HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meany

619 karma · joined September 3, 2021

submissionscomments
meany··on Thank God for Mississippi
I think the poster is referring to per capita. A quick search shows that Mississippi ($46.8k) has a higher gdp per capita then France($43.5k) but slightly lower than the UK ($47.3k). EU overall is ($38.2k)
meany··on Pfizer plans to sell its Covid vaccine at a 10k% markup in 2023
On thing to consider is that this is essential a list price. These prices do not necessarily reflect the actual price paid. From an NIH article:

"Private payers, especially large-volume purchasers, are able to negotiate deep discounts with drug manufacturers. Many private payers, including employers and managed care organizations, often contract with pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) to manage prescription drug benefits for their enrollees."

The same is true for government health care programs.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK561162/

Without more data, it's hard to know how much above the origianl $30 Pfizer will actual make per dose.

meany··on “14-hour days with no break, no bathroom”: Jeff Bezos sued by former housekeeper
It’s probably a good idea to wait for the trial to play out before passing judgment.
meany··on Musk orders Twitter to cut infrastructure costs by $1B – sources
To be fair, Jack Dorsey rolled over his ownership into the new structure. There are few people who know twitter, it’s problems, and potential than him.
meany··on Tesla engineers were on-site to evaluate the Twitter staff’s code, workers said
I think the fact that he’s taking Twitter private allows him to do what he wants. It won’t be publicly traded soon.
meany··on San Francisco Reconsiders Business Ban That Targets States’ Social Values
It’s the natural back and forth inherent in any democratic institution made up of many different constituencies.
meany··on Russia’s elite begins to ponder a Putinless future
These are pretty confident, extremely sweeping claims. I don’t think societal level forces can be so easily reduced.
meany··on Twitter engineers told to print out their code
This seems suspect. Without more confirmation, I’d hold off on believing this narrative in its entirety
meany··on UN says “No credible pathway” and “woefully inadequate” to stop global 1.5C
From my read, the previous poster does mention investing in nuclear, wind and solar. With potentially moving to fusion if it becomes available.
meany··on Why do poor Americans eat so unhealthfully? (2018)
This seems like a very small and data poor study to draw such a broad claim.
meany··on The Low Cost of Cancelling Someone
I don’t think the original poster was implying it was comparable to the out comes of Stalin and hitler. Rather that the mechanisms and patterns used to establish control over the political party the leader ran have similar characteristics.
meany··on The Cancellation of ‘Jihad Rehab’
Do you feel the same way when conservatives protest to remove childrens books on LGBTQ+ stories from childrens school reading lists? Essentially, the book is still available in other channels.
meany··on Theater of Shame – The rise of online humiliation
While there are experiences worse than death, there are instances where shaming leads to suicide. So at least in those instances the person apparently prefers death to shame. It’s likely that we all experience mental pain differently so the balance between the pain caused by shame and violence may vary by individual and culture. Also, the source of shame in one culture may elicit a “meh” response and in another drive someone to suicide.
meany··on Modernity is incompatible with planetary limits: a PLAN for the future
I think the authors do a disservice to their cause with the inclusion of judgmental, emotional rhetoric such as sentences like: “ From this perspective, it seems likely that future generations will label the past two centuries as the Fossil Fuel Age rather than the Industrial Revolution—emphasizing the critical importance of a now-depleted resource over a self-flattering celebration of human innovation”

It suggests they’re not looking at all options to solve our problems, and that there is a moral imperative to support a de-growth ideology.

meany··on SIM swapper abducted, beaten, held for ransom
I won't express an opinion on who is more altruistic, [edit] because I don't think I have sufficient data to draw a broad conclusion. Studies on college campus like these always seem pretty weak to draw societal wide conclusions from. These tiny experiments are usually conducted on college students and often are not reproduce-able.

"In one of these experiments, the researchers, led by doctoral student Paul Piff, gave participants the opportunity to share $10 with an anonymous stranger. A few days earlier, the participants had all filled out a questionnaire in which they reported their socioeconomic status. The results showed that people who had placed themselves lower on the social scale were actually more generous than upper class participants were."

This strikes me as a pretty weak study to extrapolate to any society wide conclusions.

meany··on PayPal Demonetises the Daily Sceptic
There is existing precedent for requiring companies to deal with people they don’t want to in order to enhance freedom of speech. For instance the broadcast “equal time rule”: https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/949/equal-time-...
meany··on Refreezing Earth's poles feasible and cheap, new study finds
Do you have concerns that this will trap the billions of very poor in permanent destitution? Do you see a way to stop global growth and raise these people out of poverty? Global per capita gdp is 10k. From a first glance, even if we established a global government that redistributed wealth, no one will be living well - at least by modern standards.
meany··on IMDB deleted all negative user reviews for The Rings of Power
Is it correct to interpret your view as non-Europeans did not view other groups as inferior? That the superiority of the in group is exclusive to Europe? If so, why do you think this only occurred in Europe? What made Europeans different from these other groups?
meany··on The Best Books on the Great Divergence
But Until decisiveness is defined it’s not really a debate. “Decisive” is not a concrete term, it’s subjective.
meany··on The Best Books on the Great Divergence
My undergraduate degree was in history from a top 10 university. Only say this to illustrate that I respect and love history. I thought I was going to become a historian. That said, the field has practical limits not faced by the hard sciences. You can’t test or prove your theories in History and many other humanities/social science. The best you can do is provide evidence that an event occurred. It’s the inherent limits of the field. How do you conclusively prove the cause of the French Revolution or the reasons the Japanese surrendered in WWII?

So how can you validate that any reinterpretation is forward progress and not just a change?

meany··on The Best Books on the Great Divergence
I think you would need to start be defining “decisive” for this context. Not sure the debate makes sense otherwise. Why does it matter if it was decisive or not?
meany··on The Best Books on the Great Divergence
I think one of the challenge with relying on academics of History or anthropology is that, unlike physics, consensus doesn’t necessarily progress towards a more accurate interpretation. I think the post above is suggesting that the linked academic has a agenda that is guiding their analysis. For instance they write that more advanced technology really is just more European. That rather than being more technologically “advanced” Europeans developed technology for a different context. Perhaps it’s inaccurate, but conclusions like these seem to some to be motivated by the need to retell events to achieve/support social justice movements today.

I love reading history, but I am concerned that all historical narratives are illusions - stories we string together from a minuscule subset of the data we’ve captured in writing or other records. This is particularly problematic if people, including academics, see the outcome of their historical interpretations as influencing modern power struggles.

meany··on Why Is a British Baroness Drafting California Censorship Laws?
I’m not sure it’s reasonable to expect foreigners to understand the of inner workings of a country’s system of accolades. There are 195 countries each with its own system.

In the case of the UK, a baroness title is granted but also can be inherited (at least according to Wikipedia. I didn’t know how it worked.) doesn’t this increase the likelihood of confusion for foreigners. I, for one, have a vague sense of how these work in the Uk and France - because I’ve heard of actors/musicans winning accolades there, but otherwise I’m pretty ignorant and if I was going to invest in learning more about those countries, this isn’t an area that would be high on the list.

meany··on Self-Reliance (1841)
I think you maybe confusing Emerson and Thoreau?
meany··on Japanese researchers propose a concept for making artificial gravity on the moon
Doesn’t your remark make the same type of generalization about the West that you accuse the West of making about China.
meany··on Harming the ‘outgroup’ linked to elevated activity in the brain reward circuitry
Something thing you might want to consider. as this article points out human brains evolved to push the individual to identify with a group and be hostile to other groups because it improved fitness. Through most of human existence this group survival pressure outweighed objective rational perception of reality . Political parties often tap into this in group out group emotional connection. While I agree that Republican Party logic is often weak and often emotional, I would argue that the Democratic Party is as well, just on different issues.

Another thing to think about is that by attacking an “out group” (I assume you’re not a republican) in this post you are potentially showing the behavior described in the article.

Edit- grammer

meany··on Harming the ‘outgroup’ linked to elevated activity in the brain reward circuitry
Something things you might want to consider. as this article points out human brains evolved to push the individual to identify with a group and be hostile to other groups because it improved fitness. Through most of human existence this group survival pressure outweighed objective rational perception of reality . Political parties often tap into this in group out group emotional connection. While I agree that Republican Party logic is often weak and often emotional, I would argue that the Democratic Party is as well, just on different issues.
meany··on Experts once predicted that Americans would face excess leisure time (2015)
It seems that there is a lot of emotion in your assessment because you use sweeping absolutes to describe millions of people. In my experience the world is complex and nuanced. Do you really mean to say all rich people are law breakers ala crooks? When you define rich, are you using a global scale? For instance are most people in the developed world crooks? There are good and bad people in all walks of life, all countries, races, etc. More often than not, when you get to understand the forces that impact people, you realize that what seem like simple decisions from the outside to make the world a better place have unseen negative consequences.

On a personal level, I can say my managers try to be good people, although the may not always do the best thing. In my case, my wife has stage 4 cancer and they have been tremendously supportive.

Edit: I should probably mention for full transparency I work at Amazon as it is sited in the article.

meany··on Today’s CEOs are essentially carnival barkers (2021)
This is overly hyperbolic. The article references 3 high profile CEOs and states “Todays CEOs” are essentially carnival barkers. The majority of CEOs aren’t in tech and don’t have anywhere near this life or career trajectory. Also, if you read biography of Edison, Ford, Rockfeller, etc. Many of there behaviors will seem tame. For instance, Edison electrocuted an elephant to make Teslas AC current seem too dangerous compared the DC current he was pushing.
meany··on Success isn’t down to free will – luck determines everything
The deterministic view also removes blame. If success is due to luck than so are failings - a killer is also a victim of nurture, nature and luck.

Based on the title, my interpretation is that the author would like individuals to discount their own success and be more empathetic to those less successful. However, an individual's capacity for empathy and their views on success factors, etc. are also luck based by this rationale. So it seems that the logical conclusion from this line of reasoning is an individual can't do anything other than what they're already doing, so can't ultimately be held responsible.

To be clear, I'm not suggesting the argument is wrong, just that the moral of the article (based on its focus on success) seems at conflict with the logic it is based on.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →