HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

natroniks

74 karma · joined April 28, 2015

submissionscomments
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
Do you believe a child should have the power to decide what happens to their body even at a young age? What if a 6 year old wants to get a permanent tattoo? Or a middle schooler wants a subcutaneous horn implanted on the forehead to look cool? Or a toddler refuses medical treatment? I doubt that's what you mean.

Maybe you mean a parent and child should decide together? I don't think a child has the capacity to make, or even weigh in on, decisions. Not just a newborn, even older children (most anyway) would have a difficult time making big decisions like if they should have a body part altered by surgical operation. Is it your position to postpone all non-emergency decisions regarding bodily alterations until the person is old enough to decide for themselves what happens to their body? If so, that doesn't seem practical. If you mean something else, please go on

natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
> The whole point of circumcision is to control the actions of the person later in life.

How so? According to Judaism, the whole point of circumcision is to bear the mark of the promise between God and Abraham. But if you ask me, a modern non-orthodox Jew, circumcision is a rite of passage just like Communion, or Bar Mitzvahs, or any other non-natural step in growing up. It's different for everyone and no one has asked me why it is important. But I think that's really what it comes down to, Circumcision in Judaism is a physical and indelible representation of our belonging to a community whose practices have shifted and adapted over the millennia. One of the very few practices that is described in the Torah and is also carried out today is the brit milah. So, it's carrying on tradition. It is a connection (membership?) to a rather diverse group of people. It transcends geography and time, culture and language. It may be arbitrary - maybe Jews could've figured out another way to achieve all this. But I still don't understand the harm caused by circumcision. At least, no more harm than is caused by a huge number of medical procedures all types of kids may undergo as minors.

natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
Is it ok to have your 12 year old's teeth pulled? Is it ok to get your toddler's fremulum removed? I can argue that the very idea that the body should remain intact is itself steeped in religiosity. The belief that the body we start with, we should end with, is tied to the idea of Resurrection and the Last Judgment.

> Somehow we all agree that female mutilation is horrible, but when it comes to boys it's controversial

FGM is something that affects their body's function. What is the function of the male foreskin? What malfunction arises after circumcision?

natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
> Yes, the foreskin doesn't grow back Lip and tongue ties don't grow back. Neither do teeth. Parents remove their kids' body parts if they think it's best for them. Are straight teeth healthy or just aesthetically pleasing? Is clear speech healthy or just valued in our culture?

> Yes, because travelling through the birth canal is required to live, and doesn't affect sex in later life. Also, it doesn't result in any amputations. How does circumcision affect sex in later life? If circumcision is amputation, what is removing an unsightly birthmark? Or as I've said, teeth, extra skin in one's mouth...

> We do. There's a ton of nerve endings there. Slicing of a particularly sensitive area (due to the concentration of nerve endings there) is going to be painful. Being birthed causes extreme trauma. That's why doctors measure a baby's oxygen and heart rate. So clearly some amount of pain is worth it if the gain outweighs the pain, no? Then you have to ask what is gained through ritual circumcision. The gain is religious and cultural value, so it's hard to measure precisely. But, you know, Christians give alcohol to kids every Sunday and no one's complaining.

> If you want to do it, you need to show some evidence that it is not, not throw your hands in the air and say "well, we don't know").

I'm suggesting that we consider not everything that seems obvious is in fact obvious. Should I keep my kid from having routine blood drawn or vaccination because the needle hurts? Stop clipping their nails or cutting their hair? These are all cultural practices, there's nothing intrinsically good about grooming in this way.

> I think your are deluding yourself - few doctors visits or trips to the park results in cutting off a very sensitive part of the body. I am trying not to delude myself. I am trying to clarify one thing for myself and one thing for others. For others, I want them to understand oral suction during a bris is basically unheard of outside of a fringe group. For myself, I'm trying to clarify if circumcision results in long term pain (psychological or physical)

> It is a fairly easy topic.

I think we agree. As I said, it should be easy to talk about and yet there are multiple factors one must weigh. This makes it compicated, but I'm happy we're talking about it.

> The question of "Should we amputate a part of a newborns body, one that affects future enjoyment, and known to be incredibly sensitive" is an easy one to answer.

I think the question is based on a false premise. How can one measure the joy of sex, and even if you could how would you say "this person gets less out of sex than if he had his foreskin." How can you say what the same person would feel in a hypothetical scenario? I'll just point out this very argument dates back to antiquity. Plutarch has a piece about Jews and discusses ritual circumcision - iirc he takes the stance that circumcision leads to more sexual activity and depravity because the penis is always uncovered. Greeks and Romans thought uncircumcised penises were vulgar, gross, and a sign of overt sexuality. So I would be fascinated to understand the opposite position, which you put forth, that circumcised men get less joy from sex.

natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
There are medical procedures parents must decide to pursue or not, many are voluntary. Should I get my toddler's fremulum snipped even if there's no guarantee it helps their speech? Should teeth be extracted to help straighten out other teeth even if it results in weeks of pain? Are you saying that straight teeth are of more value than religious identity? There are many hard choices a parent must make; I think circumcision is singled out because it bears cultural and religious value but no clear medical value. So let's get down to the core of this discussion: ritual circumcision bears religious and cultural value and that's pretty much it. So long as it's done safely, of course. If you want to debate the biological merits of circumcision, you're missing the religious or cultural value. > What is the downside of leaving it until the age of 18 when they can decide to get it done if they want? My understanding is that if you wait until 18, the procedure is much more involved/more difficult, more in terms of pain and in terms of health risk. Judaism puts health above all other factors, whether it's driving to seek medical attention on shabbat, or not increasing the risk of infection in newborns. Oral suction goes against the highest Jewish principle. If circumcision caused harm - bodily or psychologically - Jews (or most would not practice it. I'm not sure I understand the physical or psychical harm done
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
Not all mohels use the pipette, but what make you think using a sterile glass instrument is less hygienic than using one's mouth? And again you say both practices are widely defended. Who is defending oral suction outside of this fringe enclave of Ultra Orthodox Jews?
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
I think my gripe is the same as all racist comments. Applying something that's true for a small subset to the whole group. If you want to be specific about what type of Jews support this practice, it's a very specific community of Ultra Orthodox Jews. I tend to fall on the side of all extremism being bad, so if someone wants to say the most extreme practitioners of a given religion are bad, then that's fine. But one should not don't talk about Jews as a whole when it is but a small subset within the Ultra Orthodox community.
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
The only community that practices this archaic ritual is in NYC, so I'm not sure the specificity matters in this case. Let me also point out that the community is estimated to comprise 250K, "many" though not all of whom practice this. Avoiding granularity, there are approximately 7 million Jews in the US, which means this 250K community represents roughly 4% of all Jews. Given that (from what I gather) all examples of the practice are contained within this enclave, calling it "commonplace" is a mischaracterization at best. It is a practice held by a very small group within the broader community, which means calling this commonplace for Judaism is inaccurate. This is at most commonplace within a fringe group. My conclusion would be that outside of this fringe group, this method is not practiced by Jews at all.
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
PS this says (estimates) 3600 children a year. That's 3600 too many, but far from "common place" in my understanding of the term. I can't predict how many Jewish males are born each year, but if someone wants to provide that, I'd be curious to know what portion these 3600 represents.
natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
I have googled it, nothing I've read describes it as common or main stream. Many describe it as being performed only within a very small segment of the ultra orthodox community. I haven't found a place with reliable stats, which is unfortunate, but here is a paragraph with a recent and prety clear comment from a leading Jewish authority https://www.thehastingscenter.org/ritual-circumcision-ban-me...

Most mohels, even among the Orthodox, do use a sterile pipette, avoiding direct oral-genital contact. In 2005, the Rabbinical Council of America, the main union of modern Orthodox rabbis, issued a statement urging the abandonment of direct suction. Rabbi Moshe Tendler, a medical ethicist and dean of Yeshiva University’s (Orthodox) rabbinical school, was quoted in The JewishDaily Forward as saying: “There is no requirement to make metzitzah b’peh. The Talmud says plainly it is not part of the ritual but belongs to the medical, post-surgical component. There is no doubt that insistence on metzitzah b’peh is wrong. I firmly believe that making metzitzah b’pehis a criminal act.”

Do you have sources showing this practice is commonly accepted?

natroniks··on Infants' sense of pain is recognized, finally (1987)
I'm a circumcised male who has decided to have all 3 male children circumcised. As a Jew, if I may weigh on this, you have my background for an conflicts or biases. Also, maybe content warning is in order for genital mutiliation.

1) It is absolutely not common practice to allow a mohel to orally suck the blood out of an infant's penis. If it's practiced at all, it is only in extremely fringe groups of Jews, not just orthodox or ultra orthodox but a very small group, truly some hundreds of people, practice it. I don't have the data, probably no one does, but saying Jewish circumcisions involve this would be like suggesting all baptisms look like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aFGHerqhSC8 To call metzitzah b'peh common practice, or at all part of ritual circumcision, is an anti-semitic trope. Comparing a key tenet of Judaism to a cult is both simplistic and demeaning.

2) I grappled with the decision to have brises for my sons. I don't think it's possible to know or define how traumatic such a procedure is; is it worse than giving a 6-month old pierced ears? Is it worse than travelling through the birth canal and having your umbilical cord severed? Who knows. As obvious as it may seem, the pain of a bris impossible to gauge. My sons all began crying as soon as their diaper came off, and their crying was no more intense once the cutting occurred. By the way, it's not like they make a dotted line with marker and snip around the foreskin; whatI witnessed involved a metal device (a type of clamp I suppose) that is slid between the shaft and foreskin, and like a modified cigar cutter, the mohel cuts away the foreskin in one motion. There's a lot of discomfort, maybe pain, but as a father of 3, I assure you every doctor's visit and many trips to the park involve similar levels of harm.

3) I realize mohels are not doctors, but there are mohel academies that train and certify these specialists. To say they are not doctors is one thing (and it's true), but to say they are not medically trained is another. They don't go to medical school but they learn about the biology of the procedure, proper methods, proper tools (including sterilization), post-op treatment & care, etc.

It's not an easy topic, but I don't think it should be hard to talk about. Complicated or interesting to describe, maybe hard to judge or rationalize, but let's talk about it openly, let's avoid disparagement, and most of all let's bring some nuance to this conversation.

natroniks··on Musk SEC Filing
Thanks for contributing to my comment with further information. I find it odd (in an unconvincing sort of way) that Musk's only complaint has to do with a company-defined metric, as opposed to something like "revenue" or "cash flow" that is standardized. Twitter can define mdau's any way they choose such that, if they wanted, they could draw up the definition in order to end up with a 5% number.
natroniks··on Musk SEC Filing
I too don't know why Twitter or the press doesn't make this metric more apparent. But I will say, if Musk didn't know about this change, then he already is what he's long aspired to be: a space cadet.
natroniks··on Musk SEC Filing
It is prudent to check all facts when negotiating an acquisition. The time to do this was before agreeing to the acquisition. I would also argue the way he's doing it is wrong, but I'm not a hardball negotiator so maybe publicly venting is right. I think it is important that we all distinguish between DAU and MDAU when debating what the likely number is. Frankly, I do not understand why it matters. Musk bought the company based on the idea that it is undervalued: 1) he wants to move away from ads and 2) he wants to grow the user base. If it turns out there are fewer "real" users on the platform than previously thought, isn't that bullish for the prospect of adding more users? I find Musk's tactics to be abhorrent, but I'm looking beyond tactics at the core argument: I do not think it's clearly bad if it turned out Twitter had fewer than expected users when his case is that he can add more users. So long as they didn't fudge the money numbers - earnings and revenue - I don't see how this metric is considered material enough to break the deal.
natroniks··on Musk SEC Filing
This may have been pointed out elsewhere, but the questions surrounding the % of users that are bots/spam accounts was addressed by Twitter about 3 years ago. In early 2019, Twitter stopped reporting overall user numbers and instead offered the alternative metric "monetizable daily active users." Without saying it outright, the difference between dau and mdau is bots/spam accounts. Many articles discussed this massive change, which happened THREE YEARS AGO. Here is one such article: https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/twitter-reports-anothe... Q1 2019 was the only quarterly report I can find that included both total users and monetizable users. If we take the difference as representing bots etc, then we can see in the linked article that about 60% of overall Twitter users were not monetizable, ie, 60% of Twitter accounts were bot/spam accounts. So, this is all in the public record. Doubting how much of Twitter's overall accounts are bots - which is what Elon is pursuing - is massively different from Twitter standing by its claim that only 5% of MDAUs are bots. Elon seems to be talking about DAUs and Twitter only reports MDAUs. This distinction seems to be lost on most people following this debate. I think both parties could be offering accurate assessments: Elon could be right that over half of Twitter's users are fake, and Twitter could be right that only 5% of the MDAUs are fake. While both could be right in their assertions, Elon is in the wrong in the big picture. All of this has been disclosed publicly and Twitter never claims that only 5% of users are bots, just 5% of monetizable users. Elon's claims of malfeasance or obfuscation are wrong.
natroniks··on Why are letters shaped the way they are?
Ancient Greek and Latin letters ultimately go back to a Semitic alphabet. Any meaning of the names and shapes of letters must go back to Proto-Semitic eg Aleph looked like an oxhead and means ox; Bet (originally) looked like and means House. This is akin to if the first letter of our system were called apple and looked like an apple and produced the short "a" sound; The sound "b" was represented by a letter that looked like and was called banana; etc. Greek (and others) adopted the letter shapes and kept the names (Aleph=>Alpha, Bet=>Beta, Gimel=>Gamma, etc) even though Alpha Beta etc bear no meaning in Ancient Greek outside of the letter name. More importantly Greek (and others) adapted the letter shapes (graphemes) to fit their letter sounds (phonemes). For instance, ancient (and modern) Semitic alphabets do not include vowels. Ancient Greek really needed to write vowels. Semitic used glottal stops that Ancient Greek didn't. So, Ancient Greek took the letters of unused sounds (like Aleph, which was originally not the vowel "a" but a glottal stop not used in Ancient Greek) and attributed a vowel sound to it. After appropriating the breathy sound of Het to the long "A" sound of Eta, and a few other vowels, Greek still needed more. So they invented Omicron and Omega, which are just self-explanatory names of "small (ie short) o" and "big (ie long) O." Likewise Upsilon and Epsilon (psilon in Greek means naked/plain; so "plain uh" and "plain eh") All of this is to say that the meanings attributed to Greek or Roman or Etruscan letter shapes in those respective languages were appointed after the fact. To get at the original meaning of these letter shapes, one must refer to its Semitic origins. If interested, one may read what Theo Vennemann has to say about how the Futhark Runes may reflect a direct adoption of the Semitic alphabet by Germanic peoples rather than the more commonly held belief that Germanic tribes got the alphabet from Greeks, Etruscans and Italians.
natroniks··on Roman slaveowners were the first management theorists?
I’m no Toner but I hold a MA in Classics. I also have a management position in finance. Let me give 2 observations of the Ancient Roman world that counters two of Toner’s underlying assumptions. First, as with an leader, Romans needed to act in different ways depending on the circumstance. Caesar would eventually elevate himself above not just his own troops but all people as “Divus Caesar.” However, that came much later towards the end of his life. At the pinnacle of his military career, slutty Caesar was jeered as “every man’s girl and every woman’s boy.” And I suspect his well-known inspiration from Alexander the Great taught him the humility to eat and train alongside his troops to boost morale, as the old King of Macedon had famously done. Therefore, a Roman leader was not always trying distinguish his own behaviors from those of his followers, at least not in a way that demeaned the latter. The second issue I find troubling is his generalizing of slaves’ lives and their owners’ treatment of them. The relationship of slave vs owner was not only different across locations, but also through time. The nature of slavery at Rome developed from being mostly the capture of regional enemies, to becoming a trans-Mediterranean industry in the Middle Republic (2nd century BC). Slaves could range from a farm hand born into slavery who had to suffer wearing an iron collar like a beast of burden (“The Zoninus Collar and the Archaeology of Slavery by Jennifer Trimble 2016); to a freshly enslaved Greek scholar who lived alongside a leading Roman and had great influence on that family (Polybius in the household of the Scipios); to a more run of the mill urban slave who may have had a constructive relationship with their master (consider Tiro, who by all counts was born into slavery, and became a most valued member of Cicero’s household and was ultimately freed upon his owner’s untimely death). All of these may be exceptional cases, and yet they are vastly different from one another. Most important of all, it’s unclear that any of these slaves’ lives would fit Toner’s paradigm. Oh, actually, I have a third issue. Nowhere does Toner mention women. This in spite of the fact that women were as often as not put In in charge of managing the household’s affairs. They would also be in charge of various businesses, such as brickyards. Both at home and at work, women would have led slaves; and this means that Toner is blind to the differing managing skills between the two genders. This is something we see today in a world where men and women are thought of in a far more egalitarian way than even the most progressive of periods of Ancient Rome. Meaning, I suspect that if we can observe differences in leadership and management skills between men and women at a time when the two are on par, I would love to consider the differences observed back then when the two genders were considered practically different species. Overall, this article has some serious omissions on both sides he's arguing (ie regarding the history of Roman slavery and the tactics of a modern manager)
natroniks··on Why did we wait so long for the bicycle?
I completely agree with you, slaves were a major cultural and economic motivation behind technological innovation (or lack thereof). Consider the aforementioned example of the cotton gin, which used rather simple tech to replace slaves. This device was only invented when slavery became legally dubious. If Romans (or Greeks, or Egyptians, or the Chinese, etc) of antiquity could have opened their eyes beyond the use of slavery as a source of power, technological innovation would almost certainly have improved
natroniks··on How badly are we being ripped off on eyewear? Former industry execs tell all
eyebuydirect.com
natroniks··on Dennis M. Hope Has Owned the Moon Since 1980 Because He Says So
This guy bases his claims on the following "So I went to the library, looked up the 1968 Outer Space Treaty and, sure enough, Article 2 states: "No nation by appropriation shall have sovereignty or control over any of the satellite bodies." Meaning it was unowned land" Later in this scheme, learn, "In 2001, I had 163,000 emails from customers asking me that. The conclusion we came to was to set up a democratic republic nation called the "Galactic Government." It took us three years to write the constitution and we put it online in March 2004, when we had 3.7 million property owners and 173,562 votes for ratification. So now we’re a fully constitutionally ratified sovereign nation." So, first he says, it's cool because sovereign nations cannot stake a claim. But after decades of selling property, he formed a sovereign nation that claims ownership on the property he sold. Does this not strike everyone as contradictory and makes all claims of this Galactic Republic as null and void?
natroniks··on 'Bizarre' Jurassic dinosaur discovered in Chile
I always find it odd that generalizations can be made such as "[this] was the most abundant animal to be found 145 million years ago" when it is based on so infinitesimal a fraction of the evidence. Perhaps this article is simply missing the bulk of the data, but it strikes me as odd that a corner of the Andes could be accurately representative of the world so very, very long ago.
natroniks··on Why Hispanic-Americans live longer: A mystery that has puzzled researchers
I'm probably being naive here, but aren't Asian countries' low mortality levels recognized as a result of their diets? If there is one staple one could point to as being shared between Hispanics and Asians, must that staple be rice? I just wonder if the choice of main starch - which is consumed so commonly across cultures - distinguished Hispanic Americans from other Americans, who are more likely to rely on corn or wheat as their staple starch.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2