HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

navinsylvester

1,427 karma · joined January 18, 2012

submissionscomments
navinsylvester··on Scaling long-running autonomous coding
all these focus on long running agents without focussing on core restructure is baffling. the immediate need is to break down complex tasks into smaller ones and single shot them with some amount of parallelism. imo - we need an opinionated system but with human in the middle and then think about dreamy next steps. we need to focus on groundedness first instead of worrying about agent conjuring something from thin air. the decision to leap frog into automated long running agents is quite baffling.

boys are trying to single shot a browser when a moderate complex task can derail a repo. there’s no good amount of info which might be deliberate but from what i can pick, their value add was “distributed computing and organisational design” but that too they simplified. i agree that simplicity is always the first option but flat filesystem structure without standards will not work. period.

navinsylvester··on Jules, our asynchronous coding agent
I subscribed to ultra to give deep think a try but i will not extend it even a day for all the other packaging put together by someone who might be working for a competitor. Who does these things and the fragmentation is crazy as mentioned. Chinese deep agents may be entrenched(just kidding), its crazy that someone up the ladder is so off point and not worry about losing his job.
navinsylvester··on AI assisted search-based research works now
Ironically, https://context7.com/
navinsylvester··on Open source AI is the path forward
Here you go - https://github.com/apple/corenet
navinsylvester··on Show HN: Unstract(AGPL) – Launch LLM-powered APIs to structure unstructured docs
This looks promising. I'm looking forward to exploring this further and seeing its practical applications in streamlining document-related workflows. It's always refreshing to see new solutions emerge that potentially shift how we approach common challenges.
navinsylvester··on Google to Invest $10B in India
Why would China try these postures when the opposite country is neck deep in handling a pandemic and one which originated from its land. Is this any time for a bloody battle or power trips?. May be there is more to it than the reasoning you mentioned. Internal frictions are starting to get visible against premier due to the way he handled the covid and how much repair it has caused China globally. May be he is trying to do all this antics to shore up nationalism and create a new problem/diversion which makes covid related ones to take a back seat.

> India doesn't stand a chance in an actual conflict

If its a full blown war then may be yes. But two nuclear powers going all out and all alone will not happen so others will step in. It would complicate things for China. Ideally it should be conventional and a very short one. The rules for engagement can't be escalated, that means China has to work with severe geographic disadvantages.

navinsylvester··on iOS14 reveals that TikTok may snoop clipboard contents every few keystrokes
Chinese investment money is everywhere so they try to control the narrative. I have seen for sometime that on HN, we are open to criticize but don't take a standpoint unless its something to do with western government.

I think this is due to the flame war or rating system of HN, where active discussions are relegated to oblivion. Instead of trusting biased and funded media - we here need to introspect, without us being silenced.

May be we are mostly left so we don't have a much stronger opinion unless its right - is that the case?. Just curious - why the slack?.

navinsylvester··on Hello, World – Zerodha, India's largest stock broker
Spot on.

If yours is a small team and if many things are keeping your team busy - never address a technical debt head on until you can afford the luxury or until the business demands warrant for it. Most engineering team focus too much on technical elegance and go overboard. Rewrite culture can become nasty if unchecked.

navinsylvester··on Mistakes That Kill Startups (2006)
> 7. Choosing the Wrong Platform

> But there is a trick you could use if you're not a programmer: visit a top computer science department and see what they use in research projects

Please don't shoot yourself with this suggestion. From my personal experience Academia is so distant from what is relevant or practical to the industry.

navinsylvester··on Covid-19 is now officially a pandemic, WHO says
How do we keep up with something like covid-19 in future?. I don’t think relying on government is the way to go.

Why not build a social network which helps to build close knit communities and it can have a cascade effect on the whole populace as a side effect("good"). Some of the key points for it to work being:

    # Pool resources before hand so that the whole system is not suffocated.
    # Internal resources exposed to close knit.
    # External resources exposed to a radius.
    # Cap on internal vs external resources.
    # Split the community into smaller ones when it reaches a proportion.
    # Point system to motivate communities.
    # Ability to mobilize resource across communities.
This need not be the case with just a pandemic but can help us tide over other eventualities as well.
navinsylvester··on Covid-19 is now officially a pandemic, WHO says
I don't see any tech solutions mentioned out here. At least i would like to take a shot.

Not relying on government is the way to go.

I think we should build a social network for community welfare which can prepare us for something like this in future. Where people build communities among themselves. Key point being internal resource availability to be exposed to the close knit network and an external pool exposed to an radius. Keeping everything to the close knit shouldn't be encouraged and there should be a proportion. Ideally the network should be split when its crossing a proportion.

navinsylvester··on Metaflow, Netflix's Python framework for data science, is now open source
> using the Metaflow's built-in S3 client, you can pull over 10Gbps, which is more than you can get with e.g. aws CLI today easily

Can you please explain how you were able to better the performance of aws cli.

navinsylvester··on It took 12 weeks to ship an MVP I thought would take 3
Its hard to estimate without breaking it down to smaller tasks and this process is laborious. This process assumes we are tackling stuff in which we already have expertise.

The rule of thumb i use - anything which takes more than 3 days needs to be broken down further into tasks. If any task takes more than 3 days during execution then it needs to be broken down to more tasks.

navinsylvester··on My Favourite Git Commit
I use the following convention to start the subject of commit(posted by someone in a similar HN thread):

    Add = Create a capability e.g. feature, test, dependency.

    Cut = Remove a capability e.g. feature, test, dependency.

    Fix = Fix an issue e.g. bug, typo, accident, misstatement.

    Bump = Increase the version of something e.g. dependency.

    Make = Change the build process, or tooling, or infra.

    Start = Begin doing something; e.g. create a feature flag.

    Stop = End doing something; e.g. remove a feature flag.

    Refactor = A code change that MUST be just a refactoring.

    Reformat = Refactor of formatting, e.g. omit whitespace.

    Optimize = Refactor of performance, e.g. speed up code.

    Document = Refactor of documentation, e.g. help files.
navinsylvester··on Linux Pressure Stall Information (PSI) by Example
Ubercool.

Wasn't aware of PSI - thanks to the author. The load avg alerts are mostly late to our liking but tooling around this should really help.

navinsylvester··on Lessons we learned when debugging a scaling problem
I could have worded it better like "why packet inspection to start with".
navinsylvester··on Lessons we learned when debugging a scaling problem
Fair enough.

But wouldn't doing investigation on the error provide data point to help debug the issue. They are trying to fix a customer issue and time is also of importance here.

> just applying fixes blindly plucked from the Internet.

I wasn't recommending that.

navinsylvester··on Lessons we learned when debugging a scaling problem
Interesting read.

But i bumped into the same problem recently while working on distributed simulation. I was writing an agent for an application which talks to clients over ssh. I started getting the same error when i cranked up machine count to 60.

I googled like every layman and zeroed in on MaxStartups. Looked at the manual to cross verify and fixed the issue in 5 minutes. I agree with what ever he did after he found out the issue but it was a clear case of SSH throwing an error. Why not just look up manual or google instead of wasting time on laborious packet inspection.

navinsylvester··on What Does a Coder Do If They Can't Type?
I was thinking along these lines. Wish i had time but good that you have made considerable progress.

My motivation was different though. I wanted to break barrier to code, make cleaner/efficient/consistent code, automated tests ingestion and for the ability to port code to other languages from metadata. If you could focus also on those lines too - it would be useful for the general community too.

navinsylvester··on Linux Observability with BPF
> I'm really interested in using it to monitor for file modifications in the way that inotify is not very good

Totally agree. Have had horrible experiences with inotify. I was able to modify https://github.com/iovisor/bcc/blob/master/tools/filelife.py and get a good alternative to find new files.

It still isn't polished and haven't tested it enough so will release it back to community when its ready for beta.

navinsylvester··on Languages of India
I can say for sure - the right wing government want to impose a common identity across the nation which is a very bad idea.

Not just the languages - we have vast differences but find unity in diversity. Inclusiveness is what makes India tick. As a Tamilian i don't think we will ever allow Hindi to be enforced on us. But our first Identity is more of an Indian than a Tamilian. India is quite a fabric and we should cherish the diversity.

navinsylvester··on Show HN: ZeroHTTPd: A web server to teach Linux performance, with benchmarks
Very insightful article. Thanks for putting it together. Looking forward to an update with io_uring.
navinsylvester··on All Chromebooks will also be Linux laptops going forward
I wanted to try chrome os a month or so back with android and linux support enabled but had hell of a time. Google seems to be very restrictive on where they get to run with all goodies. Google chromebook partners weren't even allowing experimental features to be tried on their platform so had to pick an Intel NUC to have the freedom.

It all worked out fine with fyde os(chrome os flavor by a chinese company recently acquired by neverware) but with some tinkering to reset language to English and to disable fyde os sync/login with google.

I have stopped using chrome due to privacy concerns and would never use chrome os with a google login. It was just an engineers itch to see how i can break free from restrictive hardware platform and get it working.

navinsylvester··on “Lambda and serverless is one of the worst forms of proprietary lock-in” (2017)
Agree that time to market shouldn't be impeded by any unnecessary engineering.

But pick a vendor and go all-in can work for netflix'y big companies or ones with static assets on cloud. All cloud providers have their own rough edges and if you get stuck in one you might be losing your business edge. Case in point - not going to name the provider since we are partners with them, we found a provision bug - custom windows image based vm took 15 minutes to get provisioned and also exporting custom image across regions has rigid size restrictions. The provider acknowledged the bugs but they are not going to address it in this quarter but if we are netflix big - may be they could have addressed it sooner.

We have automated the cluster deployment so we can get our clusters up and running in most major cloud providers. We are careful not to be tied to vendor lock-in as much as possible since business edge cannot be compromised based on this big cloud providers, who only heed to your cry only if you are big and they care none what so ever for your business impediment. When you are expecting cloud resources which aren't going to be static - you need flexibility so the above recommendation doesn't suit all.

navinsylvester··on What we've learned about hiring engineering managers
May be the non-technical manager thing works for big companies but it might not be the case with the rest.

The problem i have seen with most non-technical managers is that they tend to crave for recognition from the tech people they manage and somehow think they can prove their worth by micro managing.

Better to have a technical manager who has better people management skills.

navinsylvester··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
With regard to crazy work hours, our platform is used by lot of VFX studios and freelancers. From our frequent interaction with them, we observed that the amount of work hours they put in are really insane.

Its the same story but unlike game developers they get into that grind very often too. I don't think this scenario is unique to game developers alone and it exists in other domains - most prevalent when artistic expectation gets mingled with technology.

navinsylvester··on Wine 4.0 released
I think Wine and Samba played a pivotal role in Linux adoption to those who are in someway tied to Windows land.

Of all the memories with Wine, the best one is still how Red Alert 2 worked flawlessly.

navinsylvester··on How to Find Hidden Cameras and Spy Gear
You can do basic detection via mobile app itself and they are surprisingly good. I know they can't replace dedicated gadgets but for most it should be enough and convenient.

On android i use Ultimate EMF Detector PRO and Hidden Camera(PRO version). These should help you to detect electro magnetic field emanating from devices and infrared camera. Be very careful while selecting the app since there are lot of similar apps in the market from shady looking companies.

navinsylvester··on How to teach Git
No one is appreciating the effort and a different take here. Let me congratulate the author on job well done.

There are people who love illustrated explanation and for those these are perfect. This is just meant as a template which others can use to build the illustrated material and in no way a comprehensive git tutorial.

navinsylvester··on Startup Playbook (2015)
Look forward to the re-write and part II.

Can you please provide a glimpse of what you want to address in the re-write.

Page 1 of 4Next →