HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

roganartu

706 karma · joined April 2, 2014

Infrastructure Engineer at Hudson River Trading

Place where I write about reliability, programming, and other things: https://www.tonylykke.com/

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/roganartu; my proof: https://keybase.io/roganartu/sigs/LyULghKURMpLPigIRAq_rQZWO_NjjkZESA4Mr_TKXYI ]

submissionscomments
roganartu··on Supreme Court: Suspending Parliament was unlawful, judges rule
We already had a referendum in 1999 which was voted down.

A president in Australia would be a significant departure from the current system, and I'm not sure I know anyone who would support it. We don't vote for a person to be Prime Minister, we vote for a person in our specific federal electoral seat and the leader of the party that wins the most seats is the Prime Minister.

This person also doesn't have any powers that their party doesn't give them for the most part. No veto powers etc afaik, and party leadership (and hence the Prime Minister) can be changed at any time by a party vote.

roganartu··on LastPass bug leaks credentials from previous site
Just store your master password in your spouse's vault and make sure they know where the vault is stored if you use an offline tool/service.

This of course assumes you are comfortable knowing that they could access your accounts while you're still alive if they wanted to, and trusting that they won't.

roganartu··on Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond? (1982)
I disagree with this. I don't think my wife falls into either of these categories and we consciously chose moissanite instead of diamond.

Our choice was mostly founded in finance, but because we thought it was a waste of money not because we couldn't afford it. She also had no interest in walking around with a $5k+ insurance liability on her finger, but she enjoyed the aesthetic of a clear centre stone. The small stones in both her engagement and wedding bands are diamonds because they are cheaper due to being more readily available.

We don't use it as a status symbol or for virtue signalling. Neither of us are active on social media, and I don't even think there is a photo of it online. She normally doesn't even wear the engagement ring, just the wedding band (which is very thin and basic). Our friends are aware it isn't a diamond, but because they asked not because we forced it on them. People who don't ask can think it's whatever they want, neither of us derive our self worth from whether her ring is perceived to be a particular type of stone.

roganartu··on Aussie ISV buys ads to wake up Google support
So much so in fact, that it is often used endearingly among friends or when praising someone's skill at something.

Source: am Australian, live in the US, had to stop saying it except when on discord with friends back home.

roganartu··on America’s social-media addiction is getting worse
The biggest concern to me is the attention span most people have today. They can't go longer than a few minutes without going outside for a cigarette. It impacts work and leisure. An assignment at work is delayed or low quality because you had a cigarette every few minutes, you don't understand what's happening in a TV show/movie because you kept looking away to light up another cigarette, you can't get interested in a good book because you can't read more than a page or two without getting another cigarette.

I am guilty of this behavior myself and it's something that I've been working on a lot lately. I recognize that this is a problem, but I don't really support the government saving us from ourselves. I think this is something that average person just needs to educate themselves on and make the decision for themselves. It's not impossible to break free from it.

roganartu··on When it comes to composition and length, passwords mostly don't matter
You need to login because accounts have different quality tiers (standard vs high definition) and different max concurrent user counts.

Hulu does this much better though. They display a hulu.com shortlink on the TV app that you type into your browser on a computer, login if you aren't already, and click a button to authorise the TV.

roganartu··on Google Cloud Networking Incident Postmortem
I used to be an SRE at Atlassian in Sydney on a team that regularly dealt with high-severity incidents, and I was an incident manager for probably 5-10 high severity Jira cloud incidents during my tenure too, so perhaps I can give some insight. I left because the SRE org in general at the time was too reactionary, but their incident response process was quite mature (perhaps by necessity).

The first thing I'll say is that most incident responses are reasonably uneventful and very procedural. You do some initial digging to figure out scope if it's not immediately obvious, make sure service owners have been paged, create incident communication channels (at least a slack room if not a physical war room) and you pull people into it. The majority of the time spent by the incident manager is on internal and external comms to stakeholders, making sure everyone is working on something (and often more importantly that nobody is working on something you don't know about), and generally making sure nobody is blocked.

To be honest, despite the fact that it's more often dealing with complex systems for which there is a higher rate of change and the failure modes are often surprising, the general sentiment in a well-run incident war room resembles black box recordings of pilots during emergencies. Cool, calm, and collected. Everyone in these kinds of orgs tend to quickly learn that panic doesn't help, so people tend to be pretty chill in my experience. I work in finance now in an org with no formally defined incident response process and the difference is pretty stark in the incidents I've been exposed to, generally more chaotic as you describe.

roganartu··on Net worth of Americans aged 18 to 35 has dropped 34 percent since 1996: study
> I would make student debt dischargeable through bankruptcy and I would also favor the federal government no longer providing, subsidizing, or guaranteeing student loans.

I completed a Bachelor and Master degrees at a top 50 world-ranked university with an (Australian) government sponsored loan of, by graduation, around $30k USD, that I never would've had a hope of funding privately at that point in my life (or honestly any point after if I had never gotten the degree and hence a high-paying job).

My loan is not dischargeable through bankruptcy, and is repaid as a percentage of taxable income (~10% at the top tier), and not repaid at all if you earn below a threshold a few multiples above the poverty line. The "interest" is actually just inflation as the cash rate from the reserve bank is applied to the outstanding balance at year end. My interest last year was $800 AUD on a $40k AUD balance.

I disagree that the problem is specifically easy access to capital. There is a value in attending university; it creates an educated population which benefits everyone. I believe the core of the problem in the US is the lack of appetite for regulation and government intervention leading to a situation where the government guarantees private capital to fund things that they don't control the cost of. This creates a reason for the lender to discount the risk of the debt (because the government guarantees it by making it undischargeable) leading to capability for borrowers to get bigger loans. Universities quickly cottoned on and billed more for less, and the cycle continues until it (eventually) collapses.

The cost of degrees in Australia are easily regulated as the majority of universities are government institutions. There is one private university but the government loan limits are often not enough to finish a 4 year degree there so in reality only rich kids whose parents wish to buy them business connections attend.

I think it's the government guaranteeing loans to expensive institutions are the problem, not that people are getting degrees. Why remove all government loan assistance? Just stop giving it to people who want to go to private universities.

roganartu··on Bill to put health warnings on soda and sugary drinks advances in California
None of the studies in that survey actually support the claim I questioned though, which is specifically about insulin response in humans. Further, they don't even support your claim that artificial sweeteners cause _more_ weight gain than equivalent sugar.

imo a big problem with these kinds of studies is the huge number of confounding factors. They tend to be studies that select participants who report drinking diet soda and those who report not drinking it, without taking into the account the fundamental lifestyle differences between the two. This is also why I'm interested in specific, measurable things that are known to cause problems, such as insulin response.

It is very common for overweight people to replace sugary soda with diet soda without making any other lifestyle changes. It is unsurprising that this doesn't yield positive results over the long-term. People who report drinking no soda, diet or otherwise, are likely already leading healthier lifestyles than those who report drinking diet soda regularly. Without controlling for these factors properly all that's really being said is that "healthier lifestyles are better for controlling weight".

I agree that diet soda is probably worse than no soda, but I haven't seen any evidence to support the idea that diet soda is worse than sugary soda when consumed in otherwise identical diets.

roganartu··on Bill to put health warnings on soda and sugary drinks advances in California
> The problem is that unnatural sweeteners produce a similar insulin response as sugar

Has this been demonstrated in humans? I've heard this many times before but have been unable to find any human studies to support it, and the mice studies I've seen often use ludicrously high dosages of the sweeteners.

roganartu··on Epic Games Is Acquiring Psyonix
> A 30% cut for what was effectively a hosting and payments processing service

> Multiple launchers (and fewer features) is annoying

You can't claim steam is just a glorified CDN and payment processor in one breath and then complain about the lack of features in other launchers/platforms in the next.

I agree that 30% was steep, but steam provides both devs and consumers a lot of features that everyone now takes for granted (like cloud saves, household licensing, workshop mod frameworks, friends and chat, and much more). The games that move to epic are either going to have to implement these features themselves, depend on epic to provide a framework for it (sentiment seems to be "don't hold your breath", or release without them.

roganartu··on A Common Blood Test Can Cost $11 or Almost $1k
We've been here for nearly two years now, but when I was interviewing with the intent of moving to the US I was very direct with employers about our insurance requirements to make sure her quality of care would not be reduced. I turned down some better offers because their insurance was worse (one company would've required her to move to a known-worse treatment until she demonstrated it didn't work for her. This escalating method of treating her condition is well known to have much poorer long-term outcomes but it's cheaper).

Re avoiding treating people with chronic conditions, my understanding is that used to be a (state-by-state) thing that the ACA federally outlawed. We live in NYC where the state had already outlawed it, so even if the ACA is rolled back we should be fine.

We have very good insurance atm. I would go so far as to say, ignoring the general craziness of dealing with the US system and the occasional billing frustration, we have better coverage now than we did in Australia because _almost everything_ is covered (even most things Australia would consider "elective" and hence one would pay for out of pocket). We pay a token $1/month for premiums because law says we have to contribute and my employer pays our deductible. As long as we stay in-network we have basically no out of pocket costs.

If I lose or leave my job I have to find a new one and transfer my visa within 30 days, or leave the country within another 90 days after that. There's a thing called COBRA which allows you to pay a relatively low fee (iirc it's ~$700/m) to continue with exactly the same insurance post-employment for a short period (I think 9-12 months? Unsure exactly). Otherwise we'd just move back to Australia. We're both Australian citizens and we aren't really interested in making the transition to being US permanent residents.

roganartu··on A Common Blood Test Can Cost $11 or Almost $1k
As an Australian living and working in the US with a wife who has a chronic medical condition that costs our insurance company on the order of $100k/yr for her regular treatments, all I can say is "Almost $1k" sounds like a gross underestimate.

An anecdote I like to share with friends back home is related to a routine blood test that she has every few months. The price the provider bills varies significantly, but one time they billed $2900. Our insurance paid them $27 like they usually do and the remainder was written off.

Imagine being sick, having no insurance, maybe no job, and receiving that bill in the mail with absolutely no way for you to know that they would probably accept over 100x less than billed. I can understand why medical expenses are the #1 cause of bankruptcy in this country.

roganartu··on Jsonnet – A data templating language
A very powerful one. You could in theory stream multiple files into jq and have it output effectively arbitrary JSON based on their contents since it supports conditionals.

I don't think it would be very pretty since it's not designed for that use case, but the jq language is certainly powerful enough to allow it.

roganartu··on A researcher needed three hours to identify me from my DNA
For anything that involves human interaction for the verification, this doesn't really work.

I generate random strings for these and store them in my password manager. On several occasions I've called companies for whatever reason and they've asked these questions to verify my identity. When I say "oh it's a random string let me open my password manager to confirm it" they often reply with "oh it's ok, you're right it's gibberish" and consider me verified.

roganartu··on Why Don't Americans Understand How Poor Their Lives Are?
> Your employees aren't allowed to work their asses off.

Strict labour laws don't really prevent this in practice, if someone _wants_ to work themselves to death they can (I've worked with a remote team from Poland before while I was in Australia. Despite Poland having far strong labour laws than Australia, some members of the Polish team voluntarily worked longer hours and just didn't report it).

What labour laws do is prevent employers from forcing employees to work crazy hours. I think it's largely a cultural difference in the end. I live and work in the US now and here I've noticed the general sentiment that employees should be thankful to have a job and so should do whatever their employer says. It's also important to realise that highly compensated tech employees are less susceptible to this needing to work insane hours because we have much better leverage, but that doesn't stop people self-imposing longer hours due to cultural differences.

roganartu··on Microsoft says encryption laws make companies wary of storing data in Australia
I think it's important to have some context here though. I can't speak for the parent commenter, but I am Australian and how I interpreted it was that our democratic system is reasonably mature, functional, and relatively free from large scale corruption.

I think the last point is the big one. Political lobbying, while still a thing, isn't as rampant as in the US for example. Bad power-grab legislation like the bill being discussed still happen, as do bad laws as a result of general incompetence, but in my experience there are far less laws that happen as a result of corporate lobbying.

A good example is the Australian tax system. There is a government provided website for filing your individual income tax return. For the vast majority of people it is prefilled, takes about 5 mins, and it's also free for everyone. Contrast this with the US where companies like Intuit lobby specifically to keep the tax code complex and to require returns prepared online be submitted through one of them so they can collect their fees.

roganartu··on U.S. teens are spending less time with their friends in person
The wording of their comment suggests heavily to me that they are from Australia. I participated in scouts in Australia about the same amount of time ago as we did somewhat similar things, going on camps where there was a reasonable amount of independence and I would have described it as arts and craftsy.

You mention concern about liability these days, but it's important to remember not everywhere is America. I can't speak to the rest of the world, but Australia is definitely nowhere near as litigious as the US. I could definitely see something like what they described still happening in Australia today.

roganartu··on Apple Watch detects irregular heart beat in large U.S. study
I have worn both the original Fitbit Charge HR and the more recent Charge 2 daily for the past few years.

Aneceotally, because the watch isn't really water resistant (not least because the bands bubble if they get wet often), I have had it run out twice in that time and both times I was on holiday somewhere with no power. Because you are unlikely to actually wear it in the shower, just leave the charger permanently in your bathroom and get in the habit of taking it off and putting it on the charger when you shower. Even if you forget for one or two days it will almost always be sufficiently charged.

roganartu··on Gun laws where guns take the most lives
For those curious to do their own investigation, all these numbers are on wikipedia (and for Australia will mostly be sourced from the Australian Bureau of Statistics where you can freely access the original reports). All things in context though. A 9% decrease over 30 years doesn't sound very impressive, but when you consider that the per-capita homicide rate in Australia is ~5x lower than the US it doesn't sound so bad.

The sex crime example is interesting, because it's a raw count and does not take into account increasing reporting and investigation rates as a result of social change. Over the past few decades Australia has had significant public awareness campaigns for domestic and sexual abuse which are suspected to have significantly impacted reporting rates: https://aic.gov.au/publications/tandi/tandi359

Statistics can be bent to show whatever you when when you assume your audience won't actually think critically. This is a very common problem on both sides of the gun debate unfortunately and I don't think leads to anything productive.

roganartu··on Go 1.12 Release Candidate 1 is released
Yeah you're right, I should've been more specific than "compiler" here.

In fact, the varcheck checker in gometalinter probably even covers this use case: https://github.com/alecthomas/gometalinter/blob/master/READM...

roganartu··on Go 1.12 Release Candidate 1 is released
That's not a language feature though, that's a compiler feature.

The Go compiler should be technically capable of doing that without breaking iota or introducing a new feature. Have you considered raising a request for it if one doesn't already exist?

roganartu··on Insurance Company Says NotPetya Is an “Act of War”, Refuses to Pay
> You wouldn't buy insurance for the bag of rice you buy at a grocery store in case you drop it outdoors, the bag splits open and the rice is ruined. Why? Because you can easily afford buying another bag of rice.

> The same reasoning applies to a car. If you have sufficient savings, you can buy yourself a new car if and when you need to. Until then, just invest the savings and reap the investment rewards, exactly like the insurance company will be doing.

But it's not the same reasoning. I can afford to buy hundreds of bags of rice every month if I need to, without stretching my budget significantly. Rice for me is pocket change, so yes insurance would make no sense.

For the vast majority of people, a car is not pocket change. Sure high income people might be able to buy another and not go bankrupt, but there's a big difference between being able to afford something, and considering the expense pocket change.

roganartu··on Memory usage of a toy C# server and client with 500K concurrent connections on
> Javascript has it now but you need to be use libraries which support it too

This applies just as much to Python asyncio so I'm not sure it's a good suggestion from that perspective. You can use an executor to wrap things that don't support asyncio but that doesn't really qualify as good asyncio/await imo.

roganartu··on Queueing theory: The science of waiting in line
My local cinema concession stand moved from a single queue to one queue per register. The variance increased noticeably every time I have visited since and all the staff I have spoken to hated the change and said they were regularly getting complaints about it. When I asked why they changed I was told one of the managers did it because it made the lines shorter and they concluded that meant the wait must also be shorter.
roganartu··on Amazon Ruined Online Shopping
To expand on this: REI used to have a lifetime, no-questions-asked return policy. They changed it (sometime in the past few years, unsure I've only been in the US for a little over one now) to a 1 year no-questions-asked policy. This does not include things on clearance (they call it REI Garage sales online) as this is (as I understand it) mostly the returned items being resold to recoup costs. Clearance items (and electronics too) have a 90 day return policy instead.

I often pay full price at REI instead if cheaper elsewhere because of the generous return policy so I guess it works.

roganartu··on A Year-Long Undercover Plot to Blow Up Eve Online's Most Notorious Space Station
You don't really need scouts around you for the logoff timer, you just need to watch dscan. Combat probes, which are used to scan down ships in space (in otherwise un-warpable locations) show up on dscan. Whoever is piloting the ship being seeded just needs to spam dscan the whole time. If combat probes appear on a short-range dscan they need to assume their current position is compromised and warp somewhere else immediately. This step is where a cloaked scout comes in handy, as they can easily and safely create a bunch of warpable bookmarks in space for you to use for this purpose.

It's a game of cat and mouse, where the mouse can sit afk with a cloak on for however long they like until they think the cat is bored or not paying attention. Also worth noting another trick if you have reliable internet is to stay afk cloaked until the daily downtime logs you off. This way it's impossible to be scanned down because everyone gets kicked from the server at the same time.

roganartu··on A Year-Long Undercover Plot to Blow Up Eve Online's Most Notorious Space Station
> for one thing, it's a little odd that you can make a freighter un-attackable by logging out with its pilot, squirreling those assets away in-game indefinitely; maybe the balance of power needs to be changed on how freighters warp out at logoff?)

It's actually pretty hard to seed such a big ship in a wormhole, which is why they had to time it for when HK had a small presence. People that live in wormholes tend to obsessively dscan (kind of like a medium-distance radar that lets you see when ships are somewhere nearby you) and rapidly scan down new signatures (which can be PVE sites or new wormholes that people could be bringing things through). On top of that, big ships like freighters are slow to warp and hence quite susceptible to being caught on the way in.

In the freighter example, in order to safe logoff as you describe one has to be uncloaked and relatively stationary (ie: not warping around) for 60s (longer if they've attacked or been attacked recently). This is quite a vulnerable time for such a large (and hence easily scannable) ship. A well skilled player in a well specced ship (like most higher-level wormhole players will be and have) can scan down, warp to, and attack (giving a 15 min logoff timer) such a big ship well within that 60s if they are paying attention.

Removing the option for people to safe logoff in dangerous space would heavily discourage exploration of basically anywhere outside of high-sec which, imo, is where the majority of interesting content in the game is.

roganartu··on A Year-Long Undercover Plot to Blow Up Eve Online's Most Notorious Space Station
I dunno. I might be biased (I was in BAERS when they were kicked out of Nova a few years ago) but this story is far more interesting to me than the one behind BAERS eviction which was, at the time iirc, the most expensive wormhole battle ever with a good 500+ billion isk destroyed.

Sure, there was seeding in both, but in the end there was only something like 15-20 caps seeded in Nova and they didn't win the battle. That battle was largely won by a small group of the prevalent untouchable meta at the time: slippery pete's, all of which fit through a single hole anyway.

I find the logistics of seeding 650 battleships and the infrastructure to support them in a hole much more interesting than rage rolling relatively few capitals into a high class hole.

Disclaimer: I won Eve shortly after the Nova eviction because I just didn't have time anymore after graduating and starting work.

roganartu··on The US spends more on healthcare for no gain says new report from Johns Hopkins
It's not that it's more expensive at one place or another for the most part. When you go in-network you are seeing providers that your insurance has a contract with. This contract includes agreed amounts for procedures. Providers will often grossly overbill (mostly because it's easier to let the billing backend resolve these limits than bill accurately in the first place) and your insurance will respond with the amount covered. The remaining amount of the bill is written off because it was in-network so the provider is not allowed (by the contract with your insurance) to bill the balance not covered to the patient.

Out-of-network does not have this protection. Your insurance will possibly cover some of the bill, normally up to some percentage of what they consider a normal amount for the procedure in the area, and then you will be billed for the entire balance. Say your provider bills $100k and your insurance says they think that procedure normally only costs $50k and you have 80% out of network coverage. You would be billed for 20% of the $50k covered as coinsurance, plus the remaining $50k that would've been written off if you were in-network.

This is generally how people get surprise bills.

For a real world example: last year my insurance got billed ~$3k for a routine blood test for my wife as part of an annual checkup. It was in-network and the insurance paid $27 and the provider wrote off the rest.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →