HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

objclxt

8,423 karma · joined September 8, 2011

submissionscomments
objclxt··on CivitAI Policy Update: Removal of Real-Person Likeness Content
> MasterCard and Visa have no business unilaterally, secretly, and unaccountably policing their idiosyncratic idea of moral righteousness. They need to move money and shut up.

Mastercard and Visa don't block companies from processing because of morals, they block them because they lose them money. They will happily process your payments for all kinds of shady schemes that are - to them - low risk.

objclxt··on On loyalty to your employer (2018)
> the OP is in the EU and UK, where none of the above is true.

You can absolutely be dismissed without cause in the UK, protections against this only kick in after two years of employment.

objclxt··on AI hallucinations: Why LLMs make things up (and how to fix it)
> Gemini and Chat GPT with search are both perfectly capable of producing decent essays with accurate citations

OK, but this quote from your essay:

> The National Cancer Institute (NCI) reports that "cigarette smoking and exposure to tobacco smoke cause about 480,000 premature deaths each year in the United States."

...that citation is wrong. It's not from the NCI at all, the NCI cited that figure which came from another paper by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

The essay doesn't have accurate citations, the model has regurgitated content and doesn't understand when that content is from a primary source or when it in turn has come from a different citation.

objclxt··on Forced to upgrade
> Some people prefer to handle their devices with care and expect to get longevity in return

I guarantee you however carefully you are handling your device it is a world apart from a datacenter.

objclxt··on Forced to upgrade
> It does seem to very much just be at the consumer level. We've still got servers chugging away in datacenters that are pushing 15 years old and still have several years of life left in them.

The datacenter is temperature controlled and the air is filtered. The server is locked in the rack and never moves. By comparison, your laptop or your phone go through hell on a daily basis.

objclxt··on New Mac Mini with M4
The entry-level 2014 Mac Mini had a launch price of 499 EUR, I'm not sure it was ever that cheap new. If anything the price has deflated.
objclxt··on Arm is canceling Qualcomm's chip design license
> question: isn't arm somewhat apple?

Not for decades. Apple sold its stake in ARM when Steve Jobs came back, they needed the money to keep the company going.

objclxt··on Gen AI Makes Legal Action Cheap – and Companies Need to Prepare
> Can you explain your thinking as to how and why it might work?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prosecution

...has a good summary of how it works in a number of countries.

objclxt··on DOJ accuses Visa of monopoly that affects price of 'nearly everything’
> It looks like Visa debit fees are about $0.21 + 0.05%. Compare that to cash handling...

Debit fees are that low because of the Durbin Amendment, which legislated caps on debit card fees (amongst other things). Credit card fees are where the real money is made, and the meat of the complaint here.

objclxt··on Amazon tells employees to return to office five days a week
> when they do go into the office, they’re just having Zoom calls in the office instead. That’s what Amazon is trying to fix here.

Not really. At a company the size of Amazon teams are often in other buildings, if not other cities or countries entirely. The zoom calls continue unabated.

objclxt··on Medieval
> Is "musicians who don't even know the genre they'll use professionally yet" a valid market in the first place?

That's not really Teenage Engineering's primary market, in the same way Rolex's primary market isn't "people who need to tell the time". Both T.E and Rolex products do their jobs really well, but the people buying them are buying more for the aesthetic than the function.

Teenage Engineering are primarily a design boutique, although musicians do use their products their main audience are collectors / audiophiles / graphic designers going through a mid-life crisis.

objclxt··on CrowdStrike's impact on aviation
> I don’t know if this is standard for software

This is pretty standard. There is almost identical language in the Windows and macOS EULAs, for example.

objclxt··on Google to shut down Google One VPN on June 20
> I was really hoping Portal was going to catch on, I really liked it and found it to be a great home VC platform.

I worked on Portal and it came down to:

1. Cambridge Analytica. It is difficult to persuade people - and the media - you can be trusted to put a camera in their homes while you’re fighting a massive privacy scandal.

2. A leadership coup resulted in the project moving under Reality Labs, which never really wanted to be in the smart device business in the first place.

There were a bunch of other issues, but these two basically doomed the project from the start, which is a shame as it was well received by those who actually bought it.

objclxt··on The Lunacy of Artemis
> They do this on earth every time they fuel the rocket. I understand it will be more difficult in space, but I don’t see why specifically this problem is the real engineering target over say, reuse.

The article goes into this in some detail. In particular:

* You have to get the propellant into space. This is going to take a large number of flights (~15) at a pace that has not been done before for a vehicle of that size (a launch every six days)

* You need to launch at pace because otherwise the propellant will boil off, which is another issue - you need to shade or insulate the propellant for a much longer period of time in much harsher conditions

* There is no gravity: whereas on earth the propellant separates relatively cleanly into liquid and gas this isn't the case in space

objclxt··on Anatomy of a credit card rewards program
> this is why crypto never took off as a replacement for credit cards

If this were true you would expect crypto to have taken off in countries with low interchange rates. Europe, for example, has far less of a rewards and points culture for payment, and (compared to the US) much lower interchange.

Crypto never took off as a replacement for credit cards for many reasons - the biggest coins out there are simply too volatile to be usable as a currency, they lack the consumer protections you get paying with a credit card, and they’re simply too complex for an average person to understand.

objclxt··on JPMorgan to sell customer transaction data to advertisers
> a lot of transaction data is already leaked to wallet providers (Google, Apple, Samsung) […] Note that these wallets get access to ALL card transactions, including physical card swipes, and not just those conducted via their platform.

That’s not true at all for Apple Pay: “Apple Pay doesn’t collect any transaction information that can be tied back to the user. Payment transactions are between the user, the merchant and the card issuer.”[1]

The system is designed such that transactional information goes directly from the bank’s server to your device, and doesn’t pass through Apple’s servers (unless you’re using Apple Card)

[1]: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/security/sec82e7bc3f8/...

objclxt··on Julian Assange granted permission to appeal against extradition to US
> I wonder what would happen if the US gave these assurances then broke them ?

The English courts are permitted to take into account whether assurances for previous extraditions have been complied with:

> When considering the adequacy of an assurance in any particular case, the courts should place appropriate weight on any assurance previously obtained in extradition requests from the same requesting country.

http://data.parliament.uk/DepositedPapers/Files/DEP2016-0191...

...this is of little comfort to Assange, but it does mean that there is an incentive for the country issuing the assurances to comply with them, otherwise their future extradition requests have a greatly increased chance of being denied.

objclxt··on British Library cyber incident review [pdf]
> I'd go further, we've turned a celebration of ignorance around cybersecurity and dismissive attitudes into virtuous slogans.

> "Don't make me think" - Krug

That quote has nothing to do with cybersecurity, it's the title of a book by Steve Krug about web usability.

I am unfortunately old enough to have read that book when it first came out, and it's exclusively around how to design front-end UIs on websites to reduce user complexity. There is no mention of infrastructure or security at all.

You're making a quote around how we should make websites more usable and understandable to users - so they can use them without thinking - into something it isn't.

objclxt··on Spotify will reduce total headcount by approximately 17%
> I can accept that... if it's said how exactly.

You are assuming that Spotify is just the consumer facing app, but it's not. It's far more.

You've got all the bits of Spotify you don't see. Like:

* Apps and interfaces for labels to ingest their music

* Reporting and billing so all those labels get paid

* An ad platform to service free-tier users

* Embedded systems. Did you know Spotify has a commercial hardware division to integrate Spotify onto smart speakers and devices?

The surface is huge.

objclxt··on Spotify will reduce total headcount by approximately 17%
> When I was junior I used to buy this explanation, but 9,000 developers is probably more then are actually working on huge projects like Linux

They don't have 9000 developers, they have 9000 employees.

objclxt··on Nvidia sued for stealing trade secrets: blunder showed rival company's code
You realize the patent you’re referring to was a design patent, not a utility patent? They are very different, the former only covers look and feel, not method.
objclxt··on Why TSA's Implementation of Facial Recognition Is More Dangerous Than You Think
> While they sit there holding my passport hostage, scrolling through who knows what data

Legally it's their passport, not yours. A passport is the property of the US government at all times.

objclxt··on Hacking Google Bard – From Prompt Injection to Data Exfiltration
> Maybe every response can be reviewed by a much simpler and specialised baby-sitter LLM?

This doesn't really work in practice because you can just craft a prompt that fools both.

objclxt··on Apple might have to pay that €13B EU tax bill after all
> Did you miss what the article says?

Yes, I read it, including the bit that said the Irish government told Apple their tax affairs were legal.

Apple paid taxes according to the laws that Ireland had at the time. The issue is not that Apple did not pay taxes according to the law, it’s that the laws themselves were incompatible with Ireland’s other obligations.

objclxt··on Warner Bros shelves finished ‘Coyote vs. Acme’, takes $30M tax write-off
> It's pretty unlikely this film will make $30 million

It would easily have made $30 million worldwide. Almost certainly domestic. You could question whether it would have made its budget back (70 million) on domestic, but for a family film with existing IP there aren’t really any blockers to clearing 30 million.

> The effects work is nowhere near done etc.

The film is finished, some critics had already seen it.

objclxt··on BBC World Service Announces Emergency Radio Service for Gaza
> Like bombing every location someone transmits from?

This is a Medium Wave service, it doesn’t work that way. The signals are reflected by the ionosphere, you can broadcast from thousands of miles away.

Nobody is going to be bombing Cyprus, where the BBC transmit from. The best you could do is jam the signal, but that’s cat-and-mouse at best.

objclxt··on Atlassian Acquires Loom
It’s a bargain compared to their Series C valuation in 2021 of $1.5 billion.
objclxt··on Unity’s new pricing: A wake-up call on the importance of open source
Yes, that's why I said "part owned". 40% of Epic is owned by Tencent.
objclxt··on Unity’s new pricing: A wake-up call on the importance of open source
> the fact that they are trying to break the Gplay/Apply monopoly shows that the Epic games leadership are not corporate piranhas like Unity's.

Epic is not doing this out of the goodness of their heart, they're doing it because it is beneficial to them. Epic is a multi-billion dollar corporation part owned by a massive conglomerate.

> BS: in reality it's usually one or two guys who actually do the actual work.

Over the last week, Godot had 32 authors pushing 52 commits. Over the last month it had 135 authors. This is not "one or two guys".

> So if Godot devs stop working on it you're stuck with a project with zero support.

Guess what, if a closed-source company decides to stop working on their product you're also stuck, but now you're even more stuck because you don't have access to the source to make your own changes!

objclxt··on The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera
> Take the record player. It looks cool.

It's not even their product, it's just a white labelled version of an existing Japanese toy!

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/234642185324

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →