HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mc-lovin

241 karma · joined May 5, 2013

submissionscomments
mc-lovin··on Chinese DIY Inventions
What are the geopolitical goals of The Atlantic here?
mc-lovin··on Chinese DIY Inventions
What exactly is the Chinese threat you are alluding to? What is going to happen when China does start working on high skill high margin stuff? And why would The Atlantic want to distract people from this?

I'm just not getting your point here.

mc-lovin··on Why People Hate the Google Bus
This is what happens when understanding of basic economics and free markets is equated with libertarianism in most people's eyes.

Without an understanding of economics, people morally equate private transactions that raise the rent in an area (which causes no externalities) with polluting someone's water supply or running down bicyclists with your giant corporate buses (which are externalities).

mc-lovin··on I took the $300K
>I'm not sure this is true. There is lots of sage advice out there pointing out what seems obvious to older, more jaded folks, which is that unless you are an actual founder, you'll probably not make too much money even on a successful exit. The information is certainly out there. It is mentioned on HN a lot.

What are you disagreeing with? I said that people know that startups don't on average pay more than big companies.

Most people I know who have considered the start-up option want the start-up experience for its own sake, not because they expect big financial gains.

mc-lovin··on Why People Hate the Google Bus
So all these issues would go away if Google paid roughly the same effective corporate tax rate as other companies?

I think the real issue is that people feel especially entitled to a share of Google and its employee's earnings, which still makes no sense to me. If by "neighbors" you mean the local community, then I don't see why Google owes anything in particular to the local community. They already pay local, state and federal taxes. If a rich guy moved next door to me, I wouldn't expect him to contribute more to the local community just because he happened to live near me. Furthermore, trying to extract rent from companies will fail in the long run since they are free to move within the US.

mc-lovin··on Why People Hate the Google Bus
Maybe he's saying that nerds should be treated as separate but not equal, in that they should be allocated their own space (SV suburbs like MTV, MLP) and not allowed to mix with the cool people in SF where they would creep out the girls.
mc-lovin··on I took the $300K
My impression is that people know they will get less money working at a startup than a big company (including the average payoff when things go really well).

They do it for the experience of working on something really new, and working in that kind of environment, not the money. The big tech companies try to be startup-like, but they can never truly emulate the startup experience.

mc-lovin··on Why People Hate the Google Bus
Google and its employees pay taxes. Can you explain why Google or its employees owe more to the community than every other company/person?
mc-lovin··on Why People Hate the Google Bus
The idea that the local community has the right to decide who lives there and what rent prices should be is simply wrong. And I don't mean wrong in the sense of natural rights, I mean that a democratic decision on these matters has already been made at a higher level. If people want more rights to decide what happens in their community their only option is to buy private land and start a commune.

I'm not a libertarian. I believe that I have a duty to pay taxes, and I even think tax rates (for me at least) are fair, and I have no problem with redistribution. But I also have rights, for example to live where I like so long as I can pay the rent and can find someone to rent to me. My impact on other people through rent prices is not an externality and does not need to be controlled by the government. A free country is a country where you can engage in private transactions as you please, not a country where everything is done with permission of the community.

Also, a lot of the animosity is fueled by something other than pure economics. If you read these kinds of articles, the complaints tend to morph from "rents are rising" to "they aren't part of the community" to "they are socially awkward white kids". The idea that political action should be taken against a group because other people find them unattractive or dislikable is sickening to me.

mc-lovin··on Petition to the European Union ("Citizen initiative") for Basic Income
Here is why I think a basic income is a bad idea.

By way of introduction, basic income is very similar to welfare or negative income taxation. Welfare already exists, and can be made completely unconditional on everything but income should governments choose. All of these methods can be thought of as a map from pre-govt-intervention earnings, to post-govt-intervention earnings, i.e.

after_tax(income) = income - tax(income) + welfare(income) + basic income = income - effective_tax(income)

The problem with basic income is that it is a barrier to thinking holistically about the above equation.

For example, a claimed benefit of basic income, is that unlike welfare, it does not decrease when you start to earn money (i.e. it is not conditional on income), and therefore does not provide a disincentive to work. In terms of the above formula, the derivative of effective_tax at 0 is close to 0. However, the cost of this is that the derivative of effective_tax must be higher at some other points. So while the poor have more incentive to work, the middle class and rich have less. The perfect system would be a balancing act between these forces, and the idea of basic income confuses the issue by suggesting there is something special about what is essential an arbitrary effective tax rate.

Another issue is that welfare can be targeted to certain groups, and have strings attached. I personally am not a big fan of targeting welfare towards particular groups, with the exception of the disabled and certain ethnic minorities. However attaching strings to welfare is a complex political, social and economic question for which there are no easy answers. I don't believe that "no strings attached" is the optimal solution.

Therefore I think that while making welfare more streamlined, less conditional on things other than income, and not dropping off too fast with income, are all ideas that need further investigation (and all of these are well studied by economists), advocating a basic income has a negative effect on both the political debate, and our conceptual understanding of the issues.

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
While you make some interesting arguments for a basic income guarantee, I think your post would be better as a top level comment.

You don't seem to have addressed anything I wrote past the first two paragraphs (which were a kind of introduction). E.g. I explained precisely what I meant by the concept being "unhelpful".

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
>It's basically like a mafiosi loan shark giving you a desperately needed loan, then threatening not to make any loans to you in the future because you don't have the means to pay it back, forcing you to do whatever they ask of you.

Fixed that for you

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
I don't want to get too bogged down in the details of this thread, so I'll just tell you straight up why I don't support the idea of a basic income guarantee. Hopefully doing so will indirectly address the issue of evidence that we were discussing.

The main problem is that the BIG is an unnecessary and unhelpful concept. I believe the sociology is that people like to believe in causes, rather than fine grained facts or principals, and so BIG is attractive as a cause in spite of not being a useful concept.

First, BIG confuses the issues around redistribution. Assuming welfare is only conditional on income, the sum total of taxation, welfare, BIG and others, can be thought of as a negative taxation system. BIG obscures this because it implies there is something special about redistribution through a "guaranteed" income. E.g. economists are very concerned about the incentive effects of welfare, because every dollar you earn results in less welfare. BIG obscures this by focusing on the flat portion (the guaranteed income) and drawing attention away from the more progressive income taxes that would be needed to pay for it.

Second, BIG is different from many current welfare systems because it is unconditional on being part of a special group (e.g. a parent, farmer, elderly) or certain actions (e.g. education, training, looking for work in good faith). I consider this to be a bad thing, in that it is too extreme in the direction of being unconditional, at least for the developed world. Both in terms of ethical fairness, political feasibility, and economic incentives, giving away money for nothing has strong limits on it. Adding a few conditions, like ensuring people are really looking for work, strikes a much better balance. So again, BIG takes a sliding scale decision (how much should welfare be conditional on certain actions, and should it be conditional on things other than income) and makes it seem like a binary decision by only providing one extreme as an alternative to the status quo.

btw, below I give a well argued article which claims BIG is a useful concept.

www.usbig.net/pdf/manyfacesofubi.pdf

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
If you look at that article, you will find it does not provide evidence for any of the claims in the post. That's not the fault of Wikipedia, as I explained, this is an extremely broad and complex issue, and most academics won't directly cover it because "basic income" is too vague a concept for them.

But that was the point I was making in the first place: you cannot cite three sources and then claim to have the evidence on your side, when these three sources don't provide the evidence that would be needed.

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
You are making very big claims without adequate references. The study shows the effects of a one-off payment, to a highly selective group (note that I'm not implying their randomization was bad, but that both treatment and control groups were very special relative to the whole population), an a particular developing country.

You may personally believe that this is part of a general phenomenon that applies to highly developed countries, to all groups of people in that country, and in the long term not just the short term, but you have presented little evidence for the claims in your first paragraph (I read all the links).

You seem to view BIG as somehow unique, when in fact it is functionally equivalent to progressive taxation plus welfare, when welfare is only conditional on income. It is also hard to argue against because it treats redistribution, which is a sliding scale, as something absolute: it suggests an (imaginary) bar for "basic" income.

I personally believe systems where welfare is primarily conditional in income, but weakly conditional on searching for work or getting training (such as Australia's) are optimal for developed countries. The government can be far more generous when it adds some strings to welfare, than when it is simply giving out money. The only issue is whether countries with different governmental frameworks can copy Australia's model.

In short, you seem to be overlooking what I consider the real interest of this study, which is its specific relevance to developing nations.

>Please, anyone, show me some research that shows BIG doesn't work well. Cheers

That's a very asymmetric way to think about the evidence for and against a particular policy.

edit: The specific problem with your evidence, is that on a such a broad topic, I would expect to see an academic review of the literature. What you provided was [1] wikipedia, [2] an interesting example with no control, and [3] something that wasn't an actual academic study, but a description of a program and it's alleged benefits without any peer-reviewed study demonstrating these benefits.

mc-lovin··on Four Steps to Google, Without a Degree
Probably because it's off-topic and people are sick of hearing about it.

It's simply a discussion people aren't interested in having, and at the end of the day it's the participants who decide what gets up or downvoted.

mc-lovin··on Want to help the poor and transform your economy? Give people cash.
This is a great article. Not because it proves a particular point (we should accept the evidence no matter where it leads) but because of the clarity of the article, and the fact that it accurately represents the academic paper: on a cursory reading of the academic paper, the randomization is truly as good as they sell it in the linked article.

I think this is potentially a big step forward in our understanding of development. It challenges the assumption that the main thing holding back development is a lack of investment in human capital (training) rather than a lack of access to physical capital.

The only issue I have is whether you can expect the same results from one-off payments, as an ongoing basic income, and whether we can expect the same results for the whole population as the group that was selected, who seem to form a very specific group.

mc-lovin··on Four Steps to Google, Without a Degree
>It's a matter of what you think is right. Do you want to have a philosophical discussion?

Certainly, you started a philosophical discussion with your top post, so wouldn't you want to have this discussion?

>I'm getting annoyed because the first responder was almost offended that I expressed a belief on what I think is right. I don't care if we disagree, but don't pretend like I'm encroaching your rights because I'm asserting myself.

Ok, I see your point, but this is a complex issue in itself, let's drop it.

mc-lovin··on Four Steps to Google, Without a Degree
>We should be discussing something like how we're going to help people If helping people is a good motive, why isn't helping yourself?

While people must strike a balance between doing what benefits themselves, and what benefits others, that is basically a personal decision. People who work at Google and other tech companies pay taxes, and benefit society in many ways through the positive externalities. It's not for you to say that this isn't enough of a contribution to society.

>It's an opinion, you can ignore it.

If you state it on HN, you can deal with people disagreeing with it, without getting annoyed.

mc-lovin··on Belief in black magic persists in Papua New Guinea
You are asking the wrong question. Superstition was one factor, but what about instances where superstition does not cause violence? Or instances (like lynchings) where mob violence is not triggered by superstition. Did you understand my analogy earlier? It seems like you are not addressing all of my argument.

Let me ask you a question this time: How would donating to any of the causes that the post I replied to advocated, help the situation in PNG. And "magic" is not an acceptable answer here.

mc-lovin··on Belief in black magic persists in Papua New Guinea
It's the the word, it's the use of the category that I object to.

Imagine a person who says "everything from the holocaust, the the weathermen, to Obamacare is possible once we accept collectivism". The problem with statement is not that there is no such notion as collectivism, but that the different manifestations of it are in no way comparable in terms of their relationship to these forms of violence.

The person I was replying to was ignoring the important, immediate causes of this event (which are described in the article), and focussing on the least important factor, i.e. superstition in general.

mc-lovin··on Belief in black magic persists in Papua New Guinea
Those organzations are nothing to do with the persecution of witchcrafit in PNG. Did you even read the article.

If you want to stop these horrific acts of violence, it would be better to give to the Catholic Church since it was a catholic nun who saved the woman in that article.

Your prejudice against religion is as irrational as what you accuse religion as being, since you put your secularist ideology ahead of the facts when you lump completely unrelated phenomena together into the category of "superstition".

mc-lovin··on Why Yahoo Buying Tumblr Is Not Great For NYC's Tech Scene
I agree, back in 2007, even at Stanford, i-banking and consulting were still very popular and glamorous.

The economy has changed, and the tech industry is booming while the finance industry has shrunk. I wouldn't attribute this to OWS, but to the general realization that the finance industry was too big, and many of its services didn't add value. For example, people will be much more skeptical of hedge funds with magical ways to make money, even though there will still be some genuine hedge funds that can outperform the market.

All these changes mean that the tech industry can compete with finance even in terms of salary.

mc-lovin··on Google Acquires Makani Power And Its Airborne Wind Turbines
can't they just turn whatever is holding the tether in place on the ground?
mc-lovin··on Google Acquires Makani Power And Its Airborne Wind Turbines
While I'm sure they will face many challenges, what they are doing is not the equivalent of putting a ground based turbine in the air.

Their "wing" is the equivalent to a part of a turbine blade, and it moves in circles like a turbine blade would. The propellors in the wing are what extract the energy, but they would not be nearly as big as the blades on a conventional wind turbine.

mc-lovin··on Google Acquires Makani Power And Its Airborne Wind Turbines
My understanding based on reading their materials, is that it is very similar to conventional wind power. "High altitude" here refers to around 600m, which disappointed me because I thought it would be an army of devices flying autonomously in the stratosphere, (I kept reading to figure out how they got the power back to earth, at which point I found out they were tethered, and not flying in the stratosphere).

So they should be very similar to wind power, except that they are tethered, rather than a turbine on a tower.

I think the main issue is how much space they use on the ground, i.e. how much space around the tether point needs to be kept clear.

EDIT: apparently even wind at 600m is better at ground level.

Furthermore, the system is not really a "turbine sitting on a wing". The wing is the turbine blade. It moves in a circle, and the propellers on the wing draw the power from it's motion. It's really an amazing idea that, the kind of thing I wish I had thought of. I think this page has the most interesting information.

http://www.makanipower.com/why-airborne-wind/

mc-lovin··on Always Be Coding – How to Land an Engineering Job
It's also a matter of attitude. If you're not willing to put up with having to study for what you perceive to be arbitrary interview questions, you probably won't do well with all the other annoying things that can't be changed that big companies tend to have.

Which is kind of what many people in this thread are saying when they say they don't want to work for a company stupid enough to use algorithms and data structures questions as their main interview method.

mc-lovin··on Teenager facing terrorism charges for something he posted on Facebook
yes, see my reply above. This is potentially a serious free speech issue, please get all the facts before dismissing it.

If the police say "We are arresting person X because of this statement, and they also did some other stuff", then this suggests that the statements are part of the charges. But as I said above, it's hard to know for certain without seeing the actual charges.

mc-lovin··on Teenager facing terrorism charges for something he posted on Facebook
You are absolutely correct that her arrest relates to a number of actions on her part, apart from the email that the quote comes from.

However, without having seen the arrest report or other documents, it seems from the news articles that the quote in my post is considered by the police to be in itself harassment.

Also, to be arrested for protected speech is bad enough, even if the charges are dismissed. Imagine if every time you held up a banner you could get arrested for harassement, it took a court case to acquit you.

mc-lovin··on Teenager facing terrorism charges for something he posted on Facebook
"Terroristic Threats" are one way that free speech is under attack. Another is harassment laws.

Law student Anya Bargh was arrested for sending an email saying "Let’s celebrate diversity by having the next dean NOT be Jewish."

If that isn't protected speech I don't know what is.

http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/03/law-student-arrested-chiefl...

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →