HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

neosat

662 karma · joined January 5, 2016

submissionscomments
neosat··on Snapchat Seeks to Raise as Much as $4B in IPO
"Their Spectacles release has the potential to build the largest real world image dataset on the planet" With Google (and now Uber) cars driving around numerous places to capture data specifically for map imagery, satellite imagery and Android/iOS phones taking tons of photos + videos I highly doubt Snap will be the one to build the world's largest image dataset. The rest of your argument makes sense though.
neosat··on Ecuador acknowledges it has "temporarily restricted" Assange's communications
So you would rather that all people (not just you) have less information for making a a massive decision that will influence the future of the country for 4 years?
neosat··on Ask HN: Good books or articles on UI design?
If you can read only one book read About Face 2.0 You can find a somewhat better about most of the topics mentioned there that go into more depth into individual topics (except maybe the core of interaction design) but About Face 2.0 will give you a solid foundation into design applied to interfaces.
neosat··on Facebook, Amazon, Google, IBM and Microsoft Create Partnership on AI
Technology is broader than just software (though I'm not implying you said it is just software). Apple is a phenomenal technology company - their hardware + software integration is unmatched and they have made advances in everything from software to hardware to supply chain optimization to manufacturing technology.

Also, they are ( or at least were) a prime example of a company that can bet on high risk, longish term investments that don't have an immediate application : e.g. their investment in chips, touch technology etc. It may not be as long term as some of the Google X stuff but I don't think it is fair to call them averse to making high risk long term investments.

neosat··on Uber launches flat fares in San Francisco through subscription
>> i.e. I could build "the Uber for when you want to go out on a date and impress someone in the car" as an overlay service.

There is a service for that. It's called Uber Black.

neosat··on Looks Can Kill: The Deadly Results of Flawed Design
> "why change what works?"

To make it better. And then to make it even better :) Isn't that what a significant amount of engineering and design endeavor is about?

neosat··on Looks Can Kill: The Deadly Results of Flawed Design
Some comments here completely miss the key point of the article and instead go down the route of whether the shifter itself should change or not.

The blunder (and yes, it is a blunder and not only in hindsight) in the shifter is that it provides poor feedback to the human. While changing technology may render some types of control not necessary, and thus correctly invite new design thinking, the fundamental human need for feedback does not change. In fact, when something that is so habitual to you changes, that is precisely when the design should provide even more feedback because otherwise you are likely to miss it. This is amplified if the consequences of not comprehending ones actions are high - which clearly was the case here.

The designers here dropped the ball. There is no way early feedback through rigorous testing on prototypes would have not identified this issue way before it went into production.

neosat··on Human or Machine: Can You Tell Who Wrote These Poems?
I got this one wrong. I thought no way a computer would be so dumb to have drawer and then drawers in the next sentence and this was a trick question to get one to say machine. Guess I overestimated the algorithm !
neosat··on Microsoft to acquire LinkedIn for $26B
HR managed services are certainly one big opportunity here as are leveraging Microsoft's B2B connections - however those are just the layer of utility services they can build over a massive 'corporate directory + network' and a feed. The opening up of that directory across companies could be huge and expand the potential competition to far more than just Oracle, Salesforce and IBM (to things like FB for Work, Slack etc.)

More thoughts on that here: https://medium.com/@ux/will-linkedin-and-microsofts-new-play...

neosat··on Study of non-programmers' solutions to programming problems [pdf]
"Would you design mathematical notations based on the opinion of 5th graders?"

Haven't read the entire paper but...learning from something doesn't mean you need to design something 'based' on that.

The advantage of studying how people unfamiliar with a specific way to solve problems will solve that problem is actually a great technique to try to understand common patterns and approaches humans think about problem solving.

Some pattern solving strategies will be more successful than others and it is worth understanding what is common to those (especially when compared to the unsuccessful ones)

Identifying patterns in the way people solve these problems can prove to be great design insights that go into the design of problem-solving solutions for those problems.

neosat··on Python Exercises for Kids
That matches a lot of my experience. I created a bunch of those lines floating on the screen which never failed to impress classmates who didn't frequent the computer lab and were stuck doing "write a program to calculate compound interest".

My neatest trick at that point was to make a 'fake' pre-loader where the progress bar showed a fake percentage with a cool graphic. My next 'impress project' was build a menu in QBasic where you could use the arrow keys on the keyboard to graphically move the highlighter on a menu. Almost everyone else at that time was doing menu selection pressing the number of the menu item. At that point I thought of it myself since there wasn't any internet in our lab so I still feel really good about it :) It also got me a spot on our school programming team primarily because no one else did the menu as quickly as I could then.

I'd like to think that I'm an interaction designer today partly because of the feedback and enjoyment I got out of doing projects like that.

neosat··on Himalayan villages that grow cannabis
I'm from one of such Himalayan villages, though I only seldom go back there now.

One important aspect to consider here is people don't necessarily think of it as illegal or a drug. There isn't really 'police' enforcing anything for the local. The local police station has like 1-2 people who pretty much just hang out and are friends with the locals.

Everyone in the village knows each other (sort of) and it is only the adult (males) that will have access to and make it. Teens and children don't really do it because someone or the other will find out and then they are in trouble, so the system corrects itself pretty quickly. I've never heard of a single case ever of overdose or anything like, though it has ruined the productivity and general health of a very large number of people.

neosat··on Good Design
The article feels ...well 'obvious'... but without any real insights into what good design really is. It's a little bit like saying "What's a good investment" - One that makes you money. Or "What's good code" One that doesn't have bugs. It tell you something that's obviously true, but there isn't much you can do with the info.

Compare that with a nugget of wisdom from Charles Eames - someone who actually built things that designers can look upto. Humble, to the point and not obvious but insightful.

Is there a design ethic? There are always design constraints and these usually include an ethic.

neosat··on Shut Up, Paul Graham: The Simplified Version
Not really (at least the way I interpreted it). PG seems to be saying that attacking the "final state" may not be the most productive approach here. Rather the discussion and consequent solutions should be focussed on the obviously bad factors that lead to this state (and his argument is that not all factors that lead to this outcome are bad - again you can disagree with that but the analogy in the article isn't appropriate because it focusses the discussion again on the outcome (the cancer)
neosat··on Shut Up, Paul Graham: The Simplified Version
"This seems akin to suggesting that skin cancer is not bad per se" is not a fair analogy. What PG is trying to say is that the state of inequality can arise from a system (of incentives) that is beneficial to humanity as a whole (you may or may not agree with him). But your biased analogy isn't a fair criticism of his argument.
← PreviousPage 5 of 5