HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

m00n

127 karma · joined November 11, 2015

submissionscomments
m00n··on Wall Street rethinks blockchain projects as euphoria meets reality
I never quite got my head around the value proposition for distributed ledgers in logistics ('smart warehouses / supply chains') and manufacturing ('industry 4.0').

Say you want to trace eco paper rolls around the globe. What could the blockchain do for you? Who are the nodes/miners/coins in this application?

When you suspect some intermediate in the paper chain to exchange eco paper for cheaper ordinary paper, how does distributing the information that he has X rolls on store prevent this scenario.

m00n··on Veteran Wall Street enforcers are landing new roles in virtual currencies
And how does your Kenyan/North Korean/Syrian person buy gasoline/rice/paper with this asset?

Meanwhile, drug cartels, first world millenials and financial investors are in possession of ~100% of this technology. They are shaping it to further their gains, scamming the naive, and undercutting legitimate sanctions and laws.

m00n··on The Exterior Algebra and Central Notions in Mathematics (2015) [pdf]
This ^. If you wonder, 'what complex numbers are all about', then chances are you can't give the universal property of the tensor product, or the definition of a Riemannian manifold, or a complex Lie group, either.

I suggest to look at the literature listings of any undergrad math curriculum to get suggestions on what to start with. There are reasons 'linear algebra' is usually taught before 'Applications of the representation theory of Lie groups in special relativity'.

Or maybe I'm too conservative in my view on math education?

m00n··on Peter Scholze and the Future of Arithmetic Geometry (2016)
I remember the buzz in Germany's math graduate community, when word of Scholze's perfectoid spaces began to go around. Reading groups spawned everywhere trying to get a grasp on the technicalities:

Work in number theory very often deals only with one of two fundamentally different settings.

* Either objects where multiplication with any natural number can be inverted ('characteristic 0', examples for such objects are the rational or complex numbers or "something inbetween the two"),

* or objects where a certain prime number p has a special role; namely, the multiplication by p is the 0-map. This sounds horrible, but it actually has a great implication: (a+b)^p = a^p + b^p, because the middle binomial coefficients are multiples of p. This makes x -> x^p a multiplicative and additive (!) map, the FROBENIUS.

Scholze introduced a way to pull the Frobenius map over to characteristic 0. He could do this 'tilting' in towers and in this way compared the theory of towers in characteristic 0 and p. For details, see his famed answer here [1].

Very soon it became clear, that this tool had remarkable applications and his thesis explored only one of them: a proof of the monodromy-weight conjecture in characteristic 0 by tilting results in characteristic p.

This result alone made the characteristic 0 neck hair stand up :-)

[1] https://mathoverflow.net/questions/65729/what-are-perfectoid...

m00n··on UBeam's Meredith Perry shows her wireless charging technology really works
Not sure, if linking to the pdf is frowned upon here: sci-hub.cc and paste the paper name, voilá.
m00n··on What Scientific Term or Concept Ought to be More Widely Known?
Since the notion of curved path (maybe aside from circular arcs) is not discussed in basic geometry, the problem would be impossible to state.

If you assume given the notion of arc-length as the least-upper-bound on lengths of piecewise-linear paths between the two points, then the triangle inequality of basic geometry suffices. This seems not more hand-wavy a proof as something about "light-travelling-at-constant-speed" analogies.

m00n··on What Scientific Term or Concept Ought to be More Widely Known?
This is a pictorial description of the proof in the sibling comment. It does not use calculus of variations, just the definition of the path length of a (differentiable parametrized) curve. If you want to call your parametrization a "light-ray" thats fine, but muddies the waters for me.

Just spell out what we mean by path, length of a path, and use calculus of a single variable. No need to introduce 'time', 'constant speed' or the like.

BTW, a truly variational proof is in the wikipedia article [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculus_of_variations#Example

m00n··on The unbearable smugness of the press
Well, it's not such a big deal, apparently. Everybody looking the other way, when the boss touches the secretary. Good times!
m00n··on The unbearable smugness of the press
Well, if you said instead, you killed several of your prior bosses and the widowed partners of some these were making public appearances in TV and you settled claims with some of them for undisclosed sums of money, yes, then I would maybe call the authorities or consider not voting you in the highest office.
m00n··on Languages: Why we must save dying tongues (2014)
Do you think that the ideas of Leibniz and Cauchy, that is differential and integral calculus, of Heisenberg and Einstein, that is Quantum mechanics and Relativity, of Curie, Mendelejew, Hahn, Bosch, ... basically, of any non-english speaking scientist with breakthrough insights, are not understood by English speaking scientists, when translated?

What makes you believe people think about concepts "In English", when they are published in English? Certainly Feynman was thinking about QM in English, even though most of the concepts were developed in Norwegian and German.

Also, I'm still waiting for a single example of an english named scientific concept, that is not understandable to a German/French expert in the field. Maybe you have at least _one_ example handy, claiming that "most scientific concepts" are of this type.

m00n··on Languages: Why we must save dying tongues (2014)
In my field of expertise, which is mathematics, this is certainly possible. My French and Russian is bad, to say the least. I doubt I have a vocabulary of more than 200 words in each, but I have no problems reading, for example, EGA [1]. Also there are entire journals in the field publicising translations of articles, which seems to contradict your claim that bleeding-edge scientific concepts are non-translatable.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89l%C3%A9ments_de_g%C3%A9o...

m00n··on Languages: Why we must save dying tongues (2014)
You are aware of the fact, that Einstein's papers are in German, right?

> The vast majority of new scientific papers are written in English and hence every new concept within them can’t be expressed in any other language since there are no corresponding vocabulary to map the new concept onto.

Non sequitur. But how about _you_ provide an example of a non-translatable concept in an English paper. Should not be hard: 'Just pick any scientific paper at random.'

m00n··on Languages: Why we must save dying tongues (2014)
To translate scientific literature is the easiest part of translation. In fact, a lot of papers don't even get translated because everyone can read them after learning 100-200 words from the respective language. I can tell you that most of my time goes by reading scientific papers in languages that are not my mother tongue.

The question discussed in this thread is _not_: Would it be beneficial to have all scientific papers in one language? It is: Would it be beneficial to have all literature, discussions, jokes, poems and songs in one language. A question, that Newton's work and the amount of NSF funded papers in 2015 has absolutely no relation to.

m00n··on Languages: Why we must save dying tongues (2014)
Some people act so self-entitled, it hurts. Just because you seem to neither have appreciation for beauty nor humanities, doesn't free you from acknowledging it in others.

Your premise seems to be that all languages are 'Turing-equivalent': Given enough time+patience you can "explain" the meaning of every expression in every other language. To be honest, a book that wastes my time "explaining" concepts from the language it was originally written in is not a book I would consider fun.

I hope you can agree, that describing a feeling is not the same as actually feeling it. But you don't accept that there are words that evoke a feeling in a native speaker, that are not evoked by reading a translation in another language?

There are already several examples of phrases in this thread that can only clumsily be explained in English, and some of them are for exactly this reason already used by English speakers. The amount of scientific publications on indivual pieces of literature should also tell you that language as art is more than describing things.

Btw, your example of scientific papers is entirely besides the point because their purpose precisely is to just describe something, instead of evoking feelings or images in the readers mind, tapping into his stream of associations/values/lifelong cultural traditions etc. You also claim that _all_ human thoughts in history are "rather limited" when compared to modern "scientific papers". This is trolling, I hope.

Finally, the fact that you make out your own language as the lingua franka of all humanity does not do much good to your argument, which has a priori nothing to do with a specific language. Rather, it makes you look stereotypical Western-centric.

m00n··on In poor neighborhoods, McDonald’s have become de-facto community centers
Your style of writing doesn't warrant a reply, but anyway:

Your "argument" seems to be: Who calls McD unhealthy or bland must be "fucking brainless", also if McD food were as cheap as it is, because it's of the worst quality, that would totally make sense. But for some reason this isn't the case. Indeed, it is "better than shit."

If you enjoy tasty food, by all means, eat it. But if you think deep-frying or pickling is the best way to serve vegetables, grilling meat puree to death the appropriate way to prepare BBQ and the main ingredient in good ice-cream can be corn-sirup, then you have a lot to discover in the world of tastes.

Go out of your comfort zone and try something new!

m00n··on A previously unnoticed property of prime numbers
Cebotarev is a bit of overkill (and not equivalent!) for this and hard to grasp, if your Algebraic Number Theory is a bit rusty.

I recommend Dirichlet's Theorem on arithmetic progressions instead (everybody loves Euler's totient function!) :

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet's_theorem_on_arithme...

m00n··on Doomsday planning for less crazy folk
I noticed some strange behaviour on that website: When I mouse-select text sometimes a word later in the same line would begin to wiggle around.

For example in the paragraph 'Gadget Upgrades'.

A short google search brought up nothing. Any clues?

m00n··on TensorFlow: open-source library for machine intelligence
Minor nitpick: The authors are not the first ones to recognize that 'tensor' makes a great (brand-) name. As someone who is paid to think about tensors this is a bit annoying, because the first thing in my mind when I read a page like OP, is "where are the tensors?". Alas, there are none.

For a mathematician, a "multidimensional data array" is not a tensor. It is a tuple. A tensor is a tuple with much more structure, associated to linear actions on its components. Said differently, if you can't tell me, what 7*[Alice] means, you have no right to call [Alice] a tensor.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2