HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rbarooah

1,972 karma · joined May 31, 2008

submissionscomments
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
and it is very difficult to separate war from protectionism as they are all on a sliding scale of policy.

Why isn't protectionism just part of the terms that nations negotiate when they trade?

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
So basically war.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Agreed, it's not just Maoism, it's the broader history of China's economic development.

Also, if protectionism, which is notably bidirectional, isn't the root cause of rural poverty in China, do we have any reason for believing that unilaterally abandoning it would alleviate the poverty?

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
That's the second time you've failed to comprehend the use of a negative. I suggest you reread what you've written.

The rest of the thread doesn't show me attempting to win any argument. I suggest rereading that too.

Whichever way my interlocutor responded to my question would neither invalidate his own position, nor 'win' an argument for me.

You are mistaking this form of discussion for a straw man because you are seeing things in black and white, when instead the question was intended to provide context.

Sometimes people ask provocative questions in order to better understand where other people are coming from. Dialog consists of more than just direct argument. Not every exchange is about gaining rhetorical advantage.

If you try playing back the comments in your head as if they are being spoken by a collegial group involved in a discussion, you'll see what I mean.

Your judgement is incorrect because you have misidentified the nature of the conversation. You are imagining there to be an argument where instead there is actually a discussion.

And on this note, do you really think it's helpful to throw comments like "straw man" into conversations you aren't constructively participating in?

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
No, not a word of what you said holds.

You're flat out wrong, and it's clear that you don't understand what a strawman is. It is more than just 'misrepresenting' your opponent's argument, which in any case I didn't do.

A straw man is where you present a weakened form of your opponent's argument in order to more easily defeat it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

As you have now acknowledged, I did not present any form of my opponent's argument at any time, let alone argue against it. What I did was to ask a question to put his statements into context.

rbarooah··on A simple experiment suggests a way to encourage truthfulness
True, as long as you mean 'instinctive' in the sense of default, rather than in the sense of innate.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
By asking a question in the negative form ("don't you think...") you are implicitly asserting what follows is your interlocutor's opinion.

This is where you are wrong. By phrasing it in the negative form I am implicitly asserting that I think that what follows is not my interlocutors opinion.

So, no straw man.

rbarooah··on Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project."
This is not quite correct. It's not a binary. The existence of one weak alternative network wouldn't be enough. We need an actual plurality of active networks.

These issues are real when you have large organizations like Google and Facebook who stand a reasonable chance of extinguishing a significant part of the diversity.

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Nowhere did I assert that this was the parent's arguement. I didn't represent his position at all.

My question adds context that changes the weight of the parent's assertions. What I wrote isn't even an argument, so it can't be a straw man.

rbarooah··on Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project."
Most of that seems to be aimed at ChromeOS - which is predictable.

I'm more interested in what he thinks of Google as a service.

rbarooah··on Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project."
Wanting to know his opinion doesn't make him the High Judge.

I'm curious because slthough I'm critical of Google for various reasons, I think it's hard to make a case against the value that Google search has brought to the world.

In the particular thread about Facebook RMS is pretty absolute in his boycott. I wondered whether he'd be more nuanced with Google.

rbarooah··on Stallman: "Facebook is an international parasitism project."
Many of Stallman's complaints about Facebook ( http://stallman.org/facebook.html ) apply equally to Google.

Does anyone know whether he regards them in the same light?

rbarooah··on Google co-founder Sergey Brin spotted wearing Project Glass prototype IRL
That OS they have 'already coded', is hardly designed for this kind of device. But yes, I'll agree they have done a lot of work on key facilities that would be needed for this.

Media coverage doesn't mean anything. Look at the media coverage Google Wave got.

As for an App store, yes - they might follow the Android model and make these things somewhat open. Equally likely is that they might make them as open as Google+ or Siri - which is very much what the videos seemed to be illustrating.

rbarooah··on Google co-founder Sergey Brin spotted wearing Project Glass prototype IRL
"But head mounted displays made by Google haven't been available for years."

Sure, but this makes your point into a circular argument.

In your first comment you indicate that the fact that these glasses have been spotted shows that Google is able to make progress.

Now you're saying that the reason that progress has probably been made on the glasses is because they're made by Google.

I do agree with you that they are probably pouring a lot more resources into this than others have. I just don't think that sighting of the glasses in public indicate anything about what progress they've made.

rbarooah··on Google co-founder Sergey Brin spotted wearing Project Glass prototype IRL
Head mounted displays have been available for years. The fact that Sergey Brin is able to test a prototype demonstrates nothing.

Admittedly, if they do have the hardware nailed, then these would be cool.

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
How so?
rbarooah··on Flashback trojan reportedly controls half a million Macs and counting
It may not be worth stating to people round here who are essentially experts in the field, but to the vast majority of everyday PC users it's not at all obvious and very much worth stating.
rbarooah··on Flashback trojan reportedly controls half a million Macs and counting
Not really - in context it's perfectly clear what they meant.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Good grief. Downvoted multiple times without explanation?

The original top-level article that this thread is about made what seemed to be a reasoned point at the end about the bailout of the auto-industry, and I am simply asking mseebach whether he disagrees with it, since he made reference to bailouts.

Why on earth would that get downvoted?

rbarooah··on Mac OS X Malware Builds Botnet More than 550,000 Strong
One russian security firm that makes money selling OSX antivirus software has made this claim without producing any evidence or even explaining how the estimate was produced.
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
So, do you disagree with the point in the original article about the bail-out of the auto industry preventing a much wider loss?
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
By talking about how the US and Britain had grown rich through trade and 'imperialist' protectionism and mentioning racism, the GP seemed to be implying that the poverty in China was somehow created by these western countries.

Aren't those modern "buy British" or "buy American" movements voluntary? Might there not be good reasons for supporting those who are economically tied to you by culture and legal jurisdiction?

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
Don't you think that decades of isolationist Maoism had more influence on the rural poverty in China than US and British protectionism?
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
The midwest has some great manufacturing industries, but the idea that it is anywhere near ready to replicate Shenzhen on any reasonable timeframe or cost basis is simply not credible.

The expertise, density and investment levels are totally different and cannot be rapidly changed.

I'll go as far to say that a devalued currency and/or cheap labor may have been the reason the manufacturing base moved initially, but technology has advanced since that time and Shenzhen has now built up an infrastructure advantage which is much harder to counter.

rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
How is it that you accept that 'colocation theory' explains Silicon Valley, but you dismiss it as explaining Shenzhen without explaining why one is different from the other?
rbarooah··on The Beer Game -or- Why Apple Can’t Build iPads in the US
I'm guessing you didn't read the piece. Wages are not the primary issue.
rbarooah··on Flashback trojan reportedly controls half a million Macs and counting
No, they are stating that Macs are not susceptible to PC viruses, which is true.

They are implying that viruses are a severe problem on PCs that Mac users do not face. This was undoubtedly true when they were running those adverts.

rbarooah··on Edit scheme on your iPad via the parse tree: Lisping launched
Too steep for a next generation programming app, but not too steep for a coffee and a muffin.
rbarooah··on Edit scheme on your iPad via the parse tree: Lisping launched
You still have the choice. You can always sell your Android tablet.
rbarooah··on Flashback trojan reportedly controls half a million Macs and counting
Serious question - how do you see us getting to there from where we are now?
← PreviousPage 5 of 30Next →