HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

personZ

2,015 karma · joined April 2, 2014

submissionscomments
personZ··on Why the Sony hack is unlikely to be the work of North Korea
The budget figure is probably BS.

All military figures are BS. North Korea has 1,000,000 active member troops. Canada has 68,000 active member troops.

North Korea has more of everything than Canada, including aircraft, boats, and even nuclear weapons.

Canada spends $23 billion per year.

And as to forces hardly to be reckoned with, if you're talking in a convention war with the US or something, sure. To put that into contrast with hacking Sony, though, is utterly ludicrous. The latter could likely be achieved paying a group less than it costs to operate a single fighter aircraft for a year.

personZ··on Reaction to the Sony Hack Is 'Beyond the Realm of Stupid'
This is a pandering article where someone acts outraged to pander to an audience.

Firstly, "cyberterrorism" has forever been defined as attacks on computer resources, not attacks on people. If a nation state crippled a business to coerce their actions, that is pretty much spot on with the definition of cyberterrorism.

Secondly, who ever said that such a theater attack would have to simultaneously hit 18,000 theaters? The threat seemed to be that any theater could be at risk. I mean, is ten theater attacks okay? Five? Two? One? Sony and theaters are not the US military or the government. They're a risk abatement private enterprise.

This is a terribly weak article. He redefines existing terminology and then strikes down absurd strawmen to get the cheering crowd to nod along.

personZ··on Putin Blames Outside Forces for Economic Woes
To suggest otherwise is to imply that US oil companies were deliberately holding back on potential profits by not pumping at full production prior to 2011

Most wells don't run at full capacity, and absolutely alter draw speeds to maximize the life and economics of a well. With the drop in prices many large energy companies with the ability to weather these drops in price will of course turn down the taps, reserving the limited holds of their wells for when the price returns. If you have n barrels of oil in your well, and you're certain the price will return to North of $100, might as well save them for then.

new discoveries and technology breakthroughs related to shale and fracking

Fracking is natural gas. On the shale side, it's worth noting that we've known about shale and how to extract it for many, many decades. The only reason it came into the forefront is that the price of oil on the global market finally made it economical -- shale oil is estimated to cost from $25 - $95 per barrel to extract and process. So the paradox is that the collapse of the world price puts a serious wrench in the shale oil production, which purportedly is the reason for the price of oil.

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/21/business/21shale.html?page...

The shale oil industry has had booms and busts before as the price of oil fluctuates.

personZ··on Theater Chains Decline to Show Sony’s ‘The Interview,’ Citing Threats
As unbelievable as many on here seem to find this, North Korea was making threats regarding this movie many months ago. Long before this hack.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-28014069

North Korea was bizarrely sensitive about this movie, and made actual, military threats regarding it.

One of the reasons, I think, that makes so many discount the North Korea angle is the belief that such would be so contrary to normal human behavior. Yet the NK leadership seems to exist in some sort of bizarro world where these sorts of actions are fine.

personZ··on Why the Sony hack is unlikely to be the work of North Korea
No, it's just a third world country, with limited means.

The military budget of North Korea is estimated to be around $10 billion USD. It has a million active troops, 6,600 tanks, 700 MLRS, 460 fighters, and so on.

The country is perilously poor. Many people starve. But the means are there for an operation like this, especially if sponsoring foreign groups, if the motivations allow.

And to counter the growing narrative that the NK thing came out of nowhere as a convenient excuse -- the country was very offended by this movie six months+ ago, long before the hack, to the point of threatening military retaliation if it was released. Engaging in or hiring hacking groups to put the pain to Sony seems entirely within the realm of the possible, though threatening actual terrorism is a bridge too far, and overplayed their hands if they were involved with that.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-28014069

personZ··on Why the Sony hack is unlikely to be the work of North Korea
And America businesses are believing NK is willing to go to war by attacking Americans on America soil because of a movie?

North Korea has repeatedly threatened nuclear war over the most banal thing. Of course it is usually treated rather lightly, but the country does have nuclear weapons.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qd1qR66gcLQ

personZ··on Theater Chains Decline to Show Sony’s ‘The Interview,’ Citing Threats
It's interesting how so many on HN are making such pronouncements, and if they've made them once, their commitment to that line just gets more and more aggressive with each comment.

But seriously, on the matter of motivations -- you're a "black hat" and you decide to screw with Sony. Fun enough, really. If you're something less than mentally incompetent, though, are you then going to threaten literal terrorism? Do you really want to draw the intense attention of very, very well resourced organizations?

If the North Korea angle seems weak, the notion that "random hackers" (the term so commonly used) are doing this for the lulz seems even less likely. There is a line where your probability of remaining unincarcerated drops dramatically.

Somewhere in between are groups who will do things for money -- where the immense risks and operational costs can be made worthwhile. North Korea has the ability to sponsor such groups.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
Your incantation of the logical fallacy is how it often appears in what could best be described as ignorant conversations.

The appeal to authority fallacy is if I measured the acidity in a lake over a long term period, and then presented my findings and someone declares that such can't be the case because the Environment Agency says it's fine. They're undermining my objective, demonstrated efforts with a hand waving appeal to someone else. If, on the other hand, I casually and lazily said "I think that there lake is acidic, no matter what anyone tells me", it isn't an appeal to authority to point out what someone who is undoubtedly in a better position thinks and actually knows.

In this case someone offhandedly, based upon nothing but the fact that they seem to want it to be true, declared the ease with which the Go team -- you know, the actual people working on it -- could add generics. No fuss, no muss. It isn't an appeal to authority to point out that they are in absolutely no position to make such a claim.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
I hope to one day see a thread with no misplaced logical fallacies.
personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
then use it but keep quiet and stop promoting it

Remarkably there has been close to zero promotion of Go on Hacker News. Occasionally various incremental update things appear on the front page, just as there are updates on C# 5, the next version of Java, etc, but there have been shockingly few "Why you should use Go" type posts.

People just use it. They don't advocate it. But when it comes up, inevitably it becomes an advocacy starting point for alternative languages. Somehow every single Go discussion, even about the most banal thing, ends up being about Rust, Haskell, F#, and so on.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
I don't think anyone's threatened by Go.

Yet your final sentence says exactly the opposite, indirectly. As if Go is some sort of scourge that these gallant guardians of language must fight.

Further, if you assess the simplicity of adding generics, and it is at odds with the actual people creating the language and tools (among whom are some of the most respected names in this industry), that's a point when you should stop and reassess your own, outsider-looking-in perspective.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
Nothing ironic about it. There are very vocal, very passionate people who pile the hate on Go in every single discussion regarding it. The list can usually be summarized as "ways that Go is not Haskell".

Which is strange, because a post about Haskell tends to be about Haskell. A post about Go tends to be a lot of people telling everyone how Go is unlike, to its detriment, other languages. Great -- go use those languages.

Why people assume that only people NOT using Go are complaining

HN doesn't have a large community of commentators, and you get to know the common personalities. There are absolutely people building solutions in Go who might think "it would be nice to have generics", and indeed that's exactly why they've never been discounted or denied by the Go team, simply deferred. But these discussions are dominated not by those people, but instead people telling you why Go is not Rust is not Haskell is not C# is not...

What's the point? We have a lot of languages and environments to choose from, and we do. Why are people seemingly threatened by Go? It's bizarre.

Generics are nice and they're important, but there are a lot of nice and important attributes to a language, and they have bigger priorities. If generics were critical to my work, I simply wouldn't use Go (and indeed, for some subsections and components, I don't for that reason. Life goes on. Different tools serve different needs).

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
Given that he has been talking about how much Go sucks for almost the entirety of its existence, I highly doubt they've ever developed in Go. It became something to be an advocate against, not a tool in the belt.
personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
I moved on

This caught my eye because I recall you being someone who has vigorously criticized Go in every single Go discussion. A quick search and I can find lengthy critiques from you going back four years.

It very much seems like you haven't moved on.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
Rust is a much better designed language which solves real problems

Yet remarkably people are solving real problems with Go. Despite all of these dire predictions and pontifications on here by so many mortally offended by Go's existence, people are simply making solutions and moving on.

I don't believe I've heard of a single significant solution with Rust. I mean, I'm sure one exists somewhere, but it seems that it's caught in the advocacy trap of people talking about how great it is (overwhelmingly in Go discussions, it seems), instead of building solutions with it.

personZ··on Summary of Golang Generics Discussion
This is exactly it. There are a lot of people who have argued passionately about this (the same crew of commentators appear with the same complaints in every single Go discussion), and now they are so deep in their advocacy that they feel their pride depends upon aggressively and vigorously defending it. It has gotten worse every time this has come up, and most of the comments are the logical conclusion. I mean seriously one of the comments calls it "ghettolang" without parody. Is this really Hacker News?

And exactly as you said -- for those people so offended by this: Move on. Use something different. Go isn't for you. As someone who has integrated Go very effectively into my life, I'm rather glad the Go team isn't listening to every railing fanatic and their pet issues.

personZ··on The Intel Enigma
Quite the opposite: It's eliminating lock-out, which is where Intel was in an ARM-only mobile world.

Intel has the most advanced fabs in the world, and the limits of their own devices has primarily been their concern about competing with themselves (which I'm sure is still the case. With each new chip they probably have internal negotiations about how to ensure it doesn't threaten their desktop and server chips). If Intel isn't disadvantaged in mobile, only a fool would count them out.

personZ··on The Intel Enigma
To reiterate, given that I apparently failed to communicate this well-

-The mobile space was essentially locked down by ARM. All of the OS', tools, and apps targeted ARM.

-Intel was on the outside looking in, so they starting giving away chips, offering their own engineering to bring Android (and other OS') to x86, and making it a compelling target for the makers.

-Intel x86 OS images for Android became available and production quality (originally only deployed in developing markets as essentially a beta). Intel x86 toolsets were available. Still, though, it didn't matter much because there was no market.

-So Intel gave away their chips. By the tens of millions. These chips are actually quite excellent (great performance, 64-bit, great graphics, low power consumption), but knowing that they were on the outside looking in, they gave them away.

The Android ecosystem now is one where x86 (and soon x86-64) is as supported as ARM is. There are tens of millions of x86 devices, and it's only accelerating. No one can ignore it.

Intel gave away chips because they were at a disadvantage, but they're quickly getting to a position where if they make a very compelling chip they no longer are sabotaged by being an outsider.

personZ··on The Intel Enigma
It isn't better, it isn't cheaper (once subsidies expire), and it doesn't have the diversity of dozens of different SoCs to choose from.

Are you actually basing this assessment on actual facts? Further, as to diversity, Qualcomm 80x absolutely dominates the Android sphere. Vendors aren't making designs with some abstract SoC that they plug in on delivery day -- they are specifically designing devices around a given SoC. Meaning they choose a 805, or K1, or Atom Z3560, and design the product and release it.

personZ··on The Intel Enigma
Once Intel stops wrapping a $50 bill around every Android tablet chip they sell, why would device makers or consumers choose Intel-powered tablets over anything else?

Why wouldn't they is the real question. Previously they wouldn't simply because platform support was mediocre to non-existent, and third party apps didn't support it or ran miserable.

It was an ARM party. x86 was a non-starter. Intel would have zero buyers if they sold at normal prices for what was destined to be a second-rate experience.

Now Android fully supports x86 (and very soon x86-64), and while many third-party apps explicitly support x86 (the NDK makes it a simple extra flag, and of course fully managed apps already fully support it), those that don't still run superbly.

Regularly here on HN we see people who are actually in this industry who don't even realize that Intel and x86 have become serious competitors. That devices they might have used are running it.

Android tablet SoCs are a commodity market with many players

Qualcomm has seen exploding revenues, now pushing $30 billion per annum and great profit margins. It is anything but a "commodity" market, and a few makers are making gangbusters.

personZ··on The Intel Enigma
"Essentially no revenue for Mobile and Communications"

While technically correct, this misses the fact that Intel has been making some huge inroads into mobile (particularly tablets). This isn't reflected in revenue because Intel has quite literally been giving them away, lubricating their use to make up for the industry being heavily ARM-centric.

http://www.zdnet.com/article/intel-to-hit-40-million-mobile-...

There are tens of millions of devices out there running Intel chips, and it is lubricating the world for the platform. Right now there are people who are running Android on Intel devices and they have absolutely no idea that they are -- the various Memo Pads, for instance. The Dell Venues.

The Memo Pad ME572C runs an Atom Z3560, a 64-bit x86-64 processor with four cores, SSE4.2, and a powerful onboard graphics solution.

Intel is laying groundwork. Anyone who looks at the revenue number and counts Intel out is being fooled. In a few years I suspect that many of the same people will be crying foul about Intel having bought themselves into a market they missed.

personZ··on LVM thin volume explained
Tangentially related - https://dennisforbes.ca/index.php/2014/06/28/database-perfor...
personZ··on Comments on the Sony Hack
You could construe that he would be instructing his employees to act illegally if he was a UK CIO.

I don't think you could construe that at all. While everyone is making great hay about his statement, the truth is that every organization makes the compromises that he mentions. While perhaps duplicating what andrewfong said, if security is supreme-

-there is zero worker mobility. Want to work at home, or bring the laptop on the flight? Security threat.

-there is zero internet connectivity. Want to browse at your desk? No chance.

-email attachments? Filesharing? Heck no.

-users have absolutely no rights on their workstation beyond the most rudimentary.

-application sets are extremely restrictive and vetted.

-Want to work in the conference room? Call the security center to configure the IPSec, MAC and port filtering security to allow you to move your locked down desktop.

And on and on. While quite a few on here seem to present the notion that they comply with all best practices, extraordinarily few do (even the NSA doesn't). And those best practices cost in both productivity, worker enjoyment, and direct expenditures.

It is never, and has never been, as easy as security versus no security. Against a dedicated, resourced foe, just about anyone and everyone is vulnerable.

personZ··on Detroit by Air
This is an absurd extrapolation. By this definition we can say that literally everything is "a lot to do with race". Is that useful?
personZ··on Uber’s Worst Screw-Ups
There was a time, not too long ago, when Uber was held high here on HN and most tech sites: Uber represented the democratic, egalitarian alternative to the evil taxi empire. Out with the old king...

As an aside, quite some time ago I canvased a number of taxi companies in the Toronto area to gauge their interest in creating essentially an open platform Uber -- a product that would offer a rich user experience similar to Uber (not copying Uber, but naturally the functionality will converge), but integrated with their dispatch systems and so on. Running a contract development shop, I was essentially pitching a researched, well considered solution to the Uber threat. There were no biters (even though those same companies seem to have endless time to petition in the media and government), and it remains a silo'd world of terrible apps, and still a fertile ground for disruption.

personZ··on Detroit by Air
The context of this discussion is the "rebirth" of Detroit, not race riots or the 1950s. If Detroit's rebirth is a high-skill, high-tech industry, the exclusion of many Detroit residents has everything to do with skills and education, and absolutely nothing to do with race.
personZ··on Detroit by Air
It's a lot about race

You just made it about race, but really it's talent pool and demographics and education/skill levels. If a software group moves to downtown Detroit, it seems destructive to hold that as a negative, as if having some bright spots is somehow a negative because that software group doesn't hire the pipe fitter with the a grade 7 education.

personZ··on Why you should move your startup to a small fishing town
Exactly how the conversation would go if it ever happened to me.

Look at the entire business model of Silicon Valley -- the vast majority of hires are fresh graduates. Party because of ageism, but also because fresh graduates are the ones who are willing to uproot their lives and move to some place with a not particularly compelling quality of life, with enormous costs of living, just to get a job. The reality is that the Valley isn't necessarily drawing the best of the best from across the continent: They're drawing the ones who are willing to move, which overwhelmingly means people just starting their adult lives.

So if someone wants to hire new graduates, being in a more remote location might be completely tenable, if not optimal, to their strategy. It is a filter.

And then there are remote workers. I live on a sprawling property in the rural extents of the exurbs of Toronto. If I worked a traditional SD job it would be a terrible commute, but I do the vast majority of my work completely remotely, with redundant high speed connections and some fat computing hardware. There is absolutely nothing that being in the center of it offers me. On the flip side I often have peers and clients to my property for BBQs and a good time.

personZ··on XSLT is a failure wrapped in pain
It's a simple data format and needs no new feature.

XSLT was developed entirely independently of XML. XML Schemas were developed entirely independently of XML.

XML itself is absurd simple. It is the epitome of simple. But you build an ecosystem of tools and standards around it. And that is of course already happening in JSON -- JSON Schemas, for instance, are now a thing.

personZ··on XSLT is a failure wrapped in pain
It's a glorious time in software development when people who make and use trivial web apps think that their domain dominates, and that their superficial knowledge reigns supreme.
← PreviousPage 2 of 18Next →