HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

red75prime

1,454 karma · joined September 24, 2015

submissionscomments
red75prime··on Recent AI models struggled to match a human algorithmic innovation
Neither Euler, nor Gödel had proven the Navier-Stokes blowup, though. And it took generations of mathematicians to prove the Fermat's theorem (it's a kind of a very slow swarm, isn't it?)
red75prime··on AI coding agents generate more code, but not more software
Is your company striving to automate design and analysis, then?
red75prime··on Recent AI models struggled to match a human algorithmic innovation
Brute force would choke on a measly decillion of alternatives. It corresponds to an extremely short proof. A combinatorial explosion doesn't allow to use brute force for anything slightly longer than toy problems. Swarm of 10000 agents is a massive smart force.
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
And? How do you know they weren't testing mitigations?
red75prime··on What mathematicians should know about the Lean Theorem Prover: reliability & AI
Yes, I am. The kernel soundness bugs in con leche that allow to prove False, to be precise. Crashes, hardware bugs, cosmic rays flipping bits and such don't count as qualifying bugs.
red75prime··on What mathematicians should know about the Lean Theorem Prover: reliability & AI
> What does it mean for con leche if further lean kernel bugs are found?

There is so much that needs to go wrong with our current understanding of math, so that it's a bit like asking "What if we find tachyons that allow us to send messages into the past?" Most likely we will not find them.

red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
You seem to be a reasonable person judging by your comment history. But you don't have programming or engineering experience, I guess? Knowing that those interactions can be harmful and acting on this knowledge and following established practices (that are born from the past errors) is not enough to prevent all errors in a novel situation.
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
I can't say whether you are being sarcastic, but Waymo has its share of problems. For example, see NHTSA recalls 24E013, 24E049, 25E034, 25E084, 26E026, 26E035.
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
You can solve CAPTCHAs with open-weights models. I guess Anthropic works on models not solving CAPTCHAs unless they (models) have a legitimate reason to do it.
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
The situation is more like: an engineer who designed the parking brake hadn't foresaw a possibility that a squirrel might store peanuts in the mechanism or something like that and gramma's foot got run over (the Anthropic case we are talking about is benign: the tip got into spam). Should we jail the engineer for causing bodily harm?
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
We should accept that to get a system that is safe to work in the chaotic real world environment the developers have to test the system in the chaotic real world environment. And that the testing might cause problems.

If this testing constitutes a criminally negligent behavior, it should be punished. Given the benign outcome (the tip got into spam, Anthropic promptly contacted the police) I doubt that it will make the case.

red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
> If you use AI to perform a crime, you should be held accountable for that crime.

Correct, but intentions matter. In this case the intention, most likely, was to test a system in the real world environment to catch any anomalies to, in turn, improve the system safety. We don't have enough information to decide whether it was a criminal negligence due to insufficient prior testing of the system in a controlled environment.

red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
The ADAS analogy continues to hold in this case too. At some point you need to test a system in the real, messy environment. The developers need this juicy training data to make the system safer. Simulations and controlled experiments can only do so much.
red75prime··on Anthropic AI model submits false tip on unsolved Philly murder, police say
"The AI company Anthropic said its model was conducting a test involving interactions with randomly selected websites when it accessed PhillyUnsolvedMurders.com and submitted false information on an unsolved homicide. The tip claimed to come from someone with information on the case."

We are at a point when you expect that you can safely give a model access, but sometimes the model doesn't do what you expect. Compare this to an advanced driver assist system. You either give it access to your car controls or it's useless. Alive or not the system shouldn't do wrong things (at least, it should be better than a median person in this regard).

red75prime··on Archaeologists Are Reconstructing the 'Invisible' Technologies of the Stone Age
Monocrystalline silicon (silicon dioxide was my brain hiccup) seems to be sufficiently stable to last hundreds of thousands of years. [1] notices constant dissolution rate of monocrystalline silicon that will keep its rectangular shape recognizable for a long time.

[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5830089/ "The observation that hydrolysis of Si NMs proceeds by surface reactions only, in a predictable manner without diffusion through defects or pin-holes"

red75prime··on Archaeologists Are Reconstructing the 'Invisible' Technologies of the Stone Age
When I was 5 I watched my grandmother making yarn using a foot-powered castle wheel. The machine rotates a string of yarn along its long axis and it collects fibers from a piece of loose wool (roving) thus extending itself. I think I've seen a drop spindle too, but I'm less certain about that.
red75prime··on Archaeologists Are Reconstructing the 'Invisible' Technologies of the Stone Age
And lots of small rectangular silicon dioxide thingies.
red75prime··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
I think determinism has nothing to do with it. If you mean sensitivity to word ordering and such, it's a generalization failure.
red75prime··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
> The core technology of an LLM is sampling from a distribution so there is literally no way to make it deterministically robust (only probabilistically).

An LLM mostly deterministically (except parallel processing nondeterminism that can be mitigated) produces a probability distribution that can be sampled deterministically: just take the highest probability token or use beam search.

red75prime··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
The problem is that people strongly believe that this is an insurmountable problem that will persist indefinitely (or for a long time) and plan accordingly, while this, most likely, will be fixed soon by adding RLCAF (RL on conversational agent feedback) or something like that.
red75prime··on Navier–Stokes Lost in Translation
You can't consider them monkeys if you need 1000 of them instead of 2^1000.
red75prime··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
"If you have nothing to say, don't post a chatbot's responses, because anyone can ask the chatbot directly if they wanted to"-principle? Well, people can't ask their chatbot directly, because it's not public.
red75prime··on In Ukraine, distributed renewables foil Russia's assaults
I'm absolutely not a fan of Trump and of politically motivated liars in general regardless of their affiliations.
red75prime··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
Whatever, then. It's totally in line with what I described as a typical usage of "category error".
red75prime··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
> we can clearly specify what AGI or ASI is

We'll have plenty of time for this, while living off UBI.

red75prime··on ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons
"You've made a machine that can be easily tuned to produce almost precisely my exact hammer and people who use the machine get freaked out that I can sue them."
red75prime··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
The original claim is "They’re fundamentally not suited to thinking like we do."

> but training does not produce such LLMs

If we are talking about fundamental limitations it should not be an empirical observation: "does not produce" (which is factually wrong, BTW). It should be a fundamental limitation: "can not produce in principle."

I still don't understand what you are talking about when you say "category mistake." I was talking about computational capabilities of LLMs with CoT that their training can exploit, not about Befunge-98.

red75prime··on Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces felony charge
Aren't high trust societies staying that way by kicking out the incorrigible violators? Pondering violence might not be treated lightly even in a high-trust society.
red75prime··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
"Category mistake" outside of kindergarten usually means "I don't like your definitions, but I can't bother to explain which definitions I use."

What do you mean exactly? "Thinking is not an algorithm."?

red75prime··on A 40ms Go garbage collector pause caused by swap
You just need to remember that garbage (unreachable reference cycles) isn't collected.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →