HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pantaloons

356 karma · joined May 19, 2011

submissionscomments
pantaloons··on Teachers Don’t Like Creative Students
I'm not sure if you are being deliberately obtuse. The lazy workers are not performing adequately under the system, they are gaming it by focusing only on monitored metrics.

This has real consequences for good teachers, who have to justify what they are trying to teach to a principal who only cares that school funding will be cut unless standardized test scores improve.

pantaloons··on Teachers Don’t Like Creative Students
Did you read what he said? The bad teachers just "teach the test", the good teachers are far better off without state provided standards and equal outcome mandates rendering the entire exercise pointless.
pantaloons··on Howard Buffet will succeed Warren Buffet as chairman of Berkshire Hathaway
Indeed, “In the world’s eyes, I could never be seen as successful as him. My dad and mom always made that clear that was okay,”

Howard was obviously not picked to succeed Warren on merit either, the chances of that are billions to one. Even though I would do the same, I can't help but feel that this kind of nepotism ultimately holds back progress. It's a shame that as humans we can't overcome paternal instincts.

pantaloons··on RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legitimacy of Anonymous
You are correct although there are a myriad of reasons why this doesn't work in practice. Perhaps I should have said augmented overlays, task queuing (macros) and so on instead -- they better illustrate the point.
pantaloons··on RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legitimacy of Anonymous
Ignoring the security through obscurity mess, the more salient point is that there are classes of problems that cannot be solved at present without a locked down client. If solving such a problem is the entire function of the device I don't know that I'm against this.

Technology will eventually solve such problems (thin clients or fully homomorphic encryption) but these have serious issues of their own.

pantaloons··on RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legitimacy of Anonymous
> Cheating would surely be rampant.

Not at all, as it is anybody can modify the game binaries in the same way they would modify the source code (albeit with more difficulty).

Cheating is prevented by having a central server validate all client actions for consistency, or in games without a simulation server (Starcraft II) having clients compare a game state hash and disconnect if they differ.

Client side cheating (Wallhacks, Aimbots) are not preventable without a locked down client, open source or not.

pantaloons··on Matrix multiplication in O(n^2.373)
A bit of a shallow point, but will anyone ever actually implement this algorithm?

I'm having trouble seeing the value of such a paper -- the size of matrices required for this result to have a clear advantage is significant, and that is completely ignoring constant factors, real world performance and parallelization considerations.

pantaloons··on Linux Mint signs a partnership with DuckDuckGo
It creates an incentive for DDG to favor Amazon, or other affiliate pages in their rankings.

A search engine where you pay for Ad placement is very different to a search engine where you (effectively) pay for rankings.

pantaloons··on “When you get right down to it, most security is based on the honor system.”
People find culture fascinating and any show which can present new cultures and institutions in an easily digestible fashion will be popular.

With the "easily digestible" part in in mind I would have to disagree that there is room for a show about software security, The IT crowd is about as close as you are going to get. Obviously I would love for a West Wing or The Wire-esque show in this area but we know how popular they turned out to be.

pantaloons··on Feds Seize 130+ Domain Names in Mass Crackdown
I think he meant DNS zone.
pantaloons··on Feds Seize 130+ Domain Names in Mass Crackdown
First they came for the fake merchandise sites...

> The fact that the authorities have once again launched a large crackdown on “rogue” websites begs the question why this legislation is needed in the first place.

Isn't the difference that SOPA allows them to mandate blocking of non-US domains by service operators? I think it's pretty clear TLDs owned or operated in the US are a lost cause at this point unless other governments oppose the TLD sovereignty claims.

pantaloons··on Image Ad Blending Works Really, Really Well
The ethics aren't as notable here as the incredible mental gymnastics undertaken by the author to pretend that this isn't questionable behavior.

Arguably we shouldn't expect advertisers to play nice, but there is still value in highlighting their transgressions lest they think nobody notices or cares.

pantaloons··on The price of a messy codebase: No LaTeX on the iPad
I'm curious where you get the idea that LaTeX is bug free. In my experience it is rare to find two packages that work together bug free, yet alone the collections of them needed to form even a respectable document.
pantaloons··on time element dropped from HTML5 spec
Bureaucracy is the price we pay for standardization. You imply that there is an easier way that could have standardized these technologies "long ago", I'd like to hear it.
pantaloons··on Jaguar recalls 18,000 cars over major software fault
There's nothing that would delight me less than driving on the road with someone who has hacked their cars firmware.

In any case this seems more like competitive advantage through obscurity than security through obscurity, for the same reason that manufacturers don't include blueprints and engine schematics.

pantaloons··on The Day Comcast's Data Cap Policy Killed My Internet for 1 Year
Regardless, the author broke the rules after being warned and received the punishment which he agreed to. That he should [and inevitably will] get special treatment for a post-hoc "internet access should be a right" post borne of no altruism rubs me the wrong way.
← PreviousPage 3 of 3