HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qarl

938 karma · joined January 29, 2016

I was banned for arguing too hard about things that matter.

"The white moderate... prefers a negative peace which is the absence of tension to a positive peace which is the presence of justice." — MLK, Letter from Birmingham Jail

I'd rather be uncomfortable.

Karl Stiefvater qarl@qarl.com www.qarl.com github.com/qarl

submissionscomments
qarl··on An Open Letter on AI and Cybersecurity from the Scientific Community
Who is the "Scientific Community"?
qarl··on BB(10) > Graham's Number
Papers are written for experts, not the public.

And nowadays LLMs are the experts. So. It will explain it to you if you ask. And it does a very nice job. You'll probably need to lose the attitude, tho.

qarl··on BB(10) > Graham's Number
The function BB() is necessarily larger than any function you can compute. It's a surprising/fascinating result.

I've had a lot of success answering questions like this by asking an LLM. It turns out they understand each other and do a great job explaining.

Here's a link for this paper:

https://claude.ai/share/81b1380d-ca03-4ecb-8475-8e0bb95ea87e

qarl··on BB(10) > Graham's Number
I'm wondering - have you asked an LLM to flesh-out the paper for you? Or walk you through the details?

I've been hearing stories of mathematicians who are developing a new found appreciation for LLMs by having them explain the other LLM's paper. I guess the paper has the necessary details but possibly not the best exposition.

EDIT:

Here's a link explaining this paper:

https://claude.ai/share/81b1380d-ca03-4ecb-8475-8e0bb95ea87e

qarl··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
Ah. Fair enough.
qarl··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
Meh.

What will software engineers do? What will mathematicians do? What will artists do?

Why are we pretending that the LLMs aren't coming for every job?

What are the humans going to do?

qarl··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
> maybe it was wrong?

Well, given the fact that President Zelinsky is saying it's right - I am not going to make leaps of logic without factual explanations.

So no, I am not going to infer that they removed it because they were wrong unless they explicitly say as much.

Nor should you.

qarl··on Just say no to OpenAI and Anthropic
Meh. I asked GPT-6 whether I should use Claude or Flash. After an annoying struggle to compare - it told me that Flash would cost me 1.7X Claude and give me a lesser model.
qarl··on Just say no to OpenAI and Anthropic
Right - but my usage is quite high and the $200/mo level gives you 4X as many tokens. That's the thing - they bribe you with crazy deals.

I looked into it a couple of months ago and it wasn't a win.

qarl··on Just say no to OpenAI and Anthropic
Umm... I'm not sure... but if you're only paying a euro a day... it sounds like your only running one agent at a time?

Your token usage absolutely scales with parallel agents. So.

qarl··on Just say no to OpenAI and Anthropic
Well... yes. Exactly.
qarl··on Just say no to OpenAI and Anthropic
Well... except that both companies offer insane subscription benefits to individuals. So a hosted open weights model still comes out more expensive.

I'd move in a second if it weren't so. But it looks like it will be about 5X more expensive for me. So.

qarl··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
Yeah, no. I am not going to sift through hundreds of lines of unrelated stuff. The only thing I see referencing the issue is a guy saying "yeah, of course, it's like Google."

I'm wondering if you have a reliable source.

qarl··on Total Annihilation, rebuilt for modern computers
Yeah - I don't even bother judging a website by how useful it is anymore - if I see an em-dash I close it before I can read anything.

Just safer that way. You don't want to get the AI on you.

qarl··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
> Because it was wrong. It was regular crawler traffic that had nothing to do with disinformation.

You got a source for that?

qarl··on 3rd Yandex Cloud Data Center Was Hit
Just in time to derail Russian disinformation before the election.

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/data-centers/russ...

I'll be curious to see how it affects the mood around HN.

EDIT: How curious - the article above removed all mention of disinformation - but you can still see it in the URL....

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Do you really not understand? Or are you trolling me? Really?
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
It won.
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Are you trolling me?

In order for it to be stripped of its first-place prize, it must have first won the first-place prize.

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
[flagged]
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Not all AI output is slop.

It is prejudice to insist otherwise.

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Have you noticed the similarities between "slop" and other slurs?
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
> so its quality is utterly immaterial and irrelevant to the discussion.

My friend, it is the heart of the point I was raising. On my thread. So explain to me how the topic I raised about the quality is irrelevant to what I am saying?

> It also didn't win.

It won first place:

> The company has stripped an entry to its Small World In Motion competition of its first place prize.

In order to be stripped of a prize one must have first won the prize.

Are you an idiot or a troll? I can't tell.

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Slop doesn't win. Slop loses. This won.
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
I hate to ruin your day - but NFTs and crypto alt coins were a scam.

AI is not.

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Be that as it may - it still won.
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
I am discussing quality.
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
I'm not saying it shouldn't have been disqualified. I did not say that.

I said that it won.

qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
I'm referring to the fact it won - which would imply something about the quality level of the AI entry.
qarl··on Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
I'm referring to the trend where all AI output is called slop. And yet here we have an example of it winning a competition.
← PreviousPage 3 of 31Next →