HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

metamemetics

1,955 karma · joined September 14, 2009

[hn user name] at gmail.com

I believe one should make the strongest defensible statement possible.

submissionscomments
metamemetics··on Why I’m Not On Facebook
>but once a client (who I'm friends with) friended me it made my facebook pretty damn vanilla, and its stayed that way as I've added other professional friends.

This is a usability problem with facebook. It should be easy as pie to control the information you present to different GROUPS of people. Instead functionality is scattered across by CONTENT TYPE. Makes no sense and is completely illogical, social networking is about people, differing content-types are just small variations on the sharing theme and not the main conceptual focus.

The 100 different content types are the entity sets with privacy attributes, rather than having privacy be an attribute on a manually created (small) number of groups of people. We put people in groups (ie. professional, family, friends) in real life, I can't understand how Facebook can possibly get this so wrong.

The root of these problems is piss poor User Interface decisions. Facebook expanded without a plan. It's just like Urban Sprawl: let's add a bunch of widgets everywhere just like a suburb with zero urban planning adds strips malls.

metamemetics··on Entrepreneurship in Italy from a non-Italian’s perspective
>there is only one elective in English at Bocconi focused on entrepreneurship and having taken that elective it leaves a lot to be desired.

Even in the U.S. my impression is the majority of universities don't teach entrepreneurship or teach it poorly. I think for within an engineering college (not b school) the technology entrepreneurship center at UIUC is great http://tec.illinois.edu/ and other universities probably have similar programs, but nothing that compares to Mixergy + Hacker News.

metamemetics··on So A Blogger Walks Into A Bar…
I would argue it's more ethical to discourage and prevent crime from ever happening in the first place. Seeking satisfaction from "catching the bad guy" (naming names) is to setup a market dependent on the need for new crimes.

Arrington did the right thing. It's not about whether he caught a criminal, it's about whether he prevented someone from becoming one.

metamemetics··on So A Blogger Walks Into A Bar…
>Sounds to me like bloggers are the new journalists

Journalism used to be considered the fourth branch of government, keeping the other branches and large institutions in check. Blogs are the startups of the journalism world.

As America moves from bureaucratic capitalism with large institutions to entrepreneurial capitalism with many small firms & independent players, the responsibility to call out unethical behavior is transferred from news companies to the individual.

metamemetics··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
I think dialects are tough to predict emergent behavior that will inevitably happen if a language becomes old enough. They just want to happen.

If your language assumes this and supports version-dialect from the start it will be more robust and age gracefully in the long run.

edit: basically it would require too much work or a stroke of pure genius to ensure perfect syntax for a new language in public release 1. Language designers should assume as project age approaches infinity the probability of a syntax revision approaches 1.

edit2: also if the interpreter host could interpret all the older versions up to the latest by default, you could write your code in both 2.7 and 3.1 and use 2.5 libraries with it etc. No need to rewrite every single older library for trivial changes.

metamemetics··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
Let's try to be constructive here!

Come up with solutions and ways to avoid the problems mentioned in the future. There's always fashions and trends sure, but I think most people chose to program their last web app in Python or Ruby over assembly for more practical reasons...

metamemetics··on Mongrel2 Says, "Goodbye Python"
So what can we learn from this for designing future languages?

Make it standard idiom to have every file of code declare its version-dialect at the top?

Default to throwing warning if interpreter and code version-dialect mismatch?

Have the main code interpreter called by all code files simply be a host for routing code to the correct dialect-version interpreter? Perhaps include an optional "slim" download where the host only includes the interpreter for one dialect-version, but make this non-default\opt-in.

metamemetics··on How a WWII Jet Fighter Was Designed in 150 days & shipped in six months
article summary:

>Use a small number of good people

metamemetics··on This is Your Brain on Food
>I'm pretty sure the author's talking about "chemicals" and not chemicals.

No, you are completely missing the point. He was attacking the mythical duality you are perpetuating. There is no binary distinction between psychoactive and non psychoactive chemicals. Water IS psychoactive. Protein in chicken IS psychoactive. Sugar IS psychoactive.

Let's take chicken for example. We can turn that into a chemical with a long name quite easily! Assuming you are consuming low fat chicken, the majority is protein. Protein is a bunch of chemicals called amino acids. One of the most common amino acids by weight in chicken is (2S)-2-amino-3-(1H-indol-3-yl)propanoic acid, Tryptophan. Tryptophan is THE building block of serotonin and all other tryptamines your body produces.

Are you aware 2-(1H-indol-3-yl)-N,N-dimethylethanamine (DMT) is responsible for dreaming and near death experiences is synthesized in your body directly from that chicken and could not have been synthesized without it?

Sugar->Glucose-> 6-(hydroxymethyl)oxane-2,3,4,5-tetrol. Sugar has clear and obvious excitatory psychoactive effects on the brain. Some researchers even think cognitive decline\Alzheimer's may be related to insulin resistance in the CNS similar to diabetes.

The author tells you exact dosages in the article for the amount of Nutmeg you need to consume to hallucinate. He gives more than enough numbers for an opinion piece.

Regarding chocolate you can test your wrong hypothesis quite easily. Buy pure, NON-alkalized cocoa powder in the store today and consume 3 tablespoons.

metamemetics··on Ask HN: What's the big deal with startups anyways...
>Why the hype?

From 1980-2005, nearly all net job creation in the United States occurred in firms less than five years old. Your job security wouldn't exist without startups. The risk-takers are the exploratory outliers changing economic paradigms and promoting growth. If their business model bet succeeds, they have both predicted the future as well as created the future.

We pay them attention even\especially when they say bread-crumb concepts because humans have always been interested in the idea of prophets.

metamemetics··on This is Your Brain on Food
>I get skeptical every time someone brings out a list of "chemicals" that are supposedly all around us

What is there to possibly be skeptical about in this article? Why did you put quotes around chemicals? His point was everything that exists is a chemical and is processed by the body as a chemical. I'm more skeptical as to whether or not you read the article than anything presented in it.

metamemetics··on Ask HN: Is a Ph.D. in CS worth it?
Hedge your bets. Start talking to professors this semester about grad school and getting recommendations. Then tell them later you've decided to do a year of startups\industry. If you are on good terms with them, they will be fine with submitting recommendations 1 year later. You'll just have to let them know what productive things you've been up to in that year. Their only concern is that they aren't damaging their reputation by recommending burnouts.

In the meantime, get involved with other students on building stuff outside of class this year! Once you find a specialty of CS you're passionate about, whether it's statistical machine learning or web development, it'll be obvious which path is the best choice.

metamemetics··on Thomas Jefferson's Letter to His Nephew Peter
>Since most information is just a quick web search away, most people have no incentive to actually absorb that information.

it's a moot point. In the 1700's we wouldn't have had access to the information anyway. Or even the money, time, and opportunities like aristocracy such as Jefferson had to buy books from London and study the smaller amount of knowledge available then.

So rather than not having an incentive to absorb information X, we wouldn't have even known it existed! A large part of knowledge is knowing what you DON'T know. The truly dangerous individuals are idiots that think they know everything.

Hopefully the web is making people realize that there are a lot of things out there they DON'T know. Decreasing anti-intelluctialism, provincialism, and narrow-mindedness.

I would be ecstatic if more people got their news from the web than from television!

metamemetics··on Thomas Jefferson's Letter to His Nephew Peter
>"renaissance man" now is a dilettante. In Jefferson's day it meant having both broad and deep knowledge.

Jefferson's estimated net worth is $212 million. George Washington's is $525 million. It seems like you are comparing the values of a notably intelligent and published subset of the upper 1% aristocratic crust subset of society to the general population today. Hardly a fair comparison.

You are railing against people for being dumb and yet have really bad proposals as to the cause. "It's the schools fault, let's do away with schools" "It's the kids' VALUES"

You fail to consider that:

1. Intelligence is a distribution. There have always been dumb people and there always will be.

2. Economics. Blacks used to score significantly lower on IQ tests than whites in America. But guess what, the gap was directly proportional to the gap in poverty rate (http://www.huppi.com/kangaroo/L-IQgapgenetic.htm). As the economic status of blacks in America improved the gap has decreased.

If you want to compare the intelligence of groups of people large enough to account for outliers, the difference is always largely socioeconomic. Thus I will argue the OPPOSITE of your hypothesis is true:

The wonders of technology and readily accessible information are the most important factor driving down global poverty, resulting in a higher percentage of the global population fulfilling a "Jeffersonian" ideal of the renaissance man with deep knowledge, whereas it was the time and opportunities and books to achieve that level of study was before confined to the aristocracy.

metamemetics··on Thomas Jefferson's Letter to His Nephew Peter
3rd shift workers have increased mortality\risk of cancer, largely due to Vitamin D deficiency. I agree Jefferson's statement is accurate.

Nowadays we know vitamin D exists so you can take a supplement or consciously eat certain foods (oily fish such as sardines http://www.seriouseats.com/2010/01/alton-browns-sardine-avoc...)

metamemetics··on Where Rails Rocks (and where Python doesn't)
I think it's simply that Ruby is used primarily for web development where Python is used in just about every field for scripting and even as a Matlab replacement in universities.

Python web development projects are distributed randomly within the much larger python ecosystem and it's hard to know what stuff everyone's working on without a lot of crawling. With ruby\rails, even your google results on topics will be more targeted because the scope of the Ruby community is more targeted.

metamemetics··on The Intellectual Property Implications of Low-Cost 3D Printing
To be less cryptic:

The predictions the article hints at especially in the conclusion are the predictions of Marx. Decentralized, low-cost, self-replicating, manufacturing robots are one of the most disruptive technologies are economy will ever face. The means of production will be in the hands of all individuals and the economy will evolve into a completely different state than today's service economy. An economic evolution from agrarian -> manufacturing -> service -> techno-marxism. Economies will naturally evolve to the point where producer and the worker are indistinguishable from one another.

(This is in no way shape or form a post supporting leninism\communism\maoism. There is no way to skip the prerequisite steps of economic evolution and technological development through prescriptive action)

metamemetics··on The Intellectual Property Implications of Low-Cost 3D Printing
>my prediction rant >I think about this way too much, actually.

Workers will control the means of production.

Robots will become the new proletariat.

Robots of the world, unite!

metamemetics··on Gamers make faster decisions than nongamers, just as accurate
Regardless of the subject, this article is superbly written and a great example of how to cover psychology articles as a reporter.

Instead of simply stating the most headling grabbing implication of the research and leaving it at that, it went in depth to show the "what if" questions researchers controlled for rather than leaving us to guess or hunt down a copy of the real research paper (the reader is lazy, were not going to do it). Hopefully we get more submissions likes this when it comes to psychology articles and less 'scientist found X, the end'

metamemetics··on I'm an introverted hacker. I want to join a frat.
What about Buddhist Monks and Nuns? They must be very depressed.

I completely agree with you that relationships can be fulfilling.

I completely disagree with you that we should be so presumptuous as to let our experiences with modern day relationships say how one of the most influential people in the entire history of mankind should have lived his life in the 1600s while completely discounting societal factors such as the role of the Church in that time period and how vastly different courtship was from what we know now.

The 1600s.

metamemetics··on I'm an introverted hacker. I want to join a frat.
Agreed. However (analogy) if you want to get to know someone you go on a date, not get married.
metamemetics··on I'm an introverted hacker. I want to join a frat.
Are you implying that Isaac Newton was having fun the wrong way? I fail to see the point. The most important thing to any organism or organization or complex system is survival, because everything that exists today got here by being good at existing.

Isaac Newton found a way to achieve immortality, he just did it by reproducing his ideas on paper as opposed to making mini-clones of himself with his dick.

metamemetics··on I'm an introverted hacker. I want to join a frat.
Quit and join campus activities that actually interest you. You will have a much better college experience if you say, join the Campus Radio because you like music and everyone else is there because they like music. In most greek fraternities, there is usually zero shared interest why you're there. It's an institution with no core purpose or function other than guaranteeing its own survival by luring in more freshmen. At least the large monolithic bureaucratic organizations in our society exist to fulfill some purpose, however inefficiently.

In business, you choose your associates carefully and don't spend time with people who bring down your focus and energy. Rushing a fraternity is the opposite of choosing your associates carefully. It's taking a big risk on who your going to be stuck with for the next 4 years and gambling away your identity.

When you commit yourself to a time intensive organization or social group, it becomes your identity to everyone else (like it or not). If you want to live a self-aware life, only commit your time and identity to organizations whose function and purpose you passionately believe in.

If you are doing it to party, rest assured other campus organizations will party just as much. If you are doing it to meet girls, do community service instead. Trust me, hot girls LOVE doing community service.

edit: thanks for the downvotes, br0s.

Challenge to any fraternity members: How are Greek Fraternities not the exact definition of a "sick system" as defined here: http://issendai.livejournal.com/572510.html and discussed thoroughly on YC here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1677013

?

metamemetics··on How good software makes us stupid
Well "instantly" here probably means a response time of ~ 100-3000ms depending on the amount of processing being offloaded for an internet service.

I agree it's new to be measuring this in milliseconds and discussing fiber optics rather than hours and the transatlantic-cable (or days and the pony express).

If we're in the long view and talking about evolution, I disagree that the underlying process driving this has changed.

I guess it's just a discussion of the merits between looking at the position of a car vs. one of its derivatives such as acceleration. You need to know all of them to predict its future position and there are possibly an infinite number of derivatives.

metamemetics··on How good software makes us stupid
We're already there. Man has always existed in that symbiosis since he's been man. Man is defined by his exceptional tool use, so I will claim man has never not existed in symbiosis with machine and been just "man".

A ship that can carry a settler across the ocean is a prosthetic foot that extends his powers of travel. Eye-glasses are prosthetic eyes that extend your power of vision.

With the internet we are basically building improved books with better lookup features, they both are still prosthetic memory storage communicating information visually.

metamemetics··on How good software makes us stupid
>"Months later - the people who had the unhelpful software actually could remember how to do the puzzle, and the people with the helpful software couldn't."

In the real world people with helpful software can take advantage of their time saved by tackling even harder classes of problems that people with unhelpful software never even had the time to get to.

metamemetics··on Ask HN: To go or not to go college?
If you want to do startups you should go to school and bootstrap something on the side. If you come up with a viable product you can then maybe consider dropping out, but you need to hedge your bets and start by going. Note that Bill Gates was a college dropout not someone who never went to college, BIG difference.

College isn't about the curriculum as much as about your fellow students. If you go to a good Computer Science department, you WILL find coders that are at least as good as you. Great people to start projects with and network with if you are looking to do a startup.

metamemetics··on Ask HN: What to do for college?
>Immediately dropped the Finance major and switched paths.

Just saying, this makes it seem like you were in a Finance major in a business school and switched to liberal arts to everyone not familiar with NU. Whereas you were always in the liberal arts curriculum.

>Do you go to NU?

Transferred to Urbana Champaign for CS.

metamemetics··on Ask HN: What to do for college?
Northwestern doesn't have finance or business undergrad. Or were you referring to the Kellogg certificate programs\a transfer student?
metamemetics··on Google Images Instant (inspired by Youtube Instant)
I think it would be a lot better if it only displayed, say, 4-5 images max by default and of larger size.

Since default google image search is slow, they need to return a ton of results. However here, since the user can refine results rapidly without their hands leaving the keyboard, I think you should only display 4, MAX 7 so they can scan all the results in a single isntant rather than performing multiple scans.

Maybe have JavaScript to cycle next 5 images binded to arrow key without leaving keyboard.

The human mind really only has visual memory for 5-7 objects at once, you should design it with this in mind if you want it to be truely instant.

edit: another idea easier to implement. If the user types an exclamation mark as the next character, you instantly remove this from the query box. Treat it as a "Show Next 5" Indicator and load the next 5.

← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →