HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

placebo

1,001 karma · joined October 7, 2014

submissionscomments
placebo··on The Best Books on the Philosophy of Mind
When someone tells me they know how to fly, I first ask them to show me before claiming they are full of it.

Of course philosophy has value but I too am quite disappointed how easily it enables very basic flawed assumptions to exist over eons even in what would be considered high academic levels. To me it feels like the equivalent of physicists today being divided on whether the earth revolves around the sun or vice versa.

Personally I think both Searle and Dennet are essentially dualists (though they'd both vehemently deny it), but each practicing a different form of dualism: Searle promoting some mysterious consciousness as some ghost in the machine, and Dennet protecting physicalism which in my book negates any subject from existing, in complete contradiction to the reality that any object (physical or otherwise) will always be just a model in someone's experience. I see Dennet as trying to squash dualism by giving the model more validity than the very real experience from which it arises, where the better path to eliminate dualism would be to try and get to the source of this division.

placebo··on Inheritance Often Doesn't Make Sense
We haven't been given an expiration date regarding ignorance and inexperience so it's no surprise we see it in 2018 or that we will continue to see it well into the future. An interesting question is whether the amount remains relatively the same or there's some "evolutional" trend, but this seems very hard to both quantify and qualify.
placebo··on Physicists propose experiment to see the ‘grin’ of quantum gravity
I find the subject fascinating, but the main impact I got from reading this was learning how a young, curious, extraordinarily intelligent person with immense potential and who already contributed so much is murdered by human stupidity. I'm reminded of a line from Elton John's song about John Lennon's death, "It's funny how one insect can damage so much grain" and wonder about the amount of grain destroyed by insects such as Hitler, Stalin and so many others. Don't have much of a point to make, just some reflections about the human condition
placebo··on Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance?
I understand that space "shrinking" is a perspective (which is why I originally placed it in double quotes) and that velocity is relative - my question was meant more as a thought experiment of taking the subjective experience of what things seem like as relative velocity increases and then extrapolate it to what they might seem like as relative velocity approaches the speed of light, i.e what would experience be like were it possible to ride on a photon. Since riding on a photon is not possible, perhaps this question is meaningless - it's just that since there is a pattern to how space is experienced with increasing relative velocities, the tendency is to extrapolate this to try and imagine how space/time would be experienced if it were possible.

That being said, I understand that a "universe of length zero" or "no time" is not relevant nor practical in the context of doing physics.

placebo··on Can retrocausality solve the puzzle of action at a distance?
Not a physicist so please bear with me:

Isn't this just an argument about definitions? It makes no sense to say that the universe has 0 size from a photon's reference frame and it also makes no sense to say the photon has a reference frame, but intuitively the experience of space "shrinking" with correlation to higher velocity for the viewer in some reference frame suggests that the as the reference approaches the speed of light, the length of space approaches zero, and while it makes no sense to speak of something with mass traveling at the speed of light, the intuition is that from that imaginary perspective space has no size.

placebo··on Atari 8 Bit Computers FAQ
After squeezing all the potential I could off my VIC-20 (and there was way more than meets the eye), I bought a 2nd hand Atari 400 which was fitted with an actual keyboard. Never asked them how they did it and never bothered to check if this was something you could add for a price or whether it was a home-made hack by the guy I bought it from - anyway, many fond memories of endless hours of gaming, though all those gaming hours meant that I developed and experimented on it far less than the previous VIC-20 ... :)
placebo··on Is Loneliness a Health Epidemic?
it's not about the number of people you are surrounded by but the depth and nature of relationship with them. Wasting energy showing off one's own conformity and following other people's conformity to society's current trend for what makes you a valuable person is bound to eventually make you crazy.

I figure that If you have the bare necessities covered (roof over your head, enough income for surviving) then you're already in a good position to reassess and build your happiness on foundations which are more solid than how many likes you receive on social media.

placebo··on Slow Thought: a manifesto
nice, thanks :)
placebo··on A Simple Algorithm That Ants Use to Build Bridges
I don't know enough about evolution so this could be way off, but I'd guess the idea is that nature "designs" the algorithm via evolution (imagine some Turing machine's code/neural net equivalent being slowly improved by trial and error over hundreds of millions of years) where the result appears like minimising a global cost/action-value function of the species and maximising its probability of survival. The question if this is different in principle from nature "implementing" a supernova or "implementing" electromagnetism or "implementing" a planet is an interesting one, but it seems like in both cases once it starts (cosmic evolution or life evolution) mathematics can be used as a map of the territory.
placebo··on Electron 2.0.0 beta
Resource usage in this reality will only become reasonable when there will be a noticeable penalty involved in unreasonable usage, but I guess it boils down to what you define as reasonable: If a noticeable penalty is measured by the end user then - sorry, enough users just don't care, which enables this technology to continue to gain popularity. If there was a law that companies need to pay a percentage of the energy their applications use then you'd quickly see everybody moving not only to native apps, but to the most efficient native apps.

In the meantime, the invisible hand is doing it's thing. Time will tell what it's thing will look like.

placebo··on Beverly Clock
I wonder if a similar principle could have been used in the construction of the late Dr David Jones’s bicycle wheel:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4762778/How-r...

placebo··on Are Monads a Waste of Time?
I think at the right dosage, it's welcome. For me, mild doses of good humour upgrade the most serious of discussions without detracting from their professionalism.
placebo··on Fake news is not the real problem
You're right that it would be nice if the article would provide more evidence to back that claim up (especially given the article's content), however I don't think it's such an outlandish claim if you look at the facts. To greatly oversimplify (with the inherent dangers of oversimplifying), suppose 50% of the population believes news item "A" is true while the other 50% of the population believes "not A" to be true. There could be different reasons for such a scenario, but if "A" is something that can actually be verified with relative ease, then having such a high percentage of people disputing "A" could very well imply that way too many people are more interested in holding on to an opinion that suits their agenda (be it psychological, political or other) than to seek out what is true.
placebo··on What Does It Mean to Die?
Only noticed your reply now. Can continue discussion via email if you're interested, but will quickly refer to what you've mentioned:

I'm aware of Tegmark's view and was quite intrigued by it at the time, but I see it more as statement suggesting that mathematics can serve as the perfect map for physics to eventually uncover rather than that mathematics can be the territory itself (Max might disagree though). I don't think I can put it any better than the eloquent way Hawking stated it about what is it that breathes fire into the equations. Having a perfect description does not create a reality, and even if quantum mechanics, gravitation, dark matter, dark energy and whatever other mysteries that no doubt will surface in the future will be perfectly understood and unified under an elegant and perfect mathematical description, it still won't explain how existence exists (and I'm not referring to the big bang - I'm referring to the very current reality). Putting it simply, the "is-ness" of reality is not the same as the rules it adheres to, since rules don't create a reality. We attempt to understand reality by noticing consistencies in our interaction with it, and then somehow confuse these consistencies (which we label with certain concepts) with the reality that generates them - or worse yet, think that these consistencies that we notice create reality.

Glad we are in sync regarding the soft problem. In order to be in sync regarding the hard problem, we should agree on what it is. Basically to agree on what the hard problem of consciousness is, we must agree that a subjective experience of being conscious is a very real thing, but at the same time there is nothing physical about the experience - measurable physical things can be correlated to the experience or even cause it, but there is nothing measurable about the very real subjective experience. That's the problem in a nutshell.

By the way, if my explanation implied a belief in dualism then my explanation was obviously inadequate. However, my beef with dualism comes from a completely different angle than the scientific approach (or, more accurately, the approach of physicalism). The ironic thing is that physicalism, which is so opposed to dualism, is inherently dualistic by definition. Try and imagine what any physical object is other than being an interpretation of something from the point of view of a subject that experiences it. Science is so focused on the objects and the relations between them that it completely misses the fact that any conceptual explanation is only made possible by a very subjective explainer.

Not sure I managed to get the point across. There's an article that I liked which ties some of these ideas together in a nice way - perhaps it will do the subject more justice:

http://nautil.us/issue/47/consciousness/is-matter-conscious

placebo··on In Switzerland, it's now illegal to boil a live lobster
I could make a long list of natural behaviours that you really wouldn't want humankind to adopt.
placebo··on What Does It Mean to Die?
Ok, I'll try to explain myself better:

First, of all, it should not surprise you that there are limits to what can be achieved with reason or knowing how things work: Within the boundary of what can be thought about there are already problems that can be proven to be unsolvable, such as finding an algorithm that can tell whether a program will halt or not (undecidable problems), or finding a formal system of rules that is both complete and consistent (Gödel's incompleteness theorem).

Now regarding physics - you said it yourself: The map is not the territory. Physics is nothing more than an ever improving map. It will never be the territory. The mental models you speak of are exactly the ever changing map which attempts to fit reality (which is what exists prior to giving it a name) to concepts which make sense to us. It is crucial to understand that our concepts/thought about reality will only ever be a subset of reality. Equations are nothing more than a description - they are not the thing in itself. Consider the question Stephen Hawking phrased: "What is it that breathes fire into the equations and makes a universe for them to describe?"

The last thing is understanding the difference between the soft problem and the hard problem of consciousness. These two problems are not on the same level at all. The soft problem can be successfully used as the "God of the gaps" type argument and therefore I could in principle agree that it can be eventually be resolved (though I might argue regarding the time frame required to solve it). The soft problem is "simply" fully understanding the functionality of the brain, part of which includes an explanation of which physical processes in the brain are followed by which experiences. The hard problem asks a completely different question: how does a physical process give rise to a subjective experience? Saying that the subjective experience is just some illusion while the physical process is real is silly considering your only access to reality is via your subjective experience, followed by your theories on what that experience means (including the thought that there are such things as physical objects).

Now the reason the hard problem of consciousness appears solvable to many people comes from the mistaken view that consciousness is an emergent phenomena of physical processes, that the "subjective" is emergent from the "objective". These terms are of course necessary for science to exist, but as many wise people who have meditated long and hard on this matter have suggested, the nature of consciousness exists prior to concepts, prior to the division of reality by the mind into subjective and objective and therefore prior to (and so beyond the scope of) scientific inquiry.

placebo··on What Does It Mean to Die?
With all due respect, I take the opinion of neuroscientists on the hard problem of consciousness as seriously as I'd take the opinion of a Zen master on issues in neuroscience.

The fact that neuroscientists might one day deliver an explanation of the soft problem of consciousness (i.e understanding exactly how the brain works and the exact correlation of every state and process to the corresponding subjective experience) will not bring any of us one iota closer to understanding the hard problem. In this case, the fact that one does not recognise there is such a problem implies ignorance more than anything else.

placebo··on In web design, everything easy is hard again
I think it has a great deal to do with abandoning something simple not because it's not good enough to do the job, but because of fear of being left behind, fear of becoming irrelevant in a world where "new and improved" is introduced at an ever growing frequency.

Sure, improvement is a good thing, but the question I think we sometimes forget to ask ourselves is when does the cost involved in certain technological improvements (more learning curves, higher process complexity, energy required to stay on top of the rapidly changing technologies and tools etc.) start to become higher than the benefits produced by the so called improvement.

I've been in this field long enough to see how many times hype beats common sense, unnecessary complexity beats simplicity, and emotion beats logic (heck, I'd bet it's a common theme outside the technology sector as well) but I'm optimistic - the bottom line is that things are improving and even though things sometimes seem circular, it's more of an upward spiral.

placebo··on Cryonics Myths
Thank you, that's news to me. While I still remain skeptical due to the orders of magnitude of complexity in the gap between C. elegans and humans, it definitely calls for a reassessment of the probability I have previously attached to it.

This is why I like HN...

placebo··on Cryonics Myths
As the procedure has not been proved to be reversible, it suggests to me that finding a future cure for the original ailment is the easiest assumption to make in this field. I'm more interested to get better answers to the myth that "Cryonics is not a belief that the dead can be revived" than those presented in the article. I'd be hard pressed to say that there are things I think are impossible, but there are a great many things I think are very improbable. In the movie A.I., there's a part where advanced aliens temporarily restore the life of the hero's "mother" using a lock of her hair and some pseudoscientific stuff about information they managed to retrieve from the space-time continuum. All this without even having access to her brain! Impossible? I don't know - perhaps having the theoretical ability to retrieve a specific configuration which maybe exists at some dimension, somehow holographically stored in the fabric of universe combined with an unimaginably advanced intelligence and technological ability might make it doable. Do I believe there's a non zero probability if it being possible? Yes. Do I believe it will ever happen? No. Although cryonics is far less presumptuous than reviving back a personality from a lock of hair and information extracted from the "spacetime continuum", the complete lack of evidence for any sort of reversibility of the process makes me extremely skeptical in the wisdom in paying for such a procedure, regardless of how well intentioned it might be.
placebo··on "Principles of Adult Behavior" by JP Barlow
Yes. Another way to look at it is the bottom line of various non-dual/mystical teachings which is basically that the best way to achieve lasting happiness is to eliminate the seeker of it (of course, not in a physical sense) - or put more accurately, to realize that the very illusion of the personal self is the root cause of the unhappiness.
placebo··on Show HN: TablePlus – A macOS client for relational databases
Likewise, was wondering whether someone would mention it here. I'm quite impressed and considering at some point paying for the premium features (mainly support of NoSQL databases).
placebo··on Ask HN: How do you manage to go through so much of good content posted on HN?
same way I manage other things, which is sort of the opposite of what one might do in SEO management - I drop the long tail, and only focus on what's left. Of course the contents of what's left depends on your personal priorities of what you find to be important. Now if that also becomes too much, rinse and repeat.
placebo··on John Perry Barlow has died
I admit my ignorance of not knowing about him previous to reading this. Also admit a sad feeling of retroactive loss now that I have learned a bit more about him. Hope he'll be a role model to others that follow.
placebo··on Training an AI to convert design mockups into HTML and CSS
I don't think it's a silly question, but I think free money basically means dismissing the money system altogether. That would work in an ideal world with ideal people but we are not that far out of the jungle yet (and I'm not referring to intelligence levels but to qualities that didn't evolve as fast as our intelligence). So, while you're right in principle, in practice there will probably still be a lot of injustice and suffering to go around long after everything is automated. Having said that, I still think it's a step in the right direction to reduce the ills of society.
placebo··on Randomness: the Ghost in the Machine? (2014)
Interesting how the concept of randomness can only exist in contrast to the recognition of order, but who notices order other than a mind that defines it as such? But this mind could not have been created in the first place were it not for some intrinsic order, some consistency in reality. Makes my head spin...
placebo··on What Does It Mean to Die?
I understand, though I think you're throwing the baby out with the bathwater here, especially since unlike quantum-woo BS, the hard problem of consciousness or the essence of "matter" is nowhere near being solved, (and I would argue unsolvable using any scientific method), so I try to differentiate between people's subjective feeling about it vs their competence in the scientific realm.
placebo··on What Does It Mean to Die?
While I'm not religious, I don't understand what specifically in that paragraph warrants dismissing a person's perspective on the matter. Could you elaborate?
placebo··on Like an AI Could Ever Spot Sarcasm
"Why stop now just when I’m hating it?" - Marvin the paranoid android
placebo··on MiniZinc: free and open-source constraint modeling language
Yes, an impressive set of problems solved with an impressive set of solvers. Quite a bit of experience stored on that site.

One thing I'm interested to know (as someone with less experience in constraint programming), is when does one employ constraint programming engines like Choco, Gecode, MiniZinc etc, vs. when metaheuristics (such as simulated annealing, genetic algorithms, etc.) are a more practical solution. Is there a rule of thumb regarding the size search space, type of problem etc. ?

← PreviousPage 6 of 14Next →