HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwdisswordfish2

936 karma · joined September 7, 2017

The HN rules still apply.

Please do not be disrespectful toward others.

Separate the commenter from the comment.

Smart commenters still make dumb comments now and then. And vice versa.

Consequently, the "identity" of the commenter is not a reliable predictor of the quality of the comment.

Shared accounts such as this one can address this problem.

Each comment must stand on its own, apart from identity and historical karma.

submissionscomments
pwdisswordfish2··on DuckDuckGo browser seemingly sends domains a user visits to DDG servers
Are you saying DDG is forcing you to send a User-Agent header?

DDG's privacy policy also goes on about the privacy implications of User-Agent headers combined with IP addresses.

So let's say I take what they have put in their privacy policy to heart and I stop sending a User-Agent header. In response DDG sends prefixed result URLs? WTF?

Using haproxy, for example, I can use a "modern browser" and send no User-Agent header. I still get prefixed result URLs.

pwdisswordfish2··on DuckDuckGo browser seemingly sends domains a user visits to DDG servers
To get prefixed result URLs, use GET not POST. Try duckduckgo.com/lite/ and lite.duckduckgo.com/lite/

If I recall correctly there is a way to turn off the prefixed result URLs without having to turn on Javascript, by adding/changing a URL parameter, e.g., kh. However that is not the default setting. Not very friendly toward the privacy-conscious user who has Javascript disabled and does not read HN to find out about otherwise undocumented URL parameter usage.

For certain queries, I can actually get a different first result based on the HTTP method I use.

pwdisswordfish2··on DuckDuckGo browser seemingly sends domains a user visits to DDG servers
"This is not to say that DDG is perfect: links you click do seem to be redirected through a /l/ page on their domain ..."

I am surprised the user is not complaining about this instead of the favicons. Their privacy policy goes on about the privacy implications of Referer headers and instead of calling out browsers for sending Referer by default, they instead give themselves power to record all the user's clicked results themselves. The Referer problem is something that can be solved by the user at the browser level through, e.g., using a client that does not send Referer, browser extensions/plug-ins that can control headers sent, or perhaps with a local proxy to remove the Referer header.

Unless DDG has changed, these prefixed result URLs are the default. It is possible to get unprefixed result URLs using the "lite" version of DDG however that is not the default. "Privacy-focused" search engine chooses less private default. News at 11.

I recently noticed that DDG has started redirecting queries submitted via POST to /lite/. The redirect is to the same domain. No explanation. I have a custom client that does not follow redirects and I now have to submit two sets of HTTP headers instead of one.

These guys are trying to make money from advertising just like everyone else. They have to be very particular in the methods they use to do it -- check the exceptions in their privacy policy -- but it is the same game. Ads and affiliate links. That sort of business and privacy are always going to be at odds with each other.

pwdisswordfish2··on Oppose the Earn IT Act
Unless this bill's critics are mistaken, if your friends are using "file encryption", i.e, encrypting the contents of the communications themselves before sending, then this bill has no effect on that.

IMO, your friends, unless they are nerds, are never going to place much value on encryption when they never actually use it themselves. When some third party tech company is doing the "end-to-end encryption" for them then your friends are really not in control of the situation, let alone having any reason to understand it. It could be a sham and they might not know it.

This bill stands to hurt tech companies but according to its critics (surprise: it's the tech companies) it does not interfere with any individual's use of encryption for communications.

No one wants third parties to have potential access their communications. However there is no law preventing a tech company that provides "encrypted messaging" from decrypting people's communications. There is not even a contract with users. If they do this, their liability is zero. There are only "promises", something like, "We promise we won't do it, unless we receive a valid subpoena" or "We have made it technically impossible to see your messages." (Nevermind metadata.)

Well, what if some other third party, like the people pushing this bill, made the same promises? Would that be "good enough"?

Of course not.

For the record, I am not taking a for/against position here. I am not a tech company nor someone trying to get access to encrypted messaging services provided by tech companies. However if something came along -- not suggesting this is it -- that created the necessary evolutionary pressure to make every person, not just "bad guys", have a basic understanding of how to encrypt a file and send it over an insecure network, without relying on a third party for the encryption, then I would think that would be a good thing.

pwdisswordfish2··on Japan auto companies triple Mexican pay rather than move to US
Paying these factory workers what they are worth, regardless of where they are situated, has been a long time coming. This is great news.
pwdisswordfish2··on The percentage of Americans who are employed has fallen from 61 to 51
"Is "employing" XX% of your population in virtual indentured servitude supposed to be something politicians are proud of?"

In 2020, in the U.S. for example, yes.

This is why these "jobs" disappeared so quickly when there is a slightest sign of economic trouble.

Someone has to do "real work" and so there will always be a need for indentured servants. Those sort of jobs will always exist. However the need for many other "jobs" has been put into question. When things get tight, companies today are more aware that they can eliminate those positions and carry on, sometimes with increased profits as a result. The pandemic is a perfect wake-up call as it purports to separate "essential" from "non-essential" jobs. With some exceptions, the more you are being paid, the more you think you are worth, the higher the chance that your job is, in fact, "non-essential". Eliminating these higher paid, non-essential positions, even temporarily, saves companies a lot of money. It is not easy to eliminate these positions under normal conditions, however in an "economic crisis", the process becomes easier.

As an employer, I can get those workers back anytime. They will be crawling over each other, lying about their qualifications, doing whatever it takes to get hired, because, on the "strength" of their non-essential job, they have built-up a standard of living that they must maintain.

pwdisswordfish2··on What It’s Like to Report on Facebook
You mean whether the decision not to invite any members of the press to the test flight was intentional or incompetence?
pwdisswordfish2··on GNU GCC does not round floating-point divisions to the nearest value
Python IIRC stores intermediate results in memory, it doesn't perform long chains of calculations entirely in FPU registers. This ensures the intermediate results are predictably rounded.

JavaScript JITs blindly use SSE without checking if it is available. Bytecode interpreters behave the same as above.

pwdisswordfish2··on Forget Google, time to end the Visa-MasterCard duopoly
Let's tackle Google first then we will have a look at the other complaints. Not going to "forget" Google. Sorry.
pwdisswordfish2··on Zero-sum thinking on immigration will make America poorer
"Why is continuous growth even a goal?"

In a pyramid scheme, it is required.

In a "greater fool" scheme, it is required.

In a political campaign, it is required because it provides a justification for lowering taxes.

pwdisswordfish2··on PHP Insights: Analyze the code quality of PHP projects
> I look forward to the April 1st version of this tool.

It would lint every appearance of a ‘<?php’ token with the message ‘you wrote your code in a crappy language’.

pwdisswordfish2··on Reducing search indexing latency to one second
Disable Javascript. For example,

https://mobile.twitter.com/search?q=

works without Javascript

pwdisswordfish2··on Microsoft removes manual deferrals from Windows Update 'to prevent confusion'
I am honstely surprised that businesses and other organisations have come to accept this constant 24/7 "updates" scenario from Microsoft without some intelligent business people calling them out on it.

Imagine if every month, every week, or even every day someone from an office supply company came around to your office and collected all your pens, pencils and other office supplies and replaced them with "updated" versions. Meanwhile you could detect no meaningful difference from the "old" ones. After a while, you would just tell them to go away: "The supplies I have are working just fine. Thanks."

pwdisswordfish2··on Unilever is latest brand to boycott Facebook
Member since the student requirement. I must have missed the "beacon of unity" phase. It is just another website.

I remember other websites providing similar functionality around the time Facebook appeared (not MySpace, Friendster, or any of those), including the ability to see who last visited your page: other members. You could then go visit their page. AFAIK, Facebook never had that. Instead it had "poke". If today you could see who is accessing your Facebook page, it would probably inhibit you from posting so much personal content. The entire design of today's Facebook is to dissuade you from activiely checking friends' or potential friends' pages on your own initiative. Instead Facebook wants to "feed" you content from other members (and advertisers). Default settings and behaviour discourage exploration and encourage relying on "suggestions" (by Facebook) instead. They even go so far as to ask for money to "promote" your page to others.

pwdisswordfish2··on Microsoft removes manual deferrals from Windows Update 'to prevent confusion'
Did the simulation require internet access?

What are the tactics Microsoft uses to deal with computers that are offline? Can those tactics be circumvented?

pwdisswordfish2··on Facebook announces policy changes ahead of 2020 elections
Certainly the problem can be seen as one of clients. The "modern web browsers" are instruments for fueling the dumpster fire. For the web, I wrote my own "user agent". A client that has zero intelligence however it is fully under the user's control. The intelligence lies with the user, not the third party authors of the client (with their business purposes and conflicts of interest).
pwdisswordfish2··on Facebook announces policy changes ahead of 2020 elections
I think this comment is too easily conflating "the internet" with "the web". Specifically, gigantic billion-page websites that people now call "platforms". The architecture and capacity of the internet we now know allows for them, but they are not an inherent property of the internet.

Web != Internet

pwdisswordfish2··on Dynamic linking
With NetBSD, it is relatively easy to compile the entire system as static. Is it easy to do this with Arch Linux? (Maybe Void Linux?)
pwdisswordfish2··on Facebook announces policy changes ahead of 2020 elections
"These services are utilities, sometimes monopolies, and must be regulated as such."

Maybe we could just start with regulating The Internet as common carrier instead of an "information service".

Anyone who is disappointed with the content of the "speech" they see on a particular "network" (a website/endpoint), should study the case of Usenet. Disprove this hypothesis: Unmoderated "public discourse" on a computer network has a tendency to descend into a sewer.

The only difference today in terms of this phenomena is the number of users of the "network" (website/endpoint) or computer network (internet).

Maybe "networks" used for communication need to migrate to "mesh" instead of "hub and spoke". Perhaps websites were not meant to have billions of pages and be called "networks".

pwdisswordfish2··on Comcast, Mozilla strike privacy deal to encrypt DNS lookups in Firefox
Comcast does not appear to be using the Mozilla brand. Am I missing something?
pwdisswordfish2··on PHP 8.0.0 Alpha 1 available for testing
The analogy is a false one. PHP was never re-written from scratch in a way that Windows was (with NT). Most of PHP’s pitfalls are still there, and only now are they being slowly removed one by one.
pwdisswordfish2··on Snowden: Tech Workers Are Complicit in How Their Companies Hurt Society
This comment is right on the money. No pun intended.

It was a serious mistake to dream that this sort of activity (surveillance and ad services) is the basis for the economy of the future. Time to wake up.

My heart sinks everytime I see an office floor of long tables and computer monitors. This is not the future we want. Don't care how much some people are getting paid now, or how easy they think their "jobs" are, the salaries will inevitably drop and the "work" will become increasingly mind-numbing. The purpose of all this: To analyse people's behaviour and serve them advertising (or worse). To pretend that people do not need to possess good judgment anymore because computers can tell us what decisions to make.

It is not an American Dream. It's a nightmare that is just beginning to take shape. Wake up.

pwdisswordfish2··on Linux to begin tightening up ability to write to CPU MSRs from user-space
That is a well-written blog post. Thanks for sharing. Wondering if I can do this with a BSD kernel.
pwdisswordfish2··on Comcast, Mozilla strike privacy deal to encrypt DNS lookups in Firefox
This just leads to a wiki page listing two TRR's, where someone admits that whatever "privacy policies" TRR's provide are not "contracts". Then someone replies that "there are legal contracts between Mozilla and those two listed providers". That does not mean those contracts relate to protecting user privacy. If you dig, there will be nothing there. There is nothing in any contract to protect any user. Neither Mozilla nor TRR's are "on the hook" for protecting user privacy. What I mean by that is that if some user's privacy is breached, there is absolutely zero liability accruing to Mozilla or TRR's.

https://wiki.mozilla.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Wthayer&a...

You, the end-user, will not get to see Mozilla's contracts. Policies are not contracts.

There seems to be some common misunderstandings about "policies" and tech companies are exploiting them. There is nothing legally binding in a policy and in the case the company deviates from the policy, there is no way for an affected user to "enforce" the policy she thought was being adhered to. This is of course assuming anyone outside the company actually discovers that a policy is being violated. Usually policy violations are non-detectable from outside the company.

pwdisswordfish2··on Comcast, Mozilla strike privacy deal to encrypt DNS lookups in Firefox
When pigs fly!

Can you imagine Mozilla CEO depleting her own compensation in order to sue a company the size of Comcast? What exactly are the claimed damages in this hypothetical lawsuit? The damages to Mozilla are _____ ? (This PR piece in Ars suggests the deal is solely to protect users. No financial details.) How about the damages suffered by users? (Whoops, they are not parties to the agreement.)

Quite the vivid imagination!

Maybe the "white knight" narrative really does work on some people.

pwdisswordfish2··on Comcast, Mozilla strike privacy deal to encrypt DNS lookups in Firefox
Can users enforce that contract if it is breached? Maybe users should be named explicitly as third party beneficiaries.

Mozilla is a company and needs to compensate its CEO and staff. The CEO received $2,458,350 in 2018.^1 Everything Mozilla does cannot be solely for users' benefit. Mozilla, the people behind it, have their own financial interests.

1. https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2018/mozilla-2018-fo...

pwdisswordfish2··on iOS14 reveals that TikTok may snoop clipboard contents every few keystrokes
"It seems like a ton of apps are abusing this feature:"

Honest question: Why do we need this feature?

As a user, I am happy to sacrafice whatever benefit it provides -- to end users -- to stop the abuse. Obviously the feature provides benefits to app developer personal data collectors.

OK by me to remove feature.

pwdisswordfish2··on Text-Only Websites
One thought is that we could have two mandated versions of every website: (a) the text-retrieval optimised version and (b) the web developer engagement version.

When this idea has come up on HN before it has been met by angry web developers claiming they "would have to maintain two websites" or some such nonsense.

However, consider that no one composes content in JSON, or even HTML. Textual content always begins as readable text. Even if only in the mind of the person creating it. There is nothing to maintain as there is nothing to "develop". All that needs to be done is add the HTTP header and deliver the text.

One of the most popular examples of text retrieval I can think of to illustrate:

https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/

Personally I prefer the directory-style "Index of" to the HTML-ised "Up / Next / Previous". Same functionality.

Even if the complaint "we would have to maintain two websites" had any substance, which website do you think would be easier to maintain?

That is a rhetorical question. That means I already know the answer.

pwdisswordfish2··on Video Game Industry Rocked by Outpouring of Sexual Misconduct Allegations
> asked a report

What does this mean exactly? Other than that, which I can’t really judge because I don’t understand it, it’s just people talking and having fun… No sexism, no discrimination, no abuse. I realize any expression of being a sexual being is frowned upon in Americas puritanical workplaces, but it’s hardly scandalous. Neither is expressly aiming at the market of heterosexual male adolescents. There is a lot of talk of working environments being “unfriendly” towards female coworkers, and it’s a legitimate problem, but it still falls very short of a “MeToo reckoning”.

TFA isn’t much better. The Avellone guy apparently got a women drunk and groped her. That’s a #MeToo worthy offense and it should be enough to prosecute and “cancel” him. The rest is him sending DMs and a weird drive-by cancel-attempt on one Omeed Dariani, who made an “unwelcome sexual overture”. The proposed party presumably said no and nothing more happened, or the article would mention it. I really don’t know what’s going on in the article. Avellone abused a woman. Dispense justice accordingly and stop trying to elevate any and all sexual behavior to the same level.

pwdisswordfish2··on Facebook’s dominance is built on anti-competitive behavior
Sounds about right as Facebook have admitted they cannot grow anymore in the US. Any growth must come from outside the US.
← PreviousPage 4 of 16Next →