HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on Both geniuses and madmen pay attention to what others ignore
In case of psychopathy, or better anti-social personality traits in general, there is some research into this, and it indicates that "genius level" intelligence is a protective factor. So a person with amoral/anti-social traits and very high score on the G factor (I think) is able to compensate, high cognitive abilities can sort of inhibit amoral impulses through sheer brute force of intellect, sort of. This makes sense because anti-social/amoral behaviour is in the general case not very adaptive and beneficial (for each successful psycho, you have vastly more of them leading miserable lives). Also, the relationship is non-linear, it only works for very high levels of intelligence. I'd love to give you some reference, but unfortunately I don't have the literature at hand ATM.
nzp··on The Writer Automaton, Switzerland [video]
Really amazing. Previous discussion on HN https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6678947
nzp··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
With the risk of sounding like an elitist prick (not the intention, and I'm really not) that photo of a Patek Phillipe and Apple Watch side by side on his wrist to me screams: This is the way the world ends, not with a bang but a digital picture of a fake butterfly. A masterpiece of craftsmanship, good taste and skill, side by side with a mass market simulation of those all those things sporting a tacky, pointless image of an animal.

I'm not an Apple fan but I do appreciate their mostly good taste and design. However, this watch is hideous. It's the first object they produced since their resurrection in 1997 that I instantly find ugly. Really, really ugly. If it was an aeroplane it wouldn't fly well. I wouldn't bet it will be unsuccessful though, there's a lot of people with bad taste out there.

nzp··on A Watch Guy's Thoughts on the Apple Watch After Seeing It in the Metal
I'm not sure it's always just about utility vs. signalling. I have no care for social signalling at all, but if I had money to throw away I would probably buy some things which you classify as signalling devices. For sure, though, I certainly wouldn't buy a blinged out gold Rolex (hideous) but rather something like a Speedmaster (on which I'd probably put a NATO or a velcro strap), and certainly not a sports car you can drive on public roads. Sure, both of these machines don't have that much practical utility, but they are engineering works of art. Just as some people collect art to show off their money, or store capital, some collect it because they appreciate good taste and amazing craftsmanship. It's still irrational but I wouldn't put it in the same bag as signalling.
nzp··on BKS Iyengar, who helped bring yoga to the West, has died
> I guess what you mean by Bliss is what the Buddhists mean by Elightenment?

Although in Buddhism there is at some point the attainment of bliss (as a factor in the first jhana[0]) the goal is to let go of that bliss and go beyond. The next step in yoga is the realisation of atman, while in Buddhism the goal, Enlightenment (which is much better translated as "Awakening") it is the very opposite--the realisation of anatman (non-self). So they're not really compatible. In fact Buddhism is doctrinally sharply opposed to all strands of Vedic thought and practice.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jhana

nzp··on Attempts to stay anonymous on the web will only put the NSA on your trail
The story in the article has nothing concrete to do with NSA. Nothing actually happened. OTOH, the mentioned "value" of pregnant women vs. non-pregnant persons to marketers is interesting.
nzp··on The logic of Buddhist philosophy
Aristotle had nothing to do with the atomic theory, other than being against it. As far as antique atomism goes, the ideas is essentially what it is in modern science---matter consists of indivisible elementary particles. It doesn't matter much that what we call "atoms" do not fit the description (at the time of their modern theoretical (re)discovery it was thought they are elementary). This simple idea, without any further elaboration as to how "atoms" work, just the idea that they exist as such, is far more powerful than it seems at first sight. Feynman thought it was the most important piece of scientific knowledge about the universe, so much so that if all scientific knowledge would to disappear but we could choose one fact to preserve, he would choose the idea of atomic theory.

Indeed any scientist relying on Aristotle would do badly, and one of the reasons was because he was against atomism.

nzp··on 2048, success and me
Development of a political (and economic) systems is dependent on technological development. Of course, the reverse is also true. Taken abstractly, we might say democracy doesn't require technology, but in the real world it doesn't happen. Democracy (I'm assuming we're speaking about the parliamentary, representative democracy) became necessary when means of production developed beyond Medieval artisanship.
nzp··on Do Men Suck At Friendship?
I don't think it's possible in this case. And, yes, I think it is a sufficient reason that such comments shouldn't be made. Not because it's exclusionary (although discrimination is an awful thing, I don't think homosexual people would mind being excluded from the implications of the premise we're discussing), but because it shows how wrong the comment is. The implication is that specifically heterosexual persons have the sex-friendship issue, or if not, then all humans have this issue, in which case the "men and women" part has to be thrown out.

Is there any evidence that friendship, sexual and romantic relations work differently among homosexual people? And to such an extent that the negative tension between sex and friendship exists only with heterosexual people? I don't know of any. Has anyone ever made a comment: "Gay men can't be friends because sex always gets in the way." or "Lesbians can't be friends because sex always gets in the way."?

I'm not implying there's homophobia in this kind of thinking, just very bad, shallow "analysis" of interpersonal relationships (of the kind you tend to get from "women magazines" and "men magazines", no surprise there) and, in some cases, a lot of rationalisation by people who only want infantile sexual relations from persons of desirable sex and don't even try to make friends, although they try to fake it to get sex (i.e. by people for whom friendship was never actually a motivating option).

nzp··on Do Men Suck At Friendship?
No, not really. What about same sex friendships in homosexual men and women? Why would we single out hetero sexuality? As I said in my comment to Colin's post, no one ever makes such a statement for homosexual relations.
nzp··on Do Men Suck At Friendship?
But the thing is, why is this considered a problem really? Should we only have sex with our enemies or persons we don't like? I understand the underlying reasoning, the questions are for the most part rhetorical, but I just don't find the whole idea very well thought out, not to mention it's completely wrong in the "always" part. Also, I never heard people say gay men or lesbians can never be friends. Why is that? Is there some bogus assumption that hetero sexuality is somehow different in nature?

The point is that the "sex part" does not have to get in the way. In most cases the sex part is very superficial, it's just an idea that comes naturally to peoples minds and it's simply not a big deal at all. People, men and women, think about sex (almost all the time, both sexes) and worthless semi random thoughts about sex with almost any person will be had. It simply is not such a big deal. The funny thing is that we are all aware of the universality and banality of these thoughts, yet act as though it's something special, extraordinary and serious. Just to be clear, I'm not advocating promiscuity (although, again to be clear, I have no moral issue with that as long as it's honest), but simply putting the whole thing to rest, it's not even worth talking about.

And it better not be true that sex stands in the way of friendship because long, commited, beautiful relationships sure involve a lot of sex and deep friendship. Sex can only stand in the way of friendship if all one wants is sex.

nzp··on Quantum Entanglement Drives the Arrow of Time
> Say I have hot coffee and lukewarm coffee. The lukewarm coffee will equilibrate faster.

It won't (all else being equal). :) Because of Newton's law of cooling, hot coffee will cool down faster (precisely, the rate of change of temperature of a solid body is proportional to the difference in temperature between the body and the environment).

nzp··on Quantum Entanglement Drives the Arrow of Time
It's kind of like that. The state of a particle in classical mechanics is a linear combination of some basis vectors which are not it's states as such. But the superposition in QM is the superpositions of states. The phase space in classical mechanics is not a vector space, but in QM it is. This is a fundamental difference because in QM you can take any number of states, make a linear combination a it will result in another perfectly valid state. Not so in classical mechanics. For example, consider a particle orbiting a point. If you take some position vectors as it moves and make a linear combination, the resulting vector will not be a possible position of a particle in this system. In QM, it would necessary be another possible state. This is a slightly sloppy example, but I hope you get the gist.
nzp··on Heartbleed
Eh, I remember how about a month ago when that recent GnuTLS bug was found the almost dominant sentiment on HN was along the lines of "how come anyone is using GnuTLS instead of OpenSSL", "GnuTLS codebase is horrible, use OpenSSL", "the guy maintaining GnuTLS is an idiot, use OpenSSL", "OpenSSL has more expert eyes on it", etc. Although I prefer OpenSSL (for no particular reason), this all seemed so obviously stupid and shortsighted, not to mention some of it factually wrong. And what do you know, a month later we get an order of magnitude worse bug in OpenSSL which was also probably an order of magnitude easier to detect. I made a comment[0] then along that line, thinking to myself that I'd really hate if I got to say "told you so" but that unfortunately I probably will get the chance. I didn't think it would be this bad though.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7346879

nzp··on 0^0
That's because Wikipedia isn't a tool to learn mathematics. Wikipedia articles (on anything) are not meant to teach about a subject (in the sense of schooling) but rather to give an exposition of a subject. It is considered to be very bad style on Wikipedia to write articles that try to teach the reader as a textbook or a class would.
nzp··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
Hm, I wouldn't say normal people, but subpopulations of normal people (i.e. not individuals but groups). It's an important distinction in this case. But it depends on how CIA analysts' estimates are aggregated if at all. In fact it would be extremely interesting if CIA normally got predictions by averaging multiple analysts' estimates. That would mean normal people with open source intel are beating trained analysts with confidential intel! In that case, we could say normal people beat CIA analysts. But to me this article implies analysts' estimates are not taken as averages. Any CIA analysts here to set the record straight? :)
nzp··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
Well, I didn't mean your comment was a case of naivete, because, TBH, the analogy with my layman physics example isn't perfect, but it reminded me, it's a similar thing: people who are or should be aware that they have only superficial info on something, act as though what they know is all there is to it. The point is, we can't possibly come up with a meaningful critique of this research based on the given article, and, I think, the most reasonable course of action in this particular case is to assume the researchers know what they're doing (considering who's involved).
nzp··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
Heh, actually, kudos to joshuahedlund[0], I found it in his comment.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7515263

nzp··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
> It just reduces the size of the crowd and shows a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics.

Why do you assume that what's in the NPR article is all there is to it, that there's no info, technical or other, left out?

Of course they thought of that, and checked. There's no regression to the mean, the elite group further improved, their estimates were 65 % better than the overall crowd.[0]

[0] http://www.economist.com/news/21589145-how-sort-best-rest-wh...

nzp··on A group of 3,000 citizens is making better forecasts than CIA analysts
In general these are valid remarks. But we're not talking about random clueless people deciding to play statistics, the research is obviously conducted by people who know how this kind of stuff (statistics) works. This reminds me of laypeople trying to poke holes in theories of physics (and I'm not talking about quacks and lunatics, just well intentioned people who think they have a better explanation based on rudimentary high school or even undergraduate science and math). It's such a charming, cute naivete. Do they really think their simple ideas never occurred to a single professional physicist who immediately saw it was wrong for a number of reasons?

So, do you really think the researchers in this case hadn't thought of this? I mean yeah, it's OK to doubt and inquire, but come on, this is so rudimentary...

> If the questions are all yes/no questions

The article says (or at least implies) that the subjects give probabilities of "yes" to each question.

EDIT: Oh, and to add, the article clearly says they're not just making shit up and randomly coming up with probabilities. They collect open source info on events and base their estimates on that. So it's not just blind guessing.

nzp··on Turkey has blocked Google DNS access to Twitter
He's probably referring to considerable fascist elements in the Maidan movement. The Right Sector[1] and Freedom[2] (formerly called Social-National Party of Ukraine). The former is "just" fascist, and the latter is neo-nazi.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_Sector

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svoboda_(political_party)

nzp··on Turkey has blocked Google DNS access to Twitter
You made a racist statement. "Unorganized dirty jungles" of Asia in contrast to, presumably, tip-top, spotlessly clean, perfectly organized European cities...
nzp··on 2048: The Nihilistic Face Of Free To Play
It seems he's promoting himself in a professional capacity with the site, for example: http://mobilemavericks.eu/work-with-us/ It would be really... courageous if he did it with an Onion style site. I too hope OP is right, though.
nzp··on 2048: The Nihilistic Face Of Free To Play
Wow, just wow. I'm not exactly a youngster without life experience about what kinds of sleaze bags people can be, but I'm still amazed and shocked when I see the liberties such people allow themselves in what they say or write. That a grown, sane person has such a lack of morals to allow oneself to drop to such levels of absurdity and dishonesty to accuse people of nihilism for giving away something valuable for free to all to use and improve is deeply troubling. This is sociopathic behaviour, plain and simple.

This is about mere games, and I hate to trivialize serious social events by comparing them to such mundane things, but these kinds of drivel always remind me of McCarthy--Welch exchange in the Senate hearings[0]. "Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?"... What else can you say to such persons... And yet since they don't have any sense of decency or shame it doesn't bother them when you confront them with their despicable behaviour.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1eA5bUzVjA

nzp··on College Notebook by Isaac Newton
With all due respect to those comments, would it really be a loss? I really, really don't want this comment end up taken as a personal attack on those commenters, that's not the point or intent. Rather, the point is let's rationally, without emotions about our egos, question what is the point of those comments. There is none. If you like something, you upvote, and iff you have any new information to add, add it. It's bearable in a submission with a low number of comments such as this, but in large ones, there tends to be also a large amount of such redundant comments. There is simply no point in posting such comments---they don't get you any karma (I hope!), they don't add any information useful to anyone, and they make it harder to go through the whole comment set.
nzp··on Poll: The new HN comment system – agree, disagree, or wait and see?
When I first learned today about this change my knee jerk reaction was the same as with most people commenting on this---it will be horrible, it will enforce groupthink, it will stifle discussion, and so on. But after some thinking, I realized it's just a knee jerk.

The thing is, HN doesn't have a problem with rudeness or bad comments that existing voting can't solve (as far as I can see). But, I do think that HN has a problem with the amount of comments on popular submissions, and of a huge amount of comments which are nominally OK (i.e. not rude, not wrong, not trolling...) and therefore cannot in good conscience be downvoted, but whose information content is near 0. With low total amount of comments, this wouldn't be a problem because most of these kinds of comments are a consequence of there being a non-manageable amount of total comments for the speed at which content goes through HN---most people don't have the time to go through the whole lot and check what has been said/pointed out/asked, and that leads to a lot of redundancy. This is very exhausting to read through, and really is a problem of signal to noise ratio, but the "noise" on HN is not the stupid or the rude (those get blasted away quickly), it's just the well meaning, decent but redundant comment made because one has something to say but can't be bothered (rightfully so when there are 300+ comments already!) to check if it's been said already.

A recent example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7427542 This was just horrible! Comment after comment telling him the exact same thing (change your CV) with almost the exact same specific advices. I went through the whole thing because I was interested and wanted to see what people have to say about this, but I was completely exhausted at the end because there was so much redundancy.

Why do I think pg's plan with pending comments would improve this? The first order effect would probably be a dramatic decrease in number of comments. The second order effect would then be that it's much, much easier to go through the whole thing and see if there's any new information you can contribute to the topic, which, if we are sane people, will lead to a dramatic decrease in noise (redundancy) (I say "if we are sane" because I take it that a sane person won't repeat already stated ideas just for the sake of repeating).

This is why I'm currently strongly in favour of the way the idea was presented originally with some tweaks that have been mentioned in the original thread yesterday. I see now that it's off by default and only per item tree, thus only serving as a weapon against rudeness and flame wars. As I don't think HN has that problem so I don't see the point of the whole thing as it stands now. I would much rather if the original form was given a chance with the mentioned fixes and attentive parameter tweaking.

As for fears of "echo chambers" and such, I don't see that currently on HN and I'm willing to give people here the benefit of the doubt that they would in aggregate do the right thing. If, on the other hand the community is so bad to end up using this as a tool for censorship then I don't think it would be a shame to have it fall apart anyway. So I don't think there's anything to lose. Useful back and forth discussions would still be able to go on with parameters reasonably tuned.

Also, I notice that a lot of people mistakenly think that 1000+ karma means your posts get auto-approved. But that's not the case, it requires 10k+ karma! Realistically, most people will never reach that even with the system as it is now, so that's completely irrelevant. Users with 1000+ karma would not be in any particular commenting advantage if the proposed change went through.

nzp··on Larry Page: I’d Rather Leave My Billions to Elon Musk Than to Charity
> Nobody's suggesting we get rid of capitalism.

With all due respect, speak for yourself.

nzp··on Larry Page: I’d Rather Leave My Billions to Elon Musk Than to Charity
I'm not sure about the US, but USSR developed one, the Energia II. It was AFAIK never built, it shared the destiny of the rest of the Energia/Buran programme, but they were certainly able and did try. I can't find any references ATM, but I'm pretty sure the US also had plans for a fully reusable Shuttle complex, before the whole thing got ridiculous in planning stages.

EDIT: And what's with the fixation on reusable rockets? It might lower some cost but it's hardly an amazing feat of science and engineering.

nzp··on Larry Page: I’d Rather Leave My Billions to Elon Musk Than to Charity
So if you were Page, you would hold Musk to the same accountability standards? (Anyway, I don't think this accountability thing has anything to do with Page's motives).
nzp··on Systems Past: The software innovations we actually use
I upvoted you because I think this is an interesting line of reasoning, but I disagree that it's a very useful one.

You seem to be implicitly defining "computation" as that which a physical computer does (machines, biological brains...). Something that literally consumes physical resources. By that logic, a Turing machine is not a computer and lambda calculus is not about computation. As I said, you could spin the semantics that way but is it useful? Does that give us useful insights?

Functions are not just syntactic notation. Functions are, by definition, mappings from set A to set B. They don't have anything to do with notation. "cos(x)" is merely a notation, yes, but not of a number but of a function. This is an important distinction. "cos(5)" evaluates to a certain number, yes, but it's not just syntactic sugar for that number. Not to mention that functions don't need to operate on sets of numbers.

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →