HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaelkeenan

1,213 karma · joined June 9, 2008

michael.keenan@gmail.com

michaelkeenan.net

michaelkeenan.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
michaelkeenan··on Why Are Lawyers So Expensive Even With The Excess Supply Of Lawyers?
I'm sad that you've been downvoted, though I disagree with you.

Occupational licensing doesn't just improve service quality (if it improves service quality), it also increases the price. The result is often that instead of great quality, the consumer gets nothing at all because ze can't afford it. This hits the poorest people hardest. In the USA, the poor have a famously bad time with healthcare and legal advice.

There are mechanisms other than mandatory qualifications by which consumers can measure quality, including voluntary qualifications, reputation, and price signaling. These aren't perfect, but neither are mandatory qualifications. Each mechanism has advantages and disadvantages.

michaelkeenan··on Truth goggles sniff out suspicious sentences in news
I've dreamed about the possibilities for automated fact-checking to improve online debate, and considered attempting to write it myself (using data sources like Wolfram Alpha and Google Public Data, and parsing natural language with a big dirty pile of regular expressions, which can't be the best approach but it's an approach I could attempt in a weekend).

For example, a program could examine a text for sentences matching "[X country] is [comparison] than [Y country]" and check that against online data sources. So if you're typing a comment into reddit or wherever, it would first check your comment for claims it can parse, and alert you if you are mistaken about something so you can change it. And if you are correct about something, but didn't supply a citation, it could add it automatically.

This could have several awesome effects:

* It would make online debates more accurate, spreading truth and knowledge.

* It might set a standard of factual accuracy; people might come to expect assertions to be backed up with citations, and regard claims as suspicious if no supporting reference is provided.

* Just knowing their facts will be checked (possibly by a future version of the software being re-run on old forum comments and highlighting inaccuracies for all to see) might make people more careful in their assertions.

If voice recognition technology improves, then this might eventually fact-check TV in real-time.

michaelkeenan··on We now have an effective vaccine for Malaria
> The chance of getting the disease is also low, probably not substantially more than getting injured in an automobile crash.

Worldwide it was estimated in 2004 that 1.2 million people were killed and 50 million more were injured in motor vehicle collisions.[1]

It is estimated that malaria causes 250 million cases of fever and approximately one million deaths annually. [2]

If we focus on the 800 million people in Sub-Saharan Africa where 90% of malaria cases occur, a rough estimate would be:

If we assume that Africa's traffic accident rate is the same as the world rate (it's not - I see that it's higher when I examine a few countries in this table[3]), it would be 141,000 deaths from traffic accidents and more than 5.9 million injuries from traffic accidents. The world death rate from traffic accidents is 20.8. I'll arbitrarily pick Zimbabwe's 27.5 to be representative of the region so the numbers should be 32% higher. That would be 186,000 deaths and more than 7.8 million injuries.

Taking 90% of the world malaria numbers, there are 900,000 deaths and 30 million cases of fever from malaria in Sub-Saharan Africa.

So if you're one of the 800 million people in that region, you're 4.8 times more likely to die from malaria than a traffic accident and 3.8 times more likely to get a fever from malaria than be injured in a traffic accident.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_collision#Epidemiology

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaria#Epidemiology

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-re...

michaelkeenan··on Toxic Nectar Kills 90% of Mosquito Populations
> The world has a long history of famines that show we quite often bump up against Malthusian limits.

Famine isn't caused by a lack of resources - it's a political problem. 87 million people died of famine in the 20th century, but none of those were in democracies. Source (though I haven't checked the numbers myself): http://markhumphrys.com/end.war.html

michaelkeenan··on Why We Do Pushups
I'm not the OP, but my office has a similar ritual. Out of about eight people in the office, usually three to six of us go out to the patio to do pushups and sometimes martial arts at about 2pm each day.

Our strongest person does about 120 pushups in a row (he is really strong); the least strong does about 10; the least strong male does about 40. We try to beat our old personal records but there's not really any competition between people.

We haven't experienced the problems predicted by others in this thread. It's not explicitly a team-building activity - it's just something some of us do. It's not led by a manager, and managers participate somewhat less than non-managers. It's not mandatory and if people are engrossed in a task, they choose not to join in that day.

michaelkeenan··on Osama bin Laden Is Dead
If you think that Obama will be re-elected without a doubt, you should go to intrade.com and bet on it. Here's the contract, currently indicating a 69.9% chance of re-election: http://www.intrade.com/v4/markets/contract/?contractId=74347...
michaelkeenan··on Joel Spolsky is doing an IAmA on reddit
Yvain wrote about this on Less Wrong. He described a study that showed that people who had just done one good act were less likely to do another: http://lesswrong.com/lw/1d9/doing_your_good_deed_for_the_day...

"All those biases that lead people to give time and money and thought to causes that don't really merit them waste not only time and money, but an exhaustible supply of moral fiber"

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: What are your best life hacks?
I don't know if anyone can give a definitive answer, but various hypotheses and experiences were brought up in a discussion of monogamy and polyamory at Less Wrong here: http://lesswrong.com/lw/2ee/unknown_knowns_why_did_you_choos...
michaelkeenan··on Zenhabits
Are you sure that's false? The Wikipedia article on carbohydrates[1] says: "Carbohydrates are a common source of energy in living organisms, however, no carbohydrate is an essential nutrient in humans."

It cites a letter to the editor in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition by Dr Eric C. Westman[2].

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbohydrate#Nutrition

[2] http://www.ajcn.org/content/75/5/951.2.full

michaelkeenan··on Views from an Egyptian
> Fun fact: Egypt is our #3 recipient of foreign aid...The US government gives Egypt $1.5 Billion every year.

The US government gives Egypt foreign aid because that is part of the agreement of the 1979 Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty[1], when Egypt became the first Arab country to officially recognize Israel.

I don't know enough about the overall situation to have an opinion, but it does seem at least plausible to me that buying peace with foreign aid might be a good thing (albeit a distasteful moral-hazard-prone good thing).

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egypt%E2%80%93Israel_Peace_Trea...

michaelkeenan··on The world is socialist
An argument against an ideology's handling of a particular problem is useless unless it quotes and responds to a respectable proponent on that subject. There are plenty of Objectivists and libertarians who have written about the provision of public goods.

Winer should read PG on How To Disagree: http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

michaelkeenan··on Amazon Route 53 - A New DNS Service from AWS
Humans generally argue to seek truth or status or both. It's a disaster that status-seeking gets involved in the process of truth-seeking, and I wish that we all would recognize that and avoid it when we can (to the extent that we can). "Please, help yourself to the last word" strikes me as motivated by status competition.
michaelkeenan··on The best investment advice you'll never get
You probably have a breadth of knowledge that comes from reading sites like HN, but the problem of course is that most people get their investment advice from banks and other investment professionals.
michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
rrc didn't deserve your condescending reply. Many policies were once implemented in a racist way. That isn't an argument against implementing them in a non-racist way. If you want to argue that the next implementation of voter tests will also be racist, you have not made the case.
michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
But when monarchies work, they work so well! The richest (per capita) country in the world, Liechtenstein, is a monarchy. I think Qatar, also a monarchy, is second-richest, though that doesn't really count because it has so much oil.
michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
> I would argue, voting is another [responsibility].

What is your argument?

michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
> I'm also a little leery of anything coming out of the Cato Institute.

The link is to Cato Unbound, where they host an essay and discussion by outsiders to the Cato Institute. The participants aren't just libertarians; Matthew Yglesias had an essay not too long ago.

> I'd rather see the opinion peer-reviewed.

It isn't formal peer review, but there are reaction essays here: http://www.cato-unbound.org/archives/november-2006/

> The author's main point seems to be that just because some people can vote, doesn't mean that they should vote. What he doesn't address is why the noise from the uninformed doesn't cancel out...(at least in my skimming).

Caplan addresses it in the last three paragraphs under How Misconceptions Are Possible, but he's pressed for space in that essay. He wrote about book about this. You can also find his argument here (PDF link): http://mercatus.org/sites/default/files/publication/Straight...

michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
Bryan Caplan argues that in his field (economics), uninformed votes don't cancel each other out. The average opinions of the uninformed (non-economist laymen) differ consistently from the average opinions of the informed (professional economists): http://www.cato-unbound.org/2006/11/06/bryan-caplan/the-myth...

I wouldn't be surprised if the same were true of other skills useful to high-quality voting, such as military strategy, education, criminology and history.

michaelkeenan··on Remind HN: Vote
If you have an obligation to vote, then it's an obligation to make an informed vote. If you haven't attempted to evaluate your decision carefully and can't make an informed vote, please don't vote.

Informed voting > not voting > uninformed voting

Greg Mankiw has a column on this: http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2006/11/election-day-approach...

michaelkeenan··on Religious Outlier
Indonesia is also very corrupt (111th out of 180 in Transparency International's index, and I have encountered the police corruption there first-hand). I wonder whether the corruption might be so bad that people wouldn't report murder to the police, and so the official statistic might be lower than it should be?

The former anti-corruption chief of Indonesia was jailed earlier this year for conspiracy to murder. I could imagine that if he's not the only government official organizing murders, then that might not reliably be reported to the police.

(This is poorly-informed speculation and I wouldn't be surprised if some knowledgeable person writes a scathing correction. Better information would be appreciated.)

michaelkeenan··on No, You can't retire rich at 30 if you sell your startup
> Wages for most people have been stagnant or declining

Wage growth has been slower than you'd expect because healthcare is getting much more expensive, so the increase is hidden in a worker's benefits, rather than being revealed in higher wages. Overall compensation is increasing: http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2007/10...

Unfortunately, most workers don't realize that their healthcare costs have a zero-sum relationship to their wages. This graph shows that point very well: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2009/10/will_low...)

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: Tips for Hackers having Kids?
> Get a white noise generator of some kind. We have a 99-cent iPhone app on our phones that we use daily.

I really like the free website simplynoise.com for white noise. Specifically, I find their oscillating brown noise to be soothing.

michaelkeenan··on Discipline: Be The Machine
Some studies have found willpower to be a limited resource. It is often likened to a muscle, because using it depletes its power in the immediate-term, but regular exercise increases its strength in the long-term. Wikipedia article on this phenomenon: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion

The Wikipedia article is quite dry, however, and I suggest this readable NYTimes article instead: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/02/opinion/02aamodt.html

Or this one: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/12/06/how-to-boost-your-w...

That second NYTimes link mentions that the mechanism of willpower depletion might be glucose depletion. Drinking a sugary drink restores willpower. (This effect has also been shown to be true of the self-control of dogs: http://www.miller-mccune.com/health/dogs-offer-clues-to-self...)

Regulating your emotions also depletes willpower (http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2009-09/mu-rda092409.... but it doesn't go into detail on the regulating emotions part). I have observed that tolerating irritating people harms my productivity.

I warn that at least one study has failed to replicate the willpower depletion result: http://lesswrong.com/lw/1fe/antiakrasia_technique_structured...

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: How are you securing your laptops in public places?
Product idea: a USB device with an accelerometer. When you need to leave your laptop for a few minutes, you insert the USB device and start a program that plays a loud siren sound if the USB device reports movement, or if it's removed. Then you lock your screen the usual way.

Downside: if they power off the laptop or remove the battery, they can still take the laptop. Would a thief do that? I imagine they'd want to leave as quickly as possible so they'd just put the lid down, remove any USB devices, and go.

michaelkeenan··on Craig Venter: 'We Have Learned Nothing from the Genome'
I was curious about the disagreement over his predictions from 1998, so I looked it up. I don't think it reflects well on him.

Spiegel interview 2010:

SPIEGEL: The genome project has been called the Manhattan Project or Moon Landing of its era. It has also been said that knowledge of the genes will change the future of humanity and become a "main driver of the world economy."

Venter: Who said that? I didn't. That was the people at the consortium.

SPIEGEL: You're wrong. You made all those statements in an interview with DER SPIEGEL in 1998.

Venter: Really? Those are Francis Collins' lines. So I may have said that that's how he describes it. I, on the other hand, have always said, "This is a race from the starting line to the finish."

Spiegel interview 1998 (translated to German by Spiegel and back to English with Google Translate[1]):

SPIEGEL: What does the knowledge of the genetic material?

Venter: The End of Ignorance, a completely new understanding of the human body and a revolution in medicine. What we plan is there, of the order of the Manhattan Project or the moon flights. The decoding of the genome will change the self-image of humanity.

[1] http://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?hl=en&...

michaelkeenan··on Startup Country
I suppose I am assuming that the purpose of a discussion on HN is truth-seeking. If we are also enforcing social norms, then it makes sense to attack the status of those who propose offensive things.

Enforcing social norms must come at the expense of truth-seeking though, and I think truth-seeking is more important. Anyone can easily think of examples from history where offensive opinions turned out to be correct, and there are sure to be views today which are regarded as offensive and are also correct.

Paul Graham wrote about this in What You Can't Say: http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html

Edit: We have drifted from the original topic somewhat. The snarkiness I objected to wasn't calling out his opponent as offensive. It was just snarkiness.

michaelkeenan··on Startup Country
If a wakeup call drives a clueless person further into their clueless position, it's the last thing they need. What they need is a persuasive argument with an escape route where they can concede while losing minimal status.

It's difficult to see it from the other side. When we see a status attack favoring a position we agree with, it feels like a righteous smiting of the enemy. But it doesn't have the effect we intuitively think it does.

michaelkeenan··on Startup Country
The needless snarkiness ("Yeah. Sure. Keep telling yourself that...Here's a tip") detracts from this comment. It would be more persuasive without it, because when you include status-lowering attacks with your factual counter-arguments, your opponent can't agree with you without lowering zir status.
michaelkeenan··on Too many laws, too many prisoners
I used to believe, fervently and automatically, that democracy was the best system. Can you blame me? No-one in my society opposes democracy. No-one sane anyway.

In the last couple of years, I've encountered well-reasoned opposing views for the first time.

Let's back up, and consider how to get an effective x, where x is a cup of coffee or a laptop or anything else. One way might be to get everyone to vote on what kind of x they like, and then give that to everyone. This is of course a terrible system, and not Starbucks nor Apple have that kind of system.

Much better to have competition. I'd be terrible at making coffee or a laptop, and it's best that I'm not trusted to make those things, or to choose who would be good at making them. Nor ought I to be trusted with running a country or choosing who to run it.

So, I think an ideal world might be a world of many smaller governments, each competing for consumers/citizens. Apply the creativity and efficiency of startups to the governing industry. I want a world of Singapores and Hong Kongs and Liechtensteins, where I can pick my government provider approximately the same way I pick my ISP or my employer.

Of course there are problems. So solve them! What better decrepit, corrupt, monopolizing old industry to fix than the governing industry? A Peter Thiel-funded startup is trying (http://seasteading.org).

See also Arnold Kling on competitive government vs. democracy: http://smartdemocracy.com/papers/kling_competitive_governmen...

And also see the reading list at the Let A Thousand Nations Bloom blog: http://athousandnations.com/recommended/

michaelkeenan··on Ask HN: How can I recognize when I don't know what I'm talking about?
There's a distinction that I've seen people miss, which I'll describe by example. Suppose you don't know Lisp, but you've seen many respectable people such as Paul Graham and Steve Yegge describe how great Lisp is for metaprogramming. This doesn't mean that you know the fact "Lisp => great for metaprogramming"! What you know is the fact "Many respectable people think => 'Lisp => great for metaprogramming'". This is an important distinction! It means you probably shouldn't talk about Lisp and metaprogramming, and if you do talk, you should make sure that you deliver the right fact, i.e. "I've heard that Lisp is good for metaprogramming", not "Lisp is good for metaprogramming".

> What I fear is looking incredible.

I'd rather that you fear being incredible (which it appears you are).

A resource that helped me think much more precisely about what I know and the level of confidence I have in that is the rationalist writings of Eliezer Yudkowsky. You might like to check out the sequences: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Sequences

When what you know differs from what is real, you have a problem where your mental map does not match the actual territory. The most important sequence, Map And Territory, addresses that: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Map_and_Territory_%28sequence...

I also recommend to you the Reductionism sequence: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Reductionism_%28sequence%29

How often do you say "I don't know"? I think Voltaire was on to something when he wrote: "He must be very ignorant, for he answers every question he is asked."

← PreviousPage 5 of 9Next →