someone that the thing does what it says it does.

We as a society haven't agreed precisely on what "privacy" means so it is effectively impossible to know is a particular service's handling of data provided to meats you definition unless you just don't hand it the data in the first place.

lotu··on Gwern's Law: Ads cost you a tenth of your users
> I bet shipping your child off to daycare every day hinders them more 90 minutes of tablet time .... household of two full time stay at home parents

Wow, no surprise there. I'm sure you recognize how privileged you and your children are to be able to grow up this way.

One size fits all advice is necessary because it is not economically feasible to provide individual expert advice to every single person. Many people unfortunately use a phone/tablet as a cheaper form of child care ignoring the child as long as they are quite and entertained.

lotu··on Facial recognition's 'dirty little secret': Millions of online photos scraped
Yes, and when uploading you are required to confirm you have the rights to do so with that photo. If we aren't going to be able to trust these type of self declarations we pretty much can't have websites where users upload photos anymore.
← PreviousPage 5 of 17Next →