HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noobly

166 karma · joined March 14, 2018

submissionscomments
noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
The point of the analogy was to represent that our actions may be essentially inconsequential if all holes are not sealed, and that larger holes or offenders should take priority. The hole size wasn't really all that important, but yes, a more accurate description would've involved a larger hole, probably.

How do we even get emission data anyway? Especially for other countries like China. For example this source is telling me our per capita emissions are higher than China, which I very much doubt: https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-pe...

noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
That analogy doesn't really apply imo.. Global murder totals don't impact me like murders in America do. Similarly, climate change effects all parties, no matter their contribution. A better analogy, imo, would be something like a leaking ship, where the portion we're responsible for has a pinhole that we're debating on if/how to patch up, while other parties have gaping holes gushing in water constantly with no clear intent to fix the hole, as we all begin our descent.

And in this case, I don't think buying a Tesla or some vegan burgers is going to make a substantial difference. As long as there's economic incentive to negatively contribute climate change, it will happen.

noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
It takes life a little bit to react to these changes though, e.g plants dying and ocean life being killed off. There's a risk of cascading effects from plant/animal network collapse. I have heard people building off of your idea though and speculating that Northern areas like Russia may be valuable in the next century as new farming land.

And I don't think people should be able to downvote a question without answering, or upvoting a response that addresses some criticism, I agree it sucks.

noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
I think hostage negotiators have a lot to teach here.
noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
From what I understand, the sun has also been getting hotter, hasn't it? I agree that man contributes to climate change, but quantifying this is where I think the conversation gets interesting. I haven't really gone very far down this hole though as it seems too muddled. And then if you do conclude man is primarily at fault, what do you do? The US is only responsible for so much output, for example, and sources like nuclear aren't viewed positively.
noobly··on It’s official: July was Earth’s hottest month on record
Science is what got us here in the first place, is it not?
noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
touche, and apologies for being impatient.
noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
>That's why we have 32 years of study on mRNA vaccines

Yes, in which they were largely viewed as non-viable and a shelfed idea at least in part due to issues like ADE. The research here was not extremely active, nor was it done on humans to the extent it is now.

>You have no basis for that.

Correct, but I have no basis to believe that some unseen risk is not present too. Given that I'm not personally at risk for COVID, I think there's wisdom in waiting a couple years (at least) to see how it unfolds. And there is a basis for ADE fears, which you ignored in favor of joking about growing a spontaneous third testicle.

>do you not think anyone has had a child since they were vaccinated?

One child would not imply it's impossible for _some_ child to have a defect.

>The data that I linked you shows otherwise?

Can you point me to where this was? The 'data' is still very immature regardless. I'm sure I could source data that comes to the opposite conclusion. It's important to view these things in aggregate, not lean on the studies you agree with. Right now, I'm finding studies that disagree often, so I think waiting for the data to mature a bit is reasonable assuming I'm not harming anyone by doing so.

>The infections from variants are still hundreds of times less severe in the vaccinated

You missed my point here - the point is that they can still get infected, not that they aren't expressing symptoms as severely.

...

Birth defects were just an example, like I said I view it as unlikely. The point is that there's a potential for unseen risk here. You've devolved into being a bit rude now, and I found your lack of skepticism tiring anyway. The data is all over the map currently, yet you seem rigid in your position - that's bad practice. You keep making arguments about the vaccines being effective at symptom reduction, but that's never been the point I'm trying to engage, since I agree with that and there is pretty conclusive data there. I will say that you can find data to the contrary (see Israel's recent stats), but mostly I'm saying that a) as someone who's already _not_at_risk_, there's arguably no net benefit to society in me taking the vaccine, so long as transmission rate reduction is largely an unknown (and even in that case, I'd prefer natural immunity) and b) there's a possibility of unforeseen and unwanted side effects / repercussions due to the vaccine - this is true despite you belittling this idea.

I'm not at risk, so I don't care about minimizing it or how effective it is. There is a possibility I may be a host to transmit COVID to people at risk though, so I care about that. As of now, natural immunity looks much more enticing than vaccination for someone like me. Why are you so opposed to this? I won't be hospitalized, so you don't have to worry about me, and I presumably will spread it similarly to how vaccinated individuals will.

noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
>You are far less likely to get infected at all if you're fully vaccinated

This is what I'm asking about, transmission. The data on this is woefully limited however.

Here's another Fauci quote:

    So far, the available Covid-19 vaccines have not been judged primarily on their ability to prevent transmission – though this is now being evaluated as a secondary endpoint for many of them. Instead, their efficacy was assessed by whether they could prevent symptoms from developing. “This means that we set our targets kind of pragmatically,” says Danny Altmann, professor of immunology at Imperial College London.

    …

    There isn’t yet any conclusive evidence that the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine can prevent people from being infected with the coronavirus – and therefore halt its spread. But there are some early signs that it might.
When these were being released, no one knew it's effects on transmission, yet the sentiment was that they certainly did, and questioning this brought about frustration.

>There's more and more data

There's also data building to the contrary. Take a look at Israel's number of cases vs vaccination status, for example. We're not at a stage where data is conclusive either way, and in that case I'm fine with waiting things out.

For example, this is what you're study says:

>The mRNA vaccines are highly effective at preventing symptomatic and severe COVID-19 associated with B.1.617.2 infection

This is not about reducing SARS-COV-2 transmission, but symptomatic COVID. These mistakes lead to misinformation spreading.

Further, this is all your second study concludes:

   Among index patients, those who had been vaccinated were likely to be less severely symptomatic2 and might have been less infectious than those who were unvaccinated.
As I'm sure you know, correlation does not imply causation, it's possible that vaccinated individuals were simply practicing better viral hygiene (especially given that they were vaccinated back in Jan/Feb, when there was less social pressure and more risk).
noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
>That it went faster doesn't mean it's less safe

No, but it does the mean the long term risk are not defined as well. What if, for example, this causes reproductive harm, or some harm to the offspring? I personally believe this is very unlikely, but it's too early to know at the moment. Or, what if the ADE risk is real, and vaccinated individuals aren't able to combat variants as effectively, perhaps even reacting worse to reinfection? It's simply too early to evaluate so many risk here. On the other hand, I can be pretty sure COVID won't cause birth defects, given that no coronaviruses do.

>hospitalization rates are 15-200X higher in the unvaccinated and death rates are 8-87X higher

Well, of course - there's a lot more unvaccinated people and cases, what else would you expect? And I'm not at risk of being hospitalized anyway, so I still see no reason to try and mitigate that risk. My time would be better spent ensuring my car is operating safely, or a million other things that could decrease my chance of harm more substantially.

Regardless, taking the vaccine is pointless beyond self-preservation if it doesn't reduce spread, and at the moment that's unknown, and complicated by the fact that some 'variants' seem to side-step the vaccine. Sitting on the side lines and waiting for more data seems reasonable to me.

noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
I understand where you're coming from in pointing out what seems to be inconsistencies. But we've been dealing with coronaviruses since the beginning, while mRNA vaccines were only deployed en masse in 2019/2020 (right?). I don't think this is so inconsistent, and I addressed this in my post. Such limited data is never ideal in making these kind of decisions, but I'd wager we know much more about COVID's risk than mRNA. As I understand it, the technology for mRNA is a few decades old, but this is the first time it's hit the market, is it not? If so, the risk is still in the process of being discovered.

Generally vaccines have a much longer trial and study period, this has been rushed due to emergency circumstances.

>But worse, you're putting your friends and family who cannot get the vaccine for actual reasons instead of gut feeling at risk.

How so? It's currently up in the air whether or not the vaccines reduce transmission.

I still disagree that I'm exposing myself to more risk by inaction. My risk is already nearly 0, so I don't really care to minimize it further anyway, but by vaccinating I'm taking on a lot of uncertainty (in personal risk, effectiveness of the vaccine over time, transmission reduction, etc), so it's impossible to assess properly with these unknowns. I would much rather just get COVID. You don't see an issue with that, right?

noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
>Deciding not to get vaccinated massively increases your risk of transmitting the virus to others.

Can you source this claim? In the original Pfizer, Moderna, etc studies, they never tested for transmissibility, only reduction of COVID-like symptoms.

>Any way you parse it, vaccination is preferable to infection.

And I disagree. I would rather have SARS-COV-2 injected into my arm personally. I'm not at risk, so taking on additional poorly defined risk such as the vaccine makes little sense from a self-preservation standpoint. From what I've seen there's not enough data to support vaccines reducing spread, but I'd like to see what you may have. And then we have the issue of variants that go right around the vaccine.

Here's a relevant quote from Fauci: "Even though you’re vaccinated, because you could get infected, not know it, and be completely without symptoms because the vaccine is preventing you from getting symptoms, but you can have virus in your nasal pharynx and then inadvertently and innocently, pass it on to someone else who’s not vaccinated. That’s the problem we’re facing."

I don't know where we're at now, but early on when the vaccines were being first deployed, it was unsure if they'd reduce transmission, even between vaccinated populations. And you see Fauci here certainly implying that's the case.

noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
Speaking strictly about mRNA vaccines, the risk is not yet well-defined, since it's a new tech, so doing a quantitative comparison at this point doesn't seem right. Additionally, the methods of data collection between vaccine and COVID risk haven't followed the same standards, making an apples to apples quantitative comparison difficult.

The risk of the vaccine is an open question that's being answered over time (consider things like ADE that caused mRNA vaccines to be put on hold prior to the pandemic). On the other hand, COVID has a pretty well defined risk being that we've seen it for 2 years now, and it's from a familiar family of viruses. We also have to consider vaccine effectiveness; is it robust to variants? over what timeline is it effective? does it reduce transmission? etc. If it is less effective in any of these categories, the risk:reward grows larger, and not taking it begins to make more and more sense.

Lastly, you have to consider when comparing these numbers, that there's a non-null probability you won't ever catch COVID. I'm not at risk, and I believe I probably have natural immunity, so I see no reason to expose myself to additional risk; it wouldn't help anyone any.

noobly··on SARS-CoV-2 Lambda variant exhibits higher infectivity and immune resistance
Some forms of immunity decrease your ability to transmit to others, which protects those at risk, so it's not just about self-preservation.
noobly··on Ask HN: Did you take the vaccine? Why or why not?
>The final reason to get the vaccine is that it's common to have the virus with no symptoms and still spread it. Even if you're willing to bear the risks of infection yourself, are you willing to make this choice for others? (Or else self-quarantine?) With "breakthrough cases" becoming more common, the vaccinated can't be assured of safety unless everyone else gets the vaccine too.

Is there sufficient evidence to support that the vaccine reduces transmission? If not, then you're not helping anyone but yourself by taking the vaccine.

noobly··on A woman who rifles through New York’s garbage, exposing the city’s excesses
I've thrown away so much stuff that has value. Pyrex erlenmyers this week, for example. I don't regret it and it's hard to do (for me), but I've learned every item you own has a cost associated with it, e.g maintenance or even just taking up space (which can compromise aesethetics/atmosphere if nothing else). And trying to sell old junk can be too time consuming and draining compared to just tossing it wholesale. I have a nice clean shop space now and it's worth cutting the losses imo.

Luckily, most of the stuff I have is used/cheap or was obtained for free, though. I try to just accumulate less now, even if free.

noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
I think by reflow I really meant "maintain zoom between page turns". On my Kobo's default software, I had to re-zoom each page (so I installed KoReader).
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
Hopefully they add open sourcing the whole stack to their roadmap. That'd be the best thing they can do imo. I'm so eager for a device like this that I can 100% get behind.
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
>fast switching between recent documents

This is what my research told me last I looked too, thanks for the confirmation that this is still true. I believe RM will deliver long term, hacker friendliness goes a long way. Not sure if it's worth the price atm, but I'll look out for a cheap used one. I could do so much more critical reading if I could do it while lying down.

noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
So you don't have issues with the lack of PDF reflow? I just want something that works for reading and doing math/cs while laying in bed.
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
That looks great, 13 inch screen ensures no reflow issues too. Are you able to flip through the pages with minimal issues while in split screen mode, or do you have to manually resize the page each time? Also, it looks like you have this in 'landscape' mode - is that correct? Awesome feature if so. Too bad these are still so niche and therefore pricey, $800 is a painful price point for such a device imo.
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
I am reading the rm2 doesn't reflow pdfs? Has this been a problem for you?
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
That is really too bad. Hopefully there's either a larger device or upgrade soon, I've been waiting a long time for something like the reMarkable to mature into a product that fits my needs.
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
Are you able to achieve a split-screen-like functionality, so you can do scratch work while referencing the text?
noobly··on The rise of E Ink Tablets and Note Takers: reMarkable 2 vs Onyx Boox Note Air
Opportunities to ask about these devices don't come up very often, so please help me decide what I want here:

I want something that allows me to do math problems while laying down horizontally, mostly before bed. With a book and paper, it's a mess trying to do this, and I require e-ink. So I need good support for reading PDFs _and_ writing on screen, which is a niche apparently. I need split screen functionality or something like it, so I can have half my screen be scratch paper, and in the other half I can flip through the text (and I need a reasonably sized screen to accommodate all this). If I cannot do this, the device is not usable enough to purchase imo. I have no desire to take notes, draw or convert my writing to text. It would be a big plus if it could also read epubs as then I wouldn't need my current ereader.

I'm leaning toward the Remarkable 2, mostly due to it shaping up to be 'hacker friendly' (so I can lean on the community to write some features) and the writing supposedly feeling real, but I don't like how expensive the little pencil nubs are and having to replace them is kind of a drag. I tend to binge research my options a couple times per year but haven't pulled the trigger yet. I get frustrated because I feel like I want something so basic that it should already exist - just a book and scratch paper in one device, with a screen that doesn't keep me awake at night or distract me with a web browser. Anyway, last I checked the Remarkable 2 didn't quite have a splitscreen feature or anything close enough, so I opted to wait.

Would appreciate any input, I'm probably going to break down and buy one this month.

noobly··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
>I dont care how my coins was moved 10 years ago. The only storage that is relevant for me, now, for value transfer is the current undisputed state

I don't have anything to add, but this has always struck me as inelegant, especially for Ethereum, which is more of a dApp platform. Can someone point me towards something that can run dApps and maintain current state with distributed consensus _without_ a blockchain (or explain why this is an ignorant question)? Also, what's wrong with truncating the chain after X blocks?

noobly··on How a carnivorous mushroom poisons its prey
Primarily indoor cultivation of oysters (most cost effective), but also lion's mane and shiitake in lower quantities along with a lot of screwing around with other species for fun. I began construction of my small scale farm just before the pandemic started looking serious (~December 2019), and my business plan was reliant on getting higher-end restaurants as customers (which have fared poorly during this). So it's been somewhat on pause, but I'm hoping things clear up soon, as I've been gathering some nice equipment for good prices over the last year (in large part due to covid, ironically).

It would be great to be able to do assays for protein content at home or for nearly free at a lab to work towards better genetics. An ~86g or "one cup" serving of raw oysters supposedly has around ~3g, and it's worth noting that a raw cup cooks down to maybe a quarter cup or less, which is probably comparatively substantial for those that don't consume meat. The Vitamin D content is also noteworthy, as apparently they're the only considerable source of this in the produce aisle (which I didn't fully appreciate until binge researching last night).

noobly··on How a carnivorous mushroom poisons its prey
As a cultivator, I wish they'd eat the fungus gnats too!.. And I wonder how much supplementing substrate with nematodes would increase protein content, or how'd I'd test this. The ratio of protein to carbs is about 1:2 in these, getting closer to 1:1 would be awesome for cost effective protein, especially as a non-meat item.

Apparently, nematodes can get a whole meter long. It'd be interesting to drop one of such size into a liquid culture or other colonized medium and see what happens, lol.

noobly··on Write Simply
He usually has a hard time reading his essays. I don't think he was making a statement on this particular one.
noobly··on Coinbase S-1
You don't need a "hardware wallet" for this. You just need your private keys.
← PreviousPage 3 of 7Next →