HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mwsherman

3,607 karma · joined July 21, 2009

https://clipperhouse.com/
submissionscomments
mwsherman··on Never trust a corporation to do a library’s job
This is a good example of narrative trumping reality, and we geeks are every bit as susceptible as anyone else.

The actual thesis of the article is that Google is losing interest in archiving efforts. Perhaps true, perhaps partially true, perhaps false, or perhaps unsupported either way. Entirely valid and worth exploring.

The second thesis is that the Internet Archive is doing good work. Great!

The title, however, is “Never trust a corporation to do a library’s job”. A generalization which no article can prove or disprove. Just dogma.

Why must we make these leaps?

mwsherman··on Groot Programming Language
It doesn’t have generics.
mwsherman··on In surprise FCC filing, Sprint endorses net neutrality
Sprint understands that it hurts their competitors more than themselves. NN is unlikely to be strong on the mobile side, and Sprint has little in the way of consumer wireline business. Verizon and AT&T have more substantial wireline businesses.

Similar to Walmart supporting a higher minimum wage. Hurts the other guys more. And a nice bit of PR.

mwsherman··on Why We Still Believe in Private Offices
An important point is that focusing on online tools (instead of in-person encounters) improves communication. Everyone is on equal footing in terms of being exposed to conversations.

In-person conversations, while arguably higher-bandwidth, are only shared by the participants. You had to have been there.

mwsherman··on FCC chairman tips his hand on net neutrality
They are foreseeable. This sort of regulation ensures that only big players (incumbents) will play, because it tilts advantage to those with better lobbyists. http://clipperhouse.com/2010/02/22/net-neutrality-and-preser...
mwsherman··on Exempting popular apps from data charges is anti-competitive
This article seems to equate two things – that which is true today, and that which the writer imagines for the future. The future is not fact.

The fact of zero rating is that it is beneficial to consumers, and progressive – the poorer one is, the more zero-rating is likely to help. That is factual, observable, measurable.

The speculation is a slippery-slope argument, and not factual. That doesn’t mean it’s wrong, but simply that it’s a priori.

Zero-rating is free shipping. I don’t know of anyone that considers free shipping anti-competitive, though one could make the same argument.

mwsherman··on StackExchange System Architecture
It’s not a secret exactly, obvs it has a public URL. It’s quietly been there for a couple of months.

We kinda wanted to have a 2.0 version of the page with live data before promoting it. This one is static with #’s we sampled at the time.

mwsherman··on Problems with the Golang runtime and toolchain
So much ad hominem – arguing of motives for designs and decisions. It makes for an odd contrast of technical opinions and unsupported speculation.
mwsherman··on Google got it wrong. The open-office trend is destroying the workplace
Why must editors title articles this way?

The article says: there are many ways in which open offices are not great.

The headline says: they are destroying the workplace.

The article doesn’t come close to making that claim, even if “destroy the workplace” were a meaningful idea.

mwsherman··on Theater Chains Decline to Show Sony’s ‘The Interview,’ Citing Threats
Seems like a good opportunity to route around the damage: release it ASAP on iTunes, Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, YouTube, perhaps for free.
mwsherman··on Uber pressures regulators by mobilizing riders and hiring vast lobbying network
You have to compare that to the non-availability of cabs. Is 5x more fair than a cab that you can’t get for any price?

An elderly, disabled, or injured person is poorly served by unavailable services.

mwsherman··on The failed economics of our software commons and what to do about it
Asking why popular software isn’t well funded is backwards. The question is, why is underfunded software popular?

Lots of under- and unfunded software is of poor quality and is ignored. Why is some of it (like OpenSSL) not ignored?

I don’t even think there is a market argument here, it’s much more pedestrian: a lot of people, based on social proof, use OpenSSL – which, short of becoming a crypto expert oneself, is entirely reasonable.

mwsherman··on The Cable Model and the Internet Model
Net neutrality is the cable model. It locks in local monopolies, aka, utilities.

I find Fred uncharacteristically confused on this. We have local monopolies because cable (and phone) were built according to a utility model. Net neutrality is the legal reification of the utility model.

mwsherman··on Go is moving to GitHub
I’m concerned that it won’t get any stars.
mwsherman··on The Pierre Omidyar Insurgency
I come away from this thinking that Omidyar doesn’t have any particular expertise or insight about running a journalism startup. He seems like a dilletante, trying to improve the world perhaps, but mostly trying to live an interesting life. Which is fine but not a recipe for success.

He’d be more effective either as a foundation giving grants to worthy journalists, or as a VC of same.

mwsherman··on Go 1.4 Beta 1 is released
I just saw David Crawshaw do a demo of a “full Go” program on Android, a 3D gopher rendered and rotatable by touch. I don’t claim to understand the details but, if I understand correctly, Go was handling the whole thing – touch events and OpenGL – without depending on interop with Java APIs.
mwsherman··on “We will sell you this microwave under the following conditions”
For what it’s worth, I make a point of calling it out. Here’s a bad one: https://twitter.com/clipperhouse/status/515206521723318273

Maybe if we make a habit of it, it’ll help a little bit. I think most devs say “give me all the permissions” out of expediency, and most users say OK for the same reason.

Is there such thing as graceful degradation here? If I say yes to Location, but no to Contacts, the app should still function but the bits that need the Contacts would be unavailable.

Or, it asks for those permissions when, and only when, it needs them.

mwsherman··on Amazon Takes a Big Step Toward Making Its Own Deliveries
I’d like to see an analysis of how close a carrier needs to be to feasibly do the last mile delivery. How far is the typical Fedex delivery from its points-of-presence? How many POP’s does Fedex have?

How many people are within reasonable last-mile distance of an Amazon POP?

mwsherman··on Generation Later, Poor Are Still Rare at Elite Colleges
Computer engineering is probably a special case. It’s easier to demonstrate skills independent of credentials. Eg, a prominent open-source project or successful app likely proves employability as much as a degree.

It’s also true that the value of an elite education decays with time. The studies I’ve seen (someone help me with a cite) seem to indicate that after 10 years, choice of school has very little predictive power for one’s career success.

I think elite schools probably are helpful for elite engineering positions. One would expect a compsci degree from, say, Carnegie Mellon if hiring for, say, compilers or chip design or operating systems. But even then, successful work outside of university can trump the credential.

mwsherman··on Wikipedia Zero and Net Neutrality: Protecting the Internet as a Public Space
Net neutrality is a very confused idea. Once one tries to define a testable law, it becomes a lot less desirable.

Since I started paying attention, the definition has changed from “QoS on the last mile” to “slowing certain protocols” to “blocking competitive services” to “blocking any services” to “not building enough capacity” to “fast lanes that aren’t CDNs” to “throttling any user” to “paying for interconnect”.

In the Wikipedia case above, it’s clearly a violation of NN and it’s clearly good for consumers. It’s a very progressive policy, I support it – and it’s not neutral.

The justification Wikimedia offers here is that they are serving the community and are not exchanging $$ with the ISP. Is this part of the definition now? And if so, do we want to start defining which sites we feel serve the community?

mwsherman··on State Laws That Stop Cities From Installing Fast Internet
Are these laws any more onerous than the ones the private providers must respect?

I don’t dispute that they are anti-competitive, but I wonder these are laws (or similar) are also the reason there is not private-sector competition. Would like to see original sources, and comparisons.

Remember, most cable and phone systems were designed by municipalities as monopolies, which is what got us here today. They were seen as utilities.

mwsherman··on StackOverflow Update: 560M Pageviews a Month, 25 Servers
As with most systems, the data store is the hard thing to scale out. That requires intelligence at the application level, and that might include CAP issues.

So for us, the SQL data store is the real “up” part of the equation. We have a fair amount of headroom there, so if we can keep sharding (and other data strategies) out of the codebase, so much the better.

(Load-balancing HTTP requests “out” is not a big deal and we are doing that.)

mwsherman··on Underscore.go
Yes, but gen is more general for type-driven code generation. It’s implemented as pluggable ‘typewriters’, which anyone can create: https://github.com/clipperhouse/gen/blob/master/CHANGELOG.md

The default ‘genwriter’ package does LINQ/underscore stuff. If someone wanted to go further with it, they could create a new package (or extend that one).

mwsherman··on We Don't Need A Corporate Income Tax
Despite the title, the real thrust of the piece is that regulations – taxes, here – are inputs into a complex system. The more complex, the less predictable and the more likely to have unintended consequences. Or, perhaps, “intended” consequences which benefit certain participants over others.

We think that of regulations as rules of the road, or adding fairness, or enhancing transparency. And they might! But those assumptions are, often, insufficient models and at worst, dangerously incorrect.

mwsherman··on Comcast Comments on FCC's Proposed Rules
Comcast is supporting having their competitors being bound by net neutrality. Comcast already is, due to the terms of the NBC merger. So they want their competitors to “suffer” similarly.

And they don’t want mobile to impinge on the fixed-line market, so they support NN in mobile, too.

A good analogy is WalMart supporting a minimum wage. They support it because it hurts their competitors (local Mom & Pops) more. [1]

Remember regulation isn’t “rules of the road”. It’s an input into a complex system.

[1] http://clipperhouse.com/2010/02/22/net-neutrality-and-preser...

mwsherman··on Developer inequality and the technical debt crisis
Yes. This is the essential description of the situation.

Or, put more empirically, if the web is terrible, why did it succeed by orders of magnitude over what preceded it?

I have fantasies, like every other dev, of controlled, predictable, statically verifiable, friendly, elegant, safe systems that also reach billions of people, with instant distribution, nominal cost, and low barrier to entry. Maybe these things are not (a posteriori) compatible.

We used to call this “rich vs reach”. Still seems true, perhaps essentially so.

mwsherman··on The IPO is dying – Marc Andreessen explains why
In this case, the ‘millions of humans’ essentially received the doctors’ foregone salary. They got a raise, in the sense that their healthcare got cheaper.

We can give them $1000 cash, or we can charge them $1000 less for the healthcare they buy. Same thing.

So, in a sense, money became less important in the acquisition of healthcare. Purchasing power increased.

This is why I make the distinction between money and economic value. The latter is the real goal.

mwsherman··on The IPO is dying – Marc Andreessen explains why
We might consider what we mean by wealth and concentration. If we mean money, perhaps. If we mean economic benefit, perhaps not.

In a previous HN thread, we considered the possibility of medicine becoming automated, imagining that (say) 80% of doctors’ labor is replaced by machines.

In this case, the monetary earnings of many doctors will go away, and those earnings will instead go to a small number of technology companies who make the products that obviated them. That feels like concentration.

If this happens, it also happens that medicine will have become dramatically cheaper, and therefore more available to a greater number of people. Thousands of doctors lose while millions of humans win. This feels like egalitarian distribution.

So perhaps we’d call these technology companies ‘oligarchs’, yet economic (not monetary) gains have gone to a much broader set of people than before – anyone who consumes medical service.

If there are several such technology companies, they will compete, reduce prices and increase the widely-distributed consumer surplus. This can happen simultaneously with their CEOs (oligarchs) getting inordinately wealthy.

mwsherman··on Welcome To Extremistan, Please Check Your Career At The Door
If (e.g.) doctors are automated out of a job, it will mean that health care has become dramatically cheaper, which is a widely distributed rise in living standards. This is more egalitarian, not less.

Thousands of doctors lose and millions of humans win.

Remember, economics is not about the distribution of money, it’s about the distribution of valuable things. In this example, health care is the valuable thing and its distribution seems greatly improved.

mwsherman··on Airbnb Is a Risky Neighbor
Why would a lender be troubled by this? The property, due to a new source of income, is worth more. Seems like more income = less risk from the lender’s point of view.
← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →