HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

musgravepeter

866 karma · joined May 8, 2013

submissionscomments
musgravepeter··on Physics Simulations
Take a look at SageManifolds: https://hyperspace.uni-frankfurt.de/2017/01/20/sagemanifolds...

My understanding is the numerical GR community is moving in this direction. The theory people tend to roll their own inside of Mathematica or Maple. Some Maple users use GRTensorIII (https://github.com/grtensor/grtensor)

Disclaimer: I am a co-creator of GRTensorIII

musgravepeter··on Physics Simulations
This might be of interest for spacetime modeling: https://arxiv.org/abs/1712.07658
musgravepeter··on New periodic orbits of the three-body problem
The close encounters will cause issues even in integrators more sophisticated than Euler. One body of research used regularizing integrators to change variables when the bodies get close, to avoid numerical instabilities.

This integrator is used in my three body app, to remove the issues due to close encounters. An old blog post of mine has the details: http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/2015/12/08/threebody-2-0/

musgravepeter··on New periodic orbits of the three-body problem
Yes, that does work. In the literature this is called a "heirarchical system"

The very simplest version is called the Euler problem. Two fixed masses and a third moving in the "dipole field". All the solutions can be explicitly determined (although only in terms of e.g. Jacobi elliptic functions and other elliptics). There's a book "Integrable Systems in Celestial Mechanics" by Mathuna.

I recently added the Euler problem to my iOS app ThreeBody: https://appadvice.com/app/threebody-lite/951920756

Some day I'll get around to adding these 600 solutions...

musgravepeter··on New periodic orbits of the three-body problem
With some symmetry you can find a couple of solutions, which is what Laplace and Lagrange did. e.g. http://www.phys.lsu.edu/faculty/gonzalez/Teaching/Phys7221/T...

The scholarpedia article is a good meta-reference:http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Three_body_problem

musgravepeter··on New periodic orbits of the three-body problem
The pre-print from arxiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.00527v4
musgravepeter··on Professors’ unprofessional programs have created a new profession
I did a project like this to get three body physics for an iOS/Android app Three Body. (http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/2015/12/). Converting Fortran from 1973 into C# for Unity. This code (only 1000 or so lines) is very dense.

I also cleaned up my own mess from 1996, when I recently re-released a General Relativity package for Maple, GRTensorIII (https://github.com/grtensor/grtensor) that was part of my PhD work. The 1996 code is not that tragic, but is far from my best work - although I did earn my PhD.

musgravepeter··on Ask HN: What are your favorite physics sites, documentaries, books?
http://theoreticalminimum.com/

Lectures by Susskind for people who know (or have forgotten) some calculus and always wanted to know more about physics.

musgravepeter··on I don’t wanna be a developer anymore
"I’m the master now. Yes that sounds arrogant and I don’t think I’m going to add that word to my LinkedIn,"

Sometime a change in language helps to soften a word with too many associations: software guru ?

musgravepeter··on Lecture Notes on General Relativity (1997)
That book looks very interesting. Thanks for the tip.
musgravepeter··on Lecture Notes on General Relativity (1997)
Entirely on the side. I ended up in telecom SW but always tried to putter away on physics-based side projects (e.g. Geodesic Asteroids and Three Body apps on iOS, Android).

In playing with geodesic equations I tried to use GRTensorII on my Mac and decided it was time to update it (my former supervisor & external examiner were very keen!). This lead me to work through "Relativists Toolkit" - doing all the problems - using GRTensor where I could. I'm now planning to spend a vacation week at the Atlantic GR conference and give a talk on GRIII. My hobbies tend to get a bit out of control!

Some of this is blogged about on http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/

musgravepeter··on Lecture Notes on General Relativity (1997)
I found Carroll's book excellent (the notes seems very similar).

As the author of a tool for GR calculations (grtensor on github) I've been collecting intro GR books. I did my PhD in GR 20 years ago and am getting back into it. My impressions so far:

Carroll is excellent.

Hartle is also great - very physics first approach.

Stephani - Good intro with some material not found in others

Shutz (the book I used in grad school) - solid intro

MTW looks great on the book shelf, very useful every time I dip into it, a bit daunting to go front to back

Zee - looks interesting, I'm only on p10

Wald - I seldom pull this off the shelf.

As a second book, I highly recommend Poisson "A relativists toolkit".

Another great resource is "Exact space-times in Einstein's General Relativity" (Griffiths and Podolsky)

musgravepeter··on Over 150 new families of Newtonian periodic planar three-body orbits
Guess I have some work to do to update my mobile app Three Body! (It presents galleries of solutions up to those found in 2013, and lets you explore your own initial placements)

iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/threebody-lite/id951920756?m... Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nbodyphysi...

The authors of the new solutions have published all the initial conditions - so hopefully it won't be too hard. (Although they use an 8th order RK integrator and the one I have is a regularizing Bulirsch-Stoer integrator).

musgravepeter··on Robert M. Pirsig has died
Easily the book I have re-read the most times.
musgravepeter··on If the Moon Were Only 1 Pixel – A tediously accurate map of the solar system
If you go to http://www.astro.princeton.edu/universe/ you can find print-outs of the entire universe all the way to the microwave background (log scale).

They're very cool.

musgravepeter··on To Live Your Best Life, Do Mathematics
To me the key point is "no clear answers" in philosophy.

In math you learn to follow a series of developments, building structure that leads to statements that are true. These are the foundation for more bricks in the wall and even bigger constructions. e.g. The proof of Fermat's last theorem.

My sense of philosophy - after reading maybe a dozen of the classics, was there was little that was accepted as true. Yes, there are self-consistent chains of reasoning but the foundation blocks are more a matter of "taste", and the amount of rigor in the chains varied - complicated by the fact that human language is inherently not very precise.

musgravepeter··on Fake Physics
I find that a bit mis-leading. While IAAP, this is not my area.

My understanding is the at the big bang there are a HUGE number of universes (the Multiverse) that are causally dis-connected, with different coupling constants for the forces and very different physics. Within our universe we have our physics, which includes QM, and one way of viewing QM is the many-worlds view.

musgravepeter··on Fake Physics
I don't think there is any intent to be misleading.

I agree that reading this blog by itself is jumping into the middle of the conversation, and terms are not explained. The multi-verse has been discussed there for years, so occasional readers may assume it is the many-worlds stuff, but it is a very different beast.

musgravepeter··on Physicists taking jobs as Silicon Valley software engineers
Depending on what "being a physicist" means, I did. Went from EE undergrad to physics PhD. Then worked in s/w but still tinker on physics projects on the side.

GRTensorIII (https://gitlab.com/grtensor/grtensor/wikis/home)

An iOS/Android app for Three Body simulations (Three Body) and a Unity gravity simulator (Gravity Engine).

I would have loved to make a living wage in physics but the post-doc path is badly paid.

musgravepeter··on The firewall transformation for black holes and some of its implications
"It boils down to a single “new physics” ingredient in black hole physics as soon as quantum effects are being considered: from now on, when quantised particles and fields are considered, only those general coordinate transformations are permitted that map space and time continuously, and they must be one-to-one,"

ISTM the argument hinges on the idea that conventional co-ordinates for a black hole are one-to-two (i.e. two "normal space" regions in a Penrose diagram) and this is the source of the quantum state paradox/firewall issue.

musgravepeter··on Spikey Spheres
Fun.

I love that weird intuition trap you mention - the volume of a N dimensional sphere of radius R sphere goes to zero as N -> infinity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volume_of_an_n-ball

musgravepeter··on What Math Do You Need for Physics?
(long)

Thanks for the interest. It is quite an odd career trajectory.

I was torn about physics vs engineering when I went into undergrad - and the advice I got was one led to more certain income - so engineering it was. However, I always felt I had missed out on "cool stuff". After working for two years, my wife decided to go back to grad school in Kingston (2 hours away) - after a year of long-distance marriage and frugal living, I quit and took a year of random physics courses (basically third year physics). I managed to get a summer job with a GR prof, who wanted me to write some Maple code - this became an an early version of grtensor.

At this point I had finagled a spot in the Master's program at Queen's, but my wife was accepted into a Phd at McGill/Montreal - so we went there. I took another term of undergrad courses (4th year phys) and found a prof who needed a student who could code - and I was accepted in the Master's program at McGill doing experimental particle physics linked to an experiment at Fermilab.

After a year at McGill, spouse decided her supervisor was not doing the work she thought and she wanted to head back to Queen's. I scrambled to finish my MSc and then went to Queen's to start a PhD in general relativity.

In a weird "Forest Gump" moment - the time at McGill attached to the CDF experiment at Fermilab means that my name is one of the 500+ names on the paper announcing the discovery of the top quark.

At Queen's I studied GR and astrophysics, leveraging my coding ability into making tools GR researchers use to this day. After the PhD, we had a young family and didn't like the look of the post-doc grind and the constant moving/low-pay that it entailed, so went off into the high-tech world.

I've spent 20+ years in hi-tech s/w. Joined yet another startup two years ago. It's still really fun. Thinking about physics is also really fun - so I try and keep a stream of physics-y side projects on the go.

Maple has since evolved and GRTensorII has gotten stale. One prof has been staying on an old version of Maple since he relies on GRTensor - worrying that when his computer dies he would have to stop using it. I figured it was time for a fix up. This is what I am doing now. I recently took a "sabbatical week" to jump start the exercise. Hopefully it will be public by the end of the year.

There is some background on how I have approached the math in a blog post I wrote last year: http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/2015/02/28/learn-physics-with-t...

For me the take away is something Scott Adams once wrote about. Either 1. Become the best at one specific thing. 2. Become very good (top 25%) at two or more things. (http://dilbertblog.typepad.com/the_dilbert_blog/2007/07/care...)

I chose (2) and it allows me to wander through both engineering and physics.

musgravepeter··on What Math Do You Need for Physics?
I did math in the wrong order. I first was "exposed to it" as an engineer undergrad - didn't care at all (just wanted to code) and barely passed eng. math.

After working for two years, went back and did undergrad physics courses (including math for phys) and started to "get it".

Then went on to a PhD in general relativity - which is a LOT of math. I went back to software and most of it leaked away.

I am now trying to get it back (20 years later) - as I resurrect a Maple package for GR, grtensor, which I co-wrote as part of my PhD. Curved space is a beautiful thing.

Penrose's recent book reminded me of his wonderful "The Road to Reality: - which is a great tour of math leading into physics.

musgravepeter··on New theory of gravity might explain dark matter
And there's http://xkcd.com/1758/

Although getting out the business of "mysterious stuff we can't detect" is very appealing, I'm reminded that the neutrino once had that status...

musgravepeter··on Orbiter Space Flight Simulator 2016 Edition
The Kepler equation solver is the standard Newton iteration, which is ok until e gets larger. The actual N-body simulator in gravity engine allows for better orbits and the integrator is configurable (Hermite, Leapfrog) and easy to extend. Colwells book has LOTS on this subject too (https://www.willbell.com/MATH/mc12.htm)

There are about 20 GE users so far, so it seems somewhat "niche". Offering an asset forces me to think a lot more about usability and documentation. I have recently added support for any solar system object and real world units - with tunable scaling. Not things I would have done if I was not making it an Asset. It's gratifying to get some uptake and the people who use it seem to like it.

If you like Three Body stuff, checkout my iOS/Android three body app. LOTS of solutions to explore. (https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/threebody-lite/id951920756?m... or https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nbodyphysi...)

musgravepeter··on Orbiter Space Flight Simulator 2016 Edition
I'm a big fan of orbiting problems. There are some cool references on your gitlab - I'll need to dig through them sometime.

Now some of my "tooting":

I did a quick JS Kepler evolver (http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/2016/05/29/planetary-orbits-in-...) and some very funky regularizing integration for the three body problem (http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/threebodyv2/).

Lots more side projects queued up - latest is a Unity Asset, Gravity Engine.

Under "hugely ambitious" is trying to grok http://www.cds.caltech.edu/~marsden/volume/missiondesign/KoL... and do real three-body trajectories.

musgravepeter··on The 2016 Nobel Prize in Physics
Can anyone recommend a "cannonical" textbook that describes K-T transitions at an upper-year undergraduate level?
musgravepeter··on Bogdanov affair
In some ill-defined dual space of a Bogdanov manifold there is the Sokal affair: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair
musgravepeter··on Struggles with the Continuum
Together with "There are no particles, only fields" (https://arxiv.org/abs/1204.4616) at the top of my web reading list.
musgravepeter··on Great Trail FAQ
There is some great info at http://www.ridethetrail.ca/. Many parts of the trail are on roads or have ATV access - which is not ideal for those who prefer human powered locomotion.

A cross-Canada trail is an awesome goal - but the reality is we have a very long way to go.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →