HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oldcynic

2,723 karma · joined May 23, 2017

submissionscomments
oldcynic··on Ask HN: Small house vs. big house?
Reverse anecdote here. I paid into my pension and hindsight clearly shows I should have paid off the mortgage instead thanks to horrific long term pension performance. Actually I should have completely skipped any pension at all and paid it into yearly ISAs.
oldcynic··on Ask HN: Small house vs. big house?
Pay off the mortgage.

The sense of freedom and security from no longer being on that particular 25 year debt treadmill is quite profound. Mortgage rates could return to 1980s 10%+ and you couldn't care less.

Course if you're planning on 3 children and you currently have a two bed property I may change my answer.

oldcynic··on Yakhchal: Ancient Refrigerators (2009)
A very good point. After reading the linked 99% piece linked above I'd perhaps extend that to "stigma, hubris and marketing".

It's not very "modern" either is it? Hmm. I wonder if that's why we got the post-war modernism school of architecture. :)

Someone used to monoculture and pesticides presumes dishonesty when hearing about the productivity of permaculture - or even traditional mixed farming as it's comparing mono yields against dozens of crops and livestock at the same time from the acre.

It's a disappointment realising, after visiting a selection of old buildings, just how much nicer the old solutions are for humans to inhabit. You get none of the harsh drying that you do with heating and AC, but you do get small temperature variations and air movement that make it far better.

I haven't come across Earthship before, surprisingly, so thanks for that.

oldcynic··on 'Hot Dog Water' seller in Vancouver gets laughs to prove point
So where do you place Aethaer who are selling bottles of "fresh" air? http://www.aethaer.com/shop There are companies selling other nationalities of air. (It's bad enough just writing that out)

Aethaer seem to have grown since their little bit of viral fame a few years ago.

oldcynic··on Yakhchal: Ancient Refrigerators (2009)
It's more shocking to realise how much we've needlessly thrown away.

There's a vast selection of old architectural techniques for controlling environment that we've thrown away, preferring to bolt an AC unit to a hugely inefficient building instead. Many are free, relying on natural convection and material properties etc, others rely on movement of water like the Yakchal.

Some, but far from all, are coming back to be seen in things like passive houses, but that remains an extremely small niche.

oldcynic··on Loudness Penalty: Find out if audio will be turned down by streaming services
Ironic you pick on Metallica as example as they basically "won" the loudness wars[0] with the release of Death Magnetic. So ridiculously overblown and compressed that it was clipping constantly and heavily featured in mainstream media. Even one of the album's mastering engineers complained.

Lars thought it was great.

[0] http://recordinghacks.com/2008/12/20/metallica-wins-the-loud...

oldcynic··on A world of free movement would be $78T richer
I think Canada and Mexico might take issue with this plan.
oldcynic··on A world of free movement would be $78T richer
Have you tried getting adequate and affordable child care? Fortunately our kids don't need it any more.

It hugely restricts available options. Either from hours available, lengthy waiting lists or simply finding that after paying childcare work is no longer making economic sense.

oldcynic··on Around the World, People Have Surprisingly Modest Notions of the ‘Ideal’ Life
Maybe they should exclude people who've seen Lucy and other such movie silliness.
oldcynic··on People are ‘ghosting’ at work, and it's driving recruiters crazy
Well I sincerely hope this trend catches on. It's about time.

Throughout my career recruiters are active about contact for two reasons only: To chase you for leads and contacts in your current place (sometimes so blatantly that the moment you put the phone down they're calling someone else in the same office and you get strong déjà vu), or when you're #1 chance - so please accept this (role|interview|phone interview). Rest of the time it's like they cease to exist so you never get answer to your question, or find out feedback of an interview.

There were a tiny minority who treated candidates as professional people.

oldcynic··on Ask HN: What are some great books that are relatively unknown in the US?
Is Michael Marshall Smith well known in the US?

Intruders was made into a BBC America series, but his earlier works are much more interesting.

Only Forward, One of Us, What You Make It, or Spares from the nineties are all well written, and all beat any of the suspense he's written as Michael Marshall. He simply seems much better writing near future dystopian sci-fi.

oldcynic··on Ask HN: What are some great books that are relatively unknown in the US?
Seconded. They are excellent. I must re-read them.

Water Margin[0] came to UK on TV in the early 80s from Japanese TV. Gained quite a following.

Journey to the West came to the UK as Monkey[1] (again a Japanese adaptation) around the same time. It was the most ridiculous, weird thing on TV. Most people at school were addicted to it. It became a cult classic. Sadly Saiyuki 2 never made it to the UK.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Water_Margin_(1973_TV_seri... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey_(TV_series)

oldcynic··on A sad update about a scissors maker that went viral
...and? Before Japan it was Hong Kong and South Korea making the crap, before that someone else. South Korea was authoritarian and autocratic, whilst its economy grew at breakneck pace starting in the 60s, and remained so until the late 90s. Japan had democracy thrust upon it rather earlier for well known reasons.

They all seem to take a markedly similar approach to development catch-up, namely a heavy emphasis on education and steadily moving from cheap and inferior copies to local innovation and quality. China is well along that route.

Authoritarianism doesn't rule out development, neither does democracy.

oldcynic··on Poverty reduces brainpower needed for navigating other areas of life (2013)
How many under 18s in that 325m? UBI would be for those of working age would it not?

I've seen arguments UBI should include pensioners, but never for it to include minors.

oldcynic··on A sad update about a scissors maker that went viral
China produces some excellent quality, and a vast amount of awful quality as for the last couple of decades that has been their selling point.

It's not so long ago that it was Japan that produced mostly crap and made lots of inferior copies of western goods. They moved past it, and now are often superior, as will China.

I see it not as China bashing more brand bashing. There's an expectation of quality from some of the old names that built reputation making a particular product. In the main, quality manufacturers that have moved production elsewhere have lost a lot of that quality - wherever they moved it to. Just the same happens when brands become just a word in someone's brand portfolio after they've been bought up a time or two.

e.g. Fiskars are huge and spent the 2000's buying up dozens of famous international luxury brands, closing their factories, and selling much inferior, made elsewhere, products on those brand names.

oldcynic··on A sad update about a scissors maker that went viral
I guess the craftspeople making scissors don't agree.

From occasional hobbies I find the sense of achievement from a manual or engineering task done well is actually far higher than from software. See Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance.

oldcynic··on China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere
Hard to be sure, but the Golf is occupying the same niche, small hatchback, that it was 40 years ago. Half a tonne of extra weight is hard to explain easily though. Wikipedia shows basic dimensions, but doesn't really explain where the weight went. But it's all cars, in all categories, getting bigger and heavier and almost becoming the next model up. There's nothing in what used to be small any more. A BMW 1 series is bigger than the old 3.

Today even downmarket brands like Kia and Daewoo don't have 70s and 80s era lack of equipment - everything comes with air bags, electric windows, ABS, GPS and so on. You used to buy a car and get a heater, maybe a radio. Pay extra for electric windows, sometimes even for mirrors and fog lights. That and more legroom doesn't explain hundreds of kilos and half tonne gains in cars of all types. I think the rest must be structural for crash resistance. Side impact protection needing thicker heavier doors, etc.

Random find: https://www.carthrottle.com/post/10-images-that-show-just-ho...

Comparing current and Mk1 Golf GTI's: http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/volkswagen/golf/87232/long-term... Amazing even the premium GTI had no power steering and no electric windows in the mk1.

oldcynic··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
That's funny, I've read the claim multiple times in the media amongst the controversy over its procurement. Not least because it took years for the US:UK dispute over technology transfer to resolve during the Bush+Blair years.

Even since resolution there's unprecedented restrictions of maintenance in RAF service, requiring some major components returned to BAe in the US when BAe are a British based company.

I'm on my way out but a quick search seems to show Israel as having the least restricted version, which is a surprise: https://www.wired.com/2016/05/israel-can-customize-americas-...

Some discussion of the Blair era issues: https://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/uk-warns-usa-over-itar-...

oldcynic··on Future generations will laugh in horror and derision at the folly of facadism
It would be cheaper to fully demolish and rebuild with a typical bland curtain wall box. So where's the economic case? There doesn't appear to be one. If it's a means of evading some regulation I'd have expected a regulatory response to such piss taking since this trend started in the 90s.

Most people who aren't architects seem to dislike modern buildings and facadism seems a way of evading rather than addressing the argument.

oldcynic··on Google Engineers Refused to Build Security Tool to Win Military Contracts
Isn't it the case that the only nation getting an F35 comparable to the US version is the UK? It's unclear if even that version is the same. Everyone else seems to be getting some sort of F35 lite export version, including Australia, Italy and possibly others.

Is that trusting one's friends or are they too unstable to trust?

oldcynic··on States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court Rules
When I'm buying privately I care about the price I pay - not the price a business can pay when reclaiming the VAT. It's not like VAT is going away with next change of govt, or even with Brexit. Everything gives you a receipt breaking out the VAT or shows it in the online basket and checkout for those that care, or reclaim, so I don't see how it lacks transparency.

Why does it matter who of buyer or retailer covers the few pennies, or if retailer makes a small price change to stick at a .99 or .00 price point? Retailers have done this forever in both directions.

oldcynic··on China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere
> Individual car weight has diminished enormously during the last 50 years

Actually quite the reverse. Individual car weight has increased enormously. The Mk1 Volkswagen Golf (1974) weighed 790-970kg. The current Mk7 weighs 1351-1395kg. An F Type Jag is 200kg heavier than an E Type.

Cars have been increasing in size such that a "Mini" is anything but (try parking one next to the original Issigonis Mini). They contain a vast range of electrical toys like aircon, ABS, airbags that add a lot of weight, and structural features like crumple zones, catalytic converters and so on. Some is the result of mandated emissions and crash regs, a lot is a result of feature-itis from the manufacturers.

That's quite apart from the trend of people choosing ever larger models, and SUVs over saloons and hatchbacks. That fashion just exacerbates the issue.

oldcynic··on China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere
Should we ignore the escalating amounts of waste, mainly from single use packaging, in the developed world meanwhile?
oldcynic··on Future generations will laugh in horror and derision at the folly of facadism
So is the result of just about every facade preservation.

Some fine examples here: https://inspiringcity.com/2016/02/14/facadism-the-laziest-an...

oldcynic··on Future generations will laugh in horror and derision at the folly of facadism
I've never understood the point of this. Why keep the often beautiful Edwardian or Victorian facade if what you construct behind it doesn't respect anything of the original you went to such lengths to keep? Bolt a standard office or apartment complex to the back and pay so little regard that the floors don't even line up with the old frontage or match in any major respect. Just build a cheap office block and be done. At least that's honest.

Then again I suppose that would reveal the Emperor's New Clothes. Modern architecture simply can't do public buildings, balance, aesthetics or anything that isn't either a standard curtain wall box or a £15bn signature tower block.

We didn't learn from all the Victorian buildings pulled down in the sixties that many now regret losing.

oldcynic··on People are recycling too much garbage, and it's threatening the industry
I'm not sure either - and there's one of the problems. We're not given the full cost and consequence of each alternative.

I did read a piece a few months back discussing glass against recycled plastic. Plastic apparently needs far more washing, and at higher temperature and pressure, before it can be recycled. The washing to remove glue, labels and dried food which are all more difficult to get off plastic, and also because plastic recycling is so easy to pollute and ruin the whole batch.

oldcynic··on People are recycling too much garbage, and it's threatening the industry
UK ban of free plastic bags has been a resounding success if you go on the lack of bags littering streets and countryside. Surprisingly perhaps the UK media seems in favour of the straws and stirrers changes (possibly excluding the Daily Mail). Industry has lobbied against both.

It seems equally clear that in the absence of bans and heavy regulation no effort will be made to reduce use so I'd be in favour of everything that pushes back against the growth of single use plastics.

oldcynic··on Learn new technology through writing a tutorial about it
It's great that there's loads of tutorials out there on most topics. it's not so good that so many of them are crap, or straight up wrong.

> it is your responsibility as a learner to decide if something makes sense or not

I disagree. It's on the teacher to explain clearly and accurately. If you can't meet that low bar don't pollute the net. The beginner is usually unable to decide which piece of conflicting advice or misinformation is correct.

For a great example of this see the php reference and the dozens of conflicting comments and recommendations on each language feature. A beginner has none of the nuance needed to decide which are helpful and which are misunderstandings. Or w3schools for an endless litany of poor and partial explanations.

> experts are far detached from the beginner's mindset and often lack the ability to explain something in simple terms

Again that's on the teacher and it need not be the case that an expert is detached (Though some can be). Explaining in simple lay terms is a different skill that is entirely unrelated to expertise of a subject.

You don't need to be expert to write a beginners tutorial, but you really should have the foundation firmly fixed (and validated by others or use) and reasonable ability to write clearly.

Until then writing a "my experience learning x" blog is a far better service to the internet. Save the tutorials a month or two more for when you have enough grasp to be helping rather than hindering.

oldcynic··on Learn new technology through writing a tutorial about it
As a few other comments, and the well known adage, have noted the best way to learn something is to teach it.

But I do take issue with "write a tutorial about it", quite strongly.

Why is teaching so helpful to learning?

It forces you to reuse those recently forged bits of memory by accessing it, along the way it shows up any gaps or misunderstandings. Like rubber duck debugging the mere act of talking through an explanation shows up the gap, and you're missing the next sentence. Now you know what you need to read up on, or clarify.

Here's the crucial bit that writing a tutorial will give you NONE of: In teaching you will explain vaguely, you'll encounter loads of people who thoroughly misunderstand your simple and obvious explanation of, let's say, C pointers. Your explanation might even have been great but surprisingly they got distracted by their phone. Then ask all sorts of inconveniently difficult questions about why their pointer increment is doing strange things, or why the compiler is not happy. You'll sometimes even become completely lost trying to debug someone else's trivial example code.

I think the whole point of the advice to teach something to learn it is this second part. It's the difficult and inconvenient questions that do wonders for your knowledge. Even someone asking "but why?" can have you realising something you just accepted isn't actually that obvious. It takes you far off the few well worn paths in your memory of the subject. Writing a tutorial achieves none of this as you'll mostly write tutorials on the few things you think you know. But don't.

Thank you for making the internet worse.

Teach, then write a tutorial.

You don't need to be years ahead, or subject expert, just weeks or months. Pair programming over skype is just fine. One of the most ridiculous things my second employer did was insist that anyone attending a course taught the others in the office what the course covered the week after. Remarkably useful policy looking back.

oldcynic··on People are recycling too much garbage, and it's threatening the industry
That's... disappointing. I don't know enough about the scheme to comment much. Maybe the fees are low enough to not encourage much change.

Perhaps we need a popular campaign of dumping all the single use plastic back to Tesco etc. :)

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →