HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mediaman

6,587 karma · joined April 20, 2009

submissionscomments
mediaman··on Launch HN: Living Carbon (YC W20) – Trees that capture and store more carbon
Lots of skeptical remarks here about engineering trees.

But as much as people fantasize about native plants completely unaltered from their natural state, the ability to dramatically reduce world hunger is a direct consequence of humans' capacity to improve crop yields such as rice and corn through breeding and engineering.

We now face a similar challenge to stave off disaster, and efforts to create improvements to existing species to accomplish it deserve the same applause as the technical plant wizardry that prevented the starvation of millions of people.

Much as the plant revolution primarily benefited the world's hungry poor, mitigating climate change also primarily benefits the world's poor, much of whom live in hot tropical climates most susceptible to wet bulb temp hazards. So it's bizarre to see so many wealthy people in this forum complain about the use of technology to achieve a goal that will be so important to prevent the deaths of so many: but I suppose it makes sense, because like eating only low yielding native foods, ignoring climate change and making fun of attempts to solve it is a privilege of wealthy folk who are best able to compensate for it with air conditioning and mobility, and whose kids and grandkids will not have to pay the price.

Living Carbon's technical methods should be scrutinized and the business model questioned, but Maddie and her team should be applauded, and the Whole Foods crowd with vague, unspecific negative thoughts should at least recognize how much luxury they have to rag on humans' attempt to use plants to better our world.

mediaman··on The Advantage of No Funding (2011)
Doing a financial product as a green self-trained dev is not a great idea. But it's also a straw man. There are many great products that don't need to handle millions of users, or are not handling bank connections, that can be bootstrapped by smart people willing to put some work into it.

If they are okay with slower growth, those people will learn a lot, may build a viable business, and will not have to deal with the stress of dealing with the board and constantly raising money.

There are many, many 5-10 person companies (or less!) that have been bootstrapped, that make a lot of money, and that have very happy founders with happy customers, and whose founders have no pressure to sell out or do things they don't want to do. The main cost is patience and willingness to not be a glitzy success story in the papers. Nobody is paid to encourage you to take this path, except for you.

mediaman··on I made an open source project – STM32 for stereovision tasks
Openmv is actually pretty great. I agree if you need 4k at 60fps, or stereoscopic, it’s not for you, but there are lots of industrial tasks that require nothing like that. I’m using it now and it’s great to program the thing in micropython and do blob tracking, fiduciary marker recognition, etc with it at 20-30fps or so, which is all I need.

I can see how you’d think it’s a commercial failure if you approach it with an incompatible use case.

mediaman··on How to know if you’re addicted
That's interesting, but suppose I like to drink a couple cups of coffee per day. It helps me get my brain active in the morning, and avoid the afternoon slump.

Are there negative consequences to me or others? Not that I can identify. The literature has no good study that suggests any long-term health problems with coffee consumption.

But I will feel out of sorts if I suddenly stop. I'll be fine again after a few days. But it seems certain there is a chemical dependence. This does not fit your definition of addiction, but it seems odd to claim that my daily coffee consumption is not, at the least, a light addiction?

mediaman··on Heuristics that almost always work
And for the robber, crime is a lot more common than he seems to think it is. Metal theft, for example, is extremely frequent: it is rare that an industrial facility would have so little theft that such a proposed heuristic would be reasonable.

If crime were that low, then the guard's position doesn't exist anyway.

So then we're just left with an empty thought exercise with no relation to reality, as an argument for how we should think about reality.

mediaman··on Peloton replaces CEO and lays off 2,800 people
Interesting. I wonder if this is a problem for some people in-person, as well, or if the video specifically causes the speech to not get processed right the first time around.

If it's a problem in both environments I could see remote work with closed captioning being a big benefit for people with certain types of neurodivergence.

mediaman··on I Quit Shopify After Five Months
That's pretty funny. I have to admit, though: "adversity" is an odd term to use when they meant challenges specifically related to your past jobs. Ask about how a candidate dealt with conflict, or dealt with being asked to meet an unreasonable timeline, sure: but adversity?

Especially for a company that worked on social equity issues, conflating life adversity with sundry issues faced in a corporate job seems odd. Your answer seems pretty appropriate!

mediaman··on The unsustainable growth of the container ship industry
Interesting. If there are a lot of new vessels built, then they could be facing poor margins again in a few years after supply comes online.

It's a lot like the airline industry. Once that vessel is built, the cost of each incremental container is almost nothing.

mediaman··on Building a modern home in the woods
Many utilities will do this based not on the amperage to the house but the peak kw used in a billing cycle - a capacity charge. This helps incentivize reduced peak usage. In your scenario it's strange because you have zero incentive to keep your maximum usage below the breaker amount, other than the per-kwh cost.
mediaman··on Building a modern home in the woods
Is this for a wood-construction sauna with a heater warming up rocks that you can steam water off of? That's a lot less mass to warm up, mostly air, and a lot less ongoing energy loss than a big heated pool.
mediaman··on The unsustainable growth of the container ship industry
Price of container shipping has skyrocketed due to high demand and the supply of ships being fairly limited, even more limited when the average trip time of a boat increases.

One question I've been thinking about is whether the ocean freight companies will respond by increasing supply of ships. These ocean shipping companies didn't actually make a lot of money prior to the pandemic: back when China-USWest prices were under $3k a container, their margins were actually kind of thin.

So if we've had all this consolidation, and there are now three alliances that handle most of the freight, what is the incentive to increase supply? Just a 30% increase in ship capacity would likely crater profits.

Is the industry going to respond with building more ships, or, like OPEC, will they be able to coordinate to constrain supply so that long-term rates settle down in the $6-8k range versus the <$3k that existed previously?

If they are able to operate as a cartel, that will have major, long-term consequences for the dynamics of geographic manufacturing and supply chains. If they can't, then the pandemic will be a multi-year blip and we'll go back to hallowing out manufacturing and sending it to Asia.

mediaman··on How should net metering affect your electric bill?
There are two environmental costs to this setup.

The first is that if he weren't frivolously moving electrons through his heater, there would be more to feed to the grid for other people. So there is an opportunity cost of reducing CO2-generating energy production elsewhere.

The second is that he installed a much bigger array than optimal, due to regulatory requirements, and that too has up-front environmental consequence. Since he's burning off that excess electricity rather than feeding it to the grid, there's really no redeeming value to an array that's too big.

mediaman··on Sweden approves plan to bury spent nuclear fuel for 100k years
Does anyone have a good political explanation for Europe's hostility to nuclear power?

Is it really just post-Fukushima nuclear concern?

There are so many pressing issues at stake - CO2 production, dependency on an increasingly aggressive foreign adversary for fuel - that it seems like there must be some logic, but I can't figure it out.

Even if wind/solar are cheaper than nuclear, it doesn't seem that they can become the only type of of energy supplied in Europe due to variability issues.

mediaman··on 13 years sailing around the world
My operating costs for a 38' are around $10-15k annually, including a slip at a (low-cost) marina and maintenance, but doing most maintenance myself. The first year had at least $10k more in "catch-up" maintenance items. I do pay others to periodically haul the boat, repaint the hull, check zincs, etc.

It would be considerably higher paying shop rates for most maintenance, or if you had expensive tastes in sails or electronics.

For me this works out to about 15-20% of the cost per boat in ongoing annual opex cost. Kind of like a software maintenance contract!

Ongoing maintenance includes stuff like:

* Engine maintenance: oil, fuel filters, oil filters, impeller, occasional corrosion repainting, occasional replacement of wear parts (belts, exhaust elbow, flex piping)

* Fixing leaks from things like deck prisms, portholes, deck, chainplates. Usually involves epoxy, sealant, disassembly of components

* Care of interior and exterior wood - varnish, or oiling, or other protection as preferred

* Regular lubrication of moving parts, such as the helm and steering assembly

* Replacement of running rigging (ropes that control sails) when it gets tired

* Checking standing rigging (steel cables that keep the mast up), replacing when needed, though these last a long time. This usually needs professional riggers and is more expensive.

* Keeping corrosion under control - stainless is never as stainless as you want

* Replacing sails every 10-15 years, assuming you are ok with more tired sails toward the end

* Having diver clean hull, also repainting hull every 2 years, replacing zincs as needed, usually 1-2x annually depending on water type

And other stuff. Replacing marine toilet pumps, fixing shower sumps, replacing bilge pumps, fresh water pumps, etc.

These things aren't as bad as they sound if you like working with your hands and have time. I like it because my day job limits the use of my hands to the keyboard. And you don't need to know how to do all this stuff - I learned almost all of it while attempting to do it, and I still learn all the time. But if hands-on work isn't your cup of tea, it will get very expensive.

The reward, beyond the fun of doing the work, is sitting on the deck, anchored at a remote island looking at incredible sunsets in the summer. Or being the only boat out on a winter day and seeing a humpback whale surface near your boat, hang around for a while. Or sitting down below next to a warm fireplace in the winter with a good book listening to the patter of rain. Sleeping on a comfortable bed in absolute silence in remote areas, far away from any cars, sirens, or other people. Trimming the sails and feeling the power of the wind energize the boat, pulling it forward as your boat nearly silently cuts through the water.

For me, totally worth it, but it does become a fairly important part of your life.

mediaman··on Zim – A Desktop Wiki
What do you prefer to use now?
mediaman··on When my wife developed Alzheimer’s, the story of our marriage kept us connected
The divorce rate is distorted because of those who have many divorces. It's split, also, across class lines.

Marriages between college-educated people are only about 30% likely to end in divorce.

mediaman··on I automated my job over a year ago and haven't told anyone
Agreed - accountants are a unique breed. They do a fair amount of basic numeric analysis and rote work that is of the sort that is beneficial to automation. But they're often very averse to technology, often stop learning any new tools early on in their career, and tend to stick to the methods they learned as juniors, even many years later.

That's a broad brush, and is certainly unfair to and untrue of some accountants. Some are Excel gods and can VBA it up with the best of them, and would have been productive software engineers in another life. But it's surprisingly true for much of the profession.

mediaman··on Ask HN: How to continue to be gracious about the good fortune of rich friends?
You are responding to a statement that wasn't quite made.

We are talking about riches here, not transitioning from poverty to an upper-middle class income. What you say is absolutely true, but only up to a point, because money has diminishing marginal returns to happiness.

Why? Because of everything you state: it is unpleasant to have to think about how you'll feed and house yourself. But it does not require riches (in western living context) to be able to stop worrying about that.

Where money stops driving happiness varies by person, and by regional cost of living, but the research we have available suggests that it's not an extraordinarily high amount. Maybe $90k or so for most people.

But if you're making $150k, will having $10m in the bank make your life dramatically happier? The evidence suggests that no, it will not. That's when money fails to buy happiness.

mediaman··on Tell HN: AWS appears to be down again
Very similar experience with sailboats.

There's nothing like being at sea, 100+ miles from civilization, reliant on the limited capacity systems on your vessel. You manage your food, you manage your water consumption, fuel, electrical usage, you're closely attuned to the weather, the sea state, the charts. There are no other visible people or people-made objects out to the horizon in all directions. If something breaks, you'd better know how it works and be able to fix it, or go without. It feels very freeing, but also provides a "back to basics" accountability.

Standing under a hot water shower with unlimited water in a spacious home shower afterward feels luxurious.

mediaman··on Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground
What exactly is the risk you are worried about?

How is a ten-year mortgage less risky than a 30 year?

mediaman··on The Amazon Empire Strikes Back
This misses the point. Of course it is possible to build 53’ containers; you cannot ship them on conventional large trans-ocean container ships. The article you link makes this point specifically, and the company is offering containers for use as shelters.
mediaman··on Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire
Let's keep it simple and comparable, and say the traditional retailer also has 34% gross margins.

In the wholesaler-retailer model, the process looks like this:

Wholesalers buys item from manufacturer for, say, $0.25. They sell item to retailer for $0.50, and keep $0.25 in gross profit. Retailer sells for $0.76, for a selling margin of 34%. The $0.26 of profit the retailer gets pays for the store, staff, logistics, net profit etc.

In Amazon's third party model, it looks like this:

Wholesaler buys item from manufacturer for $0.25. They sell item to end-customer for $0.76. They get $0.51 of profit! But now they pay Amazon a litany of fees amounting to 34% of the price the item sold at: 34% of $0.76, or about $.26. That leaves the wholesaler with the same $0.25 of profit.

The main difference in these two processes is that in the third party model, the wholesaler keeps the inventory on their books for longer, because they ship it to Amazon and then the inventory sits at Amazon (but is still owned by the wholesaler) until it sells. That means that even if they get the same profit in the end, they've employed more capital, and it gooses Amazon's return on invested capital (they don't have to own that inventory) while reducing the wholesaler's.

mediaman··on Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire
The report suggests Amazon is taking 34% of third-party sellers' revenue.

This sounds like a lot, but "revenue" in this case is the retail sales price of the goods.

Traditionally, in a wholesaler-retailer model, the retailer "keystones" their cost on the good, meaning they arrive at the selling price by doubling their cost. This is of course a somewhat antiquated idea now (markups are generally lower now) but it gives you an idea of typical gross margins before selling costs (doubling the cost would give you 50% margins).

34% means that Amazon is keeping 34% of the retail price of the product as profit. That doesn't actually strike me as particularly high. It's not low (Costco is much lower, with 15% selling margins) but it's not particularly high either.

The article goes on to complain about advertising costs. Welcome to retail! Are you ready to play slotting fees? End-cap fees? Promotional and coop fees? Most big retailers do this. I know of not-huge companies that pay millions per year, in advance, to a home improvement retailer to secure exclusivity over an entire shelf.

It's one reason why selling to retail is annoying (versus selling to businesses), because almost all big retailers are extractive and prioritize their profits over great prices to consumers. But this article comes across as if they don't know anything about retail.

There's a good argument that this kind of behavior is perhaps Day 2 behavior - the conversion into a big company that pushes for margins above all else. But it's not different from traditional retail.

mediaman··on Finishing my first game while working full-time
If you are doing it in a company office, using company property, during hours the company expects you to be working, do not expect to use "well, I'm salaried, so it doesn't matter" as a legal defense and win.
mediaman··on A U.S. submarine struck an underwater mountain last month, the Navy says
The South China Sea issue does get a fair amount of attention.

It is very unlikely that this is the cause of the Muirfield Seamount. They would have had to artificially create an underwater mountain taller than Mount Rainier to do so. The surrounding water is 16,000 feet deep.

mediaman··on Zillow seeks to sell 7k homes for $2.8B after flipping halt
A better strategy is to use the 30 year, and then invest the monthly difference in the market. Why pay down long-term funding of 3.25% cost of money and lose out from a long-term market return of 7%?

You're right about the compound interest, but compound interest can work for you as well.

mediaman··on Zillow seeks to sell 7k homes for $2.8B after flipping halt
True, with a 30 year it looks like you're paying a lot of interest, and in nominal terms (i.e., the total amount during the loan), you are.

But consider a thought experiment where you could borrow $1m at a low rate of interest, suppose 3%, from a generous lender who requires no collateral and requires an amortizing repayment. You take the $1m and reserve, say, $100k in "no-touch" cash (your cushion) and invest the remainder in the market, and suppose that the market returns an average of 7% over the long run.

In this scenario, you obviously pay much more interest than not taking the loan. The interest you pay is nearly $500k, which sounds like a lot - almost half the loan! Yet you make a tidy profit over 30 years: after paying back the loan, you have a portfolio worth over $4 million, plus the $100k reserve you still have.

While that's just a thought experiment, the math works fairly similarly for a mortgage. So long as the market returns more (over the long term - it'll be bumpy short term) than the cost of money, you will be paid handsomely for assuming lots of long-term, fixed low-interest debt and investing the proceeds.

And this leads to a second surprising conclusion: you should not pay off your mortgage. Once you've built equity, releverage the house and borrow more, so long as you take the proceeds and invest it in an instrument that will pay more than the cost of money over the long run. If interest rates rise, the math might not work.

This is bad advice for some people, because a pile of savings and investments can be a tempting target to use for luxury vehicles, or boats or whatever, and that can upset the math, although eventually you make enough with it that might be OK. But for people who can live as if those investments were illiquid, it's quite a rewarding path.

And for some people, the psychological value of living in a house with no mortgage exceeds whatever financial gains come from continuing to pay for a mortgage. And while there's nothing wrong with that, it does come at a stiff financial cost.

mediaman··on Zillow seeks to sell 7k homes for $2.8B after flipping halt
A note on the mortgage: I understand your aversion to debt, but choosing a shorter duration mortgage can increase the probability of default, even if it shortens the time to the point that you are debt free, because for any given amount of cash reserves you have it shortens the runway you have if you lose your income.

As long as mortgage money is cheap, the most profitable course of action is to use the 30 year mortgage, but keep a large chunk of money in reserve and invest the rest in the market for the long term. And never allow yourself to not be well-cushioned.

Debt gets people in trouble when they use it to get things that put them on the edge, where losing a job causes them to miss a payment. For people who stay far away from the edge, and are good with money, it's very profitable.

mediaman··on Flexport CEO on how to fix the US supply chain crisis
This sounds totally foreign to me. In the industrial world, American equipment is pretty good quality. Japanese also. And German, Italian, and French.

Chinese is cheap but their machinery is generally not very good. They screw up all sorts of stuff: wrong bearings, designs are copied but not always thoroughly thought out, weld issues, poorly programmed PLCs, incorrect wiring, poor metals quality control, dangerous safety implementations, the list goes on and on. Some bigger manufacturers are getting better there.

But places like Turkey and Korea have a nice balance of technically "good enough" and cheaper than the Euro/American products, though Korean machines have gotten more expensive and are technically very sophisticated.

The idea that anyone building a factory would turn to China for technically sophisticated machinery is interesting and would be a quick way to get fired in industry. China has gotten a lot better over the years, but I think a lot of people forget that a lot of what happens in China is assembly, not necessarily manufacturing of the subcomponents, which is where much of the actual value add is. If you do get machinery made in China, you look for those who use as much European, Japanese, Korean, or American parts as possible.

mediaman··on Apple Privacy Rules to Blame for Facebook's Lower Than Expected Quarterly Growth
There is something to this. FB has underperformed the S&P500 recently.

Over the 1 year mark, the S&P is up 31%, vs less than 13% for FB. It has underperformed over 6 months as well: less than 7% for FB compared to 9% for the market.

It's only until you look back two years and more that FB has outperformed.

Most of this is because of a roughly 15% decline in FB stock since mid-September.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →