HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noamyoungerm

116 karma · joined October 25, 2014

submissionscomments
noamyoungerm··on Undeveloped Film from a Soldier in WWII Discovered and Processed
IANAL but the word you're looking for is "derivative works". In order to develop film, you need to take someone else's work and apply your original interpretation to it.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_work

> Subject to sections 107 through 122, the owner of copyright under this title has the exclusive rights to do and to authorize any of the following:

> (2) to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work;

noamyoungerm··on The Irregular Verbs (2000)
You make several false assumptions or gross misunderstandings of how language changes.

The reason irregular verbs originally existed is because English is a Germanic language, meaning, that a thousand years ago, what we now call irregular verbs were actually regular verbs. There was a logical ordering and well understood way to modify the stem of a verb in order to agree with the subject and tense. At the time, irregular verbs changed their stem, but in a predictable and universal manner.

This all changed with the conquest of the Norman French. After the slow introduction of French and Latin into English, the verb forms we are now familiar with entered the language. In time, all verbs of Germanic origin were used the same way they had been used in Old English, while verbs brought in by the French used the forms we are familiar with today.

The reason it makes sense to see language regularization is because we have grown to expect the French form of verb agreement rather than the Germanic one. The Germanic system is more complex.

In short, the reason that "new verbs formed [are] never formed as irregular verbs ..." makes sense, is that the change from irregular Germanic verbs to regular French verbs is only about 800 years old.

noamyoungerm··on Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose faith
Is it that horrible to imagine a world where people use their own two legs to walk that last quarter mile? I don't see what makes the segway necessary.
noamyoungerm··on Google Glass future clouded as some early believers lose faith
It's very much a prototype project. The primary benefit is not so much in the product itself but rather that it makes the new concept viable and ready to exploit.

It's not that different from the first iPhone, which was really just a touch screen media player with a phone antenna.

noamyoungerm··on Welcome to a comet
If you send three grayscale images, each one taken through a different colored filter, you can reconstruct a color image back on earth by setting the red channel, green channel, and blue channel of the image to be each one of the colored filters you used to capture the image.

This isn't a grayscale image that our brain perceives on color, but rather several grayscale images, each colored separately to combine into a color image.

I seriously doubt an actual effect exists that makes us believe black and white images are actually colored.

noamyoungerm··on What neurons tell us about the 'hipster effect' when contrarians look the same
"physics math" is pretty good for a biologist http://xkcd.com/435/.
noamyoungerm··on The Life of a Pot Critic for the Denver Post
> a point where there will be companies marketing weed at us.

What did you expect? I thought it was common knowledge that the weed market would be basically swept up by companies that operate like Marlboro (and as soon as it's legal nationwide, just watch all the cigarette companies turn to weed companies)

noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
What exactly constitute the privacy rights for information that is already public?

I argue that an act that is reported in a newspaper does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy, and as a result that the right to be forgotten is distinct from the right to privacy.

More particularly, the concept of public interest is static neither in time nor is it equal across all citizens, but rights are by definition equal across all citizens. A rule that always applies except for when it doesn't is really just a venue for arbitrary decisionmaking.

noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
Just because you are permitted to say whatever you want doesn't mean you are free from responsibility for the content of your words. Words precede action, and as such uttering words entails some share of the responsibility for the action.

My meaning is, with regards to libel, that in a theoretical sense, claiming I'm a murderer would be acceptable under free speech. The reason it is problematic is that claiming I'm a murderer will cause other people to do harm to me, that is, you share in responsibility for loss on my part.

As a result, libel laws allow me to level the field - it's not that you aren't allowed to call me a murderer, but rather that you are responsible for the unjust damage you caused me by doing so. That is why it's ok to call someone a murderer if they actually killed someone - the damage is not unjust. That is also why libel laws (at least in accordance with my ideology) should be entirely restricted to the civil court of law and not the criminal one.

I'm aware that the model of free speech I'm advocating is in some cases unrealistic (most notably in the military intelligence community). However, the concept of absolutely free speech is something that countries should attempt to reach, and choosing to give citizens the ability to suppress speech lies in direct opposition to this. Democratic states need to provide rights to their citizens so that said rights form a minimum spanning set - internal conflict between security and privacy is why the US allowed itself to reach a state of mass NSA surveillance. I don't see why EU states should encourage a conflict between free speech and the right to be forgotten.

Even though the speech people seek to suppress may cause harm to them (as with libel laws), it is unreasonable to expect a person to free themselves of accountability for their actions by blaming those who merely report on the actions. People act with the expectation that their actions will have social repercussions, and the choice of action or inaction is more powerful than the choice of speech or silence.

noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
Does the search engine not have a right to freedom of speech? Who is the government to tell Google what they can or cannot say?
noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
What about Google's right to free speech? Censoring search results is a violation of Google's right to express itself, which is just as important and legally defensible as a newspaper's right to do the same.
noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
> ignores attempts to enforce the law

This means that the government is not operating in accordance with its obligation to enforce the law.

This is neither an issue with the law, nor an issue with the concept behind it - posting libelous content causes financial and personal harm, and this harm must be corrected in the civil court of law.

noamyoungerm··on Pianist asks Washington Post to remove review under 'right to be forgotten'
My right to free speech allows me to say whatever I want about anybody. There is absolutely no guarantee that I be nice or understanding or that I take into account their personal wishes.

When the government tells me that people have a right to remove embarrassing content, it's actually telling me that people have a right to restrict the speech of others.

The right to be forgotten and the right to free speech cannot coexist, because the implementation of one requires the override of another. You must choose one, but choosing both undermines the legal foundations of the modern democratic republic.

noamyoungerm··on Ask HN: How to address female coworkers getting paid less
By definition bench warmers do less work (or the same work less well), so of course they shouldn't be paid as much.
noamyoungerm··on I’m Terrified of My New TV
So does Google Now when you enable voice recognition inside other apps.
noamyoungerm··on I Hope Twitter Goes Away
A space where you have no reasonable expectation of any form of personal injury, perhaps excluding self-inflicted harm caused by negligence (e.g. cutting off your own hand in the kitchen, but not somebody else cutting off your hand in the kitchen).
noamyoungerm··on I Hope Twitter Goes Away
If users have difficulty properly using the platform, the platform is at fault. An arbitrarily naive user should never have to fight the platform to do what he wants.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2