HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pigpang

22 karma · joined March 12, 2024

submissionscomments
pigpang··on Hacking the genome of fungi for smart foods of the future
You already eat crabs, crayfish, shrimp, and honey. Asian peoples also consume many other insects as food, which reduces the demand and price for Western food.
pigpang··on Aegis v3.0 – a free, secure and open source 2FA app for Android
There is no way I will install authentificator as flatpak.
pigpang··on New studies suggest millions with mild cognitive impairment go undiagnosed
Moreover, they can be elected too. Great minds think alike.
pigpang··on Genetically engineering koji mold to create a meat alternative
Then natural meat producers will be forced out of bisness, then artificial food producers will shrinkflate and shitflate their product.
pigpang··on Japan's Space One rocket explodes seconds after liftoff
Design of those rockets is based on design of missiles, where time to hit is the most important thing. Fully electric space launcher or space lift will be much slower, but safer.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
LIGO/Virgo are better version of Michelson-Morely experiment. Gravitational waves are found, so existence of a medium is confirmed.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
Ether now known as "physical vacuum". As I told you already, expansion of spacetime is the mathematical tool, like a shader in OpenGL.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
> No, it's not, it's our best current model's description of the actual physical reality of our universe.

OK, it's our best model, but it doesn't invalidate other models, less complete or less popular, it compete with them.

> That's true, but it's also true that we can show models to be incorrect, as in, falsified by the data.

Yep. The article is about the Huble Tension, which invalidates Big Bang model. We still use it.

> the second is known to be false because there is no "gravitational redshift" of light in the universe as a whole (because models in which there would be such a redshift are known not to correctly model our data on the universe as a whole)

The Big Bang model is incomplete too: galaxies with FTL speeds, different speeds of expansion, no center of bang, no flows, no source of energy, it stretches time and space, etc.

I assume that the only infinite thing in infinite Universe is Universe itselft. All other things are finite. Thus, a photon has finite life, like any other wave.

> there is no "end of the medium"

The right-hand rule in EM suggests that we are in north hemisphere of something, so south hemisphere will have symmetrical rule, unless you believe that God chose right-hand rule for the whole infinite universe. If we are in a sphere, then that sphere rotates and have a boundary.

> what "waves" is the electromagnetic field.

"Field" is an array of numbers. You are mixing model and reality.

pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
Spacetime is 4D array of points. It's like a movie file, but with 3D frames instead of 2D frames (pictures). Expansion of space means that coordinates of points in a frame changed to move away from us, to match movie (model) with reality.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
I have my own theory, which is not disproved yet: gravitational background noise slow down light a bit. Gravitation affects whole stream of photons in uniform way, not individual photons. Moreover, it doesn't change direction of photons, so no blur or scattering. My napking maths, which I did few months ago, tells that gravitational delaying should case effect of same magnitude as in red shift, (I did calculation for one frequency only, for proper calculation I need to know the temperature of the noise).
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
"Field" means 3d array of numbers. Spacetime means 4d array of numbers. You are talking about mathematical model of Universe, while I'm talking about physics. Mountain is not just an excitement in a height field. If photon is not waving something, then it's not a wave. Physicists prove that photon is a wave.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
My theory is that redshifting caused by gravitational background noise. I did calculation somewhere on HN or Youtube few months ago and numbers are of same magnitude.
pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
It's just an interpretation. Your interpretation is similar to the Big Bang model of visible Universe expansion. If you can convince us that your model is better than other models, then we will use your model, but nobody can prove than a model is correct, unless we will find a hidden recorder somewhere which was turned on for few dozens of billion years.

Photon will hit something, or will travel until it will be redshifted to obvilion, or will travel until end of the medium (photon is a wave, so it waves something).

pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
> That seems contradictory and unintuitive, that two observers moving away from each other both measure light moving c relative to themselves, but that’s reality.

Light is a wave. Photon is a complex thing (Hopfion?), but it's a wave, so it waves something, a medium. Speed of wave propagation in a medium is constant. IMHO, it's intuitive.

pigpang··on Webb and Hubble confirm Universe's expansion rate
Unfortunatelly, title of article on HN contradicts content of article, so many HN readers skip article because of "confirmed" (in other words: nothing new).

IMHO, a Tired Light theory will better explain facts, but it will require paradigm shift, so there will be a lot of resistance before revolution.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2