HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nootropicat

906 karma · joined January 16, 2018

submissionscomments
nootropicat··on U.S. Treasury sanctions virtual currency mixer Tornado Cash
The anonymity set is the best theoretically possible - everyone in the shielded set. It's the same for zk.money and tornado - the difference compared to tornado is that tornado has fixed amounts.

There's no possible attack to deanonymize the full zero-knowledge model beyond the utilization of always existing metadata - which needs separate solutions for every such system. In practice, zcash doesn't have that many users, so the anonymity set isn't big, but that's a separate issue to technology.

The question which one is better in practice right now is a more complex one. Even a perfect solution like zcash/zk.money is useless if (just a random number) only 3 people use it, and ringct with (again a random number) 100k separate people with roughly equal tx count would obviously win. My estimate is that tornado.cash is the most anonymous. Monero is hard to estimate because there's no way to know how many spent outputs are known to the American government and/or cooperating chain analysis companies. Is it <1%? Then it's probably second best. Is it 90%? Run away.

Last but not least monero can be deanonymized retroactively by quantum computers. Tornado, zk.money and zcash can't - they can be robbed (monero can be robbed too, obviously) but that's a much better failure mode.

nootropicat··on U.S. Treasury sanctions virtual currency mixer Tornado Cash
Exactly. Monero's ringct model is easy to break statistically given some resources. Fees aren't that high. It's practical for a state to know 75+% of spent outputs by a combination of exchange info exchange and spamming. In addition there's zero output privacy (meaning honeypot->suspect->exchange creates extremely strong links when repeated).

Zcash is good, but not popular. Same for zk.money

nootropicat··on U.S. Treasury sanctions virtual currency mixer Tornado Cash
This is why PoS is a must. There's no way to hide industrial mining facilities and miners will be eventually forced to enforce sanctions. A validator even with 100k eth just needs a connection, trivial to hide.
nootropicat··on Roboticists discover alternative physics
>The theory of epicycles is not an explanatory model because it does not explain why the planets should move in circular orbits with epicyclical sub-orbits. Kepler's laws are explanatory because they explain planetary motion as a result of Newton's law of universal gravitation, are predictive because they can be used to predict the motion of the planets and are explainable because anyone can plug in the numbers and see how the results are calculated.

That's not a qualitative difference, it's a quantitative difference. Here you somewhat implicitly claim that models of lower Kolmogorov complexity for same, or better, accuracy are better, but how is that 'explanatory'? The term has no meaning. Ironically Kepler's laws are a better equivalent of epicycles, because they reduce to an imperfect approximation of Newtonian mechanics. Predicting actual orbits in a Newtonian Solar system of perfectly spherical objects with fully known matter distribution can only be done with an iterative solution.

The actual, physical reality continuously diverges from all current models, and all we can try to achieve is to reduce that error. It can't ever be eliminated unless the universe is in fact a simulation, and whatever is controlling it decides to copy humans into the parent world, then gives them external access to the full underlying state.

nootropicat··on Roboticists discover alternative physics
>To clarify: a predictive model is one that can predict novel events. An explainable model is one that can explain how it made a prediction.

Sorry but that distinction doesn't mean anything falsifiable. Did you mean an explanatory model is one that's easier to understand for a human? If so, that's certainly useful, but it may well turn out that the simplest working model of physics is incomprehensible.

nootropicat··on Two brothers selling shares in themselves
>why not just organize society to educate everyone

Because it was tried and it's a massive failure. The entire western education system is geared to help slowest learners at the expense of everyone else. It's actively harmful for those that are exceptional. Only those from rich families can escape it.

And that's only inside developed countries. The reality in rest of the world is much worse.

>nobody has a magical oracle

Yes, no perfect oracle exists, but it's enough to have something that's substantially better than random, like intelligence tests. A direct economic incentive would lead to development of more reliable predictors.

nootropicat··on Two brothers selling shares in themselves
Yes, new laws and probably technology would be needed for that too.

Ideally there would be an implant that records their entire life - which can be used to determine if they slacked off in breach of the purchase agreement.

nootropicat··on Two brothers selling shares in themselves
>Thought experiment: who can buy the most shares of others? And if they buy "well", how does the distribution of wealth shift?

It shifts to the sellers, not the buyers. That's because buyers are competing with each other which drives the expected return close to the general market rate.

Assume there's a magical oracle that tells you: this kid will generate $100M of wealth over their lifetime - to not get bogged down into discounted future value, lets say the risk free rate is 0% - but needs $500k for education and resources early. Without any investment the kid will become stuck in a local maximum in a shitty environment and generate $100k instead.

Market competition will bring the total sale amount close to 0.5%. Lets say it's 1%, although that's very high. Funds bought shares that are 'fairly' worth $1M for $500k, for a profit of $500k - not bad. The person gained $99M. Total distribution of wealth becomes more fair, not less.

nootropicat··on Two brothers selling shares in themselves
This concept completely fixes inequality and fully replaces all forms of social welfare - no more wasted potential because a smart person is born in a bad environment due to genetic lottery. Advantage from growing up in a rich family would shrink to the point of irrelevancy. Investors would filter out ghettos in search of high iq kids to buy their shares early. No more need for public schools - because everyone would get the quality they actually deserve, all paid for by private investors. Same would apply to literally every form of social welfare that exists anywhere. Right now there's no market pricing of people at all - everyone either gets less than they deserve, or more, with the fair outcome statistically borderline impossible. The outcome is a horrific waste of human potential.

I think effective tax rate would go way down - because bidding wars on people would reduce it to the market rate, and given the increasing global abundance of capital, I'm pretty sure that's going to mean low single digit taxes (ie. selling only single digit percentage of ownership).

While the end result would be a utopia, it's hard to see how it could become the norm anytime soon. The concept directly takes power away from politicians, so to become the norm a large scale collapse of the state is required. Perhaps it needs a completely new environment - like space colonies in O'Neill cylinders, in which case we're sadly centuries too early.

nootropicat··on Why falling birthrates might be a bigger deal than dominants narratives imply
How cheap kids are is irrelevant. Population grew much faster when people lived in abject poverty. People empirically don't want kids, full stop. Raising them could be free and tfr would still be below 2.

"I can't afford kids" is an excuse used by people who don't want kids but are unable to admit that. You can't actually afford kids if they would be under a real risk of starvation - which is a real risk in North Korea, not any Western country.

Don't read me wrong, I'm not saying here having kids is an obligation.

nootropicat··on Why falling birthrates might be a bigger deal than dominants narratives imply
>Sample size: zero.

By that logic it's impossible to say that any species is going extinct before it actually disappears.

The entire developed world is slowly going extinct, and drastic changes are needed to stop that. Some countries like South Korea are collapsing faster than others.

I'm not saying humanity itself will go extinct - because the industrial civilization will collapse first, stopping the demographic collapse - but under the current trend the culture will be gone, most likely viewed as degeneracy of the arrogant ancients.

nootropicat··on Why falling birthrates might be a bigger deal than dominants narratives imply
Outside of high-tech solutions (external wombs, anti-aging) there's one social: a totalitarian country forcing women to have kids. The only country I could see it happening is China.

In the absence of one of the three solutions, technological civilization will peak this century. It's not poverty or culture that leads to not having kids, it's industrialization. Any culture that automates agriculture to a sufficient level will eventually go extinct in the absence of a technological solution. Totalitarianism can work for a while but it's inherently brittle - at best it can give more time for a real technological solution.

Maybe it's the great filter.

>Even if life extension technology does begin to roll out, any model we can conjure for its use based on current economic systems will limit access to the top fraction of a percent of the population, socioeconomically speaking, and thus be irrelevant in combating the above trend.

Completely unsupported assumption. In theory antiaging could even be delivered via a virus that infects almost everyone.

nootropicat··on Looming natural gas shortages has the EU scrambling for solutions
>Both countries drew the ire of the others, and for a time, it seemed as if the European Union's internal market would break apart under pressure from the crisis due to the egoism of the member states. >A repeat this time around is to be avoided at all costs.

Because this time solidarity is in Germany's interests, duh.

>Germany Blocks Joint Gas Purchases

>But resistance is coming from large natural gas utilities in Germany, like RWE, and from industrial customers as well. They want to buy their own gas and fear that they won't be allocated sufficient supplies by the EU.

Seems like the German definition of solidarity is that they get gas from others.

nootropicat··on Breaking the warp barrier: solitons in Einstein–Maxwell-plasma theory (2021)
Ftl means there's one global reference frame most likely the cmbr one.

The reason relativity predicts weird effects like time travel is because it doesn't allow ftl as an assumption, so the only way to hack ftl into it is negative time. It's baffling how many people seriously argue about consequences of something that completely disproves the theory itself while still using it to generate predictions.

nootropicat··on Ethereum Energy Consumption
Infura is completely irrelevant as far as security goes, they have zero power to do anything related to consensus.

>The issue with PoS, of course, is that while the work function is insular, purchasing stake is not.

That's not the issue, that's the 'S' in PoS. Consensus partially breaks if majority of state is hostile (no imminent double spend risk unlike PoW, but may require a manually coordinated fork with minority of validators). It breaks for 2/3 of hostile validators in the sense that new nodes would follow a different chain while honest minority is building on its own fork.

Both failure modes require some manual coordination, but rather than successfully censor or steal, they create temporary chaos - at the cost of millions of eth. It's impossible to even buy enough now, and any attack is self extinguishing because the available supply shrinks.

Under PoW the failure mode is trivial and deadly. If the attacker owns majority of hashrate he can censor anyone forever, including other miners. There's no real defense because there's no in-protocol way to delete the attacker's asics. Switching to a gpu pow achieves nothing - because the only entity prepared for that would be the attacker itself - but it would be pointless in the more general sense, as nobody would ever trust PoW anyway, because the same attack can always be repeated. The issue is use of external resources not controlled by the protocol.

Attack from the state is one thing, infinite economies of scale is another. An entity controlling majority can multiply its income by censoring everyone else. Eventually, everyone else mining at loss disappears. Then they can only mine at a fraction of hashrate and instead of paying for energy, use a fraction of excess profits to buy more asics. In the case of any competitor they would turn all of them on again until competitor gives up. This one is eventually inevitable, hard to say how soon.

These issues are completely unsolvable in PoW.

>so Infura type entities are not necessary

It's just a rpc - it's always necessary to answer queries and send transactions. At best it could work inside js in metamask as a light node. The only theoretical attack infura could do is lie about balances to someone, but the discrepancy would be detected and that would be the end of people trusting infura (to report correct state).

nootropicat··on Ethereum Energy Consumption
>I understand Proof of Stake to be much more centralized and prone to takeovers than proof of work. So if the merge ever actually happens, it would fix the energy consumption issue at the trade-off of security (staking, aka rich get richer).

The opposite is true, proof of work is hopelessly insecure and centralized. It's hopelessly insecure because resources needed to mine are external - so any attack by the only realistic adversary (ie. a state) is always just a question of resources, and the most pessimistic cost is in low billions of dollars. Realistically - America could already 51% bitcoin by forcing regulations on existing miners for nearly zero cost.

It's also centralized because mining has infinite economies of scale. Bitcoin mining started with hobbyists mining on home pcs, now there are companies buying power plants just to mine. This only makes it easier for governments to control.

The only reason no big PoW coins were successfully attacked is because there's no clear motivation for anyone - nothing in the real world relies on any cryptocurrency to continue existing. The only realistic attack would be to try to exchange tokens on the attacked PoW network for tokens on another - which is easily done for low 9 figs, but becomes increasingly hard afterwards - making any attack uneconomical. On top of that there are legal issues - it's very possible a 51% double spending attack would be legally treated as theft.

This all changes completely the moment major countries and corporations go down if some blockchain goes down. Imagine Iran defaulting if bitcoin or ethereum gets taken over in a 51% PoW attack, with all transactions from Iran addresses censored. It would be orders of magnitudes cheaper than any serious military action. Fortunately for Iran and crypto holders that's not true. A significant adoption of a PoW network would end up in an inevitable disaster and potentially destroy any trust in cryptocurrencies forever.

Of all invented consensus methods only proof of stake can survive in a truly hostile environment. No government can print eth at will to take over ethereum, and stakers can easily stay anonymous, unlike massive corporate miners.

Bitcoin holders are very good at propaganda and pretending PoW is safe, which works as marketing, but wouldn't do anything against a real military incentive to take control over bitcoin.

>I'm much more bullish on Chia and proof-of-space/time

No, Chia has the same issue. Anything that relies on external resources as consensus votes is fundamentally insecure.

nootropicat··on Ethereum Energy Consumption
That's incorrect. There were plans to switch to hybrid PoS in 2018 which were (surprisingly even to Parity node devs) rapidly shelved. Since then a new design is being slowly worked upon. There were no plans to switch in 2019 that I recall.
nootropicat··on Ethereum Energy Consumption
Energy use can be computed from first principles given some arbitrary assumptions: average power per node and number of nodes.

There are ARM nodes that require less than 10W. Then there are more conventional servers that require ...150W? Average here is pure guesswork, but error bounds aren't that large - let's say 100W/node.

How many nodes are going to exist - I think 10k is a reasonable maximum number.

The result is 24000kWh per day. At $0.15/kWh, that means $3600 in daily energy costs.

There's also the hardware cost itself and internet connection cost (which can be zero if there's an already paid for connection) - but all in all, total, real expenses to run ethereum become a rounding error of current ones. Guesstimating hw depreciation and connection cost, daily total at $5k translates into $1.825M/year. The value of block rewards during the last 24h is ~$15M.

In other words resources required for running ethereum for ~3 hours now are going to be enough to run it for a year after the merge.

nootropicat··on Newer, better sunscreens have not been approved by the FDA
Sunscreen is a scam. Sun is good for you unless you aren't able to tan.

"Nonsmokers who avoided sun exposure had a life expectancy similar to smokers in the highest sun exposure group, indicating that avoidance of sun exposure is a risk factor for death of a similar magnitude as smoking. Compared to the highest sun exposure group, life expectancy of avoiders of sun exposure was reduced by 0.6-2.1 years. "

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26992108/

nootropicat··on Bitcoin is the only coin the SEC Chair will call a commodity
Way too many people hold various crypto for any action now. Sec can barely deal with Ripple and that's one of the easiest ones.
nootropicat··on Vitali Klitschko fake tricks Berlin mayor in video call
We are already in the reality in which video evidence has equal weight to witness statements, it just requires one serious deepfake framing attempt (later detected) for everyone to internalize that.
nootropicat··on Sex is going out of fashion?
Those interactions moved to discord (and telegram, although that's second-hand info).

I fully understand what you describe, and once I realized the truly abysmal return on time spent I cut my time on public social media by ~100x. It's just not worth it beyond an occasional comment.

nootropicat··on Parti: Pathways Autoregressive Text-to-Image Model
Eh, the cost of training is already within the reach of wealthy individuals, and as better TPUs/GPUs appear on the cloud cost drops.

This is definitely going to become commonly available tech this decade.

nootropicat··on Sex is going out of fashion?
>If anyone can do it

I think you missed most comments under this article...

nootropicat··on Ask HN: Feel bad about working in crypto, what to do?
Possession is 9/10 of the law. What some tax board thinks only matters insofar as they are able to enforce their will. People think governments are omnipotent. They are not.
nootropicat··on LaMDA is not sentient
As AIs become more lifelike the pool of humans that consider it enough grows. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if relationships with human level AI won't dominate eventually.
nootropicat··on LaMDA is not sentient
People know you can't pay a human to love you, but it's in principle possible to make an AI that loves you, assuming a human level AI exists.
nootropicat··on Ask HN: I miss Usenet. Are there any modern equivalents?
On the balance I like chats much more. In terms of personal connections per time spent on contributing I found chats to be about one order of magnitude more effective than old (gone) phpbb forums. Forums were much more transactional and impersonal in nature.

Compared to what forums morphed into - reddit, hn, similar - these are another order of magnitude worse than old forums. See, consider yours and my reply. I won't remember your nickname nor will you remember mine. There are no avatars. It's borderline machine level information exchange with the author itself a faded out barely visible string.

nootropicat··on Ask HN: I miss Usenet. Are there any modern equivalents?
The forum/mailing list format is over, most good discussions happen on discord now (some people swear by telegram - mostly Russians).

I'm not claiming it's a change for the better. I'm old enough to have caught the tail end of phpBB forums about every niche so I know what was lost. From a technical perspective forums are superior for long term discussions (especially for non-members!), but in terms where new stuff happens and where community forms - it's over. The closest replacement are specific channels on discord that allow sometimes for week-long discussions.

One of main social effects I see is that knowledge starts to get siloed. There are many technical details that exist online only on specific chats, which aren't google searchable. The main negative is that if you don't even know where to look or ask, it's way harder to figure out anything. There's also a positive: because people are forced to join they are more likely to contribute. In fact I have observed this in myself: often I only join some discord to look for one thing, but I just leave the server on afterwards. In many cases I see something worth responding to and morph from an observer into an active participant. This would never have happened on a forum. It's possible this factor is solely responsible for the current dominance of discord/telegram.

One future shift I can see is a move away from chats into VR. I don't think it's going to happen with zoomers, but alpha gen - assuming they grow up in VR spaces may find it natural to prefer literal talking as anime and furry avatars, with (almost) full nonverbal communication, instead of writing text messages to each other. In a way, it would be a return to the historical norm of human communication.

From a social trend perspective it's the same direction as the move away from forums into chats: worse information search (basically gone with VR). More emphasis on contributing and on personal relationships. The main disadvantage I can see is that it's going to place much stronger emphasis on people's characteristics: age, gender, native language.

nootropicat··on Addressing AI’s energy cost
This ignores renewable energy. What's the problem with renewables? Intermittency. Which is perfect for training. Just use a battery for a 10 minute buffer and start/stop when current energy price drops due to wind or sun energy flooding the grid.
← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →