HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mhneu

1,420 karma · joined August 25, 2016

submissionscomments
mhneu··on Retrospective review of Gödel, Escher, Bach (1996) [pdf]
At lot to agree with here:

[Deep Blue] cannot answer elementary questions about chess such as “If a bishop is now on a black square, will it ever be on a white square?” ... All that it can do is to generate a next move of extraordinary quality.

But in a deeper sense, the match between Deep Blue and Kasparov proves that Hofstadter was profoundly right. ... It is precisely this power of abstracting, of stepping outside the game to a higher-level view, that enabled Kasparov to find where Deep Blue was weak and to exploit this to win his match.

Also, I strongly agree that the music/Bach connection in the book makes little sense.

The only aspect of the book that really does not work for me is the attempt to integrate music.

And there are some very interesting insights with benefit of 20 years of hindsight.

Today, open-source chess programs are better than the best humans. (they have been "trained" via a form of adversarial learning.)

And:

Part of this, of course, is nostalgia for the halcyon years of AI when the funding agencies had more money to throw around than there were researchers to take it, and the universities had more tenure-track slots than there were Ph.D’s to fill them;

Biden just announced a desire to DOUBLE American investment in R&D. Such an optimistic time we are at right now.

mhneu··on Secret Amazon Reports Expose the Company’s Surveillance of Employee Groups
“Dozens of leaked documents from Amazon’s Global Security Operations Center reveal the company’s reliance on Pinkerton operatives to spy on warehouse workers and the extensive monitoring of labor unions, environmental activists, and other social movements.”

From another Motherboard writer:

https://twitter.com/bigblackjacobin/status/13309270540832645...

“Amazon's Global Security Operations seems to surveil literally any environmental activism, labor organizing, or social movement in Europe. One notable instance: they hired Pinkertons to infilitrate a warehouse in Wroclaw, Poland and spy on workers and managers.”

——

As corporations grow in power, we have to worry about them surveilling, not just government surveillance — governments in democracies have oversight, privacy can be invaded by corporations with less oversight.

A bunch of interesting tidbits in the article.

mhneu··on Study reveals restoration of retinal and visual function following gene therapy
Yes, it is the low hanging fruit.

The risk is also mitigated because if the gene manipulation causes cancer, it should be relatively restricted to the eye, which can be removed in the worst case.

For a long time, gene therapy was shied away from because of an early case of oncogenesis with a lentiviral vector: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/cba7/d43412c1709861aea218e4...

mhneu··on Reading too much political news is bad for your well-being
The author, Arthur Brooks, is the past president of a Republican thinktank, AEI.

Republicans have a strong incentive to encourage citizens to ignore the political news, because their policies are deeply unpopular. Republicans rely on a non-engaged citizenry for votes.

Brooks is one of the Republican elites who shapes Republican political strategy. He has a deep conflict of interest when he tells you to stop reading about politics.

mhneu··on Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Netflix
But the FAANGs have a huge unfair advantage over startups - their size gives them monopoly power that disadvantages small companies.

That's a failure of American governance. Economists used to all know that markets needed to be regulated to make competition fair --- and efficient. But the American right has pushed for 50 years to deregulate everything, and the FAANGs have benefited from this rollback of anti-trust.

I'm not sure 'poaching' is the right word, but what the FAANGs are doing is unfair. And it's unfair because they benefit from deregulation and monopoly power that hurts anyone at a small business.

mhneu··on How I Make Yogurt (2019)
I find you can even make yogurt from slightly sour milk, just by adding a little baking soda.

Details: to make good yogurt you need to bring it to 85-90C, which denatures the milk proteins and improves thickening. If the milk is acidic, it will separate into curds and whey when heated. Sour milk is acidic, so adding a little baking soda to raise the pH allows you to heat the milk without separation. Then, during the later fermentation process, the pH falls again, and the yogurt is tart.

mhneu··on The death of corporate research labs
Hold on. Corporate research labs are _fundamentally different_ than academic research labs.

Why? Time horizon.

Companies will not fund research that has a more-than-20-year expected time to product. Usually, they won't fund things that will take more than 10 years to go from R&D to product. That's because of investment-- think about startups, what LP wants to put money in a fund for more than 20 years?

On the other hand, academic labs, funded by governments, often do work that pays off more than 20 years later. Think about Watson and Crick - their work on DNA in the 40s and 50s led to antibody drugs in the 1980s that are now being used widely today.

Bell Labs was the exception that tried to do long-term, basic research work, and its failure proves that corporate funding will eventually dry up for any long-term research. There's just no business case.

The US has the biggest tech and biotech economy in the world because the US government (that is, US citizens and US society) was smart to fund longterm basic research at the highest level in the world, building universities that attract some of the best talent in the world. Corporate research labs do more short-term work.

mhneu··on Chris Hughes, a Facebook Founder, Is Working With the Government to Break It Up
The problem with any new media is that wealthy interests quickly figure out how to use it to achieve their ends by manipulating public opinion. Happened with radio. With TV. Now with social media. It's a problem.
mhneu··on Brain Simulation Promised a Decade Ago Hasn't Succeeded
This is why the US NIH gives out a lot of $3-5M R01 grants.
mhneu··on CERN migrates to open-source technologies
Exactly. Labview is a mess anytime more than one person has to maintain a codebase. Source control tools are absolutely KEY to using any language for automation. Which mostly rules out Labview.

Do you have any more workshops/hackathons scheduled?

mhneu··on CERN migrates to open-source technologies
You seem to be making an argument based on what Microsoft says. But of course, what Microsoft says is not the reason for its decision.

Microsoft offers an academic discount because it thinks that getting students to use their products makes them more money as the students continue to use them later in life. Microsoft then SAYS they are offering that discount because students/degrees/training/teaching/whatever. What it SAYS doesn't matter. It's not the reason.

Similarly, Microsoft wants CERN to pay because it thinks it can make more money in licensing fees from CERN than it can from getting people at CERN familiar with Microsoft products. (Microsoft may have gotten this wrong, if CERN pushes more non-Microsoft products into the spotlight; whether they are wrong or right isn't at issue, their reasoning is the issue.) Once deciding they can make more money if CERN pays, now Microsoft has to come up with some reasonable-sounding reason that keeps its existing academic and industry customers happy.

So they came up with that reason. But don't think for a second the REAL reason has anything to do with anything but Microsoft's bottom line. Don't let them deceive you. This decision was made by executives at Microsoft by talking about profit.

mhneu··on GPUs a ‘Game Changer’ for Nuking Noise in Nuclear Imaging
This is just a way to calculate a statistical distribution over possible body structures given an image. If the image is bad, the estimates will be bad.

Hopefully the probabilities of error are carefully quantified.

Edit: speeding up the MC estimates of absorbed dose, etc, (i.e. speeding the treatment planning process) seems like a much more clear improvment.

mhneu··on Lyft Files for IPO
If Uber and Lyft prices go up 1.5x to 2x, that suddenly means that in cities, taxis undercut them.

I'll let someone chime in who understands the taxi business financials better. But in my observations, Uber and Lyft are only slightly cheaper than taxis. If prices go up, taxi companies will cut into their profits.

I'll also say we (as a society) are very lucky that Lyft emerged as a real competitor to Uber. If one of Lyft or Uber had failed a few years ago, we'd be in a total monopoly situation by now, and "Uber" would have similar meaning as "Kleenex" or "Scotch tape" -- that is, there's only one kind of smartphone ride hailing service and everyone uses it. Maybe that was the play of both Uber and Lyft all along -- stay alive long enough to force the other out and get to monopoly well before autonomous vehicles enter. And they failed. Both are still alive. There is no one firm with a monopoly.

mhneu··on Facebook Morale Takes a Tumble Along with Stock Price
"emergent features"

Yes, exactly.

Bigger picture: one problem with moving to give algorithms more control is that you can't always anticipate the behavior of algorithms. Especially when the algorithm is being targeted by an attacker. You need to predict not just best-case or average-case behavior, you need to know all the possible worst-case behaviors.

There's a direct analogy to computer security, where we have no answers to how to make systems hack-proof. Systems and algorithms are hard and we don't have a solution to prevent exploitation.

Humans are much harder to exploit. If Russia tries to get Ukrainians banned from an event by appealing to humans, that's much more attacker-resistent than when Russia gets Ukrainians banned from Facebook by exploiting an algorithm.

mhneu··on Alex Stamos: Asking tech companies to police hate speech is “a dangerous path”
The issue is that the wealthy and also foreign adversaries are exploiting the algorithms to amplify speech that serves their interests. That typically does not serve the interests of average people.

The issue is how to avoid exploitation and manipulation.

When the KKK marched several decades ago, it got coverage in newspapers and media proportional to its influence in society. Today, the wealthy and foreign opponents can weaponize hate speech like this to fan flames of division for their own purposes. That is the problem.

mhneu··on DarkPulsar
How the FISA Court Really Works (Lawfare) https://www.lawfareblog.com/how-fisa-court-really-works

Stanford law review https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/online/is-the-foreign-inte...

The win rate is misleading for a simple reason: The requests the FISC receives are not a random or representative sample of all cases in which the executive branch believes it would benefit from a warrant. The number and type of government requests are responsive to the level of oversight the court exercises—just as a plaintiff’s decision to litigate is responsive to changes in the law. Because it is costly to make an ex parte application (in time, resources, and reputation) and because the executive has long-running knowledge of how the FISC treats applications, there is little reason to expect agencies to submit losing requests. And while the rarity of ex parte proceedings might make this outcome seem unprecedented or extraordinary, other ex parte proceedings—like those for Title III wiretaps and delayed-notice warrants—display equally lopsided results: the government “wins” almost 100% of the time.

mhneu··on DarkPulsar
NSA disciplines employees who violate their rules on who gets to access data. https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/09/nsa-spi...

And senior congressional officials, including people like Feinstein, Grassley, Burr, Schiff, and Warner, are effectively briefed on all intelligence matters. Not every member of congress is. America did a decent job after Watergate implementing supervision of intel.

NSA is probably not perfect, but it's better than the alternative. You know the old quote "Democracy isn't a great way to govern but it's better than the alternatives" -- probably fair to say "Western intelligence agencies aren't perfect but they are the best way we know to navigate today's surveillance economy and secure democracies."

mhneu··on DarkPulsar
This is well-put.

I expected our AI overlords to be robots and talking computers.

I didn't expect AI to be a set of algorithms used to subtly manipulate peoples' thinking in such a way they don't even notice. Orwell would have had a field day with surveillance capitalism.

mhneu··on How Twitter poisoned politics
When new methods of communication arise, they will eventually be exploited by the powerful and the wealthy to achieve their ends.
mhneu··on What Made Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorem Hard to Prove
Do yourself a favor and just take discrete math 1 and read a few Wikipedia articles instead.

+100, exactly. I have some familiarity with mathematical logic, and with Bach (though admittedly I'm less familiar with Escher) and I found GEB to be unintuitive at best, and misleading at worst.

To be honest, there may not be anything really magic about Goedel's incompleteness theorem once you grasp the core concept, which is: If you encode all proofs into a formal language, you can make a statement that is true but unprovable. (Which is, effectively: "This statement has no proof"). Most of Goedel's work on the incompleteness theorem was on the systematization of proofs, which can be tedious to work through.

I found at the time Godel's completeness theorem to be more interesting. Though I never got into model theory or more advanced mathematical logic so, grain of salt.

mhneu··on No class action for unhappy Uber drivers: U.S. appeals court
Link to full opinion is here: http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2018/09/25/14...

Three-judge panel, 9th Circuit.

- Richard R. Clifton, authored opinion (app. GW Bush, Repub.)

- Richard C. Tallman (app. Bill Clinton, Repub- see wikipedia)

- Sandra S. Ikuta (app. GW Bush, Repub, Fed Soc member)

mhneu··on Google Scientist Resigns Over “Forfeiture of Our Values” in China
That is a false talking point. The approval rate of FISA warrants does not reflect the strength of oversight. Be careful. There is a lot of disinformation out there designed to discredit democracies.

Discussion of why this is false: https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/online/is-the-foreign-inte...

The win rate is misleading for a simple reason: The requests the FISC receives are not a random or representative sample of all cases in which the executive branch believes it would benefit from a warrant. The number and type of government requests are responsive to the level of oversight the court exercises—just as a plaintiff’s decision to litigate is responsive to changes in the law. Because it is costly to make an ex parte application (in time, resources, and reputation) and because the executive has long-running knowledge of how the FISC treats applications, there is little reason to expect agencies to submit losing requests. And while the rarity of ex parte proceedings might make this outcome seem unprecedented or extraordinary, other ex parte proceedings—like those for Title III wiretaps and delayed-notice warrants—display equally lopsided results: the government “wins” almost 100% of the time.

mhneu··on Google Scientist Resigns Over “Forfeiture of Our Values” in China
No. I too once thought that NSA and other Western intelligence agencies were doing things we should avoid. But then I learned the difference between democratic and autocratic regimes' use of data collection. In a word: rule of law. There are teams of judges that review surveillance applications. There are strong rules and laws to prevent misuse of data - NSA employees have been disciplined for violating the rules and reading data they are not supposed to. And in the West we vote for the leadership that supervises this effort - and the leadership changes. (we've had some election problems, yes - in part due to autocrats intervening in the West lately, but democracies are working to improve) It's not about people, it's about laws.

Autocratic countries don't have the same controls.

Also, in the influence campaigns autocracies have been running in the West, there's a ton of effort put into whataboutism - 'democracies do it too'. Be careful.

mhneu··on Evernote lost its CTO, CFO, CPO and HR head as it eyes another fundraise
Oy.

I use Evernote because of its excellent image markup. You can mix images and text in notes and really document an image-based or figure-based data flow. Not sure if there's any alternative that does this as well.

mhneu··on While the planet burns our politicians fiddle
Not sure but it’s important to remember that silence on issues like climate change benefits the status quo- the companies that wish to keep up the current situation. Avoiding conversations like this is the same as taking a side - the companies’ side. Too bad it’s not discussed more.
mhneu··on While the planet burns our politicians fiddle
There is a large domestic disinformation machine in the US. The disinformation media has for decades used identity politics to get Americans to vote for policies that benefit the 0.01%. Nowhere is this clearer than with climate change.

In my experience, many of those in the disinformation bubble have no idea that climate change denial benefits oil and gas companies and is heavily funded by them.

If you’re interested in disinformation and how it affects climate change policy, the book and movie Merchants of Doubt is really great- it explains some of the strategies used.

mhneu··on Google Public DNS turns 8.8.8.8 years old
Cory Doctorow on how surveillance capitalism harms you and harms societies. http://locusmag.com/2018/07/cory-doctorow-zucks-empire-of-oi...
mhneu··on Burying ‘One Child’ Limits, China Pushes Women to Have More Babies
Trump is closer to Mao than he is Obama - in Trump's corruption, attacks on the media, attacks on the educated and intellectuals, attacks on minorities, boosting of racial nationalism, and attempts to steal tax dollars and profit off his leadership role.

The parties in the US are wildly different - one party is the party of billionaires, and you can tell because they pursue tax cuts for the very rich and cutting the social safety net for everyone else.

mhneu··on Google Public DNS turns 8.8.8.8 years old
Threat model: "surveillance capitalism". Anyone in the ad business has a strong incentive to surveil you to sell or use the data.

That's a difference between Apple and Google - Apple is at least partially in the hardware business. Google is in the ad business - the surveillance business - full stop. And I say this as a fan of Google and someone who still uses their public DNS. But it's not surprising that people wonder how they use data.

https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2018/03/facebook_and_... But for every article about Facebook's creepy stalker behavior, thousands of other companies are breathing a collective sigh of relief that it's Facebook and not them in the spotlight. Because while Facebook is one of the biggest players in this space, there are thousands of other companies that spy on and manipulate us for profit.

Harvard Business School professor Shoshana Zuboff calls it "surveillance capitalism."

mhneu··on Google Public DNS turns 8.8.8.8 years old
I laughed.
← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →