For the first time I am seriously considering whether to replace Emacs as my primary text editor on Linux.
I've been compulsively using Emacs for the past 5 years. Thanks to Emacs I felt
in love with (a dialect of) Lisp and experienced the freedom brought by a truly
programmable text editor. An enlighting experience.
About a couple of weeks ago I began using Sublime Text 2 and... wow, it gets so
many things right and out-of-the-box that I'm now fighting an inner battle to
make a choice.
I am by no means an "hardcore" Emacs user but over the years I accumulated more than
seven hundred lines of elisp code in my ~/.emacs.d/init.el. A large portion of
that file glues together stuff like ido-mode, ido-ubiquitous, smex,
AutoComplete, find-file-in-project, etc making my Emacs a lot Sublime-like.
I recently threw most of that stuff away and began working on sublime.el, which
tries to emulate Sublime Text 2 as closely as possible.
However Emacs is showing a lot of warts: ido's fuzzy matching becomes painfully
slow when dealing with lots of entries, I have yet to make find-file-in-project
behave the way I want, provide most-recently-used heuristics to ido (for any use case not covered by smex),
there's no consistent way to set a unique indentation level across major modes,
long startup times (though the emacs-as-a-daemon/emacsclient pair mitigates
the issue somewhat) and, in general, the UI is antiquated¹.
My only gripes with Sublime Text 2 are that there's nowhere near the amount of
documentation Emacs has (for obvious reasons) and that it is a (mostly)
proprietary piece of software. What if Jon is hit by a bus², looses interest in
his project or finds it unprofitable and decides to stop all development? I
would really, really hate to depend on a piece of software which is never going
to get at least bug fixes. I honestly hope that Jon is considering open-sourcing
it, should he go AWOL for any reason.
By switching to Sublime Text 2 I feel like I am betraying Emacs and all it
represents in the name of convenience. Choice, how paradoxical thou art!
I am sorry if you find this disquisition boring but I had an urge to write it
down somewhere. How liberating!
__________
¹ E.g. there's probably a way to get like find-file-in-project to show stuff as
neatly as Sublime Text 2 does but as far as I know nobody has done it, yet.
² https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_factor